Reassessing Judicial Independence and Impartiality against the Backdrop of Judicial Appointments in South Africa

Authors

  • Koos Malan University Pretoria

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i5a2156

Keywords:

dominant/ruling (political) elite, ideological assumptions, judicial appointments, judicial independence, judicial impartiality, judicial service commission, liberals, liberal constitutionalism, party detachment (of the judiciary), political insularity (o

Abstract

The South African Judicial Service Commission (JSC), considered to be exemplary for its independence, plays a pivotal part in judicial appointments. Yet the Commission has long been marred by tensions that have lately erupted into a full-blown conflict between those who could here be referred to as the transformationists, on the one hand, and the liberals, on the other. The transformationists, who may generally be regarded as falling within the sphere of influence of the ruling elite under the African National Congress (ANC), are bent on pursuing the policy of transformation. Hence they insist that the composition of the bench must reflect the national population profile and on individual judges' pursuing the ruling party's ideological goals. The liberals reject this as a threat to judicial independence and the professional competence of the judiciary. On close analysis the clash is based on incompatible interpretations of judicial independence and impartiality. This article is a critique of these interpretations against the backdrop of an assessment of what these notions can reasonably be expected to achieve.

It is argued that the liberals are harbouring unrealistic views about judiciaries, believing them to wield power which may even extend over matters of political significance, powers on a par with or even outweighing those of the political branches. However, on proper analysis it is clear that the judiciary is in fact, firstly, inherently weak and dependent on the support of the political branches; and, secondly, it is integrated into the ruling elite with whom they share the same ideological assumptions without any inclination to oppose them. Hence, the impartiality of the courts, when it comes to politically sensitive issues, is distinctively politically (regime) relative and ideologically conditioned.

Ironically the transformationists have bought into the liberals' erroneous belief in the potency of the courts (in the above-mentioned sense) and they fear, without foundation, for the political risks the courts might be posing to the ruling elite. This fear is based on an exaggerated vision of the far-reaching consequences that they ascribe to judicial independence and impartiality, believing it to render the judiciary a formidable political force on a par with the political branches. The transformationists would therefore go to extreme lengths to secure an amenable judiciary. This is exemplified by their rather improper insistence that the best candidates need not be appointed, thus compromising even the (limited) independence and impartiality which courts, on a realistic assessment, should have. In doing this the transformationists show a serious lack of appreciation of the distinctive professional nature of the judiciary, whose independence, impartiality and effectiveness are rooted not in political might but in the exceptional professional competence of the incumbents on the bench, who should be drawn from the best candidates the legal professional can produce.

      ScienceOpen_Log0343254.png

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Literature

Abraham Justices, Presidents and Senators

Abraham HJ Justices, Presidents and Senators: A History of the US Supreme Court Appointments from Washington to Clinton (Rowman & Littlefield Lanham 1999)

Bickel Least Dangerous Branch

Bickel AM The Least Dangerous Branch: The Supreme Court at the Bar of Politics (Bobbs-Merill Indianapolis 1962)

Bork 1971 Ind LJ

Bork RH "Neutral Principles and Some First Amendment Problems" 1971 Ind LJ 1-35

Budlender 2005 SAJHR

Budlender G "Transformation of the Judiciary: The Politics of the Judiciary in a Democratic South Africa" 2005 SAJHR 715-724

Calland Zuma Years

Calland R The Zuma Years: South Africa's Changing Face of Power (Zebra Press Cape Town 2013)

Cameron 1982 SALJ

Cameron E "Legal Chauvinism, Executive Mindedness and Justice: LC Steyns' Impact on South African Law" 1982 SALJ 38-75

Dahl 1957 JPL

Dahl R "Decision-making in a Democracy: The Supreme Court as a National Policymaker" 1957 JPL 279-293

Devenish 2003 THRHR

Devenish GE "The Doctrine of Separation of Powers with Specific Reference to Events in South Africa and Zimbabwe" 2003 THRHR 84-99

Du Toit Nuwe Toekoms

Du Toit ZB Die Nuwe Toekoms: 'n Perspektief op die Afrikaner by die Eeuwisseling (JP Van der Walt Pretoria 1999)

Dworkin Law's Empire

Dworkin R Law's Empire (Fontana Press London 1986)

Dworkin Taking Rights Seriously

Dworkin R Taking Rights Seriously (London Duckworth 1977)

Dyzenhaus 1982 SALJ

Dyzenhaus D "LC Steyn in Perspective" 1982 SALJ 380-393

Fiss 1993 U Miami Inter-Am L Rev

Fiss OM "The Limits of Judicial Independence" 1993 U Miami Inter-Am L Rev 57-76

Fombad 2011 Buff L Rev

Fombad CM "Constitutional Reforms and Constitutionalism in Africa: Reflections on Some Current Challenges and Future Prospects" 2011 Buff L Rev 1007-1108

Fukuyama Origins of Political Order

Fukuyama F The Origins of Political Order from Prehuman Times to the French Revolution (Profile Books London 2011)

Gordon and Bruce Transformation and the Independence of the Judiciary

Gordon A and Bruce D Transformation and the Independence of the Judiciary in South Africa (Centre for the Study of Violence in South Africa Braamfontein 2007)

Grimm "Constitutions, Constitutional Courts and Constitutional Interpretation"

Grimm D "Constitutions, Constitutional Courts and Constitutional Interpretation at the Interface of Law and Politics" in Iancu B (ed) The Law/Politics Distinction in Contemporary Public Law Adjudication (Eleven International Utrecht 2009) 22-34

Hamilton, Madison and Jay Federalist Papers

Hamilton A, Madison J and Jay J The Federalist Papers (Mentor Books New York 1961)

Hart "American Jurisprudence through English Eyes"

Hart HLA "American Jurisprudence through English Eyes: The Nightmare and the Noble Dream" in Essays in Jurisprudence and Philosophy (Clarendon Press Oxford 1983) 123-144

Hoexter Administrative Law

Hoexter C Administrative Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2007)

Kennedy Critique of Adjudication

Kennedy D A Critique of Adjudication (fin de siécle) (Harvard University Press Cambridge Mass 1997)

Klare 1998 SAJHR

Klare KE "Legal Culture and Transformative Constitutionalism" 1998 SAJHR 146-188

Kriegler Sunday Times

Kriegler J "A Lonely Life on the Bench" Sunday Times (21 April 2013) 5

Larkins 1996 Am J Comp L

Larkins CM "Judicial Independence and Democratization: A Theoretical and Conceptual Analysis" 1996 Am J Comp L 605-626

Mahommed 1999 SALJ

Mahommed I "Address by Mr Justice Mahommed, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Appeal on Accepting the Honorary Degree of Doctor of Laws at the University of Cape Town on 25 June 1999" 1999 SALJ 853-857

Malan 2005 De Jure

Malan K "The Unity of Powers and the Dependence of the Judiciary" 2005 De Jure 99-115

Malan 2008 THRHR

Malan K "The Deficiency of Individual Rights and the Need for Community Protection" 2008 THRHR 415-437

Malan 2010 TSAR

Malan K "Observations on Representivity, Democracy and Homogenization" 2010 TSAR 427-449

Marshall Constitutional Theory

Marshall G Constitutional Theory (Claredon Press Oxford 1971)

Moerane 2003 SALJ

Moerane MTK "The Meaning of Transformation of the Judiciary in the New South African Context" 2003 SALJ 708-718

Montesquieu Spirit of Laws

Montesquieu CL de S, Baron de The Spirit of Laws (translator from French into English not indicated) (Prometheus Books New York 2002)

Motala Sunday Times

Motala Z "SCA: Beware Politics Masquerading as Law" Sunday Times (11 December 2011) 5

Ntsebeza Sunday Times

Ntsebeza DB "Why Majority Black Bench is Inevitable" Sunday Times (25 July 2004) 19

O'Brien Judicial Roulette

O'Brien DM Judicial Roulette: Report of the Twentieth Century Fund Task Force on Judicial Selection (Priority Press New York 1988)

Peretti "Does Judicial Independence Exist?"

Peretti TJ "Does Judicial Independence Exist? The Lessons of Social Science Research" in Burbank SB et al (eds) Judicial Independence at the Crossroads: An Interdisciplinary Approach (Sage Thousand Oaks 2002) 103-133

Pfaff and Schneider 2001 SAJHR

Pfaff R and Schneider H "The Promotion of Administrative Justice Act from a German Perspective" 2001 SAJHR 56-90

Plaut and Holden Who Rules South Africa?

Plaut M and Holden P Who Rules South Africa? Pulling the Strings in the Battle for Power (Jonathan Ball Johannesburg 2012)

Rickard Sunday Times (2002)

Rickard C "Is the Price for Transformation Too High?" Sunday Times (21 April 2002) 16

Rickard Sunday Times (2004)

Rickard C "The Bench is Closed to Pale Males, Struggle Credentials or Not" Sunday Times (18 July 2004) 16

Rosenberg Hollow Hope

Rosenberg GN The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change? (Chicago University Press Chicago 2008)

Roux 2009 ICON

Roux T "Principle and Pragmatism on the Constitutional Court of South Africa" 2009 ICON 106-138

Roux Politics of Principle

Roux T The Politics of Principle: The First South African Constitutional Court, 1995-2005 (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2013)

Shapiro 1963-1964 Ky LJ

Shapiro M "Political Jurisprudence" 1963-1964 Ky LJ 294-345

Smuts Sunday Times

Smuts I "So Many Questions" Sunday Times (21 April 2013) 5

Tempelhoff Beeld 4

Tempelhoff E "Water-hofbevel: Rade wil wéér Appèl Aanteken" Beeld (1 August 2012) 4

Wechsler 1959 Harv L Rev

Wechsler H "Towards Neutral Principles of Constitutional Law" 1959 Harv L Rev 1-35

Wesson and Du Plessis 2008 SAJHR

Wesson M and Du Plessis M "Fifteen Years On: Central Issues Relating to the Transformation of the South African Judiciary" 2008 SAJHR 187-213

Case law

Association of Personal Injury Lawyers v Heath 2001 1 SA 883 (CC)

BTR Industries South Africa (Pty) Ltd v Metal and Allied Workers Union 1992 3 SA 673 (A)

De Lange v Smuts 1998 3 SA 785 (CC)

Democratic Alliance v Acting National Director of Public Prosecutions 2012 6 BCLR 613 (SCA)

Democratic Alliance v President of the RSA 2012 12 BCLR 1297 (CC)

Democratic Alliance v President of the RSA 2012 3 BCLR 291 (SCA)

Freedom under Law v Acting Chairperson of the Judicial Service Commission 2011 3 SA 549 (SCA)

Glenister v President of the RSA 2011 3 SA 347 (CC)

Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2000 11 BCLR 1169 (CC)

Judicial Service Commission v Cape Bar Council 2012 11 BCLR 1239 (SCA)

Minister of Health v Treatment Action Campaign 2002 10 BCLR 1033 (CC)

Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie 2006 1 SA 524

National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 1 BCLR 39 (CC)

National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v Minister of Justice 2012 12 BCLR 1517 (CC)

New National Party of South Africa v Government of the Republic of South Africa 1999 3 SA 191 (CC)

Nyathi v Member of the Executive Council for the Department of Health Gauteng 2008 9 BCLR 865 (CC)

President of the Republic of South Africa v SA Rugby Football Union 1999 7 BCLR 725 (CC)

S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)

Satchwell v President of the RSA 2002 9 BCLR 986 (CC)

Section 27 v Minister of Basic Education 2013 2 BCLR 237 (GNP)

Solidarity v South African Police Service 2014 2 SA 1 (SCA)

Thint (Pty) Ltd v National Director of Public Prosecutions, Zuma v National Director of Public Prosecutions 2008 12 BCLR 1197 (CC)

United Democratic Movement v President of the Republic of South Africa 2003 1 SA 495 (CC)

Van Rooyen v The State 2002 5 SA 246 (CC)

Zuma v DA (836/2013) 2014 ZASCA 101 (28 August 2014)

Zuma v National Director of Public Prosecutions 2009 1 BCLR 62 (N)

Legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 200 of 1993

Constitution Seventeenth Amendment Act of 2012

Judicial Service Commission Act 9 of 1994

Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000

South African Police Service Act 68 of 1995

State Liability Act 20 of 1957

International instruments

Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary (1985)

Commonwealth (Latimer House) Principles on the Three Branches of Government (2003)

Internet sources

Advocate (Columnist) 2013 http://www.citypress.co.za/columnists/which-white-judges

Advocate (Columnist) 2013 Which White Judges? http://www.citypress.co.za/columnists/which-white-judges accessed 20 August 2013

ANC 1992 http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=227

ANC 1992 Ready to Govern: ANC Policy Guidelines for a Democratic South Africa http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=227 accessed 23 August 2013

ANC 1993 http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=231www.anc.org.za/ancdocs/

policy/bill_rights

ANC 1993 A Bill of Rights for a New South Africa http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=231www.anc.org.za/ancdocs/policy/bill_rights accessed 20 August 2013

ANC 1998 http://www.anc.org.za/ancdocs/pubs/umrabulo/articles/sprst.html

ANC 1998 The State, Property Relations and Social Transformation http://www.anc.org.za/ancdocs/pubs/umrabulo/articles/sprst.html accessed 3 September 2013

ANC 2005 http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=55

ANC 2005 National Executive Committee of the African National Congress on the Occasion of the 93rd Anniversary of the ANC http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=55 accessed 30 November 2014

BLA 2013 http://www.blaonline.org.za/

Black Lawyers Association 2013 Home Page http://www.blaonline.org.za/ accessed 3 September 2013

Burger 2013 htp://www.beeld.com/opinie/2013-09-18-kommentaar-en-ontleding-n-toenemende-polisie-probleem

Burger J 2013 Kan die Polisie die Toename in Geweldadige Openbare Verset Hanteer? http://www.beeld.com/opinie/2013-09-18-kommentaar-en-ontleding

-n-toenemende-polisie-probleem accessed on 20 September 2013

Calland 2013 http://mg.co.za/article/2013-04-12-00-jscs-attitude-opens-door-to-conservatism

Calland R 2013 JSC's Attitude Opens Door for Conservatism http://mg.co.za/article/2013-04-12-00-jscs-attitude-opens-door-to-conservatism accessed on 3 September 2013

Du Plessis 2013 http://www.citypress.co.za/politics/appointing-judges-not-about-merit-alone-mogoeng

Du Plessis C 2013 Appointing Judges Not About Merit Alone - Mogoeng http://www.citypress.co.za/politics/appointing-judges-not-about-merit-alone-mogoeng accessed on 19 November 2014

Gerber 2013 http://www.netwerk24.com/nuus/2013-04-10-bestes-nie-altyd-regters?redirect_from=beeld

Gerber J 2013 Bestes nie Altyd Regters - Gaan nie net oor Verdienste http://www.netwerk24.com/nuus/2013-04-10-bestes-nie-altyd-regters?redirect_from=beeld accessed 20 September 2013

Ginwala 2008 http://www.justice.gov.za/commissions/2008_ginwala.pdf

Ginwala FN 2008 Report of the Inquiry into the Fitness of Advocate VP Pikoli to Hold the Office of National Director of Public Prosecutions Commission of Inquiry http://www.justice.gov.za/commissions/2008_ginwala.pdf accessed 19 November 2014

Hefer 2013 http://152.111.1.88/argief/berigte/beeld/2013/05/01/B1/11/gvregter.

html

Hefer O 2013 'n Politieke Kleur vir die Regbank http://152.111.1.88/argief/

berigte/beeld/2013/05/01/B1/11/gvregter.html accessed on 20 August 2013

Hoffman 2013 http://www.rapport.co.za/Weekliks/Nuus/RDK-moet-gou-leer-lees-20130419

Hoffman P 2013 RDK Moet Gou Leer Lees http://www.rapport.co.za/Weekliks/

Nuus/RDK-moet-gou-leer-lees-20130419 accessed on 20 August 2013

JSC 2010 http://www.justice.gov.za/saiawj/saiawj-jsc-criteria.pdf

Judicial Service Commission 2010 Summary of the Criteria Used by the Judicial Services Commission when Considering Candidates for Judicial Appointments http://www.justice.gov.za/saiawj/saiawj-jsc-criteria.pdf access

ed 19 November 2014

Kriegler 2009 http://web.wits.ac.za/NR/rdonlyres/101A7678-21DB-4FB1-A360-EC30A868D864/0/JudgeKrieglerPubliclecture18August2009.pdf

Kriegler J 2009 Can Judicial Independence Survive Transformation? A Public Lecture Delivered by Judge Johann Kriegler at the Wits Law School http://web.wits.ac.za/NR/rdonlyres/101A7678-21DB-4FB1-A360-EC30A868D864/0/JudgeKrieglerPubliclecture18August2009.pdf accessed 29 April 2010

Motala 2011 http://www.timeslive.co.za/opinion/columnists/2011/03/26/divination-through-a-strange-lens

Motala Z 2011 Divination Through a Strange Lens http://www.timeslive.co.za/opinion/columnists/2011/03/26/divination-through-a-strange-lens accessed on 4 April 2011

Mpshe 2009 http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71

?oid=124273&sn=Detail

Mpshe M 2009 Why I Decided to Drop the Zuma Charges http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71619?oid=124273&sn=Detail accessed 23 September 2013

Rabkin 2013 http://www.bdlive.co.za/national/law/2013/04/12/smuts-resigns-from-jsc-in-wake-of-furore-over-document

Rabkin F 2013 Smuts Resigns from JSC in Wake of Furore Over Document http://www.bdlive.co.za/national/law/2013/04/12/smuts-resigns-from-jsc-in-wake-of-furore-over-document accessed on 23 September 2013

Rickard 2012 http://www.iol.co.za/the-star/how-biased-commission-picks-judges-1.1314419#.UuZQ69L8Jkg

Rickard C 2012 How Biased Commission Picks Judges http://www.iol.co.za/the-star/how-biased-commission-picks-judges-1.1314419#.UuZQ69L8Jkg accessed on 19 August 2013

Smuts 2013 http://www.iol.co.za/sundayindependent/jsc-at-crossroads-of-transformation-1.1503772#.UuZTxtL8Jkg

Smuts I 2013 The JSC Needs to Establish Why so Many Excellent Practitioners Do Not Apply http://www.iol.co.za/sundayindependent/jsc-at-crossroads-of-transformation-1.1503772#.UuZTxtL8Jkg accessed 19 November 2014

Smuts 2013 http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/

page71619?oid=368104&sn=Marketingweb+detail

Smuts I 2013 Transformation and the Judicial Service Commission – Discussion Paper for the JSC, April 2013 http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71619?oid=368104&sn=Marketingweb+detail accessed 19 November 2014

Staff Reporter 2011 http://mg.co.za/article/2011-09-14-mantashe-defends-anc-cadre-deployment

Staff Reporter 2011 Mantashe Defends ANC Cadre Deployment http://mg.co.za/article/2011-09-14-mantashe-defends-anc-cadre-deployment accessed 23 September 2013

Sunday Independent 2013 http://www.iol.co.za/sundayindependent

/advocate-under-fire-over-jsc-1.1499914#.VIGLDLUaL-c

Sunday Independent 2013 Advocate under fire over JSC http://www.iol.co.za/sundayindependent/advocate-under-fire-over-jsc-1.1499914#.VIGLDLUaL-c accessed on 4 December 2014

Tolsi 2013 http://mg.co.za/article/2013-04-12-jsc-conflict-laid-bare-by-inconsistency

Tolsi N 2013 JSC Conflict Laid Bare by Inconsistency http://mg.co.za/article/2013-04-12-jsc-conflict-laid-bare-by-inconsistency accessed 23 September 2013

Other

Hansard (2003-02-17) 128-124

Published

10-04-2017

How to Cite

Malan, K. (2017). Reassessing Judicial Independence and Impartiality against the Backdrop of Judicial Appointments in South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 17(5), 1964–2040. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i5a2156

Issue

Section

Articles

Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.