Cross-Border Insolvency Law in Europe: Present Status and Future Prospects
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2008/v11i1a2752Abstract
In May 2007 the European countries celebrated the first lustrum of the EU Insolvency Regulation (1346/2000). This article describes where Europe stands with its model which is based on well known theories of private international law for dealing with cross-border insolvencies. The EU Insolvency Regulation provides for a national court to exercise international jurisdiction to open insolvency proceedings. The basis for international jurisdiction is the debtor’s “centre of main interests” or COMI. The two most important cases decided by the European Court of Justice (17 January 2006 Staubitz Schreiber and 2 May 2006 Eurofood) are discussed. The article further analyses the regulation’s legal concept and its procedural context and explains that 'financial institutions' are not covered by the Insolvency Regulation, but by separate directives (2001/17; 2001/24). After having taken stock several suggestions are submitted for improvement of the system of cross-border insolvency in Europe.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Bufford 2006 Columbia Journal of European Law 429
Bufford SL "International Insolvency Case Venue in the European Union: The Parmalat and Daisytek Controversies" 2006 (12) Columbia Journal of European Law 429
Bufford 2007 Northwestern Journal of International Law and Business 351
Bufford SL "Center of Main Interests, International Insolvency Case Venue and Equality of Arms: The Eurofood Decision of the European Court of Justice" 2007 Northwestern Journal of International Law and Business 351
Collins et al (eds) Conflict of Laws
Collins L et al (eds) Dicey, Morris and Collins on The Conflict of Laws 14th rev ed (Sweet & Maxwell London 2007)
Huber Europäischen Insolvenzverordnung 397
Huber U "Inländische Insolvenzverfahren über Auslandgesellschaften nach der Europäischen Insolvenzverordnung" in Schilken E et al (eds) Festschrift für Walter Gerhardt (RWS Verlag Kommunikationsforum Köln 2004)
Janger 2007 Brooklyn Journal of International Law (forthcoming)
Janger EJ "Universal Proceduralism" Paper presented at the symposium Bankruptcy in The Global Village – The Second Decade (Brooklyn School of Law 20-21 October 2006) 2007 (32) Brooklyn Journal of International Law (forthcoming)
Kolmann Kooperationsmodelle
Kolmann S Kooperationsmodelle im Internationalen Insolvenzrecht. Empfielt sich für das Deutsche internationale Insolvenzrecht eine Neuorientierung? Schriften zum Deutschen und Europäischen Zivil-, Handels- und Prozessrecht (Verlag Ernst und Werner Gieseking Bielefeld 2001)
Marquette and Barbé Insolvency Proceedings 419
Marquette V and Barbé C "Council Regulation (EC) No 1346/2000 Insolvency Proceedings in Europe and Third Countries: Status and Prospects" in Nuyts A and Watté N (eds) International Civil Litigation in Europe and Relations with Third States (Bruxelles Bruylant 2005)
Moss and Paulus 2005 Insolvency Intelligence
Moss G and Paulus C "The European Insolvency Regulation – The Case for Urgent Reform" 2005 Insolvency Intelligence October
Moss and Wessels (eds) EU Banking and Insurance Insolvency
Moss G and Wessels B (eds) EU Banking and Insurance Insolvency: An Annotated Guide and Comments on the Implementation of EC Directives 17/2001 and 24/2001 in EU Member States (Oxford University Press Oxford 2006)
Omar 2005 European Company Law 59
Omar PJ "The Convergence of Company and Insolvency Initiatives within the European Union" 2005 (2) European Company Law 59
Omar 2007 Insolvency Intelligence
Omar PJ "Addressing the Reform of the European Insolvency Regulation: Wishlist or Fancies?" 2007 Insolvency Intelligence January
Virgós 1998 Forum Internationale 11
Virgós M "The 1995 European Community Convention on Insolvency Proceedings: An Insider’s View" 1998 (25) Forum Internationale 11
Wessels Insolvency Law 294-311
Wessels B "Insolvency Law" in Smits J (ed) Encyclopaedia of Comparative Law (Edgar Elgar London 2006) 294-311
Wessels 2005 European Company Law 50
Wessels B "The EC Insolvency Regulation: Three Years in Force" 2005 (2) European Company Law 50
Wessels 2005 International Corporate Rescue 291
Wessels B “It’s Time to Cooperate” Editorial 2005 (2) International Corporate Rescue 291
Wessels 2006 European Company Law 183
Wessels B "The Place of the Registered Office of a Company: A Cornerstone in the Application of the EC Insolvency Regulation" 2006 (3) European Company Law 183
Wessels 2006 International Caselaw Alert 68
Wessels B "Twenty Suggestions for a makeover of the EU Insolvency Regulation" 2006 (12) International Caselaw Alert 31 October
Wessels International Insolvency Law
Wessels B International Insolvency Law (Kluwer Deventer 2006)
Wessels International Insolvency Law (2003 ed)
Wessels B International Insolvency Law (Kluwer Deventer 2003)
Wessels Multinational Bank Insolvency 259
Wessels B "A Glance through the Legal Principles and Key Issues of Multinational Bank Insolvency" Paper presented at Insol International Academics meeting on The Treatment of Corporate Groups in Insolvency (Cape Town South Africa 2- 4 April 2004) in Current Topics of International Insolvency Law (Kluwer Deventer 2004)
Wessels Open Insolvency Proceedings 155
Wessels B "International Jurisdiction To Open Insolvency Proceedings In Europe, In Particular Against (Groups Of) Companies" in Current Topic of International Insolvency Law (Kluwer Deventer 2004)
Wessels Realisation 229
Wessels B "Realisation of the EU Insolvency Regulation in Germany, France and the Netherlands" in Current Topics of International Insolvency Law (Kluwer Deventer 2004)
Wessels Tijdschrift voor Belgisch Handelsrecht (forthcoming)
Wessels B "Europe Deserves a New Approach to Insolvency Proceedings" Contribution to the Colloquium Two hundred years Commercial Code of Belgium (Brussels Belgium 23 March 2007) Tijdschrift voor Belgisch Handelsrecht (forthcoming)
Westbrook 2004 Texas Law Review 795
Westbrook JL "The Control of Wealth in Bankruptcy" 2004 (82) Texas Law Review 795
Register of legislation
Amministrazione straordaninaria delle grandi impresi in stato di insolvenza No 347 of 23 December 2003
Regulation (EC) No 1346/2000 of 29 May 2000
GURI No 298 of 24 December 2003
Register of court cases
BRAC Rent-A-Car International Inc [2003] 1 WLR 40 1421
Court of Appeal Skåne and Blekinge No Ö 21-05 3 February 2005
Court of Stockholm K 17664-04 21 January 2005
District Court Dordrecht LJN: AU7353 23 November 2005
District Court Frankfurt am Main 26 January 2006, ZIP 2006, 796
District Court of Rotterdam 7 June 2006, JOR 2006/52
Eurofood ECJ C-341/04 2 May 2006
German Supreme Court ZIP 2006, 529 of 9 February 2006; NZI 2006, 297
JOR 2006/59
Netherlands Supreme Court JOR 2004/87 9 January 2004
Re Aim Underwriting Agencies (Ireland) Ltd Ch D 2 July 2004
Re Cedarlease Ltd 8 March 2005
Re Ci4net.com Inc
Re Collins & Aikman Europe SA [2005] EWCH 1754 (Ch)
Re Daisytek-ISA Ltd [2004] BPIR 30
Re DBP Holdings Limited Ch D 20 May 2004
Re Eurofood IFSC Limited
Re Hettlage KgaA 4 May 2004
Re Sendo Ltd [2005] EWHC 1604 (Ch)
Susanne Staubitz-Schreiber ECJ C-01/04 17 January 2006
Svea Court of Appeal No Ö 4105-03 30 May 2003
Register of treaties and conventions
Brussels Convention on Jurisdiction and the Enforcement of Judgments in Civil and Commercial Matters 1968
Brussels Regulation 2000
Brussels Regulation 2002
Council Regulation 44/2001 22 December 2000
OJL 12 22 December 2001
Treaty of Lugano 1993
Register of Internet resources
Omar 2006 International Case-Law Alert http://www.eir-database.com 19 Feb
Omar PJ "Confronting the Challenge of Diverse Priority Rules through the European Insolvency Regulation" 2006 (10) International Case-Law Alert June [Found on internet] http://www.eir-database.com [Date of use 19 February 2008]
Pottow 2005 Virg J Int'l L http://ssrn.com/abstract=646962 27 Feb
Pottow J "Procedural Incrementalism: A Model for International Bankruptcy" 2005 45 (4) Virginia Journal of International Law [Found on internet] http://ssrn.com/abstract=646962 [Date of use 27February 2008]
Rasmussen 2007 Vanderbilt Law and Economics http://ssrn.com/ 18 Feb
Rasmussen RK "Where Are All the Transnational Bankruptcies?: The Puzzling Case for Universalism" Working Paper No 07-13 2007 Vanderbilt Law and Economics [Found on internet] http://ssrn.com/abstract=982678 [Date of use 18 February 2008]
UNCITRAL Model Law http://www.uncitral.org/ 19 Feb
UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency 1997 [Found on internet] http://www.uncitral.org/uncitral/en/uncitral_texts/insolvency/1997Model.html [Date of use 19 Feb 2008]
Wessels http://www.bobwessels.nl 18 Feb (Blog 2006-09-doc4)
Wessels B "Twenty Suggestions for a makeover of the EU Insolvency Regulation" Blog 2006-09-doc4 [Found on internet] http://www.bobwessels.nl [Date of use 18 February 2008]
Wessels http://www.bobwessels.nl 18 Feb (Blog 2007-01-doc16)
Wessels B "The Insolvency Regulation – consolidated version" Blog 2007-01-doc16 [Found on internet] http://www.bobwessels.nl [Date of use 18 February 2008]
Wessels http://www.bobwessels.nl 18 Feb (Blog 2007-06-doc2)
Wessels B "Applicable Law in Cross-border Insolvency Proceedings" Joint conference of the American Law Institute and the International Insolvency Institute on Principles for Cooperation in International Insolvency Cases (Columbia University School of Law New York City 13 June 2007) Blog 2007-06-doc2 [Found on internet] http://www.bobwessels.nl 19 Feb
Wessels http://www.bobwessels.nl 18 Feb (Blog 2007-06-doc3)
Wessels B "The Insolvency Regulation – amended annexes" Blog 2007-06-doc3 [Found on internet] http://www.bobwessels.nl [Date of use 18 February 2008]
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Bob Wessels
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}