PER/PELJ - Pioneer in peer-reviewed, open access online law publications
Author Maretha Retief
Affiliation North-West University, South Africa
Email maretharetief@gmail.com
Date Submitted 30 October 2023
Date Revised16 August 2024
Date Accepted 16 August 2024
Date Published 16 September 2024
Editor Prof A Gildenhuys
Journal Editor Prof W Erlank
How to cite this contribution
Retief M "A Case for the Need to Improve the Unilateral Double Taxation Relief for Estate Duty in South Africa" PER / PELJ 2024(27) - DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2024/v27i0a17136
Copyright
DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2024/v27i0a17136
Abstract
|
This article aims to address a specific problem statement, |
---|
Keywords
Estate duty; wealth transfer tax; double taxation relief; deceased estate.
……………………………………………………….
1 Introduction
Adam Smith, a Scottish economist, in his 1776 treatise, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, defined four criteria of a good tax system that are commonly referred to as the "canons of taxation".
1
* Maretha Retief. BCom Law (UP), LLB (UNISA), LLM in Estate Law (NWU). Faculty of Law, North-West University, South Africa. Email: maretharetief@gmail.com. ORCiD: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0209-5296. This contribution is an edited version of chapter 4 of the author's thesis, submitted in partial fulfilment of the LLD degree in Mercantile Law at the Faculty of Law, NWU. 1 Butler Condensed Wealth of Nations 70. 2 Lambert 1992 https://cooperative-individualism.org/lambert-ian_some-modern-principles-of-taxation-adam-smith-revisited-1992-jan.htm; Haupt Notes on South African Income Tax 2; Stiglingh et al Silke: South African Income Tax 5; Williams Income Tax in South Africa 6, Katz Commission 1997 http://www.treasury.gov.za/publications/other/katz/4.pdf 1.4-1.8; Margo Commission Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Tax Structure 4.42-4.50; Croome Taxpayers' Rights in South Africa 6; Meade Structure and Reform of Direct Taxation 7. 3 DTC 2015 https://www.taxcom.org.za/docs/20150723%20DTC%20First%20 Interim%20Report%20on%20Estate%20Duty%20-%20website.pdf 32. 4 OECD Inheritance Taxation 53.
One such consideration for reform under the Estate Duty Act relates to handling double taxation in respect of cross-border estates.
5
5 A cross-border estate exists when a person owns property in more than one country.
The reality of double taxation arises in a cross-border estate, for example, where the deceased owns property in one country and is a tax resident in another country, and both countries may exercise the right to tax such property. South Africans are not excluded from double taxation where a deceased is "ordinarily resident" in South Africa and owns property outside South Africa which may be subject to estate duty in South Africa as well as
to an estate
6
6 An estate tax is a transferor-based wealth transfer tax levied on the deceased estate based on the dutiable value of assets in an estate and payable by the executor. This type of taxation is often referred to as an "estate tax" or in the context of South Africa, an "estate duty". The United Kingdom also has a transferor-based wealth transfer tax but is called an "inheritance tax". See Rudnick and Gordon "Taxation of Wealth" 292; Jestle 2018 https://wiiw.ac.at/inheritance-tax-regimes-a-comparison-dlp-4690.pdf 2; Weber-Frisch and Duquennois-Djoua 2014 ERA Forum 410; OECD Inheritance Taxation 62-64. 7 An inheritance tax is levied on the beneficiaries of the estate in respect of the transfers received from the estate and is often called an "inheritance tax" or a "succession duty". See Jestle 2018 https://wiiw.ac.at/inheritance-tax-regimes-a-comparison-dlp-4690.pdf 2; Rudnick and Gordon "Taxation of Wealth" 293; Muller Wealth Transfer Taxation 1; Roeleveld 2015 SAJAR 147; OECD Inheritance Taxation 62-64. 8 Such taxation will be subject to the requirement that the exempt thresholds for inheritance related taxes upon death are exceeded in both countries. See Davis, Jooste and Beneke Estate Planning 12.3; Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 31.1. 9 OECD Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital 2017 9; Ostaszweska and Obuoforibo Roy Rohatgi on International Taxation 21; Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 9.
The impact of double taxation is minimised through unilateral relief embodied in a country's domestic legislation or through the bilateral provisions of a double taxation agreement (hereafter referred to as an estate tax treaty).
10
10 The OECD encourages unilateral relief to alleviate double taxation due to the limited network of estate tax treaties (see OECD Inheritance Taxation 128). Also see Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 22.
Section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act
11
11 Section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act 45 of 1955 (the Estate Duty Act) states that a deduction against estate duty is allowed "without in any way modifying or adding to the rights of any person under an agreement entered into by the Government of the Republic with the Government of any other country or territory relating to the prevention of or relief from double taxation in respect of estate duty, any amount of any death duties proved to the satisfaction of the Commissioner to have been paid to any other State in respect of any property situate outside the Republic and included in the estate of any person who at the date of his death was ordinarily resident in the Republic: Provided that the deduction under this paragraph shall not exceed the duty imposed on such property by this Act." 12 Proviso to s 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act. Also see Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 30.8; Stiglingh et al Silke: South African Income Tax 1017; Haupt Notes on South African Income Tax 882; Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 111; De Ferm v Von Lieres und Wilkau (WCHC) (unreported) case number 10805/2023 of 11 October 2023 para 26.
If an estate tax treaty exists, the relief under the estate tax treaty applies and section 16(c) is not available.
13
13 Section 16(c) read with s 26 of the Estate Duty Act; Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 30.8, 31.1; Davis, Jooste and Beneke Estate Planning 2.8H; Stiglingh et al Silke: South African Income Tax 1017-1018; Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 112. This conclusion is based on the wording of s 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act, that grants a credit without any modification or addition to the rights of any person under an estate tax treaty. This implies that where an estate tax treaty exists, the relief in respect of the foreign death duty is limited to the application of the estate tax treaty and the unilateral relief under s 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act is unavailable. 14 Bornman Impact of Estate Duty and Capital Gains Tax on Offshore Assets 64; Whitfield Taxation Implications 119; Wilson Potential Cross-Border Double Taxation on Death 29; Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 30.8, 31.1; Davis, Jooste and Beneke Estate Planning 2.8H; Stiglingh et al Silke: South African Income Tax 1017-1018.
For example, person A (who is ordinarily resident in South Africa and owns UK-sourced immovable property) dies. The dutiable amount of person A's estate is less than R30 million and the estate duty rate applicable in South Africa (as the country of residence) is 20%. The UK (as the country of source) imposes an inheritance tax of 40%. According to the estate tax treaty between the UK and South Africa, relief from double taxation should be granted by South Africa as the country of residence. The relief will be limited to the estate duty liability in South Africa, which is 20%. The remaining 20% inheritance tax liability will remain payable in the UK.
South Africa has entered into an estate tax treaty with the UK, the USA and Zimbabwe, as well as a combined treaty with Botswana, Lesotho and eSwatini.
15
15 Swaziland's name changed to eSwatini with effect from 19 April 2018. This change resulted from the official declaration by King Mswati III that the Kingdom of Swaziland was now to be known as the Kingdom of eSwatini in honour of the country's independence (see Legal Notice 80 of 2018 (The Declaration of Change of Swaziland Name Notice, 2018) published in the Gazette of 11 May 2018 but deemed to have come into effect on 19 April 2018). Also see Adams & Adams 2018 https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=278eafa1-d6c5-4be5-9524-10f1900fbe0c. The estate tax treaties with Botswana, Lesotho and eSwatini (previously referred to as the BLS countries), Zimbabwe and the USA were concluded under the provisions of the Death Duties Act 29 of 1922 but are still in force as the treaties continue to apply in respect of any similar taxes subsequently enacted by the contracting states. The treaty with the UK was entered into under s 26 of the Estate Duty Act and is also the only estate tax treaty that South Africa entered into that can be compared with the Estate Tax Model (see Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 23 and SARS date unknown https://www.sars.gov.za/legal-counsel/international-treaties-agreements/estate-duty-agreements/). 16 Rudnick and Gordon "Taxation of Wealth" 324; Wilson Potential Cross-Border Double Taxation on Death 22-25; Ger 2012 De Rebus 59; Ostler Impact of Estate Planning 53-54.
From an international perspective the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), which designs tax policies to align the tax treatment across countries in various fields, supports the enhancement of unilateral provisions due to the limited estate tax treaty network.
17
17 OECD Inheritance Taxation 74; Rudnick and Gordon "Taxation of Wealth" 325. 18 Section 16(c) does not currently provide for a detailed list of qualifying foreign property and would therefore include the meaning of "property" under s 3 of the Estate Duty Act. The OECD states that unilateral relief is usually provided for immovable property situated abroad, but it is often incomplete as the relief may be limited to certain types of property or to possible mismatches in the inheritance and estate tax rules of different countries (OECD Inheritance Taxation 74). Also see Michaelides International Tax Consequences 51; Wilson Potential Cross-Border Double Taxation on Death 33; Thorpe Is It Time to Abolish Estate Duty in South Africa? 39; Roeleveld 2015 SAJAR 159. 19 The Estate Duty Act does not contain any limitation rule but in practice the same approach is followed as when the estate duty liability must be apportioned for the purposes of the rapid succession rebate under the First Schedule to the Estate Duty Act. See Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 30.8; Meyerowitz 1987 The Taxpayer 117.
The following section will attempt to establish clarity in regard to these various issues in respect of unilateral relief under section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act.
2 Unilateral relief under section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act
2.1 Qualifying foreign taxes
Section 16(c) does not define what would constitute qualifying foreign death duties. Whitfield
20
20 Whitfield Taxation Implications 161, 182. 21 Michaelides International Tax Consequences 65. 22 Roeleveld 2015 SAJAR 159.
As mentioned above, double international juridical taxation arises where the same or a similar tax is imposed by different countries on the same taxpayer on the same property at the same time. In the case of inheritance tax payable by the beneficiary, the requirement of a tax imposed on the same
taxpayer is not met. However, it is accepted that it is still a similar tax imposed on the same asset by different countries at the same time (death). Roeleveld
23
23 Roeleveld 2015 SAJAR 159. 24 Michaelides International Tax Consequences 66.
Beckmann
25
25 Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 200, 225.
Since the inclusion of section 16(c) in 1960 the wording has remained the same.
26
26 Section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act was added by s 5(c) of the Estate Duty Amendment Act 65 of 1960. 27 Michaelides International Tax Consequences 66. 28 Oxford Reference 2023 https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority. 20110803095704769. The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines it as a death tax; see Merriam-Webster Dictionary 2023 https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ death%20duty. 29 Dictionary.com 2023 https://www.dictionary.com/browse/death-duty. Also see Nevil 2023 https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/death-taxes.asp. 30 Nevil 2023 https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/death-taxes.asp.
taxes. The OECD
31
31 OECD date unknown https://www.oecd.org/ctp/glossaryoftaxterms.htm.
Based on the above, it is clear that the term "death duties" is interchangeably used with "estate tax" and "inheritance tax" and means a tax levied upon death in respect of a deceased person's estate and specifically the property of an estate and not the income of the estate. In the context of estate duty, a transferor-based estate tax payable by the foreign estate clearly fits within the words "estate duty". According to the OECD,
32
32 OECD Model Double Taxation Convention on Estates and Inheritances and on Gifts (OECD Estate Tax Model) 102; OECD Inheritance Taxation 63-64. 33 Also see OECD Inheritance Taxation 64, specifically for Portugal, where stamp duty on inheritances is levied upon death on the transfer of property. It is levied at a flat rate of ten per cent on the net value of the estate. The stamp duty replaced the previous progressive inheritance tax system to cater for a simpler form of tax. Also see Michaelides International Tax Consequences 26-27; European Commission Expert Group 2015 https://www.kessler.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Ways-to-tackle-inheritance-cross-border-tax-obstacles.pdf 8. 34 In some instances, stamp duty is also levied upon death. This may be considered as a tax on the property of the deceased person. See OECD Inheritance Taxation 64. 35 OECD Estate Tax Model 90. 36 Roeleveld 2015 SAJAR 159. 37 Wilson Potential Cross-Border Double Taxation on Death 23. 38 Wilson Potential Cross-Border Double Taxation on Death 23; Roeleveld 2015 SAJAR 159. This view is aligned with the OECD's view (see OECD Estate Tax Model 2). Also see OECD Inheritance Taxation 63-64, where a list is provided of the death duties that are levied worldwide upon the estate at the death of a taxpayer. 39 OECD Inheritance Taxation 63-64, 111.
It is therefore concluded that to eliminate the double taxation in respect of the same property upon death, a qualifying foreign tax for the purposes of section 16(c) could include an inheritance tax, a gift tax or an estate tax levied upon death but could exclude any foreign income taxes (including CGT).
40
40 Most foreign countries do not levy CGT upon death and, therefore, the incidence of having to pay CGT in a foreign country and estate duty in South Africa at the same
time is minimal. For relief in respect of double taxation in respect of CGT, s 6quat of the Income Tax Act 58 of 1962 (the Income Tax Act) should be relied upon. See Roeleveld 2015 SAJAR 152; Wilson Potential Cross-Border Double Taxation on Death 32, Ostler Impact of Estate Planning 52; Thorpe Is It Time to Abolish Estate Duty in South Africa? 81; OECD Inheritance Taxation 63-64. Also see Michaelides International Tax Consequences 66, where it is submitted the ordinary meaning of "death duties" includes all foreign estate-related taxes, excluding income-related taxes.
The following section will consider the scope of foreign property that may qualify for unilateral relief under section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act.
2.2 Qualifying property
Section 16(c) does not provide for a detailed list of qualifying foreign property and would therefore include the meaning of "property" under sections 3(1)
41
41 Section 3(1) of the Estate Duty Act states "For the purposes of this Act the estate of any person shall consist of all property of that person as at the date of his death and of all property which in accordance with this Act is deemed to be property of that person at that date." 42 Also see Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 27.2; Davis, Jooste and Beneke Estate Planning 2.3.2. 43 Section 3(2) of the Estate Duty Act. 44 Section 3(2)(a) of the Estate Duty Act. Also see Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 68-69; Davis, Jooste and Beneke Estate Planning 2.3.2; Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 27.2. 45 Section 3(2)(b) of the Estate Duty Act. Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 68-69; Davis, Jooste and Beneke Estate Planning 2.3.2; Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 27.2.
The Estate Duty Act does not provide a detailed definition of what would constitute "foreign property" in the estate of a person who is ordinarily resident in South Africa. Also, no such list is found in any leading work in relation to estate duty and international deceased estates. However, even though the Estate Duty Act does not specifically state what would constitute "foreign property", it is generally understood and explained that the worldwide property of an ordinary resident is included in the estate for estate duty purposes.
46
46 Haupt Notes on South African Income Tax 863; Stiglingh et al Silke: South African Income Tax 1000; Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 27.2; Davis, Jooste and Beneke Estate Planning 2.2.
interpreted to include the foreign counterpart of any property listed in sections 3(1), (2)(a) and (b) of the Estate Duty Act.
Beckmann
47
47 Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 73. 48 Law of Property and Law of Succession. 49 Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 77. 50 Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 77.
It is submitted that it may not be feasible to provide a detailed list of foreign property in the Estate Duty Act as each foreign country involved may have its own rules regarding the different types of property. However, the generally accepted approach of including worldwide assets seems to be aligned internationally and, to the extent that a conflict in rules occurs, the approach discussed by Beckmann is supported where it will be included only if it aligns with South African rules. A possible clarification that could be considered for the purposes of section 16(c) would be to refer to foreign property that is defined or treated in a manner similar to that in which it is defined or treated in South Africa.
The next section discusses the guidance that is required regarding the exchange rate that should be applied in converting (to South African Rands), a foreign death duty paid in a foreign currency, to calculate the available relief.
2.3 Conversion of a foreign death duty liability
For the purposes of calculating the unilateral relief under the Estate Duty Act, it is important that the value of the foreign death duty paid be converted to South African currency to determine the allowable credit. The Estate Duty Act makes no provision for the exchange rate that must be used for the
purposes of section 16(c).
51
51 Michaelides International Tax Consequences 67; Meyerowitz 1987 The Taxpayer 117. 52 Michaelides International Tax Consequences 67. 53 Defined in s 1 of the Income Tax Act as "[T]he appropriate quoted exchange rate at a specific time by any authorised dealer in foreign exchange for the delivery of the currency."
The provision equivalent for income tax purposes to section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act is section 6quat of the Income Tax Act 58 of 1962 (the Income Tax Act), which similarly allows for a credit against the South African income tax liability for any foreign income tax payable in respect of foreign income that is also included in the South African taxable income.
54
54 Section 6quat(1) of the Income Tax Act. Also see SARS 2022 https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/Legal-IN-18-Rebate-and-deduction-for-foreign-taxes-on-income.pdf (SARS Interpretation Note No 18) 85. 55 Defined in s 1 of the Income Tax Act as "[T]he average determined by using the closing spot rates at the end of daily or monthly intervals during that year of assessment which must be consistently applied within that year of assessment." 56 See Haupt Notes on South African Income Tax 574; Stiglingh et al Silke: South African Income Tax 510; Michaelides International Tax Consequences 57; SARS Interpretation Note No 18 85. 57 Michaelides International Tax Consequences 57-58.
If the provision of section 6quat(1) is compared to that of section 16(c), it is noted that for the credit to apply, the foreign death duty must be paid, whereas for section 6quat purposes the foreign taxes must be proved to be payable and not necessarily actually paid. Estate duty is a once-off tax in comparison to income tax, which is levied on an annual basis.
In the context of section 16(c), an average rate over a period may minimise the effect of exchange rate differences over the different liability dates and payment dates as those differences are evened out. However, a more accurate amount is obtained by applying the spot rate, based on the actual payment made on a specific date. That will further provide certainty as to the amount that can be claimed as a credit. Goodwin
58
58 Goodwin 2019 https://www.lawskills.co.uk/articles/2019/10/the-impact-of-exchange-rates-when-administering-estates/.
although a fixed exchange rate will most likely remove the risk involved, the difficulty lies in what the right time is to set the rate. He further states that the volatility of the currency markets is a challenge as it may result in short-term spikes in rates or sudden drops.
59
59 Goodwin 2019 https://www.lawskills.co.uk/articles/2019/10/the-impact-of-exchange-rates-when-administering-estates/.
Michaelides
60
60 Michaelides International Tax Consequences 67. 61 Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 202. Beckmann refers to the same issue under the German inheritance tax law, where no legislative guidance is provided regarding the exchange rate to be used, but in practice the date when the liability comes into existence is used. 62 Section 9C read with s 10(1) of the Estate Duty Act.
The Income Tax Act also contains other exchange rate provisions applicable in different contexts,
63
63 Section 24I(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act; SARS 2023 https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/Legal-IntR-IN-101-Gains-or-losses-on-foreign-exchange-transactions.pdf 6-7. Also see Haupt Notes on South African Income Tax 571; Stiglingh et al Silke: South African Income Tax 516; SARS Interpretation Note No 18 86. 64 SARS 2015 https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/LAPD-IntR-IN-2012-63-Rules-Translation-Amounts-Foreign-Currencies.pdf 9-10.
outcome can be chosen when claiming the section 16(c) credit and the impact of the volatility of the markets can be minimised.
When considering an average exchange rate, the period over which the average should be applied becomes relevant. Estate duty is not determined in respect of a year of assessment but as a once-off tax on the value of the deceased estate as at the date of death. In the context of an inheritance tax, the liability is calculated in respect of the value of the inheritance due to the beneficiary.
A possible period over which the rate could be determined is the period from the date of death to the date of payment. As stated above, the average rate approach may provide greater flexibility in determining the converted value and may mitigate the impact of the volatility of the markets. An alternative could even include an election between a spot rate and an average rate over a qualified period, as under section 25D of the Income Tax Act. However, as death duty-related taxes are not intended to be a continuous liability, it is submitted that the spot rate on the date of payment of the foreign death duties should be considered.
65
65 Seade "Tax Revenue Implications of Exchange Rate Adjustment" 54. Seade comments that the impact of exchange rates and their relevance and application in tax legislation have hardly ever been addressed.
The next section discusses various elements regarding a limitation rule for the purpose of the application of section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act.
2.4 Limitation rule
2.4.1 General
The deduction in respect of foreign death duties is limited to the amount of estate duty payable in respect of the property in South Africa. This implies that the allowable deduction is the lesser of the estate duty payable and the foreign death duty paid on the property.
66
66 Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 30.8; Meyerowitz 1987 The Taxpayer 117.
2.4.2 Method to calculate the attribution of the foreign death duty liability
The Estate Duty Act does not provide for a method on how the foreign death duty or the estate duty attributable to the foreign property should be calculated. However, the following method is used in practice:
67
67 Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 30.8; Meyerowitz 1987 The Taxpayer 117. Also see OECD Estate Tax Model 180, where the same method is recommended in determining the foreign duties attributable for the purpose of calculating a credit.
x = a/b x c, where x = estate duty attributable to the foreign property a = value of the foreign property included in the net value of the estate b = net value of the estate in South Africa
68
68 The net value according to s 4 of the Estate Duty Act is calculated based on the total property and deemed property, less all available deductions, before taking into account the s 4A rebate of R3.5 million. c = estate duty payable on the dutiable amount The value of "x" is then reduced by the foreign death duty payable that cannot exceed the value of the estate duty payable in South Africa.
69
69 Section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act. |
Meyerowitz
70
70 Meyerowitz Administration of Estates 30.8. Also see Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates 111; De Ferm v Von Lieres und Wilkau (WCHC) (unreported) case number 10805 / 2023 of 11 October 2023 para 30, where it is stated that a foreign inheritance tax is often calculated on the receipt by the legatee in comparison to the value of the property stipulated in a will.
2.4.3 Time rule
The Estate Duty Act does not under section 16(c) provide any limitation in respect of the period during which the credit may be claimed. This effectively means that the period is open-ended, which is contradictory to administering an estate in an efficient and speedy manner. Similarly, rules of prescription apply to ensure that tax is administered in an effective manner to prevent claims from being submitted years after the deceased's tax affairs have been concluded. In the context of an estate, a time rule would also minimise unnecessary delays and encourage effective administration. The European Commission
71
71 European Commission 2011 OJ 84.
should address their unilateral provisions regarding relief of double inheritance taxation that the tax relief should be allowed only for a reasonable period, for example, for a period of ten years from the date of liability. The European Commission Expert Group
72
72 European Commission Expert Group 2015 https://www.kessler.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Ways-to-tackle-inheritance-cross-border-tax-obstacles.pdf 22. 73 European Commission 2011 OJ 82.
Estate duty is a SARS-assessed tax,
74
74 See the definition of assessment in s 1 of the Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011 (the Tax Administration Act), which means "the determination of the amount of a tax liability or refund, by way of self-assessment by the taxpayer or assessment by SARS." 75 Section 99(1)(a) of the Tax Administration Act. 76 Section 9(4)(a) and (b) read with s 9(5) of the Estate Duty Act. These exceptions include the scenario where no SARS assessment was issued in respect of an estate falling within s 18(3) of the Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965 (where the estate has a gross value of less than R250 000) and where additional assets are found within five years after the estate was distributed. 77 Section 1 of the Tax Administration Act defines a "self-assessment" as the "determination of the amount of tax payable under a tax Act by a taxpayer and— (a) submitting a return which incorporates the determination of the tax; or (b) if no return is required, making a payment of the tax." 78 Section 99(1)(b) and (c) of the Tax Administration Act. 79 The US allows for an estate tax liability to be paid over a period of ten years provided certain requirements are met.
3 International comparison
3.1 United Kingdom
The United Kingdom (the UK) levies a transferor-based inheritance tax that operates like estate duty where the liability is calculated on the value of the estate at death and payable by the executor.
The UK inheritance tax legislation makes provision for double taxation relief in one of two ways, namely through estate tax treaties
80
80 The UK has an existing estate tax treaty with South Africa to cover lifetime transfers as well as transfers on death. See Muller Wealth Transfer Taxation 276. 81 Sections 158 and 159 of the Inheritance Tax Act, 1984 (the Inheritance Tax Act). 82 Section 159(2) of the Inheritance Tax Act. HMRC 2023 https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/inheritance-tax-manual/ihtm27185.
In the case where the property is neither situated in the foreign jurisdiction nor the UK, or if it is situated in both the foreign jurisdiction and the UK, the relief is calculated according to a specific formula.
83
83 Section 159(3) of the Inheritance Tax Act. The formula is A/(A + B) = C, where A is the amount of inheritance tax payable, B is the amount of tax payable in the foreign jurisdiction and C is the smaller of A and B.
If an estate tax treaty exists, the relief under the treaty will be applied,
84
84 Section 158 of the Inheritance Tax Act. 85 Section 159(7) of the Inheritance Tax Act.
3.2 United States
The United States (the US) levies a transferor-based estate tax on the value of the estate at death, which is payable by the executor. Double estate taxation arises when a US citizen or resident owns property situated in a foreign country. The US, as the country of residence, taxes the worldwide property of the deceased, and the foreign country where the property is situated may tax the property as the country of source.
86
86 IRS 2020 https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-025-004. 87 OECD Estate Tax Model 14; Rudnick and Gordon "Taxation of Wealth" 324.
Relief for double estate taxation is provided unilaterally under section 2014 of the Internal Revenue Code, 1986 (the Internal Revenue Code) or bilaterally through the application of a tax treaty in the form of a tax credit for any death taxes paid to a foreign country by a US citizen or US resident.
88
88 Rudnick and Gordon "Taxation of Wealth" 324. 89 Section 2014(a) and (b) of the Internal Revenue Code, 1986 (the Internal Revenue Code).
Taxes that are considered similar to death taxes include estate tax, inheritance tax, legacy tax, succession tax or a similar transfer tax.
90
90 Sections 2014 and 2053 of the Internal Revenue Code. Foreign death taxes paid to a foreign jurisdiction on property not situated in that country or on property not included in the gross estate do not qualify for a credit. The foreign taxes paid are converted to US dollars on the day they are paid by using the rate of exchange on that day. Such clarity, pertaining to issues such as the type of foreign tax to be paid and the date on which the conversion to South African Rand should take place, is lacking under the Estate Duty Act. 91 See ss 2014 and 2053(d)(1) of the Internal Revenue Code. Also see IRS 2020 https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-025-004. South Africa does not have a similar election and unilateral relief is limited to a credit under s 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act.
The available credit is not unlimited and is subject to the following requirements:
(a) The qualifying tax credit in respect of foreign death taxes paid is limited to the total federal estate tax attributable to the property.
92
92 Section 2014(b) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(b) The period allowed to submit a claim for a tax credit is four years from the date the estate tax return is filed provided the foreign taxes were paid.
93
93 Section 2014(e) read with s 6018 of the Internal Revenue Code. Also see IRS 2020 https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-025-004. Proof of the payment of the foreign death taxes must be provided to the IRS before the credit will be allowed (see s 2014(e)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code). 94 Section 2014(e)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(c) If a petition for the redetermination of a deficiency was filed with the Tax Court within the required periods, the claim must be submitted within the four years or before the expiration of 60 days after the decision of the Tax Court becomes final.
95
95 Section 2014(e)(1) of the Internal Revenue Code.
If the relief available under a tax treaty is more favourable than the unilateral relief under the Internal Revenue Code, the executor can elect for the treaty relief to apply.
96
96 IRS 2020 https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-025-004. To claim the relevant relief, Form 706 should be submitted, and it must indicate the treaty provision being invoked. 97 IRS 2020 https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-025-004 read with s 2053 of the Internal Revenue Code. If death taxes were paid to a political subdivision or possession not covered by the tax treaty, the available credit will be the greater of the treaty relief, the statutory relief of a combination of the treaty relief in addition to the statutory relief.
4 Conclusion
The OECD Estate Tax Model has not been updated since 1982 and the European Commission has provided useful recommendations for the purposes of updating unilateral relief provisions in respect of double estate taxation. The OECD in its latest report, Inheritance Taxation in OECD Countries (2021), aligns its recommendations with those made by the European Commission as a sound basis on which unilateral relief provisions can be reviewed.
The lack of clear statutory guidance to claiming unilateral relief in South Africa in respect of double estate taxation was discussed, and various recommendations are proposed to enhance certainty under section 16(c) of the Estate Duty Act.
To address the uncertainty regarding the type of foreign death duty and qualifying foreign assets that may fall within section 16(c), a definition for "death duties" under section 1 of the Estate Duty Act,
98
98 See para 2.1 above. 99 See para 2.2 above. 100 See para 2.3 above.
It is further recommended that the existing limitation rule where the relief is limited to the value of the estate duty payable in South Africa in respect of the foreign asset be expanded to provide guidance on the method where an appropriation of foreign duties to an asset is required.
101
101 See para 2.4.2 above.
applied for. It is further suggested that a standard rule of, for example, five years from the date the liability arises should apply, and the Commissioner should be provided with the discretion to extend the period up to a maximum of ten years, provided sufficient proof of why the extension is needed can be provided.
102
102 See para 2.4.3 above.
In addition to the above, clear conditions on when the relief can apply should be considered. For example, the relief should not be allowed automatically, but only if applied for on death duties paid in respect of the same asset that is also subject to estate duty in South Africa, and if a tax treaty exists the unilateral relief is not available.
It is argued that implementing the above suggestions would promote the canon of certainty by providing clear guidance on how and when relief from double estate taxation can be claimed.
Bibliography
Literature
Beckmann Estate Duty on Deceased Estates
Beckmann NF Some Aspects of Estate Duty on Deceased Estates in the Republic of South Africa – with Special Reference to the Problems and Effects of Double Taxation Occurring in Relation to the German Erbschaftsteuergesetz (Inheritance Tax Act) (LLM-dissertation University of Cape Town 1993)
Bornman Impact of Estate Duty and Capital Gains Tax on Offshore Assets
Bornman C Estate Planning: The Impact of Estate Duty and Capital Gains Tax on Offshore Assets (LLM-mini-dissertation North-West University 2010)
Butler Condensed Wealth of Nations
Butler E The Condensed Wealth of Nations and The Incredibly Condensed Theory of Moral Sentiments (Adam Smith Research Trust London 2011)
Croome Taxpayers' Rights in South Africa
Croome B Taxpayers' Rights in South Africa: An Analysis and Evaluation of the Extent to which the Powers of the South African Revenue Service Comply with the Constitutional Rights to Property, Privacy, Administrative Justice, Access to Information and Access to Courts (PhD-thesis University of Cape Town 2008)
Davis, Jooste and Beneke Estate Planning
Davis DM, Jooste RD and Beneke C Estate Planning (electronic version) (LexisNexis Cape Town 2022)
European Commission 2011 OJ
European Commission "Commission Recommendation of 15 December 2011 Regarding Relief for Double Taxation of Inheritances" 2011 OJ 81-84
Ger 2012 De Rebus
Ger B "Time for Estate Duty to go?" 2012 De Rebus 59-62
Haupt Notes on South African Income Tax
Haupt P Notes on South African Income Tax 39th ed (H & H Publications Roggebaai 2020)
Margo Commission Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Tax Structure
Margo Commission Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Tax Structure of the Republic of South Africa by the Margo Commissioner (Government Printer Pretoria 1987)
Meade Structure and Reform of Direct Taxation
Meade JE The Structure and Reform of Direct Taxation (George Allen & Unwin London 1978)
Meyerowitz Administration of Estates
Meyerowitz D Meyerowitz on Administration of Estates and their Taxation (Juta Cape Town 2016)
Meyerowitz 1987 The Taxpayer
Meyerowitz D "Estate Duty – Successive Deaths – Rebate of Duty under Proviso to First Schedule – Ascertainment of 'Duty Attributable' to the Inclusion in Estate of Second-Dying of Property Inherited from the First-Dying" 1987 The Taxpayer 117-121
Michaelides International Tax Consequences
Michaelides G The International Tax Consequences Arising on the Death of South African Individuals Owning Greek or Portuguese Property and Greeks or Portuguese Owning South African Property (MCom-dissertation University of Cape Town 2011)
Muller Wealth Transfer Taxation
Muller E A Framework for Wealth Transfer Taxation in South Africa (LLD-dissertation University of Pretoria 2010)
OECD Inheritance Taxation
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Inheritance Taxation in OECD Countries (OECD Publishing Paris 2021)
OECD Model Double Taxation Convention on Estates and Inheritances and on Gifts
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Model Double Taxation Convention on Estates and Inheritances and on Gifts (OECD Publishing Paris 1983)
OECD Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital 2017
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital 2017 (Full Version) (OECD Publishing Paris 2019)
Ostaszweska and Obuoforibo Roy Rohatgi on International Taxation
Ostaszweska O and Obuoforibo B Roy Rohatgi on International Taxation [Volume 1: Principles] (Juta Cape Town 2020)
Ostler Impact of Estate Planning
Ostler LM The Impact of Estate Planning on the Effectiveness of Estate Duty as a Wealth Tax in South Africa (MCom-dissertation Rhodes University 2012)
Roeleveld 2015 SAJAR
Roeleveld J "An Argument for Either Excluding Death as a Capital Gains Tax Event or Abolishing Estate Duty" 2015 SAJAR 143-164
Rudnick and Gordon "Taxation of Wealth"
Rudnick RS and Gordon RK "Taxation of Wealth" in Thuronyi V (ed) Tax Law Design and Drafting (International Monetary Fund Washington DC 1996) 292-339
Seade "Tax Revenue Implications of Exchange Rate Adjustment"
Seade J "Tax Revenue Implications of Exchange Rate Adjustment" in Tanzi V (ed) Fiscal Policy in Open Developing Economies (International Monetary Fund Washington DC 1990) 54-65
Stiglingh et al Silke: South African Income Tax
Stiglingh M et al Silke: South African Income Tax 2021 (LexisNexis Cape Town 2020)
Thorpe Is It Time to Abolish Estate Duty in South Africa?
Thorpe L Is It Time to Abolish Estate Duty in South Africa? A Comparative Look at Global Trends in Levying Death Taxes and the Feasibility of Suggested Changes to South Africa's Current Regime (LLM-dissertation University of Cape Town 2015)
Weber-Frisch and Duquennois-Djoua 2014 ERA Forum
Weber-Frisch N and Duquennois-Djoua R "Domestic Inheritance Tax Rules in EU Member States Regarding Cross-Border Successions" 2014 ERA Forum: Journal of the Academy of European Law 409-424
Whitfield Taxation Implications
Whitfield RB Taxation Implications Arising from South African Residents Owning or Having a Tax Interest in Fixed Property in Greece (MCom-dissertation University of South Africa 2008)
Williams Income Tax in South Africa
Williams RC Income Tax in South Africa: Cases and Materials 4th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2015)
Wilson Potential Cross-Border Double Taxation on Death
Wilson K Potential Cross-Border Double Taxation on Death Limits Global Investment Opportunities for Long Term South African Resident Investors (MCom-dissertation University of Cape Town 2019)
Case law
De Ferm v Von Lieres und Wilkau (WCHC) (unreported) case number 10805 / 2023 of 11 October 2023
Legislation
South Africa
Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965
Death Duties Act 29 of 1922
Estate Duty Act 45 of 1955
Estate Duty Amendment Act 65 of 1960
Income Tax Act 58 of 1962
Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011
United Kingdom
Inheritance Tax Act, 1984
United States
Internal Revenue Code, 1986
Government publications
eSwatini
Legal Notice 80 of 2018 (The Declaration of Change of Swaziland Name Notice, 2018)
Internet resources
Adams & Adams 2018 https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=278 eafa1-d6c5-4be5-9524-10f1900fbe0c
Adams & Adams 2018 Eswatini | Swaziland Name Change Made Official by Notice in Gazette https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx? g=278eafa1-d6c5-4be5-9524-10f1900fbe0c accessed 20 September 2023
Dictionary.com 2023 https://www.dictionary.com/browse/death-duty
Dictionary.com 2023 Death Duty https://www.dictionary.com/browse/death-duty accessed 25 March 2023
DTC 2015 https://www.taxcom.org.za/docs/20150723%20DTC%20First% 20Interim%20Report%20on%20Estate%20Duty%20-%20website.pdf
Davis Tax Committee 2015 First and Interim Report on Estate Duty https://www.taxcom.org.za/docs/20150723%20DTC%20First%20Interim%20Report%20on%20Estate%20Duty%20-%20website.pdf accessed 21 February 2022
European Commission Expert Group 2015 https://www.kessler.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Ways-to-tackle-inheritance-cross-border-tax-obstacles.pdf
European Commission Expert Group 2015 Ways to Tackle Inheritance Cross-Border Tax Obstacles Facing Individuals within the EU https://www.kessler.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Ways-to-tackle-inheritance-cross-border-tax-obstacles.pdf accessed 23 March 2023
Goodwin 2019 https://www.lawskills.co.uk/articles/2019/10/the-impact-of-exchange-rates-when-administering-estates/
Goodwin 2019 The Impact of Exchange Rates when Administering Estates https://www.lawskills.co.uk/articles/2019/10/the-impact-of-exchange-rates-when-administering-estates/ accessed 31 March 2023
HMRC 2023 https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/inheritance-tax-manual/ihtm27185
HM Revenue & Customs 2023 Foreign Property: Double Taxation Conventions: Procedure with Non-Convention Countries: Introduction https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/inheritance-tax-manual/ihtm27185 accessed 26 September 2023
IRS 2020 https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-025-004
Internal Revenue Service 2020 International Estate and Gift Tax Examinations https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-025-004 accessed 4 October 2022
Jestle 2018 https://wiiw.ac.at/inheritance-tax-regimes-a-comparison-dlp-4690.pdf
Jestle S 2018 Inheritance Tax Regimes: A Comparison https://wiiw.ac.at/inheritance-tax-regimes-a-comparison-dlp-4690.pdf accessed 2 June 2023
Katz Commission 1997 http://www.treasury.gov.za/publications/ other/katz/4.pdf
Katz Commission 1997 Fourth Report on Capital Transfer http://www.treasury.gov.za/publications/other/katz/4.pdf accessed 10 January 2022
Lambert 1992 https://cooperative-individualism.org/lambert-ian_some-modern-principles-of-taxation-adam-smith-revisited-1992-jan.htm
Lambert ITG 1992 Some Modern Principles of Taxation Adam Smith Revisited https://cooperative-individualism.org/lambert-ian_some-modern-principles-of-taxation-adam-smith-revisited-1992-jan.htm accessed 10 January 2022
Merriam-Webster Dictionary 2023 https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/death%20duty
Merriam-Webster Dictionary 2023 Death Duty https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/death%20duty accessed 25 March 2023
Nevil 2023 https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/death-taxes.asp
Nevil S 2023 What are Death Taxes? How to Reduce or Avoid Them? https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/death-taxes.asp accessed 25 March 2023
OECD date unknown https://www.oecd.org/ctp/glossaryoftaxterms.htm
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development date unknown Glossary of Tax Terms https://www.oecd.org/ctp/glossaryoftaxterms.htm accessed 28 March 2023
Oxford Reference 2023 https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/ oi/authority.20110803095704769
Oxford Reference 2023 Death Duties https://www.oxfordreference.com/ view/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803095704769 accessed 25 March 2023
SARS date unknown https://www.sars.gov.za/legal-counsel/international-treaties-agreements/estate-duty-agreements/
South African Revenue Service date unknown Estate Duty Agreements https://www.sars.gov.za/legal-counsel/international-treaties-agreements/estate-duty-agreements/ accessed 5 August 2023
SARS 2015 https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/ LAPD-IntR-IN-2012-63-Rules-Translation-Amounts-Foreign-Currencies.pdf
South African Revenue Service 2015 Interpretation Note No 63 (Issue 2): Rules for the Translation of Amounts Measured in Foreign Currencies Other than Exchange Differences Governed by Section 24I and the Eighth Schedule https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/LAPD-IntR-IN-2012-63-Rules-Translation-Amounts-Foreign-Currencies.pdf accessed 26 September 2023
SARS 2022 https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/ Legal-IN-18-Rebate-and-deduction-for-foreign-taxes-on-income.pdf
South African Revenue Service 2022 Interpretation Note No 18 (Issue 5): Rebate and Deduction for Foreign Taxes on Income https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/Legal-IN-18-
Rebate-and-deduction-for-foreign-taxes-on-income.pdf accessed 26 September 2023
SARS 2023 https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/ Legal-IntR-IN-101-Gains-or-losses-on-foreign-exchange-transactions.pdf
South African Revenue Service 2023 Interpretation Note No 101 (Issue 2): Gains or Losses on Foreign Exchange Transactions https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/Legal-IntR-IN-101-Gains-or-losses-on-foreign-exchange-transactions.pdf accessed 26 September 2023
List of Abbreviations
CGT |
Capital gains tax |
---|---|
DTC |
Davis Tax Committee |
HMRC |
HM Revenue & Customs |
IRS |
Internal Revenue Service |
OECD |
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development |
OJ |
Official Journal of the European Union |
SAJAR |
South African Journal of Accounting Research |
SARS |
South African Revenue Service |
UK |
United Kingdom |
US / USA |
United States / United States of America |