Beyond Public Particpation: The disjuncture between South Africa's Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Law and Sustainable Development
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2008/v11i3a2769Abstract
One of the key strategies for achieving sustainable development is the use of the process of evaluating the potential environmental impacts of development activities. The procedure of environmental impact assessment (EIA) implements the principle of integration which lies at the core of the concept of sustainable development by providing a process through which potential social, economic and environmental impacts of activities are scrutinised and planned for. Sustainable development may not be achieved without sustained and legally mandated efforts to ensure that development planning is participatory.
The processes of public participation play a crucial role in ensuring the integration of the socio-economic impacts of a project into the environmental decision-making processes. Public participation is not the only process, nor does the process always ensure the achievement of sustainable development. Nevertheless, decisions that engage the public have the propensity to lead to sustainable development. The public participation provisions in South Africa’s EIA regulations promulgated under the National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998 show a disjuncture between the idea of public participation and the notion of sustainable development. The provisions do not create a framework for informed participation and leave a wide discretion to environmental assessment practitioners (EAPs) regarding the form which participation should assume. In order for environmental law, specifically EIA laws, to be effective as tools to promote sustainable development the laws must, among other things, provide for effective public participation. The judiciary must also aid in the process by giving content to the legal provisions on public participation in the EIA process.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Barton Underlying Concepts
Barton B “Underlying Concepts and Theoretical Issues in Public Participation in Resources Development” in Zillman DN et al (eds) Human Rights in Natural Resource Development Public Participation in the Sustainable Development of Mining and energy Resources (Oxford University Press Oxford 2002)
Birnie and Boyle International Law
Birnie PW and Boyle AE International Law and the Environment 2nd ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 2002)
Blackburn Sustainability Handbook
Blackburn WR The Sustainability Handbook Complete Management Guide to Achieving Social Economic and Environmental Responsibility (Environmental Law Institute Washington DC 2007)
Bradshaw and Burger 2005 Africanus
Bradshaw G and Burger W "Public Participation, Sustainable Development and Public Disputes: Public scoping processes in the Coega deep water port and industrial zone" 2005 (35) Africanus 44-57
DEAT Guideline No 3
DEAT Guideline No 3: General to the EIA Process (Government Printers Pretoria 2006)
Doelle and Sinclair 2006 EIA Rev
Doelle M and Sinclair J "Time for a new approach to public participation in EA: Promoting cooperation and consensus for sustainability" 2006 (26) Environmental Impact Assessment Review 185-205
Ebbesson “Public Participation”
Ebbesson J “Public Participation” in Bodansky D, Brunnéé J and Hey E (eds) The Oxford handbook of International Environmental Law (Oxford University Press Oxford 2007)
Field 2005 SALJ
Field TL “Public Participation in Environmental Decision-making: Earthlife Africa (Cape Town) v Director-General: Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism” 2005 (122) South African Law Journal 748-765
Field 2006 SALJ
Field TL “Sustainable Development versus Environmentalism: Competing Paradigms for the South African EIA Regime” 2006 (123) South African Law Journal 409-436
Glazewski Environmental Law in South Africa
Glazewski J Environmental Law in South Africa 2nd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2005)
Hafner General Principles
Hafner G “General Principles of Sustainable Development: From Soft Law to Hard Law" in Fitzmaurice M and Szuniewicz M (eds) Exploitation of Natural Resources in the 21st Century (Kluwer Law International Hague 2003)
Hamann 2003 SAJELP
Hamann R “South African challenges to the theory and practice of public participation in environmental assessment” 2003 (10) South African Journal of Environmental Law and Policy 21-32
Jones 1997 W&M ELPR
Jones EG “Risky Assessments: Uncertainties in Science and the Human Dimensions of Environmental Decision-making” 1997 (22) William and Mary Environmental Law and Policy Review 3-25
Kidd 1999 SAJELP
Kidd M “The National Environment Management Act and Public Participation” 1999 (6) South African Journal of Environmental Law and Policy 21-31
Lindeque and Cloete 2005 Acta Structtilia
Lindeque AS and Cloete CE “Public participation in lower and higher socio-economic areas in South Africa” 2005 (12) Acta Structtilia 25-41
Magraw and Hawke “Sustainable Development”
Magraw DB and Hawke LD “Sustainable Development” in Bodansky D, Brunnéé J and Hey E (eds) The Oxford handbook of International Environmental Law (Oxford University Press London 2007)
Masango 2002 Politeia
Masango R “Public Participation: A Critical Ingredient of Good Governance” 2002 (21) Politeia 2002 52-65
Murombo "Beyond Public Participation"
Murombo T "Beyond Public Participation: The Disjuncture Between South Africa's Environmental Impact Assessment (Eia) Law And Sustainable Development" Papers delivered at the Australia New Zealand Society of Ecological Economics Conference 2-6 July (Noosaville Australia 2007)
Nel 2001 SAJELP
Nel J “Stakeholder Relationships in the EIA Process: Some concerns” 2001 (8) South African Journal of Environmental Law and Policy 105-110
Osofsky 2003 LLA ICLR
Osofsky HM “Defining Sustainable Development after the Earth Summit 2002” 2003 (26) Loyola of Los Angeles International and Comparative Law Review 91-111
Osorio 2005 ED&S
Osorio LS et al "Debates on Sustainable Development: Towards a Holistic View of Reality” 2005 (7) Environment, Development & Sustainability 501-518
Pardo 1997 EIA Rev
Pardo M “Environmental Impact Assessment: Myth or Reality? Lessons from Spain” 1997 (17) Environmental Impact Assessment Review 123-142
Petersen 2006 SALJ
Paterson A “Fuelling the Sustainable Development Debate in South Africa” 2006 (123) South African Law Journal 53-62
Pinter, Hardi and Bartelmus Sustainable Development Indicators
Pinter L, Hardi P and Bartelmus P Sustainable Development Indicators: Proposals for the Way Forward (discussion paper prepared under a consulting agreement on behalf of the UN Division for Sustainable Development; Winnipeg, Canada: International Institute for Sustainable Development 2005)
Richardson and Razzaque Public Participation
Richardson BJ and Razzaque J “Public Participation in Environmental Decision-making” in Richardson BJ and Woods S (eds) Environmental Law for Sustainability (Hart Publishing Oxford 2006)
Richardson and Woods Environmental Law
Richardson BJ and Woods S "Environmental Law for Sustainability” in Environmental Law for Sustainability (Hart Publishing Oxford 2006)
Ross et al 2006 IA&PA
Ross WA et al “Common Sense in Environmental Impact Assessment: It is not as common as it should be” 2006 (24) Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 3-10
Spyke 1999 BCEALR
Spyke NP “Public Participation in Environmental Decision-making at the New Millennium: Structuring New Spheres of Public Influence” 1999 (26) Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Review 263-272
Ventriss and Kuentzel 2005 IJOTB
Ventriss C and Kuentzel W “Critical Theory and the Role of Citizen Involvement in Environmental Decision Making: A re-examination” 2005 (8) International Journal of Organization Theory and Behaviour 519-539
WCED Our Common Future
World Commission on Environment and Development Our Common Future (Oxford University Press Oxford 1987)
Wood Environmental Impact Assessment
Wood C Environmental Impact Assessment: A Comparative Review (Longman Harlow 1995)
Register of legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 1996
Environment Conservation Act 73 of 1989
GN 392-395 Government Gazette 29862 4 May 2007
GN R1182-1184 Government Gazette 18261 5 September 1997
GN R385-387 Government Gazette 28753 21 April 2006
GN R615 Government Gazette 28938 23 June 2006
National Environmental Laws Amendment Bill 2007
National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998
National Environmental Management Act: Air Quality Act 39 of 2004
National Environmental Management Act: Protected Areas Act 57 of 2003
National Environmental Management Amendment Act 8 of 2004
National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act 10 of 2004
Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000
Waste Management Bill 2008
List of court cases
BP Southern Africa (Pty) Ltd v MEC for Agriculture, Conservation, Environment & Land Affairs 2004 5 SA 124 (W)
Earthlife Africa (Cape Town) v Director-General: Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism 2005 3 SA 156 (C)
Fuel Retailers Association of SA (Pty) Ltd v Director-General, Environmental Management, Mpumalanga, and Others 2007 2 SA 163 (SCA)
Fuel Retailers Association of SA (Pty) Ltd v Director-General, Environmental Management, Mpumalanga, and Others 2007 6 SA 4 (CC)
Hichange Investments (Pty) Ltd v Cape Produce Co (Pty) Ltd t/a Pelts Products 2004 2 SA 393 (E)
MEC for Agriculture, Conservation, Environment & Land Affairs v Sasol Oil (Pty) Ltd 2006 5 SA 483 (SCA)
MEC: Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Environment and Another v HTF Developers (Pty) Ltd 2008 (4) BCLR 417 (CC)
Minister of Public Works and Others v Kyalami Ridge Environmental Association and Another 2001 3 SA 1151 (CC)
Muckleneuk/Lukasrand Property Owners and Residents Association v MEC Department of Agriculture Conservation and Environment Gauteng Provincial Government and Others (Review Application 28192/04)
Muckleneuk/Lukasrand Property Owners and Residents Association v HOD Department of Agriculture Conservation and Environment Gauteng Provincial Government and Others (Urgent Application 12137/06) (28192/04; 12137/06) [2006] ZAGPHC 86 (30 August 2006)
Silvermine Valley Coalition v Sybrand van der Spuy Boerderye and Others 2002 1 SA 478 (C)
Register of international and regional instruments
Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision-Making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters 1999
Rio Declaration on Environment and Development - United Nations Declaration on Environment and Development 1992
United Nations Declaration on Environment and Development 1992
Register of internet sources
Baumert, Herzog and Pershing 2005 http://pdf.wri.org/ 21 Jun
Baumert KA, Herzog T and Jonathan Pershing J 2005 Navigating the Numbers: Greenhouse Gas Data and International Climate Policy [Found on internet] http://pdf.wri.org/navigating_numbers_chapter2.pdf [Date of use 21 June 2007]
Bossel 1999 http://www.iisd.org/pdf/balatonreport.pdf 28 Sep
Bossel H 1999 Indicators for Sustainable Development: Theory Method and Applications: A Report to the Balaton Group [Found on internet] http://www.iisd.org/pdf/balatonreport.pdf [Date of use 28 September 2008]
CSL Forum 2007 http://www.cslforum.org/safrica.htm 21 Jun
CSL Forum 2007 An Energy Summary of South Africa [Found on internet] http://www.cslforum.org/safrica.htm [Date of use 21 June 2007]
Eskom 2007 http://www.eskom.co.za/content/ 21 Jun
Eskom 2007 The Matimba B (Medupi) Transmission Integration Project Scoping Report [Found on internet] http://www.eskom.co.za/content/294-02%20SR%20MatimbaDelta%2030-04-07v4.pdf [Date of use 21 June 2007]
Hardi and Zdan 1997 http://www.iisd.org/pdf/bellagio.pdf 28 Sep
Hardi P and Zdan T 1997 Assessing Sustainable Development: Principles in Practice [Found on internet] http://www.iisd.org/pdf/bellagio.pdf [Date of use 28 September 2008]
Holman 2008 http://www.engineeringnews.co.za/ 1 Oct
Holman J 2008 Transmission lines threaten ecotourism: action group [Found on internet] http://www.engineeringnews.co.za/article.php?a_id= 134710 [Date of use 1 October 2008]
MCM 2008 http://www.mcm-deat.gov.za/press/2007/07052007.html 1 Oct
MCM 2008 Appeal Decision by Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism on the Construction of the Proposed Eskom Holdings Limited Generation Division 4800 MW Coal Fired Power Station and Associated Infrastructure near the Lephalale Area, Limpopo Province (Matimba B) [Found on internet] http://www.mcm-deat.gov.za/press/2007/07052007.html [Date of use 1 October 2008]
Stern Review http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/ 1 Oct
HM Treasury "Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change" [Found on internet] http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/independent_reviews/stern_ review_economics_climate_change/sternreview_index.cfm [Date of use 1 October 2008]
UK EIA 2000 http://www.communities.gov.uk 28 Sep
UK Environmental Impact Assessment 2000 A guide to procedures (Queens Printer and Controller HMSO 2000) [Found on internet] http://www.communities.gov.uk [Date of use 28 September 2008]
UNECE 2001 http://www.unece.org/env/pp/documents/cep43e.pdf 28 Sep
UNECE 2001 Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision-Making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters [Found on internet] http://www.unece.org/env/pp/documents/cep43e.pdf [Date of use 28 September 2008]
UNEP 1992 http://www.unep.org/ 1 Oct
UNEP 1992 Rio Declaration on Environment and Development [Found on internet] http://www.unep.org/Documents.multilingual/Default.asp? DocumentID=78&ArticleID=116 [Date of use 1 October 2008]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 T Murombo
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}