Die dialektiek in die waardes van die 1996 Grondwet

Authors

  • Jan Swanepoel North West University(Potchefstroom Campus)

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/1998/v1i1a2900

Abstract

In his paper The Dialectics in the Values of the 1996 Constitution Jan Swanepoel discusses various value statements in the 1996 Constitution of the Republic of South Africa and focuses the attention on indications of a lack of coherence as far as these value statements are concerned. 

He does this against the background of some introductory perspectives on the 1996 Constitution. In this regard he points out that the 1996 Constitution, as successor to the 1993 Constitution with its set of thirty four constitutional principles, can be regarded as a document of political and ideological compromise. He points out that constitutions (and in particular the value statements in Bills of Rights) generally tend to be formulated rather broadly in order to promote flexibility and adaptability. He also focuses the attention on the fact that such a dialectic of values point to the variety of interests that has to be harmonized in a modern state, something which is unmistakably the case in South Africa with its heterogeneous society. 

The 1996 Constitution contains a variety of "value terms". A closer study of these terms does, however, indicate that these terms (value, principle, foundation, and the like) are not used in a very systematic or technical fashion. 

The problems regarding the value statements are, however, not only of a terminological nature. There are also some substantive problems, as becomes clear from a discussion of value terms in the Preamble and in Sections 1 and 7 of the 1996 Constitution. Swanepoel indicates that a tension exists between what can be called the "process" formulation in section 1(a) and the "state of affairs" formulation of the values in section 7(1). . While section 1(a) speaks of "the achievement of equality" and "the advancement of human rights and freedoms", section 7(1) simply makes mention of "equality" and "freedom". The dialectic between these two

formulations is discussed with reference to other relevant sections of the 1996 Constitution. 

The discussion is placed against the background of a so-called blank space in the

1996 Constitution. While the 1993 Constitution characterized South Africa as a "constitutional state", the 1996 does not contain such a characterization. It is argued in this paper that the process phrasing in section 1 (a) ties in with a social democratic view of the state as an institution bringing about social change. The "state of affairs" phrasing of section 7(1) is, on the other hand, more in line with a liberal notion of a Rechtsstaat. 

The issue concerning what type of state South Africa is under the 1996 Constitution, will depend on which of the two poles in the above-mentioned dialectic the primary emphasis will be placed. 

Since the 1996 Constitution has been ratified by the Constitutional Court, it is regarded as extremely unlikely that the above-mentioned terminological problem will be rectified in future. Swanepoel provides a diagrammatic representation of the principle, values and objectives mentioned in the 1996 Constitution. 

Further research is envisaged concerning the possibility of developing a juridical model of reconciling the social-democratic and Rechtsstaat tendencies in the 1996 Constitution within the framework of a broader vision on the state’s task in bringing about justice. 

    ScienceOpen_Log0535.png

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

BIBLIOGRAFIE

Boeke

Davis D "Equality and Equal Protection" in Van Wyk D, Dugard J, De Villiers B en Davis D (reds) Rights and Constitutionalism The new South African Legal Order (Juta Kenwyn 1994) 196-211

Davis D, Chaskalson M, De Waal J "Democracy and Constitutionalism: The Role of Constitutional Interpretation" in Van Wyk D, Dugard J, De Villiers B en Davis D (reds) Rights and Constitutionalism The new South African Legal Order (Juta Kenwyn 1994) 1-130

Dugard J "International Human Rights" in Van Wyk D, Dugard J, De Villiers B en Davis D (reds) Rights and Constitutionalism The new South African Legal Order (Juta Kenwyn 1994) 171-195

Du Plessis en Corder Bill of Rights Du Plessis LM en Corder H Understanding South Africa’s Transitional Bill of Rights (Juta Kenwyn 1994)

Ferreira Staatsregtelike Onregmatigheid Ferreira GM Staatsregtelike Onregmatigheid LLD-proefskrif PU vir CHO (Potchefstroom 1995)

Peaslee Constitutions Peaslee AJ Constitutions of Nations Vol IV The Americas (Nijhoff Den Haag 1970)

Gamble Introduction Gamble A An Introduction to Modern Social and Political Thought (St Martin’s Press New York 1981)

Jolowicz Lectures Jolowicz HF Lectures on Jurisprudence (onder redaksie van JA Jolwicz) (University of London Londen 1963)

Sabine Political Thought Sabine GH en Thorson TL An Intoduction to Modern Social and Polititical Thought (Harcourt Brace College Publishers Fort Worth 1989)

Simpson Invitation Simpson AWB An Invitation to Law (Blackwell Oxford 1994)

Van Blerk Jurisprudence Van Blerk AE Jurisprudence An Introduction (Butterworths Durban 1996)

Van Haersolte RAV "John Rawls" in Cliteur PB en Loth MA (reds) Rechtsfilosofen van de twintigste eeu (Gouda Quint Arnhem 1992) 209-228

Van Eikema Hommes Trends Van Eikema Hommes HJ Major Trends in the History of Legal Philosophy (North-Holland Publishing Company Amsterdam 1979)

Van Eikema Hommes Elementaire Grondbegrippen Van Eikema Hommes HJ De Elementaire Grondbegrippen der Rechtswetenschap Een Juridische Methodologie 2de druk (Kluwer Deventer 1983)

Van Niekerk P "Regering en Staatsgesag: die Staat, die Reg en die Politiek" in Wiechers M en Bredenkamp F (reds) Die Staat: Teorie en Praktyk (Van Schaik Pretoria 1996) 139-162 Van Wyk D "Introduction to the South African Constitution" in Van Wyk D, Dugard J,

De Villiers B en Davis D (reds) Rights and Constitutionalism The new South

African Legal Order (Juta Kenwyn 1994) 131-170

Tydskrifartikels

Botha H "The values and principles underlying the 1993 Constitution" 1994 SAPR/PL 233-244

Carpenter G "The Republic of South Africa Constituion Act 200 of 1993 - an overview" 1994 SAPR/PL 222-232

Carpenter G "Fundamental Rights- Is there a pecking order?" Codicillus 27-32

Chaplin J "Subsidiarity and Sphere Sovereignty: Catholic and Reformed Conceptions of the Role of the State" 1995 Orientation 104-129.

Cliteur PB "Rechtsbeginselen: Tussen Natuurrecht en Rechtspositivisme" 1987 Philosophia Reformata 57-70

De Wet E "Can the social state principle in Germany guide state action in South Africa in the field of social and economic rights?" 1995 SAJHR 30-49

Du Plessis LM "The genesis of the chapter on fundamental rights in South Africa’s transitional constitution" 1994 SAPR/PL 1-21

Du Plessis LM "The Bill of Rights in the Working Draft of the New Constitution: an Evaluation of Aspects of a Constitutional Text Sui Generis" Stellebosch Law Review 1996 3-24

Du Plessis LM "The jurisprudence of interpretation and the exigencies of a new constitutional order in South Africa" Voordrag gelewer by 'n Regsteoriekonferensie Doing things with words -- On meaning in legal interpretation wat gehou is by die Randse Afrikaanse Universiteit, 1-3 September, 1997.

Du Plessis LM "Menseregte in die Skadu’s en Skanse van die Ivoortoring ('n Akademiese waardering van enkele fasette van menseregtebeskerming in Suid-Afrika se finale Grondwet)" 1997 Stell LR 181-191

De Waal "A Comparative Analysis of the Provisions of German Origin in the Interim Bill of Rights" 1995 SAJHR 1-29

Erasmus G en De Waal J "Die Finale Grondwet Legitimiteit en Ontstaan" 1997 Stellenbosse Regstydskrif 31

Gouws A "Women in Political Science: (An)other Look at the Discipline” 1993 Politikon 5-24

Gouws A "Women, civil society and citizenship: a reaction to Schreiner" in Rhoodie N en Liebeberg I (reds) Democratic Nation-building in South Africa 1994 315-324

Gutto S "Concepts, Principles or Rules: the Meaning of Constitutionalised Rights in the Context of International Law" Voordrag gelewer by 'n Regsteoriekonferensie Doing things with words -- On meaning in legal interpretation wat gehou is by die Randse Afrikaanse Universiteit, 1-3 September 1997.

Hiemstra VG "Suid-Afrika terug in die wêreld langs die weg van die regstaatbeginsel" 1985 TSAR 1-10

Michelman FI "Constitutional authorship and the unoriginalist mode of constitutional interpretation" Voordrag gelewer by 'n Regsteoriekonferensie Doing things with words --On meaning in legal interpretation wat gehou is by die Randse Afrikaanse Universiteit, 1-3 September 1997.

Mureinik E "A Bridge to Where? Introducing the Interim Bill of Rights" 1994 SAJHR

Ngqiyaza B "Socioeconomic rights must be enforced in SA - Pityana" Business Day 19 September 1997 4

Stern K "A society based on the rule of law and social justice: constitutional model of the Federal Republic of Germany" 1981 TSAR 241-250

Van der Merwe D "The Roman-Dutch Law: From Virtual Reality to Constitutional Resource" Voordrag gelewer by 'n Regsteoriekonferensie Doing things with words -- On meaning in legal interpretation wat gehou is by die Randse Afrikaanse Universiteit, 1-3 September 1997.

Hommes HJ Van Eikema "De materiële rechtsstaatsidee" 1978 TSAR 42-52

Van Wyk DH "Suid-Afrika en die regstaatidee" 1980 TSAR 152-167

Van Wyk D "The South African Bill of Rights: an evaluation" 1994 SAPR/PL 278-286

Venter F "Milestones in the evolution of the new South African Constitution and some of its salient features" 1994 SAPR/PL 211-232

Venter F "Constitution-making and the Legitimacy of the Constitution" Voordrag gelewer by die IACL Round Table Conference, Turku, 23-24 May 1997

Venter F "Die Betekenis van die Bepalings van die Grondwet Die Aanhef en Hoofstuk 1" 1998 PER 1-64

Venter JJ "Reformational University Basis in Operation" 1994 Orientation 260-295

Regspraak

Du Plessis and Others v De Klerk and Another 1996 3 SA 850 (KH) Gardener v Whitaker 1995 2 SA 672 (OK) Gardener v Whitaker 1996 4 SA 337 (KH) Ex Parte Chairperson of the Constitutional Assembly: in re Certification of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996 1996 10 BCLR 1253 (KH) Mandela v Felati 1995 1 SA 251 (W) Qozeleni v Minister of Law and Order 1994 3 SA 625 (OK) S v Makwanyane 1995 (6) BCLR 665 (KH) S v Zuma and Others 1995(4) BCLR 401 (KH)

Published

10-07-2017

How to Cite

Swanepoel, J. (2017). Die dialektiek in die waardes van die 1996 Grondwet. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 1(1), 110–165. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/1998/v1i1a2900

Issue

Section

Articles