Transitional Justice in Anglophone Cameroon: Perspectives and lessons from South Africa and Rwanda
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2024/v27i0a15661Keywords:
Transitional justice, human rights violations, Anglophone Cameroon crisis, truth and reconciliation commission, criminal prosecutionAbstract
Since the fall of 2016, Anglophone Cameroon has endured the scorching stench of an internal political conflict between security forces and separatist militia groups, in which numerous human rights violations have been committed. Given the magnitude of these violations, they have been categorised as serious crimes in international law (crimes against humanity). While international law urges the prosecution of perpetrators, this paper, acknowledging the rule of law as a relevant tool in transforming and shaping societies, nonetheless opines that in post-conflict scenarios, the responses of states are not always influenced by the rule of law, as they sometimes involve factors that have no legal bearing or backing. These responses have been recognised generally to constitute components of transitional justice. This paper thus views transitional justice as comprising all the measures which states usually turn to in search of ways to respond to past atrocities, whether legal, non-legal or a combination thereof. This paper argues that the situation in Anglophone Cameroon has reached unprecedented levels of violence and given the degree of victimisation and mayhem caused to society, there is a need for transitional justice, in order to give closure to victims and restore stability. To suggest the form such transitional justice may take, the paper uses a comparative methodological approach in examining the transitional justice perspectives of South Africa and Rwanda, to assess what lessons could be drawn from them in respect of how they dealt with their legacies of past abuses. The paper recommends the establishment of an Anglophone Cameroon Truth, Justice and Reconciliation Commission (ACTJRC).
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Achankeng F "Colonial Existence, Home and Nationalism in the Narratives of British Cameroons' Exiles in the United States" 2015 The Round Table 104 319-340
Agbor AA and Njeassam EE "Beyond the Contours of Normally Acceptable Political Violence: Is Cameroon a Conflict/Transitional Society in the Offing?" 2019 PELJ 1-32
Allan A and Allan MM "The South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission as a Therapeutic Tool" 2000 Behavioural Science and the Law 459-477
Backer D "Evaluating Transitional Justice in South Africa from a Victim's Perspective" 2005 Journal of the International Institute http://hdl.handle.net/2027/spo.4750978.0012.207
Baines G "The Rainbow Nation? Identity and Nation Building in Post-Apartheid South Africa" 1998 Mots Pluriels 1-10
Berrisford S "Unravelling Apartheid Spatial Planning Legislation in South Africa: A Case Study" 2011 Urban Forum 247-263
Byrne CC "Benefit or Burden: Victims' Reflections on TRC Participation" 2004 Peace and Conflict 237-256
Cho DT and Agbor AA "An Intra-State 'Humanitarian' Crisis in the Offing? Critical Insights into the Human Rights and Humanitarian Violations in the Ongoing Anglophone Cameroon Crisis" 2022 Journal of Nation-Building and Policy Studies 5-29
Cho DT and Agbor AA "Prosecuting Human Violations Committed in the Anglophone Cameroon Crisis: A Disquisition on the Legal Framework" 2022 PELJ 1-29
Crawford J "Hopes and Fears as Kigali Launches Participative Justice" Hirondelle News Agency Lausanne (11 October 2001) 2
De Greiff P The Handbook of Reparations (Oxford University Press Oxford 2006)
De Jonge K Interim Report on Research on Gacaca Jurisdictions and its Preparations (Penal Reform International Kigali 2001)
Dinka GF "The New Social Order" in Mukong AW (ed) The Case for the Southern Cameroons (CAMFECO Washington DC 1990) 91-105
Dubow S Apartheid, 1948-1994 (Oxford University Press Oxford 2014)
Gahima G Transitional Justice in Rwanda: Accountability for Atrocity (Routledge London 2013)
Gibson JL "The Contributions of Truth to Reconciliation: Lessons from South Africa" 2006 Journal of Conflict Resolution 409-432
Graybill L and Lanegran K "Truth, Justice, and Reconciliation in Africa: Issues and Cases" 2004 African Studies Quarterly 1-8
Hamber B Transforming Societies after Political Violence: Truth, Reconciliation, and Mental Health (Springer New York 2009)
Ingelaere B "The Gacaca Courts in Rwanda" in Huyse L and Salter M (eds) Traditional Justice and Reconciliation after Violent Conflict: Learning from African Experiences (International IDEA Stockholm 2008) 25-59
Jablonski NG, Blum L and Friedman S The Colour of Our Future: Does Race Matter in Post-Apartheid South Africa? (New York University Press New York 2015)
Jones NA The Courts of Genocide: Politics and the Rule of Law in Rwanda and Arusha (Routledge London 2010)
Kaliisa S "Kigali Begins Training Judges for New Justice System in December" Internews Arusha (25 October 2001) 1
Kaufman ZD and Clark P (eds) After Genocide: Transitional Justice, Post-Conflict Reconstruction, and Reconciliation in Rwanda and Beyond (Oxford University Press 2009)
Kavuro C "Rwanda Reconciliation Process: Outcome Analysis of Gacaca Courts" Unpublished contribution delivered at the Great Lakes Region Shareholders' Conference for Sustainable Peace (September 2011 Cape Town)
Kavuro C "Gacaca Courts, Reconciliation and the Politics of Apology in Post-Genocide Rwanda" 2017 SACJ 38-71
Kim NK and Hong MH "Politics of Pursuing Justice in the Aftermath of Civil Conflict" 2019 Journal of Conflict Resolution 1165-1192
Konings P "Anglophone University Students and Anglophone Nationalist Struggles in Cameroon" in Abbink J (ed) Vanguard or Vandals Youth Politics and Conflict in Africa (Brill Leiden 2005) 163-190
Konings P and Nyamnjoh FB "The Anglophone Problem in Cameroon" 1997 JMAS 207-229
Legide KK "The Facets of Transitional Justice and 'Red Terror' Mass Trials of Derg Officials in Post-1991 Ethiopia: Reassessing its Achievements and Pitfalls" 2021 Journal of African Conflicts and Peace Studies 1-33
Lin O "Demythologizing Restorative Justice: South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission and Rwanda's Gacaca Courts in Context" 2005 ILSA J Int'l & Comp L 41-85
Lykes MB and Mersky M "Reparations and Mental Health: Psychosocial Interventions towards Healing, Human Agency, and Rethreading Social Realities" in De Grieff P (ed) The Handbook of Reparations (Oxford University Press Oxford 2006) 589-622
Malamud-Goti J "Transitional Governments in the Breach: Why Punish State Criminals?" 1990 Hum Rts Q 1-16
Mibenge C "Enforcing International Humanitarian Law at the National Level: The Gacaca Jurisdictions of Rwanda" 2004 YIHL 410-424
Nagy R "Traditional Justice and Legal Pluralism in Transitional Context: The Case of Rwanda's Gacaca Courts" in Quinn JR (ed) Reconciliation(s): Transitional Justice in Postconflict Societies (McGill-Queen's Press Montreal 2009) 86-115
Ndlovu-Gatsheni SJ and Tafira CK "The Land Question in South Africa: History of Dispossession, Political Discourse, and Post-Apartheid Government Policy" in Lumumba-Kasongo T (ed) Land Reforms and Natural Resource Conflicts in Africa: New Development Paradigms in the Era of Global Liberalization (Routledge London 2015) 135-148
Ntoubandi FZ Amnesty for Crimes against Humanity under International Law (Martinus Nijhoff Leiden 2007)
Orentlicher DF "Settling Accounts Revisited: Reconciling Global Norms with Local Agency" 2007 International Journal of Transitional Justice 10-22
Palmer N "International Criminal Law and Border Control: The Expressive Role of the Deportation and Extradition of Genocide Suspects to Rwanda" 2020 LJIL 789-807
Pineteh E "Memories of Home and Exile: Narratives of Cameroonian Asylum Seekers in Johannesburg" 2005 Journal of Intercultural Studies 379-399
Pommerolle ME and Heungoup HDM "The 'Anglophone Crisis': A Tale of the Cameroonian Postcolony" 2017 African Affairs 526-538
Reyntjens F "Le Gacaca ou la Justice du Gazon au Rwanda" 1990 Politique Africaine 31-41
Sarkin J "The Tension between Justice and Reconciliation in Rwanda: Politics, Human Rights, Due Process and the Role of the Gacaca Courts in Dealing with the Genocide" 2001 JAL 143-172
Schabas WA "Post-Genocide Justice in Rwanda: A Spectrum of Options" in Kaufman ZD and Clark P (eds) After Genocide: Transitional Justice, Post-Conflict Reconstruction, and Reconciliation in Rwanda and Beyond (Oxford University Press 2009) 207-227
Schabas WA "National Courts Finally Begin to Prosecute Genocide, the 'Crime of Crimes'" 2003 JICJ 39-63
Schabas WA "Amnesty, the Sierra Leone Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the Special Court for Sierra Leone" 2004 UC Davis Journal of International Law and Policy 145-169
Scharf MP "Swapping Amnesty for Peace: Was There a Duty to Prosecute International Crimes in Haiti?" 1996 Tex Int'l LJ 31 1-42
Stevens G "Truth, Confessions and Reparations: Lessons from the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission" 2005 African Safety Promotion 23-39
Teitel R "Transitional Justice in a New Era" 2003 Fordham Int'l LJ 893-906
Teitel RG "Transitional Justice Genealogy" 2003 Harv Hum Rts J 69-94
Truth and Reconciliation Commission Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa Report Volume 1 (The Commission Cape Town 1998)
Trouille HL "France, Universal Jurisdiction and Rwandan Génocidaires: The Simbikangwa Trial" 2016 JICJ 195-217
Tutu D No Future without Forgiveness (Doubleday New York 1999)
Van der Merwe H and Chapman AR Truth and Reconciliation in South Africa: Did the TRC Deliver? (University of Pennsylvania Press Philadelphia 2008)
Westberg MM "Rwanda's Use of Transitional Justice after Genocide: The Gacaca Courts and the ICTR" 2010 U Kan L Rev 331-367
Case law
AZAPO v Truth and Reconciliation Commission 1996 8 BCLR 1015 (CC)
The Citizen 1978 (Pty) Ltd v McBride 2011 8 BCLR 816 (CC)
The Prosecutor v Paul Bisengimana (Judgment and Sentence) 2006 ICTR 00-60-T
The Prosecutor v Vincent Rutaganira (Judgment and Sentence) 2005 ICTR-95-1C-T
Legislation
Rwanda
Organic Law Establishing the Organisation, Competence and Functioning of Gacaca Courts Charged with Prosecuting and Trying the Perpetrators of the Crime of Genocide and Other Crimes against Humanity, Committed between October 1 1990 and December 31 1994 Organic Law No 16/2004 of 2004, as modified by Organic Law No 28/2006 of 2006
South Africa
Group Areas Act 41 of 1950
Immorality Act 23 of 1957
Prohibition of Mixed Marriages Act 55 of 1949
Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act 34 of 1995
Public Safety Act 3 of 1953
Reservation of Separate Amenities Act 49 of 1953
Suppression of Communism Act 44 of 1950
Terrorism Act 83 of 1967
Unlawful Organisations Act 34 of 1960
International instruments
UN Committee against Torture: Consideration of Reports Submitted by States Parties under Article 19 of the Convention: Conclusions and Recommendations, South Africa UN Doc CAT/C/ZAF/CO/1 (2006)
UN Security Council Resolution 977: Designation of Arusha as the Seat of the International Tribunal for Rwanda UN Doc S/RES/977 (1995)
Internet sources
Act Alliance 2019 Life-Saving Assistance and Resilience-Building for IDPs in the Anglophone Regions of Cameroon https://reliefweb.int/report/
cameroon/act-alliance-appeal-cameroon-conflict-emergency-cmr191 accessed 10 December 2019
Amnesty International 2010 Safer to Stay Silent: The Chilling Effect of Rwanda's Laws on "Genocide Ideology" and "Sectarianism" https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/afr47/005/2010/en/ accessed 20 March 2021
Amnesty International 2018 A Turn for the Worse: Violence and Human Rights Violations in Anglophone Cameroon https://www.amnesty.org/
download/Documents/AFR1784812018ENGLISH.PDF accessed 3 July 2019
Brankovic J 2014 African Union Transitional Justice Policy Framework in Practice: Implementing Accountability Measures https://www.csvr.org.za/
african-union-transitional-justice-policy-framework-in-practice-implementing-accountability-measures/ accessed 24 February 2024
Cameroon-info.net 2016 Honorable Joseph Wirba: Ceux qui Affirment que le Cameroun Doit Être Divisé en Deux Ont Raison http://www.cameroon-info.net/article/cameroun-honorable-joseph-wirba-depute-du-bui-ceux-qui-affirment-que-le-cameroundoit-277266.html accessed 27 June 2020
Dionne S 2018 Cameroon on a Brink of Civil War as English Speakers Recount "Unbearable" Horror https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/06/
world/africa/cameroon-election-biya-ambazonia.html accessed 22 June 2020
Human Rights Watch 2011 Justice Compromised: The Legacy of Rwanda's Community-Based Gacaca Courts https://www.hrw.org/report/2011/05/31/
justice-compromised/legacy-rwandas-community-based-gacaca-courts accessed 20 March 2021
Human Rights Watch 2018 "These Killings Can Be Stopped": Abuses by Government and Separatist Groups in Cameroon's Anglophone Regions https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/report_pdf/cameroon0718_web2.pdf accessed 27 July 2019
Human Rights Watch 2019 Cameroon: New Attacks on Civilians by Troops, Separatists https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/03/28/cameroon-new-attacks-civilians-troops-separatists accessed 24 June 2020
Human Rights Watch 2019 Cameroon: Security Forces Kill Civilians, Rape Woman https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/07/22/cameroon-security-forces-kill-civilians-rape-woman accessed 25 February 2024
International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda 2008 Directive on the Assignment of Defence Counsel https://unictr.irmct.org/sites/unictr.org/
files/legal-library/directive-assignment-defence-counsel_en_fr.pdf accessed 28 May 2021
International Crisis Group 2017 Cameroon's Anglophone Crisis at the Crossroads https://d2071andvip0wj.cloudfront.net/250-cameroons-anglophone-crisis-at-the-crossroads_0.pdf accessed 26 July 2019
Longari M 2018 Cameroon's President Vows "National Dialogue" to Ease Tensions with Anglophone Separatists https://www.france24.com/
en/20190911-cameroonian-president-biya-national-dialogue-anglophone-separatists accessed 14 September 2019
Merten M 2021 Land Expropriation without Compensation: Amending Constitution's Section 25 Draws to a Close – but EFF Makes Last Stand for Nationalization https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-05-16-amending-constitutions-section-25-draws-to-a-close-but-eff-makes-last-stand-for-nationalisation/ accessed 18 April 2021
Moyo N 2022 Rhodes University Helps Brings History to the Present through the Digitisation of Cradock 4 Inquest Documentation https://www.ru.ac.za/latestnews/rhodesuniversityhelpsbringshistorytothepresentthroughthedigitisationo.html accessed 30 August 2023
National Prosecuting Authority 2023 NPA Further Enhances Efforts to Ensure Effective Handling and Prosecution of TRC Cases https://www.npa.gov.za/media/npa-further-enhances-efforts-ensure-effective-handling-and-prosecution-trc-cases accessed 30 August 2023
Overseas Security Advisory Council 2019 Cameroon 2019 Crime and Safety Report https://www.osac.gov/Country/Cameroon/Content/Detail/
Report/b1678858-8009-43c5-9c7b-160eea6972d9 accessed 20 June 2020
SABC News Online 2015 Understanding Amnesty in South Africa: What Really Happened at the TRC? https://social.shorthand.com/SABCNews
Online/nyCsx09gnf/understanding-amnesty-in-south-africa accessed 19 April 2021
Steflja I 2012 Challenges of Transitional Justice in Rwanda https://www.africaportal.org/publications/challenges-of-transitional-justice-in-rwanda/ accessed 25 April 2021
United Nations International Commission of Inquiry on Darfur 2005 Report of the International Commission of Inquiry on Darfur to the United Nations Secretary-General https://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/D2867CFA4E80B979C1256FC4005209FC-ici-sud-25feb.pdf accessed 28 April 2021
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Derrick T Cho
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}