Harnessing Intellectual Property for Development: Some Thoughts on an Appropriate Theoretical Framework

  • Caroline Bongiwe Ncube University of Cape Town
Keywords: Intellectual property, equity, stakeholder interests, right to work, access to knowledge.


 This paper considers how an appropriate theoretical framework for Intellectual Property may be constructed. Such a framework would be the lens through which contested IP issues may be resolved and upon which national IP policy and legislation might be based. The paper begins by highlighting the inherent tensions in IP, which are caused by the various stakeholder interests that this body of law seeks to balance, and by the cross-cutting nature of IP. It contends that in order to more equitably balance the contesting rights of the creators and users, IP rights should be formulated and enforced so as to meet societal goals or serve public interest, be responsive to the economic environment, and take cognisance of the human rights claims of both creators and users.


National socio-economic goals should inform such a framework in a way that ensures that IP is used as a means to achieve these goals and is not perceived as an end. This will require nuances in policy and legislation that meet the country's needs. In particular, as a developing country South Africa would do well to exploit available flexibilities in the various international IP agreements by which it is bound.


Due regard also ought to be had to the users' need for affordable access to IP-protected goods in order that they may exercise the right to work and access to knowledge, as provided for by ss 22 and 16 of the Constitution respectively. Similarly, creators ought to be given due recognition, together with reasonable reward and remuneration for their efforts. This will be achieved through the creation of an IP system that provides protection that is compatible with the nature of the good being protected and the manner in which the creative process unfolds. Such protection should rely on registration systems are efficient, simplified and affordable. The accompanying enforcement system should be equally accessible, although the costs of enforcement would depend on the forum used to secure redress. Finally, the resulting IP regulatory framework should be both certain and clear.




Barrat Battle for Policy Space

Barrat A The Battle for Policy Space: Strategic Advantages of a Human Rights Approach in International Intellectual Property Negotiations (PhD-thesis UCT 2008)

Bessen and Meurer Patent Failure

Bessen J and Meurer MJ Patent Failure: How Judges, Bureaucrats and Lawyers put Innovators at Risk (Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ 2008)

Bird 2006 ABLJ

Bird RC "Defending intellectual property rights in the BRIC economies" 2006 ABLJ 317-363

Bird "Impact of Coercion"

Bird RC "The Impact of Coercion on Protecting US Intellectual Property Rights in the BRIC Economies" in Jain SC (ed) Emerging Economies and the Transformation of International Business: Brazil, Russia, India and China (BRICs) (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2006) 431-451

Bird and Cahoy 2007 NJTIP

Bird RC and Cahoy DR "The emerging BRIC economies: lessons from intellectual property negotiation and enforcement" 2007 NJTIP 400-425

Chander and Sunder 2007 UC Davis L Rev

Chander A and Sunder M "Is Nozick kicking Rawl's ass? Intellectual Property and Social Justice" 2007 UC Davis Law Review 563-579

Chang 2001 Journal of Human Development

Chang H-J "Intellectual property rights and economic development: historical lessons and emerging issues" 2001 Journal of Human Development 287-309

Chapman 2002 Journal of International Economic Law

Chapman AR "The human rights implications of intellectual property protection" 2002 Journal of International Economic Law 861-882

Cross 2010 PELJ

Cross JT "Property Rights and Traditional Knowledge" 2010 PELJ 12-47

Davis "Economic Activity"

Davis DM "Economic Activity" in Woolman S, Roux T and Bishop M Constitutional Law of South Africa 2nd ed (Butterworths Durban 1996 revision 1998) 29-15–29-19

Davis "Education"

Davis DM "Education" in Cheadle MH, Davis DM and Haysom NRL (eds) South African Constitutional Law: The Bill of Rights (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2002 revision April 2012) 24-1–24-6

Davis "Freedom of Expression"

Davis DM "Freedom of Expression" in Cheadle MH, Davis DM and Haysom NRL (eds) South African Constitutional Law: The Bill of Rights (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2002 revision April 2012) 11-1–11-11

De Beer "Defining WIPO's Development Agenda"

De Beer J "Defining WIPO's Development Agenda” in De Beer J (ed) Implementing the World Intellectual Property Organisation's Development Agenda (International Development Research Centre and Wilfrid Laurier University Press Ottawa 2009) 1-23

De Villiers 2006 SALJ

De Villiers R "Computer programs and copyright: The South African perspective" 2006 SALJ 315-337

Dean 2012 Without Prejudice

Dean O "A new tradition in legislation" 2012 12(10) Without Prejudice 41-42

Dean Handbook of South African Copyright Law

Dean OH Handbook of South African Copyright Law (Butterworths Durban 1987 revision 2006)

Drahos "Death of a Patent System"

Drahos P "Death of a Patent System - Introduction" in Drahos P (ed) Death of Patents (Lawtext London 2005) 1-11

Drahos Philosophy of Intellectual Property

Drahos P A Philosophy of intellectual property (Dartmouth Aldershot 1999)

Dutfield Intellectual Property Rights

Dutfield G Intellectual Property Rights and the Life Science Industries: A Twentieth Century History (Ashgate Aldershot 2003)

Dutfield and Suthersanen Global Intellectual Property Law

Dutfield G and Suthersanen U Global Intellectual Property Law (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2008)

Elkin-Koren and Salzberger Law, Economics and Cyberspace

Elkin-Koren N and Salzberger EM Law, Economics and Cyberspace: The Effects of Cyberspace on the Economic Analysis of Law (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2004)

Evenson 2001 Case W Res J Int'L L

Evenson RE "Comment: Intellectual Property Rights and Economic Development" 2001 Case W Res J nt'L L 187-190

Fisher "Theories of IP"

Fisher W "Theories of IP" in Munzer S (ed) New Essays in the Legal and Political Theory of Property (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2001) 168-199

Gibbons 2011 SMU L Rev

Gibbons LJ "Do as I Say (Not as I Did): Putative Intellectual Property Lessons for Emerging Economies from the Not So Long Past of the Developed Nations" 2011 SMU L Rev 923-974

Helfer 2007 UC Davis LR

Helfer LR "Towards a human rights framework for intellectual property" 2007 UC Davis LR 971-1020

Idris Intellectual Property

Idris K Intellectual Property - A Power Tool for Economic Growth (WIPO Geneva 2003)

Jonker "Access to Learning Materials"

Jonker J "Access to Learning Materials in South Africa: The Convergence of Developmental and Rights-based Arguments for Access to Knowledge" in Rens A and Khan R Access to Knowledge in South Africa (ISP Yale & IPU UCT Cape Town 2009) 113-146

Kaplan "Intellectual Property Rights"

Kaplan D "Intellectual Property Rights and Innovation in South Africa: A Framework" in WIPO The Economics of Intellectual Property in South Africa (WIPO Geneva 2009) 1-17

Krause 2000 Seattle UL Rev

Krause W "Sweeping the e-commerce patent minefield: the need for a workable business method exception" 2000 Seattle UL Rev 79-106

Le Roux 2003 SALJ

Le Roux W "Sex work, the right to occupational freedom and the constitutional politics of recognition" 2003 SALJ 452-465

MacQueen et al Contemporary Intellectual Property

MacQueen HL et al Contemporary Intellectual Property: Law and Policy (Oxford University Press Oxford 2007)

Masango 2010 SAJLIS

Masango CA "Indigenous traditional knowledge protection: prospects in South Africa's intellectual property framework?" 2010 SAJLIS 74-80

Maskus 2000 Case W Res J Int'L L

Maskus KE "Intellectual property rights and economic development" 2000 Case W Res J Int'L L 471-506

Maskus "Foreign Direct Investment"

Maskus KE "The Role of Intellectual Property Rights in Encouraging Foreign Direct Investment and Technology Transfer" in Fink C and Maskus KE (eds) Intellectual Property and Development: Lessons from Recent Economic Research (World Bank and Oxford University Washington, DC 2005) 41-74

McIntyre and Mooney "Where Now With Equity? "

McIntyre D and Mooney G "Where Now With Equity?" in McIntyre D and Mooney G (eds) The Economics of Health Equity (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2007) 249-268

Ncube 2012 SLR

Ncube CB "Equitable intellectual property protection of computer programs in South Africa: some proposals for reform" 2012 SLR 438-461

Ncube and Laltaika 2013 JIPLP

Ncube CB and Laltaika E "A new intellectual property organisation for Africa? " 2013 8(2) JIPLP 114-117

Okediji 2003 SJICL

Okediji, RL "Narratives of developing country participation in the global intellectual property system" 2003 SJICL 315-385

Ostergard Development Dilemma

Ostergard RL The Development Dilemma: The Political Economy of Intellectual Property Rights in the International System (Law And Society) (LFB Scholarly Publishing New York 2003)

Pollack 2002 Rutgers Computer & Tech LJ

Pollack M "The multiple unconstitutionality of business method patents: common sense, congressional choice, and constitutional history" 2002 Rutgers Computer & Tech LJ 61-120

Rautenbach 2005 TSAR

Rautenbach IM "The right to choose and practise a trade, occupation or profession the momentous and meaningless second sentence of section 22 of the Constitution" 2005 TSAR 851-862

Rens "Introduction"

Rens A "Introduction" in Rens A and Khan R Access to Knowledge in South Africa (ISP Yale & IPU UCT Cape Town 2009) 3-9

Schonwetter, Ncube and Chetty "South Africa"

Schonwetter T, Ncube CB and Chetty P “South Africa” in Armstrong C et al (eds) Access to Knowledge in Africa: The Role of Copyright (UCT Press Cape Town 2009) 231-239

Tong 2009 JWIP

Tong L-A "Copyright protection for computer programs in South Africa: Aspects of sui generis categorisation" 2009 JWIP 266-296

Tong "Intellectual Property System"

Tong L-A "Does the Intellectual Property System Offer Adequate Protection for Traditional Knowledge?" in Klopper H et al (eds) Law of Intellectual Property of South Africa (LexisNexis Durban 2011) 375-381

Van der Merwe 2010 PELJ

Van der Merwe A "Can traditional knowledge be effectively covered under a single 'umbrella'" 2010 PELJ 2-10

Vaver Intellectual Property Rights

Vaver D Intellectual Property Rights: Critical Concepts in Law (Routledge London 2006)

Yu "China Puzzle"

Yu PK "Intellectual Property, Economic Development and the China Puzzle" in Geravis D (ed) Intellectual Property, Trade and Development Strategies to Optimise Economic Development in a TRIPS Plus Era (Oxford University Press Oxford 2007) 173-220

Yu "China Exception"

Yu PK "Intellectual Property, Foreign Direct Investment and the China Exception" in Jain SC and Bird RC (eds) The Global Challenge of Intellectual Property Rights (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2008) 153-176

Register of legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Intellectual Property Laws Amendment Bill No 8B of 2010

Traditional Leadership and Governance Framework Act 41 of 2003

Register of government publications

Integrated Strategy on the Promotion of Entrepreneurship and Small Enterprises: Unlocking the Potential of South African Entrepreneurs (DTI Pretoria 2005)

Policy Framework for the Protection of Indigenous Traditional Knowledge through the Intellectual Property System and the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment Bill, 2008 (Gen N 552 in GG 31026 of 5 May 2008)

South African Company Law for the 21st Century: Guidelines for Corporate Law Reform (GN 1183 in GG 26493 of 23 June 2004)

White Paper on Small Business: National Strategy for the Development and Promotion of Small Business in South Africa (DTI Pretoria 1995)

Register of international instruments

Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, Including Trade in Counterfeit Goods (1994) (TRIPS)

International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966) (ICESCR)

UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (2007) (UNDRIP)

Register of case law

Affordable Medicines Trust v Minister of Health of RSA 2005 6 BCLR 529 (CC)

Azapo v The President of the Republic of South Africa 1996 4 SA 671 (CC)

JR 1013 Investments CC v Minister of Safety and Security 1997 7 BCLR 925 (E)

In re certification of the Constitution of the RSA 1996 4 SA 744 (CC)

Reddy v Siemens Telecommunications (Pty) Ltd 2007 2 SA 486 (SCA)

Register of internet sources

Dean 2012 blogs.sun.ac.za

Dean O 2012 New Traditional Knowledge Bill – Sui Generis Protection for TK blogs.sun.ac.za/iplaw/2012/02/27/the-new-traditional-knowledge-bill/ [date of use 1 Nov 2012]

De Villiers and Tshaya 2008 www2.warwick.ac.uk

De Villiers C and Tshaya T "Software and business method patents" 2008(2) JILT www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/law/elj/jil/2008_2/devilliersandtshaya/ [date of use 2 Mar 2013]

Henderson and Kane 2001 www2.warwick.ac.uk

Henderson K and Kane H "Internet patents: will they hinder the development of e- commerce?" 2001(1) JILT www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/law/elj/jilt/

_1/henderson [date of use 2 Mar 2013]

Lesser 2001 www.wipo.int

Lesser W 2001 The Effects of TRIPS Mandated Intellectual Property Rights on Economic Activities in Developing Countries www.wipo.int/export/sites/www/

about-ip/en/studies/pdf/ssa_lesser_trips.pdf [date of use 2 Mar 2013]

Property Rights Alliance 2008 internationalpropertyrightsindex.org

Property Rights Alliance 2008 International Property Rights Index, 2008 Report internationalpropertyrightsindex.org/index.php?content=home [date of use 2 Mar 2013]

Property Rights Alliance 2011 internationalpropertyrightsindex.org

Property Rights Alliance 2011 International Property Rights Index, 2011 Report internationalpropertyrightsindex.org/ATR_2011%20INDEX_Web.pdf [date of use 12 Feb 2013]

Rengecas 2013 afroip.blogspot.com

Rengecas T 2013 Africa IP Forum Reflections afroip.blogspot.com/2013/03/

africa-ip-forum-2013-reflections-tracy.html [date of use 1 Mar 2013]

Royal Society of Arts 2006 www.thersa.org

Royal Society of Arts 2006 Promoting Innovation and Rewarding Creativity: A Balanced Intellectual Property Framework for the Digital Age www.thersa.org/

__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/54834/adephi-promoting-innovation-and-rewarding-creativity-january-2007.pdf [date of use 12 Feb 2013]

SA Government Information 2008 www.info.gov.za

SA Government Information 2008 Apex Priorities www.info.gov.za/otherdocs

/2008/apex-priorities0208.pdf [date of use 1 Mar 2013]

Seleti 2012 www.pmg.org.za

Seleti Y 2012 DST Report on IKS Activities: A Progress Report on Sui Generis Legislation www.pmg.org.za/report/20120613-indigenous-knowledge-systems-iks-activities-sui-genris-legislation-b [date of use 28 Feb 2013]

Sen 2000 issat.dcaf.ch

Sen A "What is the role of legal and judicial reform in the development process?" in Papers delivered at the Role of Legal and Judicial Reform in Development, World Bank Legal Conference 5-6 June 2000 Washington DC 1-29 issat.dcaf.ch/index.php/fre/content/download/2331/20258/file/What%

is%20the%20role%20of%20legal%20and%20judicial%20reform%20in%20the%20development%20process%20Sen%20(2000).pdf [date of use 3 Mar 2013]

South African Government News Agency 2013 www.sanews.gov.za

South African Government News Agency 'Dti working on finalising intellectual property policy' 27 February 2013 www.sanews.gov.za/south-africa/dti-working-finalising-intellectual-property-policy [date of use 28 Feb 2013]

Teljeur 2002 www.tips.org.za

Teljeur E 2002 Intellectual Property Rights in South Africa: A Review www.tips.org.za/files/Teljeur_IPRs_paper_2003.PDF [date of use 2 Mar 2013]

The Presidency 2008 www.thepresidency.gov.za

The Presidency 2008 Development Indicators www.thepresidency.gov.za/

learning/me/indicators2008/development_indicators.pdf [date of use 2 Mar 2013]

The President 2012 www.parliament.gov.za

The President 2012 Letter from the President dated 19 September 2012, in ‘Announcements, Tablings and Committee Reports No. 125-2012, Fourth Session, Fourth Parliament, 26 September 2012: Bill Referred Back to National Assembly' 3226 www.parliament.gov.za/live/commonrepository/

Processed/20121001/462777_1.pdf [date of use 3 Mar 2013]

UN 2001 hdr.undp.org

UN 2001 Human Development Report: Making New Technologies Work for Human Development hdr.undp.org/en/reports/global/hdr2001/chapters/ [date of use 13 Feb 2013]

UNCTAD 2011 www.unctad.org

UNCTAD 2011 Global Investment Trends Monitor No 5 (January 2011) www.unctad.org/en/docs//webdiaeia20111_en.pdf [date of use13 Feb 2013]

WIPO 2003 www.wipo.int

WIPO 2003 Understanding How IP Relates to E-commerce www.wipo.int/sme/en/e_commerce/ip_ecommerce.htm [date of use 2 Mar 2013]

WIPO 2013 www.wipo.int

WIPO 2013 Diplomatic Conference to Conclude a Treaty to Facilitate Access to Published Works by Visually Impaired Persons and Persons with Print Disabilities www.wipo.int/dc2013/en/ [date of use 28 Feb 2013]

How to Cite
NcubeC. B. (2017). Harnessing Intellectual Property for Development: Some Thoughts on an Appropriate Theoretical Framework. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 16(4), 368-395. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i4a2420