No Country for Old Women: A Critique of Grobler v Phillips 2023 1 SA 321 (CC)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2023/v26i0a16342Keywords:
Access to Land, evictions, ESTA Occupiers, Jurisprudence, constitutional property law, PIEAbstract
Land and land rights remain a contested issue in South Africa. Grobler v Phillips centered on the eviction of an 86-year-old woman, Mrs Phillips, and her disabled son from property she had lived on since she was 11 years old. After a fourteen-year court battle the Constitutional Court granted an eviction order against Mrs Phillips. This case note consists of a discussion of the judgments of the Magistrate's Court, High Court, Supreme Court of Appeal and Constitutional Court. It is found that the Constitutional Court erred in its decision as it applied a formalistic approach, disregarded the narrative of the occupier and did not sufficiently challenge the current neo-liberal regime in which property rights operate.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Bell J and Matthews S "Dependency, Paternalism and Financial Control of Women on South African Wine Farms" 2022 Gender Questions 1-16 DOI: https://doi.org/10.25159/2412-8457/10874
Boggenpoel ZT "Property and Access: Inequality of Land Relations and the Continued Vulnerability of Women" 2023 SALJ 387-412 DOI: https://doi.org/10.47348/SALJ/v140/i2a6
Bonner P "South African Society and Culture, 1910-1948" in Ross R, Mager A and Nasson B (eds) The Cambridge History of South Africa (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2011) 254-318 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521869836.008
Bourdeaux K "Land Reform as Social Justice: The Case of South Africa" 2010 Economic Affairs 13-20 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0270.2009.01967.x
Brandt and Ncapayi 2016 Anthropolgy Southern Africa
Brandt F and Ncapayi F "The Meaning of Compliance with Land and Labour Legislation: Understanding Justice through Farm Workers' Experience in the Eastern Cape" 2016 Anthropolgy Southern Africa 215-231 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23323256.2016.1211020
Cheru F "Overcoming Apartheid's Legacy: The Ascendancy of Neoliberalism in South Africa's Anti-Poverty Strategy" 2001 TWQ 505-527 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01436590120071768
Department of Land Affairs White Paper on South African Land Policy (Department of Land Affairs Pretoria 1997)
Devereux S "Violations of Farm Workers' Labour Rights in Post-Apartheid South Africa" 2019 Development Southern Africa 382-404 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0376835X.2019.1609909
Du Plessis W and Pienaar J "The More Things Change, the More They Stay the Same: The Story of Communal Land Tenure in South Africa" 2010 Fundamina: A Journal of Legal History 73-114
Du Toit AD "The Micro-Politics of Paternalism: The Discourse of Management and Resistance on South African Fruit and Wine Farms" 1993 Journal of Southern African Studies 314-336 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03057079308708362
Evans L "Gender, Generation and the Experiences of Farm Dwellers Resettled in the Ciskei Bantustan, South Africa, ca 1960-1976" 2013 Journal of Agrarian Change 213-233 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-0366.2012.00369.x
Fourie D "The Neoliberal Influence on South Africa's Early Democracy and Its Shortfalls in Addressing Economic Inequality" 2022 Philosophy and Social Criticism 1-22 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/01914537221079674
Hall R et al "Farm Workers and Farm Dwellers in Limpopo Province, South Africa" 2013 Journal of Agragrian Change 47-70 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/joac.12002
Hawthorne L "Legal Tradition and the Transformation of Orthodox Contract Theory: The Movement from Formalism to Realism" 2006 Fundamina: A Journal of Legal History 71-86
Hoexter C "Courageous Creativity and Anti-Formalism in Administrative Law: Notable Contributions from the Jurisprudence of Johan Froneman" 2022 CCR 121-136 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2989/CCR.2022.0005
Klare KE "Legal Culture and Transformative Constitutionalism" 1998 SAJHR 146-188 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.1998.11834974
Kloppers HJ and Pienaar GJ "The Historical Context of Land Reform in South Africa and Early Policies" 2014 PELJ 677-706 DOI: https://doi.org/10.4314/pelj.v17i2.03
Lemke S and Jansen van Rensburg F "Remaining at the Margins: Case Study of Farm Workers in the North-West Province, South Africa" 2014 Development Southern Africa 843-858 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0376835X.2014.951990
Magidimisha HH and Chipungu L Spatial Planning in Service Delivery (Palgrave Macmillan Cham 2019) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-19850-3
McCusker B, Moseley WG and Ramutsindela M Land Reform in South Africa: An Uneven Transformation (Rowman and Littlefield Lanham 2016)
Mntungwa D The Impact of Land Legislation on Farm Dweller Evictions (MA-dissertation University of the Witwatersrand 2014)
Muller G "The Legal-Historical Context of Urban Forced Evictions in South Africa" 2013 Fundamina: A Journal of Legal History 367-396
Narsiah S "Neoliberalism and Privatization in South Africa" 2002 GeoJournal 29-38
Nattrass G A Short History of South Africa (Johnathan Ball Johannesburg 2019)
Nolan PJ Paternalism and Law: The Micro-Politics of Farm Workers' Evictions and Rural Activism in the Western Cape of South Africa (LLD-thesis University of Edinburg 2007)
Ntsebeza L and Hall R The Land Question in South Africa: The Challenge of Transformation and Redistribution (Pretoria HSRC Press 2007)
Orton L, Barrientos S and Mcclenaghan S "Paternalism and Gender in South African Fruit Employment: Change and Continuity" 2001 Women's Studies International Forum 469-478 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0277-5395(01)00166-2
Peet R "Ideology, Discourse, and the Geography of Hegemony: From Socialist to Neoliberal Development in Postapartheid South Africa" 2002 Antipode 54-84 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8330.00226
Pienaar J Land Reform (Juta Cape Town 2014)
Pienaar J "'Unlawful Occupier' in Perspective: History, Legislation and Case Law" in Mostert H and De Waal MJ (eds) Essays in Honour of CG van der Merwe (LexisNexis Durban 2011) 309-329
Pienaar J "Farm Workers: Extending Security of Renure in terms of Recent Legislation" 1998 SAPL 423-437
Pienaar J "Land Reform Embedded in the Constitution: Legal Constextualisation" 2015 Scriptura 1-20 DOI: https://doi.org/10.7833/114-0-1116
Quinot G "Substantive Reasoning in Administrative-Law Adjudication" 2010 CCR 111-139 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2989/CCR/2010.0005
Roodt M "Security of Tenure and Livelihood Options in South Africa: A Case Study of a Rural Community Facing Eviction under Post-Apartheid Legislation in the Eastern Cape Province" 2007 Africanus 3-12
Ross R A Concise History of South Africa (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2008) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511805806
Rugege S "Land Reform in South Africa: An Overview" 2004 Int'l J Legal Info 283-312 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0731126500004145
Sibanda S "Not Purpose-Made! Transformative Constitutionalism, Post-Independence Constitutionalism and the Struggle to Eradicate Poverty" 2011 Stell LR 482-500
Spierenburg M "Living on Other People's Land; Impacts of Farm Conversations to Game Farming on Farm Dwellers' Abilities to Access Land in the Eastern Cape, South Africa" 2020 Society and Natural Resources 280-299 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/08941920.2019.1584342
Van der Sjide E "Tenure Security for ESTA Occupiers: Building on the Obiter Remarks in Baron v Claytile Limited" 2020 SAJHR 74-92 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.2020.1773308
Van der Walt AJ Property in the Margins (Bloomsburg Oxford 2009) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195391572.003.004
Waldman L "Monkey in a Spiderweb: The Dynamics of Farmer Control and Paternalism" 1996 African Studies 62-86 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00020189608707840
Walters H "The Burden of Responsibility and the Breakdown of Traditional Paternalism on Farms in the Western Cape" 2012 Anthropology Southern Africa 91-99 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23323256.2012.11500028
Wegerif M, Russell B and Grundling I Still Searching for Security: The Reality of Farm Dweller Evictions in South Africa (Nkuzi Development Association Polokwane 2005)
Williams G "Slaves, Workers, and Wine: The 'Dop System' in the History of the Cape Wine Industry, 1658-1894" 2016 Journal of Southern African Studies 893-909 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03057070.2016.1234120
Case law
Daniels v Scribante 2017 4 SA 341 (CC) DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351179270-11
Department of Land Affairs v Goedgelegen Tropical Fruits 2007 6 SA 199 (CC)
Grobler v Phillips 2023 1 SA 321 (CC)
Grobler v Phillips (446/2020) [2021] ZASCA 100 (14 July 2021)
Klaase v Van der Merwe 2016 6 SA 131 (CC)
Mahlangu v Nkosi (43615/21) [2023] ZAGPPHC 120 (23 February 2023)
Molusi v Voges 2016 3 SA 370 (CC)
Oranje v Rouxlandia Investments 2019 3 SA 108 (SCA)
PE Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)
Snyders v De Jager 2017 3 SA 545 (CC)
Legislation
Abolition of Racially Based Land Measures Act 108 of 1991
Communal Property Association Act 28 of 1996
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Distribution and Transfer of Certain State Land Act 119 of 1993
Extension of the Security of Tenure Act 62 of 1997
Group Areas Act 36 of 1966
Group Areas Act 41 of 1950
Group Areas Act 77 of 1957
Interim Protection of Informal Land Rights Act 31 of 1996
Land Reform (Labour Tenants) Act 3 of 1996
Land Restitution and Reform Laws Amendment Act 78 of 1996
Land Titles Adjustment Act 111 of 1993
Native Trust and Land Act 18 of 1936
Natives Land Act 27 of 1913
Natives Urban Areas Act 21 of 1923
Pegging Act 35 of 1943
Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998
Prevention of Illegal Squatting Act 52 of 1951
Provision of Land and Assistance Act 126 of 1993
Rural Areas Amendment Act 112 of 1993
Upgrading of Land Tenure Rights Amendment Act 34 of 1996
Internet sources
Advisory Panel on Land Reform and Agriculture 2019 Final Report of the Presidential Advisory Panel on Land Reform and Agriculture https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201907/panelreportlandreform_1.pdf accessed 21 September 2023
Atkinson D, Pienaar D and Zingel J 2004 "From on Farm to Own Farm?" The Role of Farm Worker Unions in Land Reform in South Africa http://www.aridareas.co.za/wpcontent/uploads/2015/Papers/Atkinson%20D%20%20Pienaar%20D%20%20Zingel%20J%20-20From%20on%20 Farm%20to%20Own%20Farm.pdf accessed 14 June 2023
Cousins B 2016 Land Reform in South Africa is Sinking. Can It be Saved? https://www.nelsonmandela.org/uploads/files/Land__law_and_leadership_-_paper_2.pdf accessed 14 June 2023
Cowling M, Hornby D and Oettle L 2017 Tenure Security of Labour Tenants and Former Labour Tenants in South Africa https://www.parliament.gov.za/ storage/app/media/Pages/2017/october/High_Level_Panel/Commissioned_Report_land/
Commissioned_Report_on_Tenure_Security_AFRA.pdf accessed 14 June 2023
Devereux S and Solomon C 2011 Shooting the Messenger: Controversy over Farmworker Conditions in South Africa https://www.future-agricultures.org/themes/growth-and-social-protection/shooting-the-messenger-controversy-over-farmworker-conditions-in-south-africa/ accessed 21 September 2023
Hall 2003 https://repository.uwc.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10566/4422/ elarsa_op_2_rural_restitution.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
https://repository.uwc.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10566/4422/elarsa_op_2_rural_restitution.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y accessed 14 June 2023
Hall R, Kleinbooi K and Mvambo N 2002 What Land Reform has Meant and Could Mean to Farm Workers in South Acrica http://mokoro.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/what_land_reform_has_meant_to_farm_workers_sa.pdf accessed 14 June 2023
High Level Panel 2017 Report of the High Level Panel on the Assessment of Key Legislation and the Acceleration of Fundamental Change https://www.parliament.gov.za/storage/app/media/Pages/2017/october/High_Level_Panel/HLP_Report/HLP_report.pdf accessed 2 October 2023
Nkuzi Development Association and Social Surveys 2005 Summary of Key Findings from the National Evictions Survey https://sarpn.org/documents/ d0001822/Nkuzi_Eviction_NES_2005.pdf accessed 4 October 2023
South African Government date unknown Land Reform https://www.gov.za/issues/land-reform accessed 21 September 2023
Walker C 2017 The Land Question in South Africa: 1913 and Beyond https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190277734.013.79 accessed 21 September 2023 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190277734.013.79
Williams G 1996 Transforming Labour Tenants https://www.gavinwilliams. org/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/1996-Transforming-Labour-Tenants-Gavin-Williams1.pdf accessed 14 June 2023
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Allison Geduld
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}