Traditional Knowledge and Patent Protection: Conflicting Views On International Patent Standards
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2010/v13i4a2701Keywords:
Traditional knowledge, patent protection, international patent standards.Abstract
As diseases continue to spread around the globe, pharmaceutical and biotech companies continue to search for new and better drugs to treat them. Most of these companies have realised that useful compounds for these purposes may be found in the natural resources that indigenous and local communities use. And yet, even though the importance of these biological resources to global health and economic livelihood is well recognised, the legal ownership and control of this traditional knowledge is still very controversial. This article undertakes a comparative analysis of American and European, as well as international legal regulations on patent law and traditional knowledge. Key questions include: What is traditional knowledge? How have the national patent laws of these countries treated the protection of plant variety and plant genetic resources? What are the existing international standards for patents, and what implications do they have for protecting traditional knowledge? And finally, what protection systems are emerging for the future?
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Barton Der 'Ordre public'
Barton T Der 'Ordre public' als Grenze der Biopatentierung (Erich Schmidt Verlag Berlin 2004)
Bender 2003 Tulsa J Comp & Int’l L
Bender K "North and South: The WTO, TRIPS, and the Scourge of Biopiracy" 2003 Tulsa J Comp & Int’l L 281-319
Cantuária Marin Providing Protection
Cantuária Marin PL Providing Protection for Plant Genetic Resources. Patents, Sui Generis, Systems, and Biopartnerships (Kluwer Law The Hague 2002)
Carroll 2005 Am U L Rev
Carroll AE "A Review of Recent Decisions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit" 1995 Am U L Rev 2433-2495
Cohen 1998 Mich L Rev
Cohen JE "Lochner in Cyberspace: The New Economic Orthodoxy of 'Rights Management'" 1998 Mich Law Rev 462-556
Conway-Jones 2005 How L J
Conway-Jones D "Safeguarding Hawaiian Traditional Knowledge and Cultural Heritage: Supporting the Right to Self-Determination and Preventing the Co-modification of Culture" 2005 How L J 737-762
Correa Intellectual Property Rights
Correa CM Intellectual Property Rights, the WTO and Developing Countries (Zed books London 2000)
Correa Traditional Knowledge
Correa CM Traditional Knowledge and Intellectual Property. Issues and Options Surrounding the Protection of Traditional Knowledge (Quaker United Nations Office Geneva 2001)
DeGeer 2003 New Eng J Int'l & Comp L
DeGeer ME "Biopiracy: The Appropriation of Indigenous Peoples' Cultural Knowledge" 2003 New Eng J Int'l & Comp L 179-208
Dolder 2007 Biotechnology Law Report
Dolder F "Traditional Knowledge and patenting: The Experience of the Neemfungicide and the Hoodia Cases" 2007 Biotechnology Law Report 583-590
Dutfield 2003 Case W Res J Int'l L
Dutfield G "TRIPS-Related Aspects of Traditional Knowledge" 2001 Case W Res J Int’l L 233-275
Dutfield Intellectual Property Rights
Dutfield G Intellectual Property Rights and the Life Science Industries: a Twentieth Century History (Ashgate Dartmouth 2003)
Ekpere OAU’s Model Law
Ekpere JA The OAU’s Model Law, Organisation of African Unity (Scientific, Technical & Research Commission Lagos 2000)
European Commission Report on the International Protection
European Commission Report on the International Protection of Expressions of Folklore under Intellectual Property Law (European Commission Brussels 2000)
European Patent Office Scenarios for the Future
European Patent Office Scenarios for the future: Evolution of the System (Munich 2008)
Garcia 2007 Berkeley La Raza L J
Garcia J "Fighting Biopiracy: the Legislative Protection of Traditional Knowledge" 2007 Berkeley La Raza L J 5-28
Gervais TRIPS Agreement
Gervais D The TRIPS Agreement: Drafting History and Analysis 2nd ed (London Sweet & Maxwell 2003)
Gervais 2005 Mich St L Rev
Gervais D "Traditional Knowledge and Intellectual Property: A TRIPS-Compatible Approach" 2005 Mich St L Rev 137-166
Ghosh 2003 Colum J Asian L
Ghosh S "Globalization, Patents, and Traditional Knowledge" 2003 Colum J Asian L 73-120
Golden 2001 Emory L J
Golden J "Biotechnology, Technology Policy and Patentability: Natural Products and Invention in the American System" 2001 Emory L J 101-191
GRULAC Traditional Knowledge
Group of Countries of Latin America and the Caribbean (GRULAC) Traditional knowledge and the need to give it adequate intellectual property protection - WO/GA/26/9 (GRULAC Geneva 2000)
Jiang 2008 Harvard Int Rev
Jiang F "The Problem with Patents. Traditional Knowledge and International IP Law" 2008 Harvard Int Rev 30-33
Kalb 2005 Newsweek
Kalb C "Pharmacy Island" 2005 Newsweek 145(26A) 54-56, 58
Kate and Laird Commercial Use
Kate KT and Laird SA The Commercial Use of Biodiversity: Access to Genetic Resources and Benefit-Sharing (Earthscan Publications London 1999)
Kloppenburg First the Seed
Kloppenburg Jr. J First the Seed: the Political Economy of Plant Biotechnology, 1492-2000 (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1988)
Kothari "Beyond the Biodiversity Convention"
Kothari A "Beyond the Biodiversity Convention: a View from India" in Sánchez V and Juma C (eds) Biodiplomacy: Genetic Resources and International Relations (African Centre for Technology Studies Nairobi 1994) 67-86
Lambert, Srivastava and Vietmeyer "Medical Plants"
Lambert J, Srivastava J and Vietmeyer N "Medical Plants: Rescuing a Global Heritage" 1997 in World Bank Technical Paper No 320 (World Bank Washington 1997)
Lochen Die völkerrechtlichen Regelungen
Lochen T Die völkerrechtlichen Regelungen über den Zugang zu genetischen Ressourcen (Mohr Siebeck Tübingen 2007)
Mgbeoji Global Biopiracy
Mgbeoji I Global Biopiracy: Patents, Plants, and Indigenous Knowledge (Cornell University Press Ithaca 2006)
Mgbeoji "Patents and Plant Resources-Related Knowledge"
Mgbeoji I "Patents and Plant Resources-Related Knowledge: Towards a Regime of Communal Patents for Plant Resources-Related Knowledge" in Burhenne-Guilmin F and Bonilla MC (eds) Environmental Law in Developing Countries (Gland World Conservation Union 2002) 79-116
Nijar "A Conceptual Framework"
Nijar GS "A conceptual framework and essential elements of a rights regime for the protection of Indigenous rights and biodiversity" in Third World Network Intergovernmental Committee on the Convention on Biological Diversity 20 June-1 July (Penang 1994) accessible at http://www.grain.org/briefings/ [date of use 25 November 2010]
Nijar In Defense of Local Community
Nijar GS In Defense of Local Community Knowledge and Biodiversity (TWN Penang 1996)
Oguamanam 2003 St Thomas L Rev
Oguamanam C "Between Reality and Rhetoric: The Epistemic Schism in the Recognition of Traditional Medicine in International Law" 2003 St Thomas L Rev 59-108
Oller "EPO accepts traditional knowledge database"
Oller P "EPO accepts traditional knowledge database" 2009 Managing Intellectual Property 13 February 2009
Pott 1944 Mod L Rev
Pott H "The Definition of Invention in Patent Law" 1944 Mod L Rev 113-123
Ragavan 2001 Minn Intell Prop Rev
Ragavan S "Protection of Traditional Knowledge" 2001 2 Minn Intell Prop Rev 1-60
Sampath Regulating Bioprospecting
Sapmpath PG Regulating bioprospecting: Institutions for Drug Research, Access, and Benefit Sharing (United Nations University Press Tokyo 2005)
Schecter and Thomas Principles of Patent Law
Schecter RE and Thomas JR Principles of Patent Law (St. Paul, Minn. Thomson West 2004)
Sheridan 2005 Nature Biotechnology
Sheridan C "EPO neem patent revocation revives biopiracy debate" 2005 Nature Biotechnology 1-12
Shiva et al Enclosure and Recovery
Shiva V et al The Enclosure and Recovery of the Commons (Research Foundation for Science, Technology and Ecology New Delhi 1997)
Sibley Law and Strategy
Sibley KD The Law and Strategy of Biotechnology Patents (Butterworth-Heinemann London 1994)
Sinnot World Patent Law
Sinnot J World Patent Law and Practice (Matthew Bender New York 1977)
Staffler Towards a Reconciliation
Staffler JC Towards a Reconciliation Between the Convention on Biological Diversity and TRIPS Agreement: an Interface among Intellectual Property Rights Biotechnology, Traditional Knowledge and Benefit Sharing (University of Geneva Geneva 2001)
Stenton 2004 Eur. Intell Prop Rev
Stenton G "Biopiracy within the Pharmaceutical Industry: a Stark Illustration of how Abusive, Manipulative and Perverse the Patenting Process can be Towards Countries of the South" 2004 Eur Intell Prop Rev 17-26
Stoianoff "International Perspective"
Stoianoff NP "An International Perspective on the Implementation of the Biodiversity Treaty and Access to Biological Resources" in Soianoff NP Accessing Biological Resources: Complying with the Convention on Biological Diversity (Kluwer Law International The Hague 2004)
Subbiah 2004 BC Int’l & Comp L Rev
Subbiah S "Reaping What They Sow: The Basmati Rice Controversy and Strategies for Protecting Traditional Knowledge" 2004 BC Int’l & Comp L Rev 529-559
Taubman and Leistner "Traditional Knowledge"
Taubman A and Leistner M "Traditional Knowledge" in von Lewinski S (ed) Indigenous Heritage and Intellectual Property: Genetic Resources, Traditional Knowledge and Folklore (Wolters Kluwer Law & Business Austin 2008) 59-92
Ten Kate and Laird Commercial Use of Biodiversity
Ten Kate K and Laird S The commercial use of biodiversity – Access to Genetic Resources and Benefit Sharing (Earthscan London 1999)
Torrance 2008 Geo Int’l Envtl L Rev
Torrance AW "An Extinction Bar to Patent Ability" 2008 Geo Int’l Envtl L Rev 237-270
UNCTAD TRIPs Agreement
UNCTAD The TRIPs Agreement and Developing Countries (UNCTAD New York 1996)
Von Hahn Traditionelles Wissen
Von Hahn A Traditionelles Wissen indigener und lokaler Gemeinschaften zwischen geistigen Eigentumsrechten und der 'public domain' (Springer Berlin 2004)
Wagner and Pachenberg IIC
Wagner H and Pachenberg J "Paris Convention Priority: a Unique American Viewpoint Denying 'the Same Effect' to the Foreign Filing" 1974 IIC 362-381
WHO Strategy for Traditional Medicine
WHO Strategy for Traditional Medicine 2000-2003 (WHO Geneva 2000)
Wilson Diversity of Life
Wilson EO The Diversity of Life (New York Norton 1992)
WIPO Matters Concerning Intellectual Property
WIPO Matters Concerning Intellectual Property and Genetic Resources, Traditional Knowledge and Folklore - WO/GA/26/6 (WIPO Geneva 2000)
WIPO "Intellectual Property Needs"
WIPO "Intellectual Property Needs and Expectations of Traditional Knowledge as Prior Art" in WIPO Report on Fact-Finding Missions on Intellectual Property and Traditional Knowledge (WIPO Geneva 1998-1999)
WIPO Survey on Existing Forms
WIPO Survey on Existing Forms of Intellectual Property Protection for Traditional Knowledge - WIPO/GRTKF/IC/2/9 (WIPO Geneva 2001)
Wolfrum "Convention on Biological Diversity"
Wolfrum R "The Convention on Biological Diversity: Using State Jurisdiction as a Means of Ensuring Compliance" in Wolfrum R (ed) Enforcing Environmental Standards: Economic Mechanisms as Viable Means? (Springer Berlin 1996) 372-393
Register of cases
European Patent Office
Prapagatin material/Ciba-Geigy OJ EPO 112 (1984) T 49/83
Hybrid Plants/Lubrizol OJ EPO 71 (1997) T320/87
Plant Cells/Plant Genetic Systems OJ EPO 545 (1995) T356/93
Privy Council, United Kingdom
Attorney-General v Adelaide Steamship Co 1913 Appeal Cases 781 (1913)
United States of America
American Hoist & Derrick Co v Sowa & Sons Inc 725 F2d 1350 (Fed Cir) cert Denied 469 US 821 (1984)
Dennis v Pitner 106 F 2d 142 (7th Cir 1939)
Diamond v Chakrabarty 447 US 303 (1980)
Dunway v New York 442 US 200 (1979)
Le Roy v Tatham 55 US 156 (1852)
Register of legislation
Plant Patent Act 1930, 35 United States Code
Plant Variety Protection Act 1970 84, Statute 1542, 7 United States Code
Register of international documents
Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights 1994
Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) 1994 33 International Law Materials 1197
Convention Establishing the World Intellectual Property Organization 1967
Convention Establishing the World Intellectual Property Organization 1967 21 United Nations Treaty Series 1749
Convention on Biological Diversity 1992
Convention on Biological Diversity 1992 31 International Legal Materials 813
Convention on the Grant of the European Patents 1973
Convention on the Grant of the European Patents 1973 13 International Legal Materials 276
Directive 98/44/EC 1998
Directive 98/44/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 6 July 1998 on the legal protection of biotechnological inventions, Official Journal L 213, 30/07/1998 0013–0021
ILO Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention
ILO Convention Concerning Indigenous and Tribal Peoples in Independent Countries 1989 (C169) 28 International Legal Materials 1389
International Convention for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants 1961
Union pour la Protection des Obstentions Vegetales (International Convention for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants) 1961 15 United Nations Treaty Series 89
Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property 1883
Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property of March 1883, revised in Stockholm in July 1967, United Nations Treaty Series 305
Patent Cooperation Treaty 1970
Patent Cooperation Treaty 1970 1160 United Nations Treaty Series 231
UN Martinez Cobo Report
Cobo JRM Study of the Problem of Discrimination against Indigenous Populations - UN Doc. E/CN.4/Sub.2/1986/7 1986
Register of Internet sources
Anonymous www.en.wikipedia.org
Anonymous (date unknown) Neem Tree www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neem [date of use 16 Jun 2009]
German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety 2008 www.bmu.de
German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety 2008 Study on the Economic Dimension of Biological Diversity is Carried Out from Bonn - Press Release No. 289/08 www.bmu.de/english/press_releases/archive/16th_legislative_period/pm/42729.php 8 [date of use 16 Jun 2009]
Pandeya and Koshy 2009 www.livemint.com
Pandeya R and Koshy J 2009 Ginger Can’t be Patented in Europe Now www.livemint.com/2009/02/05214415/Ginger-can8217t-be-patented.html [date of use 16 Jun 2009]
Shiva www.twnside.org.sg
Shiva V (date unknown) The Neem Tree – a Case History of Biopiracy www.twnside.org.sg/title/pir-ch.htm [date of use 16 Jun 2009]
WIPO 2009 www.wipo.int/
WIPO 2009 Program Activities – Traditional Knowledge www.wipo.int/tk/en/tk/ [date of use 16 Jun 2009]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Adam Andrzejewski
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}