Lessons for Nigeria from the Experience of South Africa in Managing the Challenges of Transfer of Title and Administration of Fragmented Property Schemes

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2023/v26i0a15638

Keywords:

Fragmented property scheme, sectional title, transfer of title, management, South Africa, Nigeria

Abstract

A "fragmented property" or "multiple unit" property is one in which several persons have ownership or title interest in sections or parts of a single property scheme. The title interest could be in a block of flats/apartments or maisonettes in a building, and a building in a group of buildings, or townhouse(s), and fully detached houses in a complex or estate. Without clear rules regulating the nature and scope of title, the use of individual units in the scheme, and the conduct and inter-personal relations of the parties involved, incessant litigation or self-help remediation is likely to be common.

In Nigeria the first fragmented property scheme was established by the government in 1959 to provide accommodation for senior  public servants. Several others have followed, and the establishment of housing estates is no longer restricted to the government. However, the intractable problem with schemes in Nigeria is that there is a lack of a specific legal framework to address the provision of an unimpeachable title to buyers, and for the administration of schemes for the benefit of all parties. There is therefore a need to address the problems associated with the transfer of title and the administration of fragmented property schemes. Doing so is the objective of this article.

To achieve that objective, the legal framework applicable to fragmented property schemes in South Africa is critically
considered with a view to learn from the experience of the country's robust legislation developed by caselaw, in addition to academic opinions over a period exceeding half a century. Recommendations to deal with the challenges in Nigeria regarding the issues of transfer of title and management of fragmented property schemes are proposed.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bibliography

Literature

Adeyinka RB "Transparency in Land Title Registration: Strategies to Eradicate Corruption in Africa Land Sector" 2020 African Journal on Land Policy and Geospatial Sciences 162-173

Baboolal-Frank R "An analysis of sectional title dispute litigation in South Africa" 2021 JIDS 659-670 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jnlids/idaa023

Banire M "Administration of Consent Provision for under the Land Use Act: A Curse or Blessing – Case Study of Lagos State" in Utuama AA (ed) Critical Issues in Nigerian Property Law: Subject Matter Analysis and Commentary (Malthouse Press Lagos 2016) 101-134

Cowen DV "The South African Sectional Titles Act in Historical Perspective: An Analysis and Evaluation" 1973 CILSA 1-38

Edward ST "Comparative Lessons in Sectional Title Laws: Mitigating Urban Inequality in South Africa" 2022 OJLS 1013-1039

Egidiaro BA et al "Residents' Transformation of Dwelling Units in Public Housing Estates in Lagos, Nigeria: Implications for Policy and Practice" 2013 International Journal of Education and Research 1-20

Horn JG and Pienaar GG "Exclusive Use Rights in terms of Sectional Title Legislation" 2021 Stell LR 91-109

Moloto S "Sectional Titles Schemes: The Impact of Non-Functioning Body Corporates on the Affordable Housing Market" 2020 SA Affordable Housing 29-30

Nwuba CC and Nuhu SR "Challenges to Land Registration in Kaduna State, Nigeria" 2018 Journal of African Real Estate Research 141-172 DOI: https://doi.org/10.15641/jarer.v1i1.566

Olanipekun W "Constitutionality of an Unconstitutional Act: The Unconstitutional Entrenchment of the Land Use Act in the Nigerian Constitution" in Utuama AA (ed) Critical Issues in Nigerian Property Law (Malthouse Press Lagos 2016) 155-168

Olatunbosun AJ "A Comparative Analysis of Residential Quality of Public and Private Estates in an Urban Centre of Lagos, Nigeria: A Case Study of Iba Estate in Ojo and Unity Estate in Alimoso" 2018 Journal of Geography and Regional Planning 46-60 DOI: https://doi.org/10.5897/JGRP2017.0659

Pienaar GJ and Horn JG Sectional Titles and Other Fragmented Property Schemes 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2020)

Steenkamp L and Lubbe D "The Sectional Title Industry in South Africa: Perspectives of Accounting and Auditing Practitioners" 2015 Corporate Ownership and Control 550-559 DOI: https://doi.org/10.22495/cocv12i2c5p4

Van der Merwe CG "A Critical Analysis of the Innovations Introduced by the Sectional Titles Amendment Bill of 2010" 2011 Stell LR 115-136

Van der Merwe CG "Comparative Survey of the Legal Challenges Faced by Mixed-Use Sectional Title (Condominium) Developments" 2018 TSAR 36-51

Van Schalkwyk CL and Van der Merwe CG "A Critical Analysis of the Role of the Developer in Sectional Title Developments" 2008 TSAR 222-237

Yahaya Y "The Land Use Act and the Nigerian Housing Sector" 2019 Central Bank of Nigeria Economic and Financial Review 105-139

Case law

Nigeria

Ibrahim v Mohammed (2003) LPELR-1409 (SC)

Nlewedim v Uduma (1995) 6 NWLR (Pt 402) 383 (SC)

Osho v Foreign Finance Corporation (1991) 4 NWLR (Pt 184) 157 (SC)

South Africa

BAE Estates and Escapes (Pty) Ltd v The Trustees for the Time Being of the Legacy Body Corporate and Pam Golding Property Management Services (Pty) Ltd 2020 4 SA 514 (WCC)

Body Corporate – Montpark Drakens v Smuts 2007 JOL 19484 (W)

Body Corporate of Marine Sands v Extra Dimensions 121 (Pty) Ltd 2020 2 SA 61 (SCA)

Bouramis v Body Corporate of the Towers 1995 4 SA 106 (D)

Central Developments Tshwane (Pty) Ltd v Body Corporate, Twee Riviere Aftree Oord (635/2019) [2020] ZASCA 107 (21 September 2020)

De La Harpe v Body Corporate of Bella Toscana (10088/2013) [2014] ZAKZDHC 63 (28 October 2014)

Herald Investments Share Block (Pty) Ltd v Meer; Meer v Body Corporate of Belmont Arcade 2011 2 All SA 103 (KZD)

Khyber Rock Estate East Home Owners Association v 09 of Erf 823 Woodmead Ext 13 CC (7689/2006) [2007] ZAGPHC 137 (14 August 2007)

Oribel Properties 13 (Pty) Ltds v Blue Dot Properties 271 (Pty) Ltd 2010 4 All SA 282 (SCA)

Wiljay Investments v Body Corporate, Bryanston Crescent 1984 2 SA 722 (T)

Legislation

Nigeria

Companies and Allied Matters Act 3 of 2020

Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999

Lagos State Lands Registration Law 1 of 2015

Land Use Act 6 of 1978

South Africa

Community Schemes Ombud Service Act 9 of 2011

Income Tax Act 58 of 1962

National Credit Act 35 of 2005

Sectional Titles Act 95 of 1986

Sectional Titles Amendment Act 63 of 1991

Sectional Titles Schemes Management Act 8 of 2011

Internet sources

Aderibigbe AE et al 2015 An Assessment of Land Title Registration Process in Osun State, Nigeria: Proceedings of the 15th African Real Estate Society Conference https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/An-Assessment-Of-Land-Title-Registration-Process-In-Aderibigbe-Gbolahan/56abcd9f0b7e 7278d8bd60bd2f82cee45f87da0a accessed 14 February 2023

Adesomoju A and Ramon O 2018 CJN Says Supreme Court's Diary Filled till 2021, Lawyers Worry https://punchng.com/cjn-says-supreme-courts-diary-filled-till-2021-lawyers-worry/ accessed 15 February 2023

Allied Market Research 2020 Nigeria Facility Management Services Market Outlook – 2027 https://www.alliedmarketresearch.com/nigeria-facility-management-services-market-A06327 accessed 14 February 2023

FESTAC Online Date Unknown FESTAC Town: History and Background https://festaconline.com.ng/festac-town-history-and-background/ accessed 13 February 2023

Ghebru H and Okumo A 2016 Land Administration Service Delivery and Its Challenges in Nigeria: A Case Study of Eight States International Food Policy – International Food Policy Research Institute Working Paper 39 https://www.canr.msu.edu/fsp/publications/researchpapers/Land_administration_service_delivery_and_its_challenges_in_Nigeria_A_case_study_of_eight_states.pdf accessed 12 February 2023

Lagos State Land Use and Allocation Committee 2022 Schedule of Fees and Levies https://landsbureau.lagosstate.gov.ng/schdule-of-fees/ accessed 12 February 2023

Libra Law Office Date Unknown Land Tenure and Land Use in Nigeria: Towards the Innovative Use of Sectional Title Ownership https://libralawoffice.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/LAND-TENURE-AND-LAND-USE-IN-NIGERIA-TOWARDS-THE-INNOVATIVE-USE-OF-SECTIONAL-TITLE-OWNERSHIP-LATEST.pdf accessed 13 February 2023

Lightstone Property 2018 Sectional Title Buying Performance https://www.lightstoneproperty.co.za/news/Sectional_Title_buying_performance_September_2018.pdf accessed 15 February 2023

Nigeria Property Centre Date Unknown VGC Area Guide https://nigeriapropertycentre.com/area-guides/lagos/lekki/victoria-garden-city accessed 13 February 2023

Ojie E 2022 In Nigeria, Residential Associations are the New LGAs https://nairametrics-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/nairametrics.com/2022/ 11/27/in-nigeria-residential-estates-associations-are-the-new-lgas/?amp=1 accessed 13 February 2023

Okon D 2022 76% of Residents are into Energy Theft, Says 1004 Estate Chairperson https://www.thecable.ng/76-of-residents-are-into-energy-theft-says-1004-estate-chairperson accessed 13 February 2023

South African Revenue Service 2012 Interpretation Note No 64 in terms of Section 10(1)(e) of the Income Tax Act No 58 of 1962 https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/LAPD-IntR-IN-2012-64-Arc-85-IN64-Issue-2-Archived-on-17-August-2015.pdf accessed 15 February 2023

Schindlers Attorneys 2017 Penalty Fees/Charges and Sectional Title Body Corporate https://www.schindlers.co.za/2017/penaltychargesbodycorp/ ?pdf=8302 accessed 15 February 2023

Sunday O 2020 1004 Estate Residents Bicker over Electricity Crisis https://guardian.ng/news/1004-estate-residents-bicker-over-electricity-crisis/ accessed 15 February 2023

World Bank 2023 Land Area - Nigeria https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ AG.LND.TOTL.K2?locations=NG accessed 14 February 2023

Published

23-11-2023

Issue

Section

Special Edition: Land & Customary Law

How to Cite

Omidire, K. (2023). Lessons for Nigeria from the Experience of South Africa in Managing the Challenges of Transfer of Title and Administration of Fragmented Property Schemes. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 26, (Published on 23 November 2023) pp 1 - 28. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2023/v26i0a15638

Similar Articles

1-10 of 1163

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.