An Evaluation of the Self-Regulation of Promotional Competitions in South Africa
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2016/v19i0a730Keywords:
promotional competitions, prize competitions, prize promotions, consumer protection, industry codes, self-regulation, advertising, sales promotion.Abstract
Promotional competitions are competitions in which prizes are awarded by lot or chance in order to promote goods or services. In order to protect participants and consumers against abuse, these competitions are usually regulated by gambling or consumer protection legislation. However, the relevant legislation is often complemented by self-regulation, which is the focus of this contribution.
Self-regulation entails the regulation or governing of an industry by the role players in that industry. This article commences by explaining the relevant terminology and exploring self-regulation in general, including the various forms of self-regulation and the binding force thereof. The nature of self-regulation is discussed together with the advantages and challenges associated with this form of regulation. This is followed by some examples of self-regulation on a global level in order to provide a comparative perspective on the topic. The provisions of the International Chamber of Commerce’s Consolidated Code of Advertising and Marketing Communications Practice are summarised and the European Advertising Standards Alliance’s role in self-regulation is considered. Attention is also given to the relevant industry codes in the United Kingdom in view of the comprehensive way in which promotional competitions are covered by the self-regulation in that country.
The main part of the article centres on the self-regulatory position in South Africa. The brief overview of the role and function of the Advertising Standards Authority of South Africa (ASASA) is provided. The provisions of the ASASA’s Code of Advertising Practice are then examined and some ASASA rulings are discussed in order to illustrate the relevant principles. Thereafter, the focus shifts to the Code of Conduct of the Wireless Application Service Providers’ Association, which contains detailed provisions relating to promotional competitions. Some relevant rulings are also considered. In conclusion, comments are made regarding the current state of the self-regulation of promotional competitions in South Africa.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Baldwin, Cave and Lodge Understanding Regulation
Baldwin R, Cave M and Lodge M Understanding Regulation: Theory,
Strategy, and Practice (Oxford University Press Oxford 2012)
Bennett 2007 Practical Lawyer
Bennett SC "An Introduction to Sweepstakes and Contests Law" 2007 The
Practical Lawyer 39-50
Black 1996 MLR
Black J "Constitutionalising Self-Regulation" 1996 MLR 24-55
Black 2001 CLP
Black J "Decentring Regulation: Understanding the Role of Regulation and
Self-Regulation in a 'Post-Regulatory' World" 2001 CLP 103-146
Black 2002 AJLP
Black J "Critical Reflections on Regulation" 2002 AJLP 1-35
Boddewyn Advertising Self-Regulation
Boddewyn JJ Advertising Self-Regulation and Outside Participation: A
Multinational Comparison(Quorum Books New York 1988)
Boddewyn 1989 Journal of Advertising
Boddewyn JJ "Advertising Self-Regulation: True Purposeand Limits" 1989
Journal of Advertising 19-27
Brand Media Law
Brand R Media Law in South Africa (Kluwer Law International Alphen aan
den Rijn 2011)
Cunningham 2000 JPM
Cunningham A "Advertising Self-Regulation in a Broader Context" 2000
JPM 61-83
Casey and Scott 2011 JLS
Casey D and Scott C "The Crystallization of Regulatory Norms" 2011 JLS
-95
Circus Promotional Marketing Law
Circus P Promotional Marketing Law: A Practical Guide 6th ed
(Bloomsbury Professional Haywards Heath 2011)
Crown, Bray and Earle Advertising Law
Crown G, Bray O and Earle R Advertising Law and Regulation 2nd ed
(Bloomsbury Professional Haywards Heath 2010)
De Jager and Smith Advertising and the Law
De Jager C and Smith E Advertising and the Law (Butterworths Durban
De Stadler Consumer Law Unlocked
De Stadler E Consumer Law Unlocked (Siber Ink Cape Town 2013)
Du Plessis "Introduction to Integrated Marketing Communication"
Du Plessis F "Introduction to Integrated Marketing Communication" in Du
Plessis PJ et al Integrated Marketing Communication: A Contemporary
Approach 3rd ed (Van Schaik Pretoria 2010) 1-19
Dresden "United Kingdom"
Dresden B "United Kingdom" in Promotion Marketing Association and
Global Advertising Lawyers Alliance International Promotion Marketing
Law Book 2nd ed (PMA Educational Foundation New York 2010) 268-282
Ginosar "Regulation of Advertising"
Ginosar A "The Regulation of Advertising" in Levi-Faur D (ed) Handbook
on the Politics of Regulation (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2011) 254-266
Gray 2005 Young Consumers
Gray O "Responsible Advertising in Europe" 2005 Young Consumers 19-
Gunningham and Rees 1997 L&P
Gunningham N and Rees J "Industry Self-Regulation: An Institutional
Perspective" 1997 L&P 363-414
Haufler Public Role for the Private Sector
Haufler V A Public Role for the Private Sector: Industry Self-Regulation in
a Global Economy (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Washington DC 2001)
Huyse and Parmentier 1990 JCP
Huyse L and Parmentier S "Decoding Codes: The Dialogue between
Consumers and Suppliers through Codes of Conduct in the European
Community'' 1990 JCP 253-272
International Chamber of Commerce Consolidated Code
International Chamber of Commerce Consolidated Code of Advertising
and Marketing Communications Practice 9th revision (International
Chamber of Commerce Paris 2011)
Koekemoer Advertising and Sales Promotion
Koekemoer L Advertising and Sales Promotion (Juta Cape Town 2014)
Labarbera 1980 JAR
Labarbera PA "Analyzing and Advancing the State of the Art of Advertising
Self-Regulation"1980 JAR 27-38
Melville and Yeates "Section 82"
Melville N and Yeates J "Section 82" in Eiselen S and Naudé T (eds)
Commentary on the Consumer Protection Act (original service) (Juta
Claremont 2014) 82-1 –82-6
Ogus 1995 OJLS
Ogus A "Rethinking Self-Regulation" 1995 OJLS 97-108
Ramsay Consumer Law and Policy
Ramsay I Consumer Law and Policy: Text and Materials on Regulating
Consumer Markets 2nd ed (Hart Oxford 2007)
Reader 1995 U PaJ Int'l Bus L
Reader TW "Is Self-Regulation the Best Option for the Advertising Industry
in the European Union? An Argument for the Harmonization of Advertising
Laws through the Continued Use of Directive" 1995 U PaJ Int'l Bus L 181-
Schimmel Advertising Law
Schimmel G Advertising Law: A Guide to the Code of Advertising Practice
(Juta Claremont 2014)
Scott 2012 German Law Journal
Scott C "Beyond Taxonomies of Private Authority in Transnational
Regulation" 2012 German Law Journal 1329-1338
Semenik et al Advertising and Promotion
Semenik RJ et al Advertising and Promotion: An Integrated Brand
Approach 6th ed (South-Western Cengage Learning Mason 2012)
Shimp Integrated Marketing Communication
Shimp TA Integrated Marketing Communication in Advertising and
Promotion 8th ed (South-Western Cengage Learning Mason 2010)
Taylor 2011 Without Prejudice
Taylor N "Promotional Competitions –Let the Promoter Beware" April
Without Prejudice 17-20
Van Eeden Consumer Protection Law
Van Eeden E Consumer Protection Law in South Africa (LexisNexis
Durban 2013)
Van Heerden "Marketing"
Van Heerden C "Marketing" in Eiselen S and Naudé T (eds) Commentary
on the Consumer Protection Act (original service) (Juta Claremont 2014) 1 –
Van Heerden "Section 36"
Van Heerden C "Section 36" in Eiselen S and Naudé T (eds) Commentary
on the Consumer Protection Act (original service) (Juta Claremont 2014)
-1 –36-15
Verbruggen Transnational Private Regulation
Verbruggen P Transnational Private Regulation in the Advertising Industry
(Hague Institute for the Internationalisation of Law The Hague 2011)
Verbruggen "Enforcement of Transnational Private Regulation"
Verbruggen P "Enforcement of Transnational Private Regulation of
Advertising Practices: Decentralization, Mechanisms and Procedural
Fairness" in Cafaggi F (ed) Enforcement of Transnational Regulation:
Ensuring Compliance in a Global World(Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2012)
-327
Verbruggen 2013 Regulation & Governance
Verbruggen P "Gorillas in the Closet? Public and Private Actors in the
Enforcement of Transnational Private Regulation" 2013 Regulation &
Governance 512-532
Vos Regulating Offensive Advertising
Vos SW De Gustibus non est Disputandum: Regulating Offensive
Advertising in a Democratic South Africa (LLD thesis University of Pretoria
Woker Advertising Law
Woker T Advertising Law in South Africa(Juta Kenwyn 1999)
Woker 2010 Obiter
Woker T "Why the Need for Consumer Protection Legislation? A Look at
Some of the Reasons behind thePpromulgation of the National Credit Act
and the Consumer Protection Act" 2010 Obiter 217-231
Rulings and case law
Advertising Standards Authority of South Africa
Archers / L Nel / 4779 (10 May 2006)
Brooks Sweeto / GH Smith / 725 (4 August 2005)
CAT Watches / Rajash Seejarim / 1391 (13 July 2004)
City Mageu Competition / Mageu Number One / 1758
(17 November 2004)
Coca Cola Vitamin Water / S Antonellos / 2015-576F
(30 April 2015)
Denny Mushrooms SMS Competition / E A Van Zyl / 7383
(24 November 2006)
DSTV Competition / JW Sherwood / 4578 (14 March 2006)
DSTV Golf / Maureen Tiearney (6 November 2003)
Federal Mogul Competition / M Kent / 13839
(28 July 2009)
Magnum Competition / P Howard / 2014 –1261F
(19 August 2014)
MTN Man United Competition / R Haupt / 17738
(27 June 2011)
Olympics 2012 Competition / N van der Lingen / 19461
(15 February 2012)
R1 Million House Competition / Mr B Oldenboom / 1402
(30 July 2004)
Racumin / M M Keys / 1834 (7 February 2005)
SMS Competitions / C Pearce / 8539 (13 March 2007)
Sokka Kings / I Butler / 706 (3 June 2005)
Sowetan BMW Competition / S Zwane / 2014 –1841 F
(8 January 2015)
Sta-Soft / T Marshall / 1683 (23 November 2004)
Steers / Mr T Spicer / 184 (15 September 2003)
Ster Kinekor Competition / M du Plessis / 8610
(13 April 2007)
Sunday Times Food and Travel Magazine / Mr E Schwentzek / 1044
(12 July 2004)
Supa Quick / Tiger Wheel & Tyre / 10316
(13 December 2007)
Twinsaver Spoil-Yourself Competition / Kimberly Clark / 4622
(13 June 2002)
Wireless Application Services Providers' Association
Celerity Systems (BulkSMS) (Complaint No 718)
Clickatell (Complaint No 8128)
Clickatell (Complaint No 8228)
Exactmobile (Compliant No 4196)
HP Computek (Compliant No 11370)
Independent SMS Telecommunications (Pty) Ltd (Complaint No 0067)
Mira Networks (Complaint No 4696)
Mobile NOBO (IP) / Tanla Mobile (SP) (0118) (Compliant No 15268)
Viamedia (SP) Xcite Mobile (IP) (Compliant No 12969)
General
Kumalo v Cycle Lab (Pty) Ltd (31871/2008) [2011] ZAGPJHC 56 (17 June
O'Keefe v Argus Printing and Publishing Co Ltd 1954 3 SA 244 (C)
Wells v Atoll Media (Pty) Ltd 201] 4 All SA 548 (WCC)
Legislation
South Africa
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008
Consumer Protection Act Regulations (GN R293 in GG 34180 of 1 April
Electronic Communications Act 35 of 200
Lotteries Act 57 of 1997
Independent Broadcasting Act 153 of 1993
Value-Added Tax Act 89 of 1991
United Kingdom
Communications Act 2003
Gambling Act 2005
Government publications
GN 224 in GG 36253 of 22 March 2013
GN 817 in GG 38107 of 17 October 2014
GN R271 in GG 38637 of 30 March 2015
GN 33 in GG 39631 of 29 January 2016
International instruments
Interinstitutional Agreement on Better Law-Making Concluded between the
European Parliament, the Council of Europe and the European
Commission, 2003/C321/01 (2003)
Internet sources
ASASA 2015 http://bit.ly/24SaaDn
Advertising Standards Authority of South Africa 2015 About the ASASA
http://bit.ly/24SaaDn accessed 20 June 2015
ASASA 2015 http://bit.ly/1Otx6zh
Advertising Standard Authority of South Africa 2015 Advertising Code of
Practice http://bit.ly/1Otx6zhaccessed 20 June 2015
Bizcommunity 2013 http://bit.ly/24SapOI
Bizcommunity 2013 FASA to Handle Alternative Dispute Resolutions for
Franchise Sector http://bit.ly/24SapOI accessed 16 June 2015
CAP 2013 http://bit.ly/1TdC6Ko
Committee of Advertising Practice 2013 Help Note: Promotions with Prizes
http://bit.ly/1TdC6Ko accessed 11 July 2015
CAP 2014 http://bit.ly/1YsfvNZ
Committee of Advertising Practice 2014 Code of Advertising Practice
http://bit.ly/1YsfvNZ accessed 20 June 2016
Danish Consumer Ombudsman 2015 http://bit.ly/1V22ED3
Danish Consumer Ombudsman 2015 ICC Codeshttp://bit.ly/1V22ED3
accessed 15 August 2015
EASA date unknown http://bit.ly/1sbV9hq
European Advertising Standards Alliance date unknown What is EASA?
http://bit.ly/1sbV9hq accessed 16 June 2015
EASA date unknown http://bit.ly/1TTSmT6
European Advertising Standards Alliance date unknown South Africa
http://bit.ly/1TTSmT6 accessed 16 June 2015
EASA 2003 http://bit.ly/1ZRlSKV
European Advertising Standards Alliance 2003 Advertising Self-
Regulation: The Essentials http://bit.ly/1ZRlSKV accessed 24 August 2015
EASA 2004 http://bit.ly/1TTSqCr
European Advertising Standards Alliance 2004 The EASA Best Practice
Self-Regulatory Model http://bit.ly/1TTSqCr accessed 27 August 2015
EASA 2009 http://bit.ly/1XaD0w7
European Advertising Standards Alliance 2009 International Guide to
Developing a Self-Regulatory Organisationhttp://bit.ly/1XaD0w7 accessed
August 2015
EASA 2013 http://bit.ly/1TbKhw7
European Advertising Standards Alliance 2013 Blue Book 6
http://bit.ly/1TbKhw7 accessed 16 June 2015
German Association of Communications Agencies date unknown
German Association of Communications Agencies date unknown
Germany: Self-Regulatory Organisationshttp://bit.ly/1WxZesS accessed
August 2015
IARN 2009 http://www.iarn.org/
International Audiotex Regulators Network 2009 Welcome to the IARN
http://www.iarn.org/ accessed 16 August 2015
ICC 2015 http://bit.ly/1VX1idT
International Chamber of Commerce 2015 Commission on Marketing and
Advertisinghttp://bit.ly/1VX1idT accessed 16 June 2015
ICC 2015 http://bit.ly/23QNnW1
International Chamber of Commerce 2015 Marketing and Advertising
http://bit.ly/23QNnW1 accessed 15 August 2015
ICC 2015 http://bit.ly/228Wdz4
International Chamber of Commerce 2015 Self-Regulation
http://bit.ly/228Wdz4 accessed 15 August 2015
Jacobson 2014 http://bit.ly/1TNObFG
Jacobson P 2014 Rewritten WASPA Code Better Regulates Mobile
Services in SA http://bit.ly/1TNObFG accessed 20 June 2015
MCA 2015 http://bit.ly/23QNKjB
Marketing Code Authority 2015 The Code http://bit.ly/23QNKjB accessed
February 2016
PhonepayPlus 2015 http://bit.ly/1snqDBG
PhonepayPlus 2015 Code of Practice http://bit.ly/1snqDBG accessed 4
May 2015
PhonepayPlus date unknown http://bit.ly/1V3Nayx
PhonepayPlus date unknown Service-Specific Guidance Note:
Competitions and Other Games with Prizes http://bit.ly/1V3Nayx accessed
May 2016
Senden 2005 http://bit.ly/1Ore1Dh
Senden L 2005 "Soft Law, Self-Regulation and Co-Regulation in European
Law: Where Do They Meet?" 2005 EJCLhttp://bit.ly/1Ore1Dh accessed
July 2015
Swedish Advertising Ombudsman About http://bit.ly/1snrgvc
Swedish Advertising Ombudsman 2015 Abouthttp://bit.ly/1snrgvc
accessed 15 August 2015
WASPA 2015 http://bit.ly/1TTTplZ
Wireless Application Service Providers' Association 2015 About WASPA
http://bit.ly/1TTTplZ accessed 20 June 2015
WASPA 2016 http://bit.ly/1TdFqoN
Wireless Application Service Providers' Association 2016 The WASPA
Codeof Conduct http://bit.ly/1TdFqoN accessed 1 February 2016
WASPA 2016 http://bit.ly/24SdG0p
Wireless Application Service Providers' Association 2016 WASPA
Constitutionhttp://bit.ly/24SdG0p accessed 1 February 2016
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2016 Daniel Strachan
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}