Battered Women and the Requirement of Imminence in Self-Defence

Keywords: Imminence and battered women, abused women, necessity and abused women, self-defence, self-defence and abused women, defences for abused women, battered woman syndrome and imminence, , right to life, putative defence, cycle of viole, proportionality and self-defence, justification and excuse and self-defence

Abstract

Should the South African courts abolish the traditional imminence standard, something must be used to stand in its place. The identification of the various alternatives which have been suggested to replace imminence - most notably the establishment of the "reasonable woman standard" as advanced in the case of S v Engelbrecht 2005 (92) SACR 41 (W) - has moved the law of self-defence into the realm of subjectivity. The end result not only undermines self-defence as a justification defence, but is also unworkable for a number of reasons. For instance, utilising expert testimony to explain how the battered woman’s syndrome affects individual perception would leave a judge with no meaningful way to determine if that abused woman’s belief in the imminence of danger was reasonable, even if viewed from her distorted perspective. It is suggested that no reference need be made to the "reasonable battered woman", since South African courts already do this to a limited extent by taking a number of factors into account in determining if the abused woman acted reasonably. By rethinking certain factors in the situation as a set of relatively innocuous normative propositions, the abused woman’s actions can be judged in accordance with standard propositions in the law of self-defence.

    

References

Bibliography

Aggergaard 2002 Wm Mitchell L Rev

Aggergaard SP "Criminal Law-Retreat from Reason: How Minnesota's New No-retreat Rule Confuses the Law and Cries for Alteration" 2002 Wm Mitchell L Rev 657-694

Ally and Viljoen 2003 SACJ

Ally D and Viljoen F "Homicide in Defence of Property in an Age of Constitutionalism" 2003 SACJ 121-136

APA Diagnostic and Statistical Manual

APA Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders 4th ed (APA Washington 1994)

Ashworth Principles of Criminal Law

Ashworth A Principles of Criminal Law 4th ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 2003)

Bruce 2003 SAJHR

Bruce "Killing and the Constitution - Arrest and the Use of Lethal Force" 2003 SAJHR 430-454

Burchell and Hunt General Principles of Criminal Law (1970)

Burchell EM and Hunt PMA South African Criminal Law and Procedure: General Principles of Criminal Law Vol 1 (Juta Cape Town 1970)

Burchell and Hunt General Principles of Criminal Law (1983)

Burchell EM and Hunt PMA South African Criminal Law and Procedure: General Principles of Criminal Law Vol 1 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 1983)

Burchell and Milton Principles of Criminal Law (1997)

Burchell JM and Milton JRL Principles of Criminal Law 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 1997)

Burchell and Milton Principles of Criminal Law (2005)

Burchell JM and Milton JRL Principles of Criminal Law 3rd ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)

Burke 2002 N C L Rev

Burke AS "Rational Actors, Self-Defense and Duress; Making Sense not Syndromes out of the Battered Woman" 2002 N C L Rev 211-316

De Wet and Swanepoel Strafreg

De Wet JC and Swanepoel HL Strafreg 4th ed (Butterworths Durban 1985)

Ferzan 2004 Ariz L Rev

Ferzan KK "Defending Imminence: From Battered Women to Iraq" 2004 Ariz L Rev 213-262

Flack 1999 Responsa Meridiana

Flack L "The South African Criminal Law under Analysis in our new Constitutional Dispensation: Are we Looking for an 'Excuse'? An Exposition of S v Goliath 1972 (3) SA 1 (A)" 1999 Responsa Meridiana 69-78

Fletcher 1996 U Pitt L Rev

Fletcher GP "Domination in the Theory of Justification and Excuse" 1996 U Pitt L Rev 507-553

Goldman 1994 Case W Res L Rev

Goldman LE "Non-confrontational Killings and the Appropriate Use of Battered Child Syndrome Testimony: The Hazards of Subjective Self-defense and the Merits of Partial Excuse" 1994 Case W Res L Rev 185-250

Hatcher 2003 NYU Ann Surv Am L

Hatcher GH "The Gendered Nature of the Battered Woman Syndrome: Why Gender Neutrality Does not Mean Gender Equality" 2003 NYU Ann Surv Am L 21-50

Heller 1998 Am J Crim L

Heller K.J "Beyond the Reasonable Man? A Sympathetic but Critical Assessment of the Use of Subjective Standards of Reasonableness in Self-defense and Provocation Cases" 1998 Am J Crim L 1-120

Kazan 1997 Man L J

Kazan P "Reasonableness, Gender Difference and Self-defense Law" 1997 Man L J 549-576

Kaufman 2007 New Crim L Rev

Kaufman WRP "Self-defense, Imminence, and the Battered Woman" 2007 New Crim L Rev 342-369

Kreminitzer and Ghanayim 2004 U Tulsa L Rev

Kremnitzer M and Ghanayim K "Twenty-five Years of George P. Fletcher's Rethinking Criminal Law: Proportionality and the Aggressor's Culpability in Self-defense" 2004 U Tulsa L Rev 834-875

Labuschagne 1998 THRHR

Labuschagne JMT "Die Mishandelde Vrou-sindroom, Die Redelike Persoon-standaard end ie Grense van Noodweer" 1998 THRHR 538-541

Labuschagne 1999 Stell L R

Labuschagne JMT "Die Proses van Dekonkretisering van Noodweer in die Strafreg: 'n Regsantropologiese Evaluasie" 1999 Stell L R 56-68

Labuschagne 2003 Obiter

Labuschagne JMT "Geregtigheidse Misdaadelementologie en 'n Subjektiewe Omskrywing van Noodweer: Opmerking oor Onlangse Ontwikkeling in die Engelse en Skotse Reg" 2003 Obiter 103-120

Milton Common Law Crimes

Milton JRL South African Criminal Law and Procedure: Common Law Crimes Vol 2 3rd ed (Juta Cape Town 1996)

Nourse 2001 U Chi L Rev

Nourse VF "Self-defense and Subjectivity" 2001 U Chi L Rev 1189-1235

Packer Limits of Criminal Sanction

Packer HL The Limits of Criminal Sanction (Stanford University Press California 1969)

Reddi 2005 SACJ

Reddi M "Battered Woman Syndrome: Some Reflections on the Utility of this 'Syndrome' to South African Women Who Kill Their Abusers" 2005 SACJ 259-278

Ripstein 1996 U Pitt L Rev

Ripstein A "Self-defense and Equal Protection" 1996 U Pitt L Rev 685-724

Robinson Criminal Law Defenses

Robinson PH Criminal Law Defenses Vol 1 (West St Paul, Minn 1984)

Rosen 1986 Am U L Rev

Rosen CJ "The Excuse of Self-defense: Correcting a Historical Accident on Behalf of Battered Women Who Kill" 1986 Am U L Rev 1-56

Rosen 1993 N C L Rev

Rosen RA "On Self-defence, Imminence, and Women Who Kill Their Abusers" 1993 N C L Rev 371-387

Schulhofer 1990 Soc Phil & Pol

Schulhofer SJ "The Gender Question in Criminal Law" 1990 Soc Phil & Pol 76-105

Snyman 1979 Int’l & Comp L Q

Snyman CR "The Normative Concept of Mens Rea - A New Development in Germany" 1979 Int’l & Comp L Q 184-211

Snyman Criminal Law (2002)

Snyman CR Criminal Law 4th ed (Butterworths Durban 2002)

Snyman 2003 THRHR

Snyman CR "Private Defence in Criminal Law - An Unwarranted Raising of the Test of Reasonableness - S v Dougherty 2003 (2) SACR 36 (W)" 2003 THRHR 325-331

Snyman 2004 SACJ

Snyman CR "The Two Reasons for the Existence of Private Defence and Their Effect on the Rules Relating to the Defence in South Africa" 2004 SACJ 178-192

Snyman Strafreg

Snyman CR Strafreg 5th ed (Butterworths Durban 2006)

Snyman Criminal Law (2008)

Snyman CR Criminal Law 5th ed (Butterworths Durban 2008)

Stark 1995 Alb L Rev

Stark E "Re-Presenting Woman Battering: From Battered Woman Syndrome to Coercive Control" 1995 Alb L Rev 973-1026

Steyn 1932 SALJ

Steyn IVZ "Noodweer" 1932 SALJ 462-478

Struesser 1990 Man L J

Struesser L "The 'Defence' of 'Battered Woman Syndrome' in Canada" 1990 Man L J 185-195

Unikel 1992 NWU L Rev

Unikel R "Reasonable Doubts: A Critique of the Reasonable Woman Standard in American Jurisprudence" 1992 NWU L Rev 326-375

Veinsreideris 2000 U Pa L Rev

Veinsreideris ME "The Prospective Effects of Modifying Existing Law to Accommodate Pre-emptive Self-defence by Battered Women" 2000 U Pa L Rev 613-644

Walker Battered Woman

Walker LE The Battered Woman (Harper Row New York 1979)

Walker 1991 Psychotherapy

Walker LE "Post Traumatic Stress Disorder in Women: Diagnosis and Treatment of Battered Woman Syndrome" 1991 Psychotherapy 20-35

Register of cases

Canada

R v Lavallee 1999 55 CCC (3d)

R v Malott 1998 1 SCR 123 (SCC)

R v Melaragni 1992 96 (CCC) (3d) 78 (Ont Court GD)

R v Nelson 1992 71 CCC (3d) 449 (Ont CA)

R v Patel 1994 87 (CCC) 3d 97 (SCC)

England

Regina v Dudley Stephens 14 QBD 273 (1894)

South Africa

Du Plessis v De Klerk 1995 2 SA 40 (T)

Ex Parte Minister of Justice: In re S v Van Wyk 1967 1 SA 488 (A)

Government of Republic of South Africa v Basdeo 1996 1 SA 355 (A)

Ntanjana v Minister of Justice 1950 4 SA 398 (C)

R v Cele 1945 NPD 173

R v Hayes 1904 TS 383

R v Jack Bob 1929 SWA 32

R v K 1956 3 SA 353 (A)

R v Nomahleke 1928 GWL 8

R v Patel 1959 3 SA 121 (A)

R v Ziklalala 1953 2 SA 568 (A)

S v Baloyi 2000 1 BCLR 86 (CC)

S v De Oliviera 1993 2 SACR 59 (A)

S v Engelbrecht 2005 2 SACR 41 (W)

S v Ferriera 2004 2 SACR 454 (SCA)

S v Govender 2001 4 SA 273 (SCA)

S v Makwanyane 1995 6 BCLR 665 (CC)

S v Mnguni 1966 3 SA 776 (T)

S v Mogohlwane 1982 2 SA 587 (T)

S v Mokgiba 1999 1 SACR 534 (O)

S v Motleleni 1976 1 SA 403 (A)

S v Ntuli 1975 1 SA 429 (A)

S v Steyn 2010 1 SACR 411 (SCA)

S v T 1986 2 SA 112 (O)

S v Van Vuuren 1961 3 SA 305 (E)

S v Walters 2002 7 BCLR 663 (CC)

United States

S v Norman 378 SE 2d 8 12 (NC) 1989

Tennessee v Garner 471 US 1 (1985)

Register of legislation

Canadian Criminal Code, 1985

Constitution of Republic of South Africa, 1996

Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977

Domestic Violence Act 116 of 1998

Published
2017-04-26
How to Cite
GoosenS. (2017). Battered Women and the Requirement of Imminence in Self-Defence. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 16(1), 70-127. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i1a2305
Section
Articles