Reflections on the Biowatch Dispute – Reviewing the fundamental rules on costs In the light of the needs of constitutional and/or public interest litigation
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2009/v12i1a2721Abstract
Using as a case study the recent decision on costs in the Biowatch matter, this article critically examines the traditional fundamental rules on costs in the light of the needs of constitutional and a fortiori public interest litigation. The fundamental rules on costs are taken to include the two traditional principles (that costs are a matter of judicial discretion and that to a successful party should be awarded his costs), the requirement that the discretion be exercised judicially, the test for interference in costs orders in a court of appeal, and the characterisation of costs orders as requiring the exercise of only a narrow discretion on appeal. In the light of the decisions in the Biowatch matter it is argued that the current rules do not meet the new needs of constitutional and/or public interest litigation as regards access to justice, equal protection and benefit of the law, proportionality, and the accountability of the judiciary. Suggestions are made for possible reform.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Brooke 2006 JEL
Lord Justice Brooke "David Hall Memorial Lecture – Environmental Justice
– The Cost Barrier" 2006 (18) Journal of Environmental Law 341-356
Cilliers Law of Costs
Cilliers AC Law of Costs Online (Lexis-Nexis Butterworths Durban 2008)
Dugard 2006 SAJHR
Dugard J "Court of first instance? Towards a pro-poor jurisdiction for the
South African Constitutional Court" 2006 (22) South African Journal of Human Rights 261-282
Friedman "Costs"
Friedman A "Costs" in Woolman S (ed) Constitutional Law of South Africa 2nd ed (Juta Lansdowne 2002)
Heywood and Hassim "Remedying the maladies"
Heywood M and Hassim A "Remedying the maladies of 'lesser men and women': The personal, political and constitutional imperatives for improved access to justice" (Paper delivered at a symposium in honour of Justice
Edwin Cameron on 10 October 2008 at the School of Law, University of the Witwatersrand)
Hirte 1991 ICLQ
Hirte HA "Access to the courts for indigent persons: A comparative analysis" 1991 (40) International & Comparative Law Quarterly 91-123
Preston 1991 JELL
Preston BJ "Public enforcement of environmental laws in Australia" 1991
(6) Journal of Environmental Law and Litigation 39-79
Working Group on Access to Environmental Justice 2008 JPEL
Working Group on Access to Environmental Justice "Ensuring access to justice in England and Wales: Report of the Working Group on Access to Environmental Justice" 2008 (9) Journal of Planning & Environment Law 1253
Register of legislation
Access to Justice Act 1999 (UK)
Administration of Estates Act 24 of 1913
Companies Act 61 of 1973
Companies Act of 1926
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996
Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977
Genetically Modified Organisms Act 15 of 1997
National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998 Promotion of Access to Information Act 2 of 2000
Supreme Court Act 59 of 1959
Register of cases
ANC v Minister of Local Government and Housing, KwaZulu-Natal 1998 (3) SA 1 (CC), 1998 (4) BCLR 399
Armbruster v Minister of Finance 2007 (6) SA 550 (CC), 2007 (12) BCLR 1283
Attorney-General, Eastern Cape v Blom 1988 (4) SA 645 (A)
Bel Porto School Governing Body v Premier of the Province, Western Cape 2002 (3) SA 265 (CC), 2002 (9) BCLR 891
British Columbia (Minister of Forests) v Okanjan Indian Band [2003] 3 SCR (SCC)
Bookworks (Pty) Ltd v Greater Johannesburg Transitional Metropolitan Council 1999 (4) SA 799 (W)
Chirwa v Transnet Ltd 2008 (4) SA 367 (CC), 2008 (3) BCLR 251
Coalition of Citizens for a Charter Challenge v Metropolitan Authority (1993)
NSR (2d) 1; 103 DLR (4) 409 (SCTD)
Democratic Alliance v Masondo NO 2003 (2) SA 413 (CC)
Department of Land Affairs v Goedgeleden Tropical Fruits (Pty) Ltd 2007 (6)
SA 199 (CC), 2007 (10) BCLR 1027
Ex Parte Minister of Safety and Security: In re S v Walters 2002 (7) BCLR 663
(CC)
Ex Parte Neethling 1951 (4) SA 331 (A)
Ferreira v Levin NO (2) 1996 (2) SA 61 (CC), 1996 (4) BCLR 441
Fripp v Gibbon 1913 AD 354
Fuel Retailers Association of Southern Africa v Director-General Environmental
Management, Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Environment, Mpumalanga Province 2007 (6) SA 4 (CC)
Giddey NO v JC Barnard & Partners 2007 (5) SA 525 (CC), 2007(2) BCLR 125 Gory v Kolver NO (Starke intervening) 2007 (4) SA 97 (CC), 2007 (3) BCLR 249
Griffiths v Mutual & Federal Insurance Co Ltd 1994 (1) SA 535 (A)
K & S Dry Cleaning Equipment (Pty) Ltd v South African Eagle Insurance Co Ltd 2001 (3) SA 652 (W)
Kilian v Geregsbode, Uitenhage 1980 (1) SA 808 (A)
Levben Products (Pvt) Ltd v Alexander Films (SA) (Pty) Ltd 1957 (4) SA 225 (SR)
Mahomed v Kazi's Agencies (Pty) Ltd 1949 (1) SA 1162 (N)
MEC: Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Environment v HTF
Developers (Pty) Ltd 2008 (2) SA 319 (CC), 2008 (4) BCLR 417
MEC for Education: KwaZulu Natal, Thulani Cele: School Liaison Officer, Anne Martin: Principal of Durban Girls' High School, Fiona Knight: Chairperson of the Governing Body of Durban Girls' High School v Navaneethum Pillay,
Governing Body Foundation, Natal Tamil Vedic Society Trust, Freedom of
Expression Institute 2008 (2) BCLR 99 (CC)
Merber v Merber 1948 (1) SA 446 (A)
Motsepe v Commissioner for Inland Affairs 1997 (2) SA 898 (CC), 1997 (6) BCLR 692
Napier v Barkhuizen 2007 (5) SA 323 (CC), 2007 (7) BCLR 691
Naylor & another v Jansen 2007 (1) SA 16 (SCA)
Neugebauer & Co Ltd v Herman 1923 AD 564
Njongi v Member of the Executive Council, Department of Welfare, Eastern
Cape 2008 (4) SA 237 (CC), 2008 (6) BCLR 571
NM v Smith 2007 (5) SA 250 (CC)
Occupiers of 51 Olivia Road, Berea Township v City of Johannesburg 2008 (4)
SA 237 (CC), 2008 (5) BCLR 475
Penny v Walker 1936 AD 241
Premier, Province of Mpumalanga v Executive Committee of the Association of Governing Bodies of State-aided Schools: Eastern Transvaal 1999 (2) SA 91 (CC), 1999 (2) BCLR 151
Protea Assurance Co Ltd v Matinise 1978 (1) SA 963 (A)
Rex v Zackey 1945 AD 505
Rondalia Assurance Corporation of SA Ltd v Page 1975 (1) SA 708 (A)
S v Makwanyane 1995 (3) SA 391 (CC), 1995 (6) BCLR 665
SACCAWU v Irvin & Johnson Ltd (Seafoods Division Fish Processing) 2000 (3) SA 705 (CC)
Sanderson v Attorney-General, Eastern Cape 1998 (2) SA 38 (CC), 1997 (12) BCLR 1675
South African Broadcasting Corporation Ltd v National Director of Public
Prosecutions 2007 (1) SA 523 (CC)
Steenkamp NO v Provincial Tender Board Eastern Cape 2007 (3) SA 121 (CC), 2007 (3) BCLR 300
Swartbooi v Brink 2006 (1) SA 203 (CC), 2006 (5) BCLR 502 (CC)
Tjospomie Boerdery (Pty) Ltd v Drakensburg Botteliers (Pty) Ltd 1989 (4) SA 31 (T), [1989] 4 All SA 228
Trustees, Biowatch Trust v Registrar: Genetic Resources 2005 (4) SA 111 (T)
Trustees for the time being of The Biowatch Trust v Registrar Genetic
Resources (A831/2005) [2007] ZAGPHC 270
Trustees of the time being of the Biowatch Trust v Registrar Genetic Resources (Open Democracy Advice Centre as Amicus Curiae) (A831/2005) [2008] ZAGPHC 135
Union of Refugee Women v Director: Private Security Industry Regulatory
Authority 2007 (4) SA 395 (CC), 2007 (4) BCLR 339
Van der Merwe v Road Accident Fund 2006 (4) SA 230 (CC), 2006 (6) BCLR 682
Wildlife Society of Southern Africa v Minister of Environmental Affairs and
Tourism 1996 (3) SA 1095 (Tks)
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Tracy-Lynn Humby
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.