A Comparative Analysis of the Treatment of Inflation in South African Capital Gains Tax and the Accrual Systems
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2023/v26i0a14118Keywords:
Capital Gains Taxation, Marital Property Regimes, Zugewinngemeinschaft, Inflation, Capital Gains Tax Inclusion Rate, Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, Income Tax Act 58 of 1962Abstract
Inflation is often defined as a continuous and considerable rise in prices in general. Recently it has become a focal point due to globally elevated levels of inflation. Considering its treatment in the South African legal system, this article unpacks the contrary approaches of the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984 (MPA) and the Income Tax Act 58 of 1962 (ITA) regarding inflation. These two Acts are considered as they provide different approaches to inflation, therefore different outcomes. While the MPA makes provision for inflation in determining the growth of each of the estates of spouses married out of community with the accrual system, the ITA does not recognise inflation insofar as it relates to capital gains tax. Comparing the approaches of the MPA and the ITA reveals disparities in the law and justifies the investigation conducted in this article.
Accordingly, this article compares the effect of inflation and capital gains tax and why inflation is not considered when determining the base cost of an asset for capital gains tax purposes. To explain the inconsistency between the MPA and the ITA, this article firstly unpacks the characteristics of the South African matrimonial property regime insofar as it relates to inflation. Thereafter, the article characterises the South African application of the capital gains tax and articulates the shortcomings of existing capital gains tax provisions and the resulting challenges in the application of both Acts.
In comparing the ways in which the MPA and the ITA deal with inflation, a clear distinction becomes evident. This article finds that, while the initial inclusion rate for capital gains tax inflation is largely accommodated, subsequent increases in the inclusion rate have erased this provision. Given these findings, this article suggests that the current South African capital gains tax regime's inclusion rate be further investigated to determine whether a wider set of exclusions could be developed to better accommodate inflation.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Barker B "Expanding the Study of Comparative Tax Law to Promote Democratic Policy: The Example of the Move to Capital Gains Taxation in Post-Apartheid South Africa" 2005 Penn St L Rev 703-728
Black J A Dictionary of Economics (Oxford University Press New York 1997)
Bryan MF and Cecchetti SG The Consumer Price Index as a Measure of Inflation (National Bureau of Economic Research Cambridge 1993) DOI: https://doi.org/10.3386/w4505
Buckle RA "Introduction: Tax Policy Reform New Zealand Style" 2010 NZEP 129-136 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00779954.2010.496142
Burman L and White D "Taxing Capital Gains in New Zealand" 2003 NZJTLP 355-386
Cassidy J "Capital Gains Tax in South Africa: Lessons from Australia?" 2004 SA Merc LJ 164-195
Cnossen S and Bovenberg L "Fundamental Tax Reform in The Netherlands" 2001 International Tax and Public Finance 471-484 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011287428702
Coester M "Die vermögensrechtlichen Wirkungen der Ehe in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland" in Referate des deutsch-schwedischen Juristentreffens (13-17 September 1988 Heidelberg) 61-82
Coetzee K et al (eds) A Student's Approach to Income Tax: Natural Persons 2018 (LexisNexis Durban 2017)
De Jong M "The Need for New Legislation and/or Divorce Mediation to Counter Some Commonly Experienced Problems with the Division of Assets upon Divorce" 2012 Stell LR 225-240
De Jong M and Pintens W "Default Matrimonial Property Regimes and the Principles of European Family Law – A European-South African Comparison (Part 2)" 2005 TSAR 551-566
Evans C "Taxing Capital Gains: One Step Forwards or Two Steps Back" 2002 Journal of Australian Taxation 114-135
Gutuza T "The Headquarter Company Structure in the Southern African Context: A South African Tax Law Perspective" 2014 CILSA 187-205
Halho A "A Note on Deferred Community of Gains: The Theory and the Practice" 1975 McGill LJ 589-595
Harding M Taxation of Dividend, Interest, and Capital Gain Income (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Paris 2013)
Hockley GC "Capital Gains and Inflation" 1968 BTR 3-8
Jacomb M "A History of Taxing Capital Gains in New Zealand: Why Don't We" 2014 Auckland U L Rev 124-149
Knur A Probleme der Zugewinngemeinschaft (Publishing House for the Social Sciences Wiesbaden 1959) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-663-02855-0
Leyser J "'Equality of the Spouses' under the New German Law" 1958 Am J Comp L 276-287 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/837569
Lorenz W "Die Verfügungsbeschränkungen im Rahmen der Zugewinngemeinschaft" 1959 JZ 105-109
Maroun W, Turner M and Sartorius K "Does Capital Gains Tax Add or Detract from the Fairness of the South African Tax System?" 2011 SAJEMS 436-448 DOI: https://doi.org/10.4102/sajems.v14i4.131
McLeod R et al Tax Review 2001: Final Report October 2001 (Tax Review Committee Wellington 2001)
Mohr P et al Economics for South African Students 5th ed (Van Schaik Pretoria 2015)
Oguttu AW "Resolving the Conflict between Controlled Foreign Company Legislation and Tax Treaties: A South African Perspective" 2009 CILSA 73-114
Rabenowitz P et al (eds) The South African Financial Planning Handbook 2016 (LexisNexis Durban 2016)
Sadka E "An Inflation-Proof Tax System? Some Lessons from Israel" 1991 SPIMF 135-155 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3867038
South African Law Commission Report Pertaining to the Matrimonial Property Law with Special Reference to the Matrimonial Affairs Act, 1953, the Status of the Married Woman, and the Law of Succession in so far as it Affects the Spouses. RP26/1982 (SALC Pretoria 1982)
Scherpe JM "A Comparative Overview of the Treatment of Non-Matrimonial Assets, Indexation and Value Increases" 2013 CFLQ 61-81
Sinclair JD "The Financial Consequences of Divorce in South Africa: Judicial Determination or Private Ordering" 1983 ICLQ 785-811 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/iclqaj/32.4.785
Sinclair JD "Divorce and the Judicial Discretion – In Search of the Middle Ground" 1989 SALJ 249-259
Tanzi V Taxation, Inflation and Interest Rates (International Monetary Fund Washington DC 1984)
Thiele W "Die grobe Unbilligkeit des Zugewinnausgleichs: § 1381 BGB im Bereich der Anwendungsmaximen des § 242 BGB" 1960 JZ 394-398
Thiele LK "The German Marital Property System: Conflict of Laws in a Dual-Nationality Marriage" 1982 Cal W Int'l LJ 78-127
Tiong A "The New Zealand Tax Reforms of 2010" 2010 Auckland U L Rev 294-304
Van Wyk AH "Matrimonial Property System in Comparative Perspective" 1983 Acta Juridica 53-74
Case law
Commissioner for Inland Revenue v Stott 1928 3 SATC 253
Commissioner for Inland Revenue v Visser 1937 8 SATC 271
Eisner v Macomber 1920 252 US 189 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0016-0032(20)91612-5
Legislation
Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984
Matrimonial Affairs Act 37 of 1953
Income Tax Act 58 of 1962
Internet sources
Lightstone 2021 House Price Indices https://lightstoneproperty.co.za/adminNews/news.aspx?cId=3 accessed 18 November 2021
South African Revenue Service 2000 Guide to Capital Gains Tax http://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/national%20budget/2000/cgt/cgt.pdf accessed 17 July 2019
South African Revenue Service 2018 Comprehensive Guide to Capital Gains Tax (Issue 7) https://www.sars.gov.za/AllDocs/OpsDocs/
Guides/LAPD-CGT-G01%20%20Comprehensive%20Guide%20to%20Capital%20Gains%20Tax.pdf accessed 17 July 2019
Tax Policy Chief Directorate, National Treasury Capital Gains Tax http://www.ftomasek.com/NationalTreasury.pdf accessed 17 July 2019
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Davin Olën, Henk Kloppers
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}