The Value Added Tax Implications of Illegal Transactions
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2011/v14i4a2592Keywords:
Value Added Tax, illegal transactions, vendor registration, output VAT, input VAT, tax neutrality, tax morality.Abstract
In the case of MP Finance Group CC (In Liquidation) v CSARS the High Court of Appeal ruled that income "received by" a taxpayer from illegal gains will be taxable in the hands of the taxpayer. This article explores whether or not the decision in the MP Finance-case (and preceding cases on the taxation of illegal receipts) can be applied to determine if illegal transactions are subject to VAT and moreover if a trader in illegal goods and services should register as a VAT vendor. Although strictly speaking no analogy can be drawn between the charging provisions for income tax and VAT, it is clear that in the determination of the taxability of illegal income, the courts applied the principle of tax neutrality. In terms of the principle of tax neutrality, taxes are not concerned with the legality or illegality of a transaction, but rather with whether the transaction complies with the requirements for it to be taxed or not. That said, the European Court of Justice has a different approach in applying this principle. According to the European Court of Justice where the intrinsic nature of the goods excludes it from the commercial arena (like narcotic drugs) it should not be subject to VAT, but where the goods compete with a legal market it must be subject to VAT. Charging VAT on illegal transactions might give the impression that government benefits from criminal activities. However, if illegal transactions are not subject to VAT the trader in illegal goods will benefit as his products will be 14% cheaper than his rival’s. Is this necessarily a moral dilemma? In conclusion three arguments can be deduced on the question if illegal transactions should be subject to VAT:
1. Illegal transactions should not be taxed at all. Illegal goods or services fall outside the sphere of the application of the charging provision in section 7(1) of the VAT Act. Moreover, taxing illegal transactions lends a quasi-validity to the contract and gives the impression that government benefits from crime.
2. The intrinsic nature of the goods concerned should determine the VAT-ability thereof. Where the nature of the goods excludes it from the commercial sphere, like narcotics, it should not be subject to VAT. Where the illegal goods compete with a legal market the goods should be subject to VAT to eliminate unjust competition.
3. The principle of tax neutrality makes it clear that the illegality of a transaction has no influence on its taxability. The charging provision in terms of section 7(1) of the VAT act is not concerned with the legality of the transaction. If the transaction complies with the requirements for it to be taxed, it should be subject to VAT.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Beneke and Silver VAT Handbook
Beneke C and Silver M (eds) Deloitte VAT Handbook 7th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2009)
Boomsma et al VAT in Europe
Boonsma A et al (eds) Ernst & Young VAT in Europe (Sweet & Maxwell London 1989)
Buckett VAT in the European Community
Buckett A VAT in the European Community 2nd ed (Butterworths London 1992)
Christie Law of Contract
Christie RH The Law of Contract in South Africa 5th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2006)
Classen 2007 SA Merc LJ
Classen LG "Legality and Income Tax - Is SARS 'Entitled to' Levy Income Tax on Illegal Amounts 'Received by' a Taxpayer?" 2007 SA Merc LJ 534-553
Clegg Practical Guide
Clegg D LexisNexis Practical Guide to VAT 2007 13th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2007)
Collins English Dictionary
William Collins and Sons Co Ltd Collins English Dictionary 6th ed (HarperCollins Publishers New York 2003)
Coopers and Lybrand Guide to VAT
Coopers and Lybrand (ed) A Guide to VAT in the EU: The single market changes 1994 update (Kluwer Brussels 1994)
Dale and Nieuwenhuizen VAT Yearbook
Dale S and Nieuwenhuizen WAP VAT Yearbook 2009: VAT Decisions of the European Court of Justice 1974-2008 (Wolters-Kluwer Deventer 2009)
De Koker and Kruger Value Added Tax
De Koker AP and Kruger D Value Added Tax in South Africa: Commentary (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2009)
Ferguson and Rubin Handy Guide
Ferguson S and Rubin RRR Handy Guide to VAT (Handy Publications Trust Roosevelt Park 1991)
Hutchison and Pretorius Kontraktereg
Hutchison D and Pretorius CJ (eds) Kontraktereg in Suid-Afrika (Oxford Cape Town 2010)
Huxham and Haupt Notes on South African Income Tax
Huxham K and Haupt P Notes on South African Income Tax 2010 (H&H Publications Roggebaai 2010)
Huxham and Haupt South African VAT
Huxham K and Haupt P South African VAT: The Book (H&H Publications Constantia 1991)
James VAT Demystified
James A VAT Demystified (Southern Book Publishers Constantia Park 1991)
Keesling 1958 UCLA Law Review
Keesling FM "Illegal Transactions and Income tax" 1958 UCLA Law Review 26-46
Kerr Principles
Kerr AJ The Principles of the Law of Contract 6th ed (Butterworths Durban 2002)
Maasdorp Institutes
Maasdorp AFS The Institutes of South African Law: Book II: The Law of Obligations 7th ed (Juta Johannesburg 1961)
Meyerowitz Meyerowitz on Income Tax
Meyerowitz D Meyerowitz on Income Tax 2008 (The Taxpayer Cape Town 2008)
Morris, Huxham and Haupt Getting to Know VAT
Morris JRP, Huxham K and Haupt P Getting to Know VAT: A Practical Guide (SA Institute of Taxation Cape Town 1988)
Muller 2007 Obiter
Muller E "The Taxation of Illegal Receipts: A Pyramid of Problems! A discussion on ITC 1789 (Income Tax Court – Natal)" 2007 Obiter 166-181
Olivier 2008 TSAR
Olivier L "The Taxability of Illegal Income" 2008 TSAR 814-819
Pugsley 2001 Tax Planning
Pugsley S "Selling the Game - Part IV: Income from illegal services" 2001 Tax Planning 15(4) 89-92
Soanes and Stevenson Concise Oxford English Dictionary
Soanes C and Stevenson A (eds) Concise Oxford English Dictionary 11th ed (Oxford University Press New York 2008)
Stiglingh et al South African Income Tax 2010
Stiglingh M et al Silke: South African Income Tax 2010 (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2010)
Stiglingh et al South African Income Tax 2011
Stiglingh M et al Silke: South African Income Tax 2011 (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2010)
Terra and Wattel European Tax Law
Terra BJM and Wattel PJ European Tax Law: Student Edition 5th ed (Kluwer Deventer 2008)
Van der Merwe et al Kontraktereg
Van der Merwe S et al Kontraktereg: Algemene Beginsels 3rd ed (Juta Cape Town 2007)
Register of cases
England
Partridge v Mallandaine 1886 2 TC 179
European Union
Karlheinz Fischer v Finanzamt Donaueschingen Case C-283/95 ECJ
R v Goodwin & Unstead Case C-3/97 ECJ
Staatssecretaris van Financiën v Coffeeshop "Siberië" vof Case C158/98 ECJ
Town and County Factors Ltd v Commissioners of Customs and Excise Case C-498/99 ECJ
Vereniging Happy Family Rustenburgerstraa Inspecteur der Omzetbelasting Case 289/86 ECJ
Namibia
CIR v NAMSOV Fishing Enterprise (Pty) Ltd 2009 2 SA 567 (NmS)
South Africa
Barclays National Bank v Brownlee 1981 3 SA 579 (D)
Brooks Lemos Ltd v CIR 1947 2 SA 976 (A)
Case IT 11282 2005 ZATC 5 (18 March 2005)
CIR v Delagoa Bay Cigarette Co 1918 TPD 391
CIR v Delfos 1933 AD 242
CIR v People's Stores (Walvis Bay) (Pty) Ltd 1990 2 SA 353 (A)
First National Bank of Southern Africa Ltd v Perry 2001 3 SA 960 (SCA)
Geldenhuys v CIR 1947 3 SA 265 (C)
Hamilton-Browning v Dennis Barker Trust 2001 4 SA 1131 (N)
Henry v Branfield 1996 1 SA 244 (D)
ITC 1545 54 SATC 464
ITC 1624 59 SATC 373
ITC 1792 67 SATC 236
Jajbhay v Cassim 1939 AD 537
Klokow v Sullivan 2006 1 SA 259 (SCA)
Lategan v CIR 1926 CPD 203
Mamoojee v Akoo 1947 4 SA 733 (N)
Metcash Trading Ltd v Commissioner South African Revenue Services 2001 1 SA 1109 (CC)
Milner Street Properties (Pty) Ltd v Eckstein Properties (Pty) Ltd 2001 4 SA 1315 (SCA)
MP Finance Group CC (In Liquidation) v CSARS 69 SATC 141
National Educare Forum v CSARS 2002 3 SA 111 (TkHC)
Ochberg v CIR 1933 CPD 256
Price Waterhouse Meyernel v Thoroughbred Breeders' Association of South Africa 2003 3 SA 54 (SCA)
Rooiberg Minerals Development Co Ltd v Du Toit 1953 2 SA 505 (T)
Shell's Annandale Farm (Pty) Ltd v Commissioner, South African Revenue Services 2000 3 SA 564 (C)
Swart v Smuts 1971 1 SA 819 (A)
Warren and De Ville v Cacouris 1951 2 SA 574 (T)
Weare v Commissioner, South African Revenue Services 2005 4 SA 488 (SCA)
United States of America
Commissioner of Internal Revenue v Doyle 231 F2d 635 (11 April 1956)
European Union
Sixth Council Directive of 17 May 1977 on the harmonization of the laws of the Member States relating to turnover taxes - Common system of value added tax: uniform basis of assessment (77/388/EEC)
South Africa
Counterfeit Goods Act 37 of 1997
Gauteng Liquor Act 2 of 2003
Income Tax Act 58 of 1962
Prevention and Combating of Corrupt Activities Act 12 of 2004
Sales Tax Act 103 of 1978
Sexual Offences Act 23 of 1957
Value Added Tax Act 89 of 1991
Register of internet sources
Háború [date unknown] taxwar.net
Háború A [date unknown] Capone and the illegal income tax taxwar.net/capone-illegal-income-tax.html [date of use 20 Jun 2011]
MSN Money Staff 2009 articles.moneycentral.msn.com
MSN Money Staff 2009 Bribes, thefts and other taxable income articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Taxes/Advice/BribesTheftsAndOtherTaxableIncome.aspx?page=1 [date of use 20 Jun 2011]
Onoue-Oliveira 2010 www.articlesbase.com
Onoue-Oliveira F 2010 The taxation of illegal receipts and the deduction of expenditure related thereto www.articlesbase.com/regulatory-compliance-articles/the-taxation-of-illegal-receipts-and-the-deduction-of-expenditure-related-thereto-3627008.html#axzz1Po6G6zAs [date of use 20 Jun 2011]
Vanek 2008 www.moneywebtax.co.za
Vanek M 2008 SARS after your illegal income too www.moneywebtax.co.za/moneywebtax/view/moneywebtax/en/page259?oid=2815&sn=Detail [date of use 11 Jun 2011]
Vos 2006 www.deneysreitz.co.za
Vos A 2006 Illegal contracts - 'clean H&s;' & public policy www.deneysreitz.co.za/index.php/news/illegal_contracts_clean_h_public_policy/ [date of use 9 Feb 2011]
Webber Wentzel Attorneys 2005 www.webberwentzel.com
Webber Wentzel Attorneys 2005 The taxation of illegal proceeds www.webberwentzel.com/wwb/content/en/page1874?oid=1929&sn=Detail&pid=1874 [date of use 7 Feb 2011]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 SP van Zyl
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}