Aspects of Land Administration in the Context of Good Governance
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2009/v12i2a2726Keywords:
Good governance, Transparency, Accountability, Professional ethos, Financial control, Land administration, Land reform, Land restitution, Land redistribution, Tenure reform, Communal land rights, Land policy, Land registration, Equal protection, CadastralAbstract
This paper explores aspects of land administration where public funding and interests necessitate the application of good governance practices. The South African land reform programme is divided in three sub-programmes, namely land restitution, land redistribution and tenure reform. Land reform is a vast subject, based on policy, legislation and case law. Therefore it is impossible to deal with good governance principles over the wide spectrum of land reform. Special attention is however given to the land restitution programme in terms of the Restitution of Land Rights Act 22 of 1994 and tenure reform in the rural areas by means of the Communal Land Rights Act 11 of 2004. The purpose is not to formulate a blueprint for good governance or to indicate which good governance principles will solve all or most of the land tenure problems. It is rather an effort to indicate that policies and procedures to improve good governance in some aspects of land reform are urgently needed and should be explored further.Restitution of Land Rights Act and the Communal Land Rights Act, is extensive and far-reaching. However, many legislative measures are either impractical due to financial constraints and lack of capacity of the Department of Land Affairs, or are not based on sufficient participation by local communities. Land administration should furthermore be planned and executed in the context of global good governance practices. This includes equal protection; clear land policy principles; land tenure principles according to the needs of individuals and population groups; flexible land registration principles to accommodate both individual and communal land tenure; and appropriate institutional arrangements. It is clear that established good governance principles may solve many of the problems encountered in land administration in South Africa. It is a topic that needs to be explored further.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Adams, Cousins and Manona "Land tenure"
Adams M, Cousins B and Manona S "Land tenure and economic development in rural South Africa" in Cousins B (ed) At the crossroads:
Land and agrarian reform into the 21st century (Agrarian Studies School of
Government University of the Western-Cape 2000) 110-114
Anon Legalbrief 2008 (Sep)
Anon "Cost escalates due to land Bill delays" Legalbrief 4 September 2008 4
Anon Legalbrief 2008 (Oct)
Anon "Land officials to explain discrepancies" Legalbrief 8 October 2008 2 Anseeuw and Mathebula "Pre- and post settlement implications"
Anseeuw W and Mathebula N "Linking restitution of land to development: pre- and post settlement implications" Paper presented at Land, Memory,
Reconstruction and Justice Conference 13 September 2006 Houwhoek, South Africa (Proceedings on CD)
Badenhorst, Pienaar and Mostert Law of Property
Badenhorst P, Pienaar J and Mostert H Silberberg-Schoeman's Law of Property (LexisNexis Durban 2006)
Bohlin "Choosing cash over land"
Bohlin A "Choosing cash over land: Considering the time factor in urban land claims" Paper presented at Land, Memory, Reconstruction and Justice
Conference 13 September 2006 Houwhoek, South Africa (Proceedings on CD)
Bosch and Hirschfield "Legal analysis"
Bosch D and Hirschfield E "Legal analysis of communal property institutions used in land reform" (Unpublished report for the CSIR Pretoria 2004)
Botha 2008 JCRDL
Botha MM "Can whistle-blowing be an effective good governance tool?"
Journal of Contemporary Roman-Dutch Law 482-495
Bottomley Sake24 2008
Bottomley EJ "Kommissie kla eienaars druk grondpryse op" Sake24 16 October 2008 3
Carey Miller and Pope Land title
Carey Miller DL and Pope A Land title in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2000)
Claassens 2005 Acta Juridica
Claassens A "The Communal Land Rights Act and women – does the Act remedy or entrench discrimination and the distortion of the customary?" 2005 Acta Juridica 42-81
Conway and Xipu "Securing post settlement support"
Conway A and Xipu T "Securing post settlement support towards sustainable restitution – lessons from Covie" Paper presented at Land,
Memory, Reconstruction and Justice Conference 13 September 2006
Houwhoek, South Africa (Proceedings on CD)
Cousins 2005 Stell LR
Cousins B "'Embeddedness' versus titling: African land tenure systems and the potential impact of the Communal Land Rights Act 11 of 2004" 2005 Stellenbosch Law Review 488-513
Cousins et al "Perspectives"
Cousins T, Hornby D, Kingwell B, Royston D and Trench T "Perspectives on land tenure security in rural and urban South Africa" (Unpublished AFRA report Pietermaritzburg 2005)
Dale 1997 Urban Studies
Dale PF "Land tenure issues in economic development" 1997 (34) Urban Studies 1621-1633
Dale and McLaughlin Land administration
Dale PF and McLaughlin JD Land administration (Oxford University Press Oxford 1999)
Dalrymple Expanding land tenure
Dalrymple K Expanding land tenure to alleviate poverty (PhD thesis
University of Melbourne2005)
De Bruin Beeld 2008
De Bruin P "Grootste grondeis sloer steeds" Beeld 21 October 2008 8
De Jager "Organised agriculture"
De Jager T "Organised agriculture's experiences on successes, challenges and concrete proposals" (Unpublished paper presented at the Conference on Land Reform in South Africa 26 August 2008 Pretoria)
De Villiers Land reform
De Villiers B Land reform: Issues and challenges (Konrad-AdenhauerStiftung Johannesburg 2003)
De Wet and Mgujulwa "When rights go wrong"
De Wet C and Mgujulwa E "When rights go wrong: The dynamics of as successful land restitution claim in the Eastern Cape" Paper presented at
Land, Memory, Reconstruction and Justice Conference 13 September 2006 Houwhoek, South Africa (Proceedings on CD)
Deininger and Binswanger 1999 World Bank Observer
Deininger K and Binswanger H "The evolution of the World Bank's land policy: principles, experience, and future challenges" 1999 (14) The World Bank Observer 247-276
Du Plessis, Olivier and Pienaar 2005 SAPL 186-207
Du Plessis W, Olivier NJJ and Pienaar JM "Land matters: New developments" 2005 (1) South African Public Law 186-207
Du Plessis, Olivier and Pienaar 2005 SAPL 435-457
Du Plessis W, Olivier NJJ and Pienaar JM "Land matters: New developments" 2005 (2) South African Public Law 435-457
Ferreira-Snyman and Ferreira 2006 SAYIL
Ferreira-Snyman MP and Ferreira GM "Global good governance and good global governance" 2006 South African Yearbook of International Law 5594
Geyer "Post-settlement support"
Geyer C "SADC overview of post-settlement support in South Africa"
(Unpublished paper presented at the Conference on Land Reform in South Africa 26 August 2008 Pretoria)
Godden and Tehan "Translating native title"
Godden L and Tehan E "Translating native title to individual title in
Australia: Are real property forms and indigenous interests reconcilable?"
Paper in the Proceedings of the Reading Property Law Conference April 2006 7-38
Groot and McLauglin Geospatial data infrastructure
Groot R and McLauglin J Geospatial data infrastructure: Concepts, cases and good practice (Oxford University Press Oxford 2000)
Gwanya "Land and agrarian reform"
Gwanya T "Land and agrarian reform in South Africa" (Unpublished paper presented at the Conference on Land Reform in South Africa 26 August 2008 Pretoria)
Hall "Successes, challenges and concrete proposals"
Hall R "Successes, challenges and concrete proposals on land reform"
(Unpublished paper presented at the Conference on Land Reform in South Africa 26 August 2008 Pretoria)
Harcombe Cadastral model
Harcombe PR A cadastral model for low value lands – the NSW western lands experience (MGeo dissertation University of Melbourne 2002)
Hunt 2005 Development Policy Review
Hunt D "Some outstanding issues in the debate on external promotion of land privatization" 2005 Development Policy Review 199-218
Kirk "Evolving role of the state"
Kirk M "The context for livestock and crop-livestock development in Africa: The evolving role of the state in influencing property rights over grazing resources in sub-Saharan Africa" in McCarthy N et al (eds) Property rights, risk, and livestock development (International Food Policy Research Institute Washington 2000) 23-54
Liebenberg and Horn "Unfair criticism"
Liebenberg JL and Horn A "Unfair criticism: An alternative interpretation of the restitution deadlock" Paper presented at Land, Memory, Reconstruction and Justice Conference 13 September 2006 Houwhoek, South Africa (Proceedings on CD)
Mostert and Pienaar "Formalization"
Mostert H and Pienaar J "Formalization of South African communal land title and its impact on development" in Cook E (ed) Modern studies in property law III (Oxford University Press Oxford 2005) 317-340
Mulolwa Integrated land delivery
Mulolwa A Integrated land delivery: Towards improving land administration in Zambia (PhD thesis Technische Universiteit Delft 2002)
Nichols Land registration
Nichols SE Land registration: Managing information for land administration
(PhD thesis University of New Brunswick 1992)
Nonyana 2000 Butterworths Property Law Digest
Nonyana MR "Communal property associations and their impact on the formation of small business in the rural sector" 2000 Butterworths Property Law Digest 2-7
Nonyana 2005 Butterworths Property Law Digest
Nonyana MR "Some disturbing facts on implementing the Communal Land
Rights Act" 2005 Butterworths Property Law Digest 1-5
Ocheje 2007 Journal of African Law
Ocheje PD "In the public interest: forced evictions, land rights and human development" 2007 (2) Journal of African Law 173-214
Pienaar 2009 JSAL
Pienaar GJ "Die grondwetlikheid van die voorgestelde
onteieningsraamwerk vir Suid-Afrika" 2009 Journal of South African Law 344-352
Pienaar 2007 JCRDL
Pienaar GJ "The need for a comprehensive land administration system for communal property in South Africa" 2007 Journal of Contemporary RomanDutch Law 556-570
Pienaar 2006 JSAL
Pienaar GJ "The land titling debate in South Africa" 2006 Journal of South African Law 435-455
Pienaar 2000 JSAL
Pienaar GJ "Registration of informal land-use rights in South Africa" 2000 Journal of South African Law 442-468
Pienaar 1996 JSAL
Pienaar GJ "Die Suid-Afrikaanse registrasiestelsel – waarheen vorentoe?"
Journal of South African Law 205-226
Pienaar "Communal property arrangements"
Pienaar K "Communal property arrangements: A second bite" in Cousins B
(ed) At the crossroads: land and agrarian reform into the 21st century
(Agrarian Studies School of Government University of the Western-Cape 2000) 322-328
Pienaar and Mostert 2005 SALJ
Pienaar JM and Mostert H "The balance between burial rights and land ownership in South Africa: Issues, content, nature and constitutionality"
South African Law Journal 633-652
Rakai Customary land tenure
Rakai MET Incorporating customary land tenure into a land administration system (MSc dissertation University of Melbourne 1993)
Sarfaty 2005 Yale LJ
Sarfaty GA "The World Bank and the internationalization of indigenous rights norms" 2005 Yale Law Journal 1791-1818
Terblanche Grondbeheer
Terblanche A Die landelike swart vrou se reg op grondbeheer (LLM dissertation NWU2005)
Tong "Judicial versus administrative settlement"
Tong M "Judicial versus administrative settlement of claims" Paper presented at Land, Memory, Reconstruction and Justice Conference 13 September 2006 Houwhoek, South Africa (Proceedings on CD)
Van der Merwe Sakereg
Van der Merwe CG Sakereg (Butterworths Durban 1989)
Van der Walt 2005 Edinburgh LR
Van der Walt AJ "Ownership and eviction: constitutional rights in private law" 2005 Edinburgh Law Review 32-64
Van der Walt 2002 SAJHR
Van der Walt AJ "Exclusivity of ownership, security of tenure and eviction orders: a critical evaluation of recent case law" 2002 South African Journal of Human Rights 371-419
Van der Walt 2001 SALJ
Van der Walt AJ "Dancing with codes – protecting, developing and deconstructing property rights in a constitutional state" 2001 Journal of South African Law 258-311
Van der Walt 1995 SAPL
Van der Walt AJ "Land reform in South Africa since 1990 – an overview" 1995 SA Public Law 1-30
Van der Walt 1992 SAJHR
Van der Walt AJ "The fragmentation of land rights" 1992 South African
Journal of Human Rights 431-450
Van der Walt and Pienaar Introduction
Van der Walt AJ and Pienaar GJ Introduction to the law of property (Juta Cape Town 2006)
Ventura and Mohamed "Information technologies"
Ventura SJ and Mohamed MA "Use of information technologies to model indigenous tenure concepts" (Unpublished research paper University of Wisconsin-Madison 1999)
Walker "Defining restitution by default"
Walker C "Defining restitution by default: the redevelopment of Cato Manor" Paper presented at Land, Memory, Reconstruction and Justice Conference
September 2006 Houwhoek, South Africa (Proceedings on CD)
Williamson "Best practices"
Williamson IP "Best practices for land administration systems in developing countries" Paper delivered at the Long Term Development of Land Management Policies Conference 25-27 July 2000 Jakarta
Williamson "Land administration"
Williamson IP "Land administration 'best practice' – providing the infrastructure for land policy implementation (Unpublished report University of Melbourne 2001)
World Bank Indicators
World Bank World development indicators 2006 (Development Data Center Washington 2006)
World Bank Sourcebook
World Bank The Sustainable land management sourcebook (The World Bank Washington 2008)
Zevenbergen Systems
Zevenbergen JA Systems of land registration: aspects and effects (PhD thesis Technische Universiteit Delft 2002)
Ziqubu, Cousins and Hornby "Individual tenure rights"
Ziqubu N, Cousins T and Hornby D "Using local practises and records to secure individual tenure rights in common property situations" (Paper presented at the National Land Tenure Conference July 2003 Durban)
Register of legislation and policy documents
Communal Land Rights Act 11 of 2004
Communal Property Associations Act 28 of 1996
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 103 of 1993
Deeds Registries Act 47 of 1937
Development Facilitation Act 67 of 1995
Extension of Security of Tenure Act 62 of 1997
GN 1654 in GG 30468 of 13 November 2007
Housing Act 107 of 1997
Interim Protection of Land Rights Act 31 of 1996
Land Reform (Labour Tenants) Act 3 of 1996
Land Survey Act 8 of 1997
Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998
Provision of Certain Land for Settlement Amendment Act 26 of 1998
Provision of Land and Assistance Act 126 of 1993
Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999
Restitution of Land Rights Act 22 of 1994
White Paper on Land Reform 1991
White Paper on South African Land Policy 1997
Register of international agreements
African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights 1981
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 1966
Register of court cases
Nhlabati v Fick 2003 7 BCLR 806 (LCC)
Port Elizabeth Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)
Tongoane and Others v The National Minister of Agriculture and Land Affairs
Case number 11678/2006 Transvaal High Court (unreported)
Tshishonga v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development 2007 4 BLLR 327 (LC) 352F
Register of internet resources
Enemark 2003 www.fig.net/
Enemark S 2003 Capacity building for developing sustainable land administration infrastructures www.fig.net/pub/monthly_articles/july_2003/ Stig_Enemark_July2003.pdf [accessed on 8 November 2008]
UNECE 1996 www.sigov.si/
United Nations Economic Commission for Europe 1996 Land administration
guidelines: with special reference to countries in transition
www.sigov.si/mola/Preview/html/projects.html#nas1 [date of access 6 November 2008]
World Bank 1994 www.worldbank.org/
World Bank 1994 Governance: the World Bank's experience www.worldbank.org/wbi/governance/about.html [date of access 10 November 2008]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 JM Pienaar
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}