Silence is Golden: The Lack of Direction on Compensation for Expropriation in the 2011 Green Paper on Land Reform
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i2a2186Keywords:
Compensation for Expropriation, Land Reform, Willing-buyer-willing-seller, Expropriation, Green Paper on Land Reform.Abstract
The government set the target for redistribution of land to 30% by 2014. They have adopted the "willing-buyer-willing-seller" model that relies on a voluntary transaction between farmers and government to acquire such land. Frustrated at the slow pace of land reform, the ruling party is starting to indicate that the state will in future rely on its expropriation powers to acquire such land.
Section 25 of the Constitution makes it clear that when the state expropriates property, compensation must be paid. The current act, the 1975 Expropriation Act, determines that such compensation must be market value, while the Constitution lists market value as only one of at least five factors that must be taken into account when determining compensation.
There have been various attempts at drafting legislation that will bring compensation practices in line with the Constitution, with the latest Bill published in March 2013. This article focusses on the Green Paper that preceded the Bill, and argues that not much direction is given on how compensation for expropriation should be calculated.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Badenhorst" 1998 De Jure
Badenhorst PJ "Compensation for Purposes of the Property Clause in the New South African Constitution" 1998 De Jure 251-270
Badenhorst , Pienaar and Mostert Law of Property
Badenhorst PJ, Pienaar JM and Mostert H Silberberg and Schoeman's The Law of Property 6th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2006)
Budlender "Constitutional Protection of Property Rights"
Budlender G "The Constitutional Protection of Property Rights" in Budlender G, Latsky J and Roux T Juta's New Land Law (Juta Cape Town 1998) ch 1.
BVerfGE 24, 367 [1968] (Hamburgisches Deichordnungsgesetz)
Chaskalson and Lewis "Property"
Chaskalson M and Lewis C "Property" in Chaskalson M et al (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa (Juta Cape Town 1996) ch 31
Claassens 1993 SAJHR
Claassens A "Compensation for Expropriation: The Political and Economic Parameters of Market Value Compensation" 1993 SAJHR 422-427
Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)
Du Plessis "South African Constitution"
Du Plessis LM "The South African Constitution as Monument and Memorial and the Commemoration of the Dead" in Christensen R and Pieroth B (eds) Rechtstheorie in rechtspraktischer Absicht (Duncker and Humblot Berlin 2008) 189 – 205.
Du Plessis 2011 Stell LR
Du Plessis WJ "The (shelved) Expropriation Bill B 16-2008: an unconstitutional souvenir or an alarmist memento?" 2011 Stell LR 352-375
Du Plessis and Olivier 1997 BPLD
Du Plessis W and Olivier N "The Old and the New Property Clause" 1997 BPLD 11 – 16.
Everingham and Janneke 2006 Journal of Southern African Studies
Everingham M and Janneke C "Land Restitution and Democratic Citizenship in South Africa" 2006 Journal of Southern African Studies 545-562
Georgiou Determination of Compensation
Georgiou S The Determination of Compensation for the Expropriation of Special Purpose Properties (Thesis University of the Witwatersrand 1988)
Gildenhuys 1977 TSAR
Gildenhuys A "Markwaarde as Vergoedingsmaatstaf by Onteiening" 1977 TSAR 1 – 13.
Gildenhuys Onteieningsreg
Gildenhuys A Onteieningsreg 2nd ed (Butterworths Durban 2001)
Grütter Regsposisie van die Huurder
Grütter EGM Die Regsposisie van die Huurder by Onteiening (LLM-thesis University of the Witwatersrand 1986)
Jacobs Law of Expropriation
Jacobs M The Law of Expropriation in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 1982)
Klare 1998 SAJHR
Klare K "Legal Culture and Transformative Constitutionalism" 1998 SAJHR 146-188
Lahiff 2007 Third World Quarterly
Lahiff E "'Willing Buyer, Willing Seller': South Africa's failed experiment in market-led agrarian reform" 2007 Third World Quarterly 1577-1597
Liebenberg Socio-Economic Rights:
Liebenberg S Socio-Economic Rights: Adjudication under a Transformative Constitution (Juta Cape Town 2010)
Muller Impact of Section 26
Muller G The Impact of Section 26 of the Constitution on the Eviction of Squatters in South African Law (LLD-dissertation US 2011)
Naidu Sunday Independent
Naidu E 'Greedy farmers knock land reform Sunday Independent 19 September 2004 1
Penny 1966 SALJ
Penny P "Compensation upon Expropriation" 1966 SALJ 185-204
Pienaar and Mostert 2005 SALJ
Pienaar JMJ and Mostert H "The Balance Between Burial Rights and Landownership in South Africa: Issues of Content, Nature and Constitutionality" 2005 SALJ 633-660
Schoeman Farmers Weekly
Schoeman L 'Farmers fear land reform' Farmers Weekly 30 July 2010 22
Sinkins Witness
Sinkins E 'Slow reform 'brings tension' Witness 12 April 2010 5
Van der Walt Constitutional Property Law
Van der Walt AJ Constitutional Property Law 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)
Van der Walt 2005 SAJHR
Van der Walt AJ "The State's Duty to Protect Property Owners vs The State's Duty to Provide Housing: Thoughts on the Modderklip Case" 2005 SAJHR 144-161
West Business Day
West E 'Farm body warns on KwaZulu tensions' Business Day 19 January 2007 2
Register of legislation
Communal Property Associations Act 28 of 1996
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Expropriation Act 63 of 1975
Extension of Security of Tenure Act 62 of 1997
Land Reform (Labour Tenants) Act 3 of 1996.
Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act 28 of 2002
National Heritage Resources Act 25 of 1999
National Water Act 36 of 1998.
Natives Land Act 27 of 1913
Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998
Provision of Land and Assistance Act 126 of 1993
Restitution of Land Rights Act 2 of 1994
Subdivision of Agricultural Land Act 70 of 1970
Register of government publications
Draft Expropriation Bill, 2013 (GN 234 in GG 36269 of 20 March 2013)
Expropriation Bill B16-2008
Green Paper on Land Reform (2011)
South African Land Policy White Paper (1997)
Register of case law
Bestuursraad van Sebokeng v M & K Trust & Finansiële Maatskappy (Edms) Bpk 1973 3 SA 376 (A)
Brink v Kitshoff 1996 4 SA 197 (CC)
City of Cape Town v Helderberg Park Development (Pty) Ltd 2007 1 SA 1 (SCA)
Durban Corporation v Lewis 1942 NPD 24
Du Toit v Minister of Transport 2003 1 SA 586 (C)
Du Toit v Minister of Transport 2006 1 SA 297 (CC)
Estate Hemraj Mooljee v Seedat 1945 NPD 22
Estate Marks v Pretoria City Council 1969 3 SA 227 (A)
Ex parte former Highland Residents: In Re Ash v Department of Land Affairs 2000 2 All SA 26 (LCC)
First National Bank of SA Ltd t/a Wesbank v Commissioner, South African Revenue Service; First National Bank of SA Ltd t/a Wesbank v Minister of Finance 2002 4 SA 768 (CC)
Held v Administrateur-Generaal vir die Gebied van Suidwes-Afrika 1988 2 SA 218 (SWA)
Hermanus v Department of Land Affairs: In Re Erven 3535 and 3536, Goodwood 2001 1 SA 1030 (LCC)
Hirschman v Minister of Agriculture 1972 2 SA 887 (A)
Katzoff v Glaser 1948 4 SA 630 (T)
Khumalo v Potgieter 2000 2 All SA 456 (LCC)
Krause v SA Railways and Harbours 1948 4 SA 554 (O)
May v Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe; Thomas Family v Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe; Cairns Family Trust v Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe; Frogmore Tobacco Estates (PVT) Ltd v Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe 1985 4 SA 185 (ZH)
Minister of Agriculture v Estate Randeree 1979 1 SA 145 (A)
Minister of Lands and Natural Resources v Moresby-White 1978 2 SA 898 (RAD)
Minister of Transport v Du Toit 2005 1 SA 16 (SCA)
Minister of Water Affairs v Mostert 1966 4 SA 690 (A)
Nhlabathi v Fick 2003 7 BCLR 806 (LCC)
Nkosi v Bührman 2002 1 SA 372 (SCA)
Pienaar v Minister van Landbou 1972 1 SA 14 (A)
Pietermaritzburg Corporation v South African Breweries Ltd 1911 AD 501
President of the Republic of South Africa v Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd (Agri SA and Legal Resources Centre, Amici Curiae) 2005 5 SA 3 (CC)
Serole v Pienaar 2000 1 SA 328 (LCC)
Southern Transvaal Buildings (Pty) Ltd v Johannesburg City Council 1979 1 SA 949 (W)
Sri Raja Vyricherla v Revenue Divisional Officer Vizagapatam 1939 2 All ER 317
Todd v Administrator, Transvaal 1972 2 SA 874 (AD)
Register of internet sources
Agri SA 2011 www.agrisa.co.za
Agri SA 2011 Green Paper on Land Reform www.agrisa.co.za/Dokumente/Landreform.pdf [date of use 21 May 2013]
ANC 2012 www.anc.org.za
ANC 2012 Land Reform Policy Discussion Document www.anc.org.za/docs/discus/2012/landpolicyproposals_june2012g.pdf [date of use 21 May 2013]
Committee on Rural Development and Land Reform 2012 www.pmg.org.za
Committee on Rural Development and Land Reform 2012 Review on Land Acquisition and Willing Buyer Willing Seller Principle: briefing by Department of Rural Development and Land Reform; Committee Report on Joint Oversight Visits to the Northern Cape, Limpopo, Free State and Mpumalanga: Discussion www.pmg.org.za/report/20120523-department-rural-development-and-land-reform-findings-study-commissio [date of use 21 May 2013]
Greenberg Date Unknown www.amandlapublishers.co.za
Greenberg S Date Unknown Green Paper on Land Reform: No Change for the Landless www.amandlapublishers.co.za/amandla-magazine/101-amandla-issue-2223/1080-the-green-paper-on-land-reform-no-change-for-the-landless--by-stephen-greenberg [date of use 21 May 2013]
Manjengwa 2006 www.plaas.org.za
Manjengwa J 2006 Natural Resource Management and Land Reform in Southern Africa www.plaas.org.za/sites/default/files/publications-pdf/CBNRM%2015.pdf [date of use 16 Jul 2013]
SAPA 2006 mg.co.za
SAPA 2006 Farmers Seek Clarity on Land-Seizure Threat mg.co.za/article/2006-08-14-farmers-seek-clarity-on-landseizure-threat [date of use 17 Jul 2013]
SAPA 2012 www.news24.com
SAPA 2012 Land Chair Wants 'Bantustans' Cleared www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/Politics/Land-chair-wants-Bantustans-cleared-20120523 [as on 21 May 2013]
Swartz 2006 www.news24.com
Swartz S 2006 White Farmers Face October Deadline www.news24.com/News24/South_Africa/News/0,,2-7-1442_1981939,00.html [date of use 11 Nov 2008]
Wanneburg 2006 www.iol.co.za
Wanneburg G 2006 State Gives White Farmers Strict Deadline www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/state-gives-white-farmers-strict-deadline-1.289109#.UeZUM403B8E [date of use 17 Jul 2013]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Elmien WJ du Plessis
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}