Legal Research Methodology and the Dream of Interdisciplinarity




Philosophy of science, Multidisciplinary research, Interdisciplinary research, Transdisciplinary research, Methodology


There are increasing calls for academics to abandon "traditional" disciplinary research and to engage in multi-, inter- and transdisciplinary research.  The argument is that this will serve to break down working in "silos" and somehow lead to more innovative research.  This article examines the concepts of multidisciplinary, interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary research to determine if this kind of research is possible in legal research.  The basic premise is that science is unified by the need for some kind of justification, arguably in the form of falsifiability of theories.  But science is also divided into natural, social and human sciences and this article argues that this division is based on methodological differences.  Whilst the natural sciences employ a mostly empiricist methodology and the human sciences employ a mostly rationalist methodology, the social sciences seem to employ a mixture of the two methodologies.  Law is a human science and moreover a professional discipline.  Some argue that this professional nature militates against multi-, inter- and transdisciplinary (MIT) research as it requires law students to be taught how to "think like a lawyer".  The article concludes that most law researchers engage in multidisciplinary research on a regular basis, but that interdisciplinary research is highly unlikely and transdisciplinary research almost never happens.



Download data is not yet available.


Metrics Loading ...



Ambler Don't Sell Your Coat

Ambler H Don't Sell Your Coat: Surprising Truths about Climate Change (Lansing Greenwich 2011)

Andreski Essential Comte

Andreski S (ed) The Essential Comte: Selected from Course de Philosophie Positive (translated from the original French by M Clarke) (Croom Helm London 1974)

Balkin 1996 Wash & Lee L Rev

Balkin JM "Interdisciplinarity as colonisation" 1996 Wash & Lee L Rev 949-970

Bell Climate of Corruption

Bell L Climate of Corruption: Politics and Power behind the Global Warming Hoax (Greenleaf Press Austin 2011)

Carayol and Thi 2005 Research Evaluation

Carayol N and Thi TUN "Why do academic scientists engage in interdisciplinary research?" 2005 Research Evaluation 70-79

Clarey Worthless

Clarey A Worthless: The Young Person's Indispensable Guide to Choosing the Right Major (Paric Excelsior 2011)

Coing 1989 Am J Comp L

Coing H "German 'Pandektistik' in its relationship to the former 'ius commune'" 1989 Am J Comp L 9-15

Collini What are Universities For?

Collini S What are Universities For? (Penguin London 2012)

Delingpole Watermelons

Delingpole J Watermelons: The Green Movement's True Colours (Publius Books New York 2011)

Descartes Philosophical Writings

Descartes R The Philosophical Writings of Descartes Vol II (translated from the original French by J Cottingham et al) (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1984)

Dworkin Law's Empire

Dworkin R Law's Empire (Belknap Press Cambridge Mass 1986)

Feyerabend Against Method

Feyerabend P Against Method (Verso London 1988)

Finnis Natural Law

Finnis J Natural Law and Natural Rights (Oxford University Press Oxford 1980)

Fish There's No Such Thing as Free Speech

Fish S There's No Such Thing as Free Speech (and It's a Good Thing Too) (Oxford University Press New York 1994)

Garwood Flat Earth

Garwood C Flat Earth: The History of an Infamous Idea (Pan Macmillan London 2007)

Gorham Philosophy of Science

Gorham G Philosophy of Science (Oneworld Oxford 2009)

Hobbes Leviathan

Hobbes T Leviathan (Oxford University Press Oxford 1946)

Hoctor “Legal Realism”

Hoctor S "Legal Realism" in Roederer C and Moellendorf D (eds) Jurisprudence (Juta Cape Town 2004) 158-185

Holmes 1897 Harvard LR

Holmes OW "The path of the law" 1897 Harvard LR 457-478

Holmes Age of Wonder

Holmes R The Age of Wonder: How the Romantic Generation Discovered the Beauty and Terror of Science (Harper London 2011)

Hugo Lehrbuch Eines Civilistischen Cursus

Hugo G Lehrbuch Eines Civilistischen Cursus, Philosophische Encyclopedie für Juristen (Berlin 1799) vol 5

Hutchinson 1987 Yale LJ

Hutchinson AC "Indiana Dworkin and the Law's Empire" 1987 Yale LJ 637- 665

Hutchinson 1994 Dalhousie LJ

Hutchinson AC "Playing the game" 1994 Dalhousie LJ 263-277

Inhofe Greatest Hoax

Inhofe J The Greatest Hoax: How the Global Warming Conspiracy Threatens Your Future (WND Books Washington 2012)

Janssen and Goldsworthy 1996 Agricultural Systems

Janssen W and Goldsworthy P "Multidisciplinary research for natural resource management: conceptual and practical implications" 1996 Agricultural Systems 259-279

Jori “Introduction”

Jori M "Introduction" in Legal Positivism (New York University Press New York 1992)

Kant Prolegomena

Kant I Prolegomena to Any Future Metaphysics That Will be Able to Come Forward as Science (translated from the original German by P Carus) (Hackett Indianapolis 1977)

Kelsen 1941 Harvard LR

Kelsen H "The pure theory of law and analytical jurisprudence" 1941 Harvard LR 44-70

Kop Legisme en Privaatrechtswetenschap

Kop PC Legisme en Privaatrechtswetenschap (Kluwer Deventer 1992)

Kroeze 2006 SA Public Law

Kroeze IJ "Matrix iuris: travels in the hyperreality of the law" 2005 SA Public Law 320-334

Kuhn Structure of Scientific Revolutions

Kuhn TS The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (University of Chicago Press Chicago 1962)

Langdell Selection of Cases

Langdell CC A Selection of Cases on the Law of Contract (Little & Brown Boston 1871)

Lawson Appeal to Reason

Lawson N An Appeal to Reason: A Cool Look at Global Warming (Overlook London 2009)

Locke Two Treatises on Civil Government

Locke J Two Treatises on Civil Government (Routledge London 1884)

Lyotard Postmodern Condition

Lyotard J-F The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge (translated from the original French by G Bennington and B Massumi) (Manchester University Press Manchester 1984)

Marnewick "Preparation for Trial”

Marnewick CG "Preparation for Trial: Legal Research" in Litigation Skills for South African Lawyers (LexisNexis Butterworth Durban 2007) 221-235

McNeil, Garcia-Godos and Gjerdaker Interdisciplinary Research

McNeill D, García-Godos J and Gjerdaker A (eds) Interdisciplinary Research on Development and the Environment (University of Oslo Oslo 2001)

Minda Postmodern Legal Movements

Minda G Postmodern Legal Movements: Law and Jurisprudence at Century's End (New York University Press New York 1995)

Montford Hockey Stick Illusion

Montford AW The Hockey Stick Illusion: Climategate and the Corruption of Science (Stacey Intl London 2010)

Nussbaum Citizens of the World

Nussbaum M Citizens of the World: A Classical Defense of Reform in Liberal Education (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1997)

Nussbaum Not for Profit

Nussbaum MC Not for Profit: Why Democracy Needs the Humanities (Princeton University Press Princeton 2010)

Okasha Philosophy of Science

Okasha S Philosophy of Science: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford University Press Oxford 2002)

Popper Conjectures and Refutations

Popper KR Conjectures and Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge (Routledge London 1989)

Popper Logic of Scientific Discovery

Popper KR The Logic of Scientific Discovery (Routledge London 2002)

Raymond Cathedral and the Bazaar

Raymond ES The Cathedral and the Bazaar: Musings on Linux and Open Source by an Accidental Revolutionary (O'Reilly Cambridge 2001)

Rosenfield 1992 Soc Sci Med

Rosenfield PL "The potential of transdisciplinary research for sustaining and extending linkages between the health and social sciences" 1992 Soc Sci Med 1343-1357

Ross On Law and Justice

Ross A On Law and Justice (Stevens & Sons London 1958)

Ross "Law and Economics"

Ross D "Law and Economics" in Roederer C and Moellendorf D (eds) Jurisprudence (Juta Cape Town 2004) 186-213

Russell Human Knowledge

Russell B Human Knowledge: Its Scope and Limits (Allen and Unwin London 1948)

Russell Scientific Outlook

Russell B The Scientific Outlook (Allen and Unwin London 1949)

Schlag 1990 Stanford LR

Schlag P "Normative and nowhere to go" 1990 Stanford LR 167-191

Schlag 1991 U Pa LR

Schlag P "Normativity and the politics of form" 1991 U Pa LR 801-932

Schlag 1992 U Colo L Rev

Schlag P "Writing for judges" 1992 U Colo L Rev 419-423

Schlag "Values"

Schlag P "Values" in Laying Down the Law: Mysticism, Fetishism, and the American Legal Mind (New York University Press London 1996) 42-59

Schlag 1997 Harvard LR

Schlag P "Law and phrenology" 1997 Harvard LR 877-921

Schlag Enchantment of Reason

Schlag P The Enchantment of Reason (Duke University Press Durham 1998)

Singer 1984 Yale LJ

Singer JW "The player and the cards: nihilism and legal theory" 1984 Yale LJ 1-70

Smolin Trouble with Physics

Smolin L The Trouble with Physics: The Rise of String Theory, the Fall of a Science and What Comes Next (Penguin London 2006)

Spencer Great Global Warming Blunder

Spencer RW The Great Global Warming Blunder: How Mother Nature Fooled the World's Top Climate Scientists (Encounter Books New York undated)

Sussman Eco-tyranny

Sussman B Eco-tyranny (WND Books Washington 2012)

Van Caenegem Historical Introduction to Private Law

Van Caenegem RC An Historical Introduction to Private Law (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1988)

Van der Walt 1995 SAJHR

Van der Walt AJ "Tradition on trial: a critical analysis of the civil-law tradition in South African property law" 1995 SAJHR 169-206

Van der Walt 1998 Acta Juridica

Van der Walt AJ "Un-doing things with words: the colonisation of the public sphere by private-property discourse" 1998 Acta Juridica 235-281

Van Hoecke "Legal Doctrine"

Van Hoecke M "Legal Doctrine: Which Method(s) for What Kind of Discipline?" in Methodologies of Legal Research (Hart Oxford 2011) 1-18

Venter et al Regsnavorsing

Venter F et al Regsnavorsing: Metode en Publikasie (Juta Cape Town 1990)

Winter 1990 Stanford LR

Winter SL "Bull Durham and the uses of theory" 1990 Stanford LR 639-693

Winter 1991 Texas LR

Winter SL "Foreword: On building houses" 1991 Texas LR 1595-1626

Wittgenstein Remarks on the Foundation of Mathematics

Wittgenstein L Remarks on the Foundations of Mathematics (Blackwell Oxford 1978)

Woxland 1989 Law Library Journal

Woxland TA "Why can't Johnny research? or it all started with Christopher Columbus Langdell" 1989 Law Library Journal 451-464

Zwalve Hoofdstukken uit de Geschiedenis van het Europese Privaatrecht

Zwalve WJ Hoofdstukken uit de Geschiedenis van het Europese Privaatrecht Deel 1: Inleiding en Zakenrecht (Wolters-Noordhof Groningen 1993)

Register of internet sources

NASA 2012

NASA 2012 The 2012 Transit of Venus [date of use 22 Oct 2012]

Silbey 2007

Silbey J 2007 Truth Tales and Trial Films - Suffolk University Law School Faculty Publications Paper 45 [date of use 11 Aug 2012)

Thurgood Marshall School of Law 2011

Thurgood Marshall School of Law 2011 The Center for Legal Pedagogy [date of use 22 Oct 2010]

Vashist, McKay and Marchall 2011

Vashist R, McKay J and Marchall P 2011 Revealing a Research Agenda: An Inter-disciplinary Perspective to Strengthen IS Research on Boundary Spanning - ACIS 2011 Proceedings Paper 54

[date of use 11 Aug 2012)

Yale 2012

Yale 2012 Yale launches Ph.D. in Law to train aspiring professors [date of use 22 Oct 2012]



How to Cite

Kroeze, I. J. (2017). Legal Research Methodology and the Dream of Interdisciplinarity. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 16(3), 35–65.




Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.