The Intricacies of Land Reform in Namibia: An Overview of the Land Question in Namibia 33 Years After Independence
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2023/v26i0a14715Keywords:
Namibia, colonial dispossession, willing seller willing buyer, transformation, land redistribution, land reformAbstract
It is trite that at independence in 1990 Namibia inherited a skewed land distribution system in favour of a white minority, which necessitated the newly elected government to take drastic steps to redress the historical injustices pertaining to land ownership. The steps taken to address the land issue were birthed at the first National Conference on Land in 1991. This article investigates those measures and their effectiveness or lack thereof in satisfactorily solving the land question. One of those measures is the Willing-Seller Willing-Buyer Policy (WSWB) which, together with the legislative framework on land has failed dismally in ensuring the equitable distribution of land and realising the transformative aims of the Constitution. The article identifies various challenges Namibia faces in addressing the land issue, including the difficulty in implementing a mandatory policy of expropriation of private lands without compensation in a capitalist society. It further criticises the concept of national reconciliation adopted at the first National Land Conference in that it may have deprived the country of an opportunity to holistically address the skewed land distribution system once and for all. The article finds that the major constraints to meaningful land reform in Namibia are contained in the legislative framework and policies on land, which emanate from pre-independence provisions contained in the 1982 Constitutional Principles. The article also finds that due to those inherent constraints in the legislative framework, it is impossible to realise the transformative aims of the Constitution which include, equality in land distribution. There is therefore a need to rethink land reform in Namibia. In this regard, it is imperative to infuse the concept of restorative justice in the debate of land and to compel private landowners to participate in the process of land reform.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Alden C and Anseeuw W "The Gathering Storm? Namibia and the Land Question" 2016 Journal of Political Science 1-32
Amoo SK "Land Reform in Namibia: Beyond 2018" in Odendaal W and Werner W Neither Here nor There: Indigeneity, Marginalisation and Land Rights in Post-Independence Namibia (Legal Assistance Centre Windhoek 2020) 13-34
Amoo SK and Harring S "Intellectual Property under the Namibian Constitution" in Bösl A, Horn N and Du Pisani A (eds) Constitutional Democracy in Namibia: A Critical Analysis after Two Decades (Macmillan Education Windhoek 2010) 299-309
African Union Framework and Guidelines on Land Policy in Africa Land Policy in Africa: A Framework to Strengthen Land Rights, Enhance Productivity and Secure Livelihoods (ECA Publications and Conference Management Section Addis Ababa 2010)
Azadi H and Vanhaute H "Mutual Effects of Land Distribution and Economic Development: Evidence from Asia, Africa, and Latin America" 2019 Land Journal 1-15 DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/land8060096
Chitonge H "Participatory Land Governance in Africa: The Key to Raising Productivity and Promoting Equitable and Sustainable Land Use" in African Development Bank Rethinking Land Reform in Africa: New Ideas, Opportunities and Challenges (African Development Bank Abidjan 2020) 198-210
De Villiers S et al "Land Governance in Namibia" Unpublished contribution delivered at the Land Governance in Southern Africa Symposium Conference (3-4 September 2019 Windhoek)
Delgado G A Short Socio-Spatial History of Namibia (ILMI Working Paper No 9) (Namibia University of Science and Technology, Integrated Land Management Institute Windhoek 2018)
Dlamini SRA Taking Land Reform Seriously: From Willing Seller-Willing Buyer to Expropriation (LLM-thesis University of Cape Town 2014)
Forrest JB "Land, Agriculture and Racial Inequality in South-West Africa" 2001 Historia 345-346
Geiseb S "The Genocide against the Ovaherero and Nama Peoples" European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights and Akademie der Künste Colonial Repercussions: Namibia 115 Years after the Genocide of the Ovaherero and Nama (European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights Berlin 2019)
Glinz C "The High Court of Namibia: 'Gunther Kessl v Ministry of Lands and Resettlements and 2 Others. Case No 27/2006 and 266/2006'. A Test Case for the Namibian Land Reform Program" 2009 Law and Politics in Africa, Asia and Latin America 263-274 DOI: https://doi.org/10.5771/0506-7286-2009-2-263
Gumede N and Makuwira J "Contemporary Challenges of Post-Colonial Land Reform in Namibia: Lessons for South Africa" 2018 Journal of Public Administration 565-579
Hall R and Ntsebeza L The Land Question in South Africa: The Challenge of Transformation and Redistribution (HSRC Press Cape Town 2007)
Hangula L "Land Reform in Namibia" 2000 Population–Development–Environment in Namibia 75-92
Harmse PJ Guidebook on Laws Relating to Immovable Property in Namibia (Ministry of Land and Resettlement Windhoek 2014)
Harring S "The Stolen Lands under the Constitution of Namibia: Land Reform under the Law" Unpublished contribution delivered at the AASA Conference (July 2000 Windhoek)
Home R "Law in African Land Reform: Contested Areas" in African Development Bank Rethinking Land Reform in Africa: New Ideas, Opportunities and Challenges (African Development Bank Abidjan 2020) 132-141
Horn N "The Forerunners of the Namibian Constitution" in Bösl A, Horn N and Du Pisani A (eds) Constitutional Democracy in Namibia: A Critical Analysis after Two Decades (Macmillan Education Windhoek 2010) 63-82
Horn N "The Western Sahara Case: Land Reform and Pre-Colonial Land Rights in Namibia" 2015 SADC Law Journal 96-109
Hunter J "Who should Own the Land? An introduction" in Hunter J (ed) Who should Own the Land? Analyses and Views on Land Reform and the Land Question in Namibia and Southern Africa (Konrad-Adenauer-Foundation Windhoek 2004) 1-7
Khapoya V The African Experience 4th ed (Routledge New York 2012)
Lahiff E "Stalled Land Reform in South Africa" 2016 Current History 181-187 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1525/curh.2016.115.781.181
Lahiff E "Wiling-Buyer, Willing-Seller: South Africa's Failed Experiment in Market-Led Agrarian Reform" 2007 Third World Quarterly 1577-1597 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01436590701637417
Mthembu A "Reflections on Expropriation-based Land Reform in Southern Africa" 2019 Town and Regional Planning 54-65 DOI: https://doi.org/10.18820/2415-0495/trp75i1.7
Mufune P "Land Reform Management in Namibia, South Africa and Zimbabwe: A Comparative Perspective" 2010 International Journal of Rural Management 1-31 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/097300521100600101
Mumbuu E "Kapofi Brushes Off 'Sell-Out' Tag" New Era (28 September 2022) 3
Mumbuu E "WBWS Policy has not Failed" The Namibian (Windhoek, 28 September 2018) 5
Muundjua FU "Historical Origins of the Ovaherero and Nama Genocide" in European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights and Akademie der Künste Colonial Repercussions: Namibia 115 Years after the Genocide of the Ovaherero and Nama (European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights Berlin 2019) 11
Pankhurst D A Resolvable Conflict? The Politics of Land in Namibia (University of Bradford England 1996)
Republic of Namibia, Ministry of Lands, Resettlement, and Rehabilitation National Land Policy (Ministry of Lands, Resettlement, and Rehabilitation Windhoek 1998)
Seervai HM Constitutional Law of India: A Critical Commentary 3rd ed (University of Michigan Ann Arbor 2005)
Swartbooi B "On the Land Question" in European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights and Akademie der Künste Colonial Repercussions: Namibia 115 Years after the Genocide of the Ovaherero and Nama (European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights Berlin 2019) 15
Takigawa T "Landownership and Land Reform Problems of the Philippines" 1964 The Developing Countries 58-77 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1746-1049.1964.tb00670.x
Von Wietersheim E This Land is My Land! Motions and Emotions around Land Reform in Namibia (Friedrich Ebert Stiftung Windhoek 2021)
Walker C "The Land Question in South Africa: The Challenges of Transformation and Redistribution" Unpublished contribution delivered at the Harold Wolpe Memorial Trust Conference (25-27 March 2004 Cape Town)
Werner W "A Brief History of Land Dispossession in Namibia" 1993 Journal of Southern African Studies 135-146 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03057079308708351
Werner W "Land Reform in Namibia: Motor or Obstacle of Democratic Development?" Unpublished paper presented at a conference titled Land Reform in Southern Africa (28 May 2003 Berlin)
Case law
Günther Kessl v Ministry of Lands and Resettlement (High Court of Namibia) case numbers 27/2006 and 266/2006 (6 March 2008)
Namibia Grape Growers and Exporters Association v Ministry of Mines and Energy (SA 14 of 2002) [2004] NASC 6 (25 November 2004)
Ongwediva Town Council v Jonas (HC-NLD-CIV-MOT-GEN-2018/00001) [2018] NAHCNLD 22 (12 March 2018)
Wohlfart v Bergh (HC-MD-CIV-MOT-GEN-2019/00004) [2019] NAHCMD 264 (28 May 2021)
Legislation
Agricultural Commercial Land Reform Act 6 of 1995
Communal Land Reform Act 5 of 2002
Constitution of the Republic of Namibia, 1990
International instruments
African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights (1981)
Internet sources
De Vos P 2013 Willing Buyer, Willing Seller Works… If You Have a Lifetime to Wait https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2013-06-13-willing-buyer-willing-seller-works-if-you-have-a-lifetime-to-wait/ accessed 18 May 2022
Fuller B and Eiseb G 2002 Commercial Farm Market in Namibia: Evidence from the First 11 Years (IPPR Briefing Paper No 15) https://ippr.org.na/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/BP15.PDF accessed 13 August 2023
Lund C, Odgaard R and Sjaastad E 2006 Land Rights and Land Conflicts in Africa: A Review of Issues and Experiences https://pure.diis.dk/
ws/files/68278/Land_rights_and_land_conflicts_in_Africa_a_review_of_issues_and_experiences.pdf accessed 14 August 2023
Melber H 2018 The Battles over Land in Namibia https://africasacountry.com/2018/12/the-battles-over-land-in-namibia accessed 16 May 2022
Melber H 2018 Namibia's Long-Standing Land Issue Remains Unresolved https://theconversation.com/namibias-long-standing-land-issue-remains-unresolved-105301 accessed 22 May 2022
Melber H 2020 How the First Redistribution Attempt Failed https://www.dandc.eu/en/article/policy-proposed-namibias-first-national-land-reform-conference-early-1990s-never-took accessed 16 May 2022
Penciakova V 2010 Market-Led Agrarian Reform: A Beneficiary Perspective of Cedula Da Terra. LSE Working Paper Series N⁰ 10-100 https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/136670/WP100.pdf accessed 16 May 2022
Tjiriange N 2014 Willing Seller, Willing Buyer Policy – Is It Effective? https://allafrica.com/stories/201403201483.html accessed 16 May 2022
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 KF Mundia, R Haimbili
![Creative Commons License](http://i.creativecommons.org/l/by/4.0/88x31.png)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.