Independent Candidacy and Electoral Reform: New Nation Movement NPC v President of the Republic of South Africa

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2022/v25ia12746

Keywords:

Accountability, closed-list party system, electoral system, inclusivity, independent candidacy, multi-party democracy, parliamentary system, proportional representation, transparency

Abstract

In the New Nation case, the Constitutional Court declared the provisions of the Electoral Act that prevent independent candidates from competing in provincial and national elections unconstitutional. It ruled that the impugned provisions violated independent candidates' constitutional rights to stand for public office, to freedom of association and to dignity. In a minority judgment, Froneman J disagreed and held that the Constitution contemplates a right to contest elections as a party-nominee only. The differences between the majority and minority judgments are largely the result of distinct interpretive approaches. The majority conducted an analysis of the right to stand for public office within a restricted textual framework that has the potential to disturb the harmonious inter-relationship between the right and the electoral and parliamentary framework for its realisation. This result flows from the fact that the Constitution still reflects the exclusively party-based electoral and parliamentary systems of its predecessor in several important respects. At best, this situation may result in independents being largely at the mercy of political parties for meaningful execution of their legislative and oversight obligations. At worst, they may be excluded from exercising core parliamentary functions altogether. Therefore, to avoid disturbing the normative coherence between the right to stand for public office, the foundational democratic values, and the electoral and parliamentary arrangements, constitutional amendments appear to be necessary for the implementation of the court's order. In any event, expectations about the contribution to electoral reform of allowing independents to contest elections must be tempered by the low political impact of independent representatives on governance, as well as the ambivalence surrounding the democratic functionality of independent candidacy, when measured against the values of transparency and accountability.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Literature

Botha H and Woolman S "Limitations" in Woolman S et al (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa Service 2 (Juta Cape Town 2014) 34‒1 - 34‒136

Brancati D "Winning Alone: The Electoral Fate of Independent Candidates Worldwide" 2008 The Journal of Politics 648-662 https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022381608080675 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022381608080675

Ehin P et al Independent Candidates in National and European Elections (European Parliament Brussels 2013)

Ehin P and Solvak M "Party Voters Gone Astray: Explaining Independent Candidate Success in the 2009 European Elections in Estonia" 2012 Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties 269-291 https://doi.org/10.1080/17457289.2012.682579 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17457289.2012.682579

Eisner KD "Non-major-party Candidates and Televised Presidential Debates: The Merits of Legislative Inclusion" 1993 U Pa L Rev 973-1027 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3312447

Fick G "Elections" in Woolman S et al (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa Service 2 (Juta Cape Town 2014) 29‒1 - 29‒32

Karyeija GK "The Impact of Independent Members of Parliament in Multi-Party Democracies: The Ugandan Case" 2019 Africa Journal of Public Sector Development and Governance 60-71 https://journals.co.za/

doi/10.10520/EJC-1b111ec56c

Kreuser C and Slade B "Decreasing Voter Participation in South Africa and the Call for Electoral Reform through Allowing Independent Candidates" 2021 SAPL 1-22

Mateng'e F "Protesting the Independent Candidacy in Tanzania's Elections: A Bona Fide Cause?" 2012 Journal of Politics and Law 18-32 DOI: https://doi.org/10.5539/jpl.v5n1p18

Schaffner BF, Streb M and Wright G "Teams without Uniforms: The Nonpartisan Ballot in State and Local Elections" 2001 Political Research Quarterly 7-30 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/106591290105400101

Šebík K "Selected Aspects of Candidates Standing in Local Elections in the Slovak Republic" 2016 Contemporary European Studies 5-25

Tavares AF, Raudla R and Silva T "Best of Both Worlds? Independent Lists and Voter Turnout in Local Elections" 2020 Journal of Urban Affairs 955-974 https://doi.org/10.1080/07352166.2019.1623682 accessed 11 September 2021 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07352166.2019.1623682

Wolf A "Former RCD Officials Stage a Comeback in Municipal Elections in Tunisia" 2018 Journal of North Africa Studies 551-556 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13629387.2018.1483869?journalCode=fnas20& DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13629387.2018.1483869

Wolf L "The Right to Stand as an Independent Candidate in National and Provincial Elections: Majola v The President" 2014 SAJHR 159-182 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19962126.2014.11865102

Wolf L "Practical Implications for the Electoral System: New Nation Movement NPC v President of the Republic of South Africa" 2021 SALJ 58-87 DOI: https://doi.org/10.47348/SALJ/v138/i1a4

Case law

Aparty v Minister of Home Affairs, Moloko v Minister of Home Affairs 2009 3 SA 649 (CC)

Castañeda Gutman v México (IACHR) Series C no 184 (6 August 2008)

Executive Council of the Western Cape Legislature v President of the Republic of South Africa 1995 4 SA 877 (CC)

Executive Council Western Cape v Minister of Provincial Affairs and Constitutional Development 2000 1 SA 661 (CC)

Majola v The State President of the Republic of South Africa [2012] ZAGPJHC 236 (30 October 2012)

Matatiele Municipality v President of the RSA (No 2) 2007 6 SA 477 (CC)

New Nation Movement NPC v President of the Republic of South Africa 2020 6 SA 257 (CC)

New Nation Movement NPC v President of the Republic of South Africa 2019 5 SA 533 (WCC)

Oran v Turkey (ECHR) Applications nos 28881/07 and 37920/07 (2014)

Phillips v Director of Public Prosecutions, Witwatersrand Local Division 2003 3 SA 345 (CC)

Ramakatsa v Magashule 2013 2 BCLR 202 (CC)

S v Mhlungu 1995 3 SA 867 (CC)

Tanganyika Law Society v United Republic of Tanzania; Mtikila v United Republic of Tanzania Applications nos 009/2011 and 011/2011 no (ACHPR) (2011)

United Democratic Movement v President of the Republic of South Africa 2003 1 SA 495 (CC)

Legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 200 of 1993

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Electoral Act 73 of 1998

Electoral Laws Amendment Act 34 of 2003

Local Government: Municipal Structures Act 117 of 1998

Political Party Funding Act 6 of 2018

Government publications

Electoral Amendment Bill [B1-2022]

Electoral Laws Second Amendment Bill [B34-2020]

GN 1660 in GG 45716 of 31 December 2021

International instruments

African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights (1981)

American Convention on Human Rights (1969)

Internet sources

Chetty K 2020 Electoral Reform: Understanding the New Nation Movement Case https://hsf.org.za/publications/hsf-briefs/electoral-reform-understanding-the-new-nation-movement-case accessed 17 October 2020

De Vos P 2009 Electoral System in Need of Change https://constitutionallyspeaking.co.za/electoral-system-in-need-of-a-change/ accessed 24 November 2020

The Electoral Knowledge Network date unknown ACE Project - Independent Candidates https://aceproject.org/ace-en/topics/lf/lfb/lfb05/lfb05b/lfb05b02 accessed 29 November 2020

Electoral Task Team 2003 Report of the Electoral Task Team https://static.pmg.org.za/docs/Van-Zyl-Slabbert-Commission-on-Electoral-Reform-Report-2003.pdf accessed 30 October 2020

Fakir E 2020 A Referendum and Thorough-going System Reform is the Way to Political Rehabilitation https://www.africanews24-7.co.za/in-political-rehabilitationdex.php/southafricaforever/a-referendum-and-thorough-going-system-reform-is-the-way-to/ accessed 28 October 2020

Feltham L 2020 Reforming a Broken System: Can Electoral Act Amendments Revive Faith in SA's Democracy? https://mg.co.za/politics/2020-08-18-reforming-a-broken-system-can-electoral-act-amendments-revive-faith-in-sas-democracy/ accessed 10 January 2021

Griffiths J 2020 Changes to Electoral Act Will not Fundamentally Alter South Africa's Political Landscape https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2020-06-24-changes-to-electoral-act-will-not-fundamentally-alter-south-africas-political-landscape/ accessed 14 March 2021

Grootes S 2021 Our Political System has Failed – The Election Structure and the Players Within It May Have To Change https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-09-16-our-political-system-has-failed-the-election-structure-and-the-players-within-it-may-have-to-change/ accessed 25 September 2021

Haffajee F 2021 The No-voters: More than 13 Million South Africans Who can Vote haven't Registered for 1 November Polls https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-09-21-the-no-voters-more-than-13-million-south-africans-who-can-vote-havent-registered-for-1-november-polls/ accessed 15 October 2021

High Level Panel 2017 Report of the High Level Panel on the Assessment of Key Legislation and the Acceleration of Fundamental Change https://www.parliament.gov.za/storage/app/media/Pages/2017/october/High_Level_Panel/HLP_Report/HLP_report.pdf accessed18 November 2020

Independent Electoral Commission date unknown Municipal Election Results https://results.elections.org.za/dashboards/lge/ accessed 6 November 2021

Independent Panel 2009 Report of the Independent Panel Assessment of Parliament https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201409/panelassessparl.pdf accessed 18 November 2020

Mafolo K 2021 Mmusi Maimane Touts Success of "Independent" Candidates as Black Eye for Big Party Politics https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article_tag/2021-elections/#article-1090739 accessed 6 November 2021

Moosa M and Hofmeyr J 2021 South Africans' Trust in Institutions and Representatives Reaches New Low https://afrobarometer.org/sites/default/files/publications/Dispatches/ad474south_africans_trust_in_institutions_reaches_new_low-afrobarometer-20aug21.pdf accessed 30 August 2021

Ndletyana M 2020 South Africa: Independent Candidates will Change the Game https://www.theafricareport.com/29970/south-africa-independent-candidates-will-change-the-game/ accessed 17 February 2021

Paton C 2021 ANC Leadership Opts for Minimal Changes to Electoral Law https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2021-09-15-anc-leadership-opts-for-minimal-changes-to-electoral-law/ accessed 23 September 2021

Schulz-Herzenberg C 2020 The South African Non-voter: An Analysis - Konrad Adenauer Foundation, The Midpoint Paper Series No 2/2020 https://www.kas.de/documents/261596/10543300/The+South+African+non-voter+-+An+analysis.pdf/acc19fbd-bd6d-9190-f026-8d311078b670?version=1.0&t=1608 accessed 25 August 2020

Tandwa L 2020 "ConCourt Judgment Brings Power Back to the People" - Political Leaders React https://www.news24.com/news24/southafrica/

news/concourt-judgment-brings-power-back-to-the-people-political-leaders-react-20200611 accessed 23 March 2021

Published

2022-06-15

How to Cite

Pretorius, L. (2022). Independent Candidacy and Electoral Reform: New Nation Movement NPC v President of the Republic of South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 25, (Published 15 June 2022) pp 1 – 34. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2022/v25ia12746

Issue

Section

Case Notes