The Concept of Social Justice in Mine-Host Community Involvement and Benefit Accrual: Reflections from Mineral Extraction in Zimbabwe
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2024/v27i0a16617Keywords:
Minerals, social justice, distributive justice, procedural justice, remedial justice, mine-host communities, involvement, benefit accrual, ZimbabweAbstract
Minerals play a vital role in societal and economic growth. As finite and non-renewable resources, minerals inevitably diminish upon extraction. Consequently, there is an expectation that the extraction process should involve and benefit the local communities hosting these resources. Despite expectations of benefitting local communities, mineral extraction often results in more economic, social, and environmental burdens than advantages for them. This contribution is centred on a theoretical inquiry, employing the concept of social justice to explore and mitigate the disparities in the distribution of costs and benefits experienced by mine-host communities. It aims to balance the inequities, emphasising the principles of distributive, procedural and remedial justice to reconcile the losses and gains in a fair and equitable manner
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Adler MD "Corrective Justice and Liability for Global Warming" 2007 U Pa L Rev 1859-1867
Albertyn C "Contested Substantive Equality in the South African Constitution: Beyond Social Inclusion Towards Systemic Justice" 2018 SAJHR 441-468 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.2018.1550938
Anderson ES "What is the Point of Equality?" 1999 Ethics 287-337 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/233897
Anon "Minerals and Location Found in Zimbabwe" 2023 Mining Zimbabwe 48-49
Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics (transl David Ross) (Oxford University Press London 1954)
Arneson RJ "Rawls, Responsibility, and Distributive Justice" in Salles M and Weymark JA (eds) Justice, Political Liberalism, and Utilitarianism: Themes from Harsanyi (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2007) 80-107 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511619595.004
Bennett T Pasts Beyond Memory: Evolution Museums Colonialism (Routledge London 2004) DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203647066
Bentham J An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (eds Bums JH and Hart HLA) (Athlone Press London 1970)
Bhatasara S "Black Granite Mining and the Implications for the Development of Sustainability in Zimbabwe: The Case of Mutoko Communities" 2013 Environment, Development and Sustainability 1527-1541 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-013-9456-y
Bilchitz D "Judicial Remedies and Socio-Economic Rights: A Response to Christopher Mbazira" 2008 ESR Review 9-12
Buyse AC "Lost and Regained? Restitution as a Remedy for Human Rights Violations in the Context of International Law" 2008 Heidelberg Journal of International Law 129-153
Carter A The Philosophical Foundations of Property Rights (Harvester, Wheatsheaf London 1989)
Chaskalson A "From Wickedness to Equality: The Moral Transformation of South African Law" 2003 ICON 590-609 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/1.4.590
Du Plessis WJE "The Usefulness of Michelman's Utilitarian Approach to Compensation for Expropriation in South Africa" 2013 Stell LR 359-376 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2381892
Dworkin R Freedom's Law: The Moral Reading of the American Constitution (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1996)
Dworkin R "Hypothetical Contracts and Rights" in Sterba JP (ed) Justice: Alternative Political Perspectives (Wadsworth Belmont 1992) 145-158
Dworkin R Sovereign Virtue: The Theory and Practice of Equality (Harvard University Press Cambridge 2000)
Dworkin R Taking Rights Seriously (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1977)
Ebbesson J "Introduction: Dimensions of Justice in Environmental Law" in Ebbesson J and Okowa P Environmental Law and Justice in Context (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2009) 1-36 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511576027.002
Fraser N "Social Justice in the Age of Identity Politics: Redistribution, Recognition and Participation" in Fraser N and Honneth A (eds) Redistribution or Recognition: A Political-Philosophical Exchange (Verso London 2003) 7-109
George H Progress and Poverty (Robert Schalkenbach Foundation New York 1879)
Gibson JL "Group Identities and Theories of Justice: An Experimental Investigation into the Justice and Injustice of Land Squatting in South Africa" 2008 Journal of Politics 700-716 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022381608080705
Greenberg M "Proving Environmental Inequity in Siting Locally Unwanted Land Uses" 1993 Risk: Health Safety and Environment 236-252
Hare RM "Justice and Equality" in Sterba JP (ed) Justice: Alternative Political Perspectives (Wadsworth Belmont 1992) 185-199
Hart HLA The Concept of Law (Oxford University Press Oxford 1961)
Heyns A "Mining Community Development in South Africa: A Critical Consideration of How the Law and Development Approach the Concept "Community" 2019 Law and Development Review 561-593 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/ldr-2019-0022
Heyman SJ "Aristotle on Political Justice" 1992 Iowa L Rev 851-863
Hooft VP "The Theory of Justice and our Obligations towards Future Generations" 1987 Archives for Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy 30-36
Humby T "The Community Preferent Right to Prospect or Mine: Navigating the Faultlines of Community, Land, Benefit and Development in Bengwenyama II" 2016 SALJ 316-351
Humphreys M, Sachs JD and Stiglitz JE Escaping the Resource Curse (Columbia University Press New York 2007)
Kuehn R "A Taxonomy of Environmental Justice" 2000 Env't L Rep 10681-10703
Langton M and Mazel O "Poverty in the Midst of Plenty: Aboriginal People, the 'Resource Curse' and Australia's Mining Boom" 2003 Journal of Energy and Natural Resources Law 31-65 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02646811.2008.11435177
Liebenberg S "Toward an Equality-Promoting Interpretation of Socio-Economic Rights in South Africa: Insights from the Egalitarian Liberal Tradition" 2015 SALJ 411-437
Locke J The Second Treatise of Government (ed Peardon TP) (Liberal Arts Press New York 1952)
Madonsela T "Social Justice Transcending Inequalities" 2020 Global Governance 1-20 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/19426720-02601008
Maguire R and Lewis B "The Influence of Justice Theories on International Climate Policies and Measures" 2012 Macquarie Journal of International and Comparative Environmental Law 16-35
Marx KE Critique of the Gotha Program (Progress Publishers Moscow 1970)
Mashaw JL Due Process in the Administrative State (Yale University Press New Haven 1985)
Mill JS Utilitarianism (Parker, Son and Bourn London 1863)
Miller D "Recent Theories of Social Justice" 1991 British Journal of Political Science 371-391 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007123400006207
Miller D Principles of Social Justice (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1999)
Millon DK "Theories of the Corporation" 1990 Duke LJ 201-262 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1372611
Murombo T "Law and the Indigenisation of Mineral Resources in Zimbabwe: Any Equity for Local Communities?" 2010 SAPL 568-589
Murombo T "Regulating Mining in South Africa and Zimbabwe: Communities, the Environment and Perpetual Exploitation" 2013 LEAD 31-49
Nickel JW "Preferential Policies in Hiring and Admissions: A Jurisprudential Approach" 1975 Colum L Rev 534-558 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1121772
Nielsen K Equality and Liberty (Rowman and Alanheld Totowa 1985)
Nkongolo JK "Improving Mineral Governance through a Fundamental Rights Approach to Community Participation: The Africa Charter of Human and People's Rights as the Legal Basis" 2014 African Journal of Democracy and Governance 81-99
Nnajiofor O and Ifeakor C "Robert Nozick's Entitlement Theory of Justice: A Critique" 2016 Ogirisi: A New Journal of African Studies 170-183 DOI: https://doi.org/10.4314/og.v12i1.8
Nozick R Anarchy, State and Utopia (Basic Books New York 1974)
Okharedia AA "Aristotle and the South African Constitution: The Presence of the Past" 2005 Phronimon 1-14
Palmer D Looking at Philosophy: The Unbearable Heaviness of Philosophy Made Lighter 4th ed (McGraw-Hill Higher Education Boston 2006)
Rawls J Justice as Fairness: A Restatement (Harvard University Press Cambridge 2001) DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv31xf5v0
Rawls J Political Liberalism (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1996)
Rawls J A Theory of Justice (Oxford University Press London 1971) DOI: https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674042605
Rawls J A Theory of Justice Rev ed (Oxford University Press London 1999) DOI: https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674042582
Robinson L and Reeser C Ethical Decision-Making in Social Work (Allyn and Bacon New York 2000)
Rodes RE "Social Justice and Liberation" 1996 Notre Dame L Rev 619-629
Sachs JD and Warner AM "The Curse of Natural Resources" 2001 European Economic Review 827-838 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0014-2921(01)00125-8
Sadurski "Law's Legitimacy and 'Democracy-Plus'" 2006 OJLS 377-399 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.937833
Schlosberg D "Reconceiving Environmental Justice: Global Movements and Political Theories" 2004 Environmental Politics 517-540 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0964401042000229025
Schrader-Frechette K Environmental Justice: Creating Equality, Reclaiming Democracy (Oxford University Press New York 2002) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/0195152034.001.0001
Schwartz J "From Libertarianism to Egalitarianism" 1992 Social Theory and Practice 259-288 DOI: https://doi.org/10.5840/soctheorpract199218311
Sen A "The Possibility of Social Choice" 1999 American Economic Review 349-378 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.89.3.349
Sen A Development as Freedom (Oxford University Press New York 1999)
Sen A The Idea of Justice (Harvard University Press Cambridge 2009) DOI: https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674054578
Shelton D "Describing the Elephant: International Justice and Environmental Law" in Ebbesson J and Okowa P (eds) Environmental Law and Justice in Context (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2009) 55-75 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511576027.004
Sidgwick H The Methods of Ethics (Dover New York 1966)
Singer P The Expanding Circle: Ethics, Evolution, and Moral Progress (Princeton University Press Princeton 1981)
Solum 2004 S Cal L Rev
Solum LB "Procedural Justice" 2004 S Cal L Rev 181-322 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.508282
Swat M "Apartheid Reparations: In Search of an Appropriate Remedial Theory" 2013 SAPL 73-90
Taylor V "Social Justice: Reframing the 'Social' in Critical Discourses in Africa" in De Coninck J, Culp J and Taylor V African Perspectives on Social Justice (Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung Kampala 2013) 12-25
Tyler T "Obeying the Law in America: Procedural Justice and the Sense of Fairness" 2001 Issues of Democracy 16-21
Tyler TR and Mentovich A Mechanisms of Legal Effect: Theories of Procedural Justice (Robert Wood Johnson Foundation New York 2011)
United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Social Justice in an Open World: The Role of the United Nations (UN New York 2006)
Van der Ploeg F "Natural Resources: Curse or Blessing?" 2011 Journal of Economic Literature 366-420 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/jel.49.2.366
Van Soest D "Strange Bedfellows: A Call for Reordering National Priorities from Three Social Justice Perspectives" 1994 Social Work 710-717
Vanclay F "Project-Induced Displacement and Resettlement: From Impoverishment Risks to an Opportunity for Development?" 2017 Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 3-21 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14615517.2017.1278671
Young I Justice and the Politics of Difference (Princeton University Press Princeton 1990)
Case law
African Human Rights System
African Commission of Human and Peoples' Rights v The Republic of Kenya App No 006/2012 (26 May 2017)
African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights v Republic of Kenya App No 006/2012 (Judgment (Reparations) of 23 June 2022)
Centre for Minority Rights Development (Kenya) and Minority Rights Group International on behalf of Endorois Welfare Council v The Republic of Kenya ACHPR Comm No 276/2003 (2010)
Social and Economic Rights Action Center and the Center for Economic and Social Rights v Nigeria ACHPR Com No 155/96 (2001) DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3070689
Permanent Court of International Justice
The Factory at Chorzow (Germany v Poland) (Merits, Judgment of 13 September 1928) [1928] PCIJ Rep Series A, No 17
South Africa
Allpay Consolidated Investment Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Chief Executive Officer, South African Social Security Agency 2014 1 SA 604 (CC)
Baleni v Minister of Mineral Resources 2019 2 SA 453 (GP)
City of Johanesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Blue Moonlight Properties Ltd 39 (Pty) 2012 2 BCRL 150 (CC)
Doctors for Life International v Speaker of the National Assembly 2006 6 SA 416 (CC)
Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (CC)
Haakdoornbult Boerdery CC v Mphela 2007 5 SA 596 (SCA)
Occupiers of 51 Olivia Road, Berea Township and 197 Main Street, Johannesburg v City of Johannesburg 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)
President of the Republic of South Africa v Hugo 1997 4 SA 197 (CC)
Soobramoney v Minister of Health, Kwazulu-Natal 1997 12 BCLR 1691 (CC)
Sustaining the Wild Coast v Minister of Mineral Resources 2022 1 All SA 796 (ECG) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/bhj.2023.26
Zimbabwe
Chikutu v Minister of Lands HH 02/2022 (2022)
Malvern Mudiwa v Mbada Mining Private Limited HC 6334/09 (2009)
Legislation
South Africa
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Marine Living Resources Act 18 of 1998
Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act 28 of 2002
Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000
Zimbabwe
Constitution of Zimbabwe Amendment (No 20) Act, 2013
Finance Act 1 of 2018
Finance Act 2 of 2020
Mines and Minerals Act 38 of 1961
International instruments
African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights (1981)
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966)
Internet sources
African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights 2005 Report of the African Commission's Working Group of Experts on Indigenous Populations/Communities https://iwgia.org/images/publications/African_Commission_book.pdf accessed 26 January 2024
Andre C and Velasquez M 1989 Calculating the Consequences: The Utilitarian Approach to Ethics https://www.scu.edu/mcae/publications/iie/v2n1/calculating.html accessed 26 January 2024
Centre for Natural Resource Governance 2021 Zimbabwe: Dinde Community Fights to Stop Coal Mining Project http://www.minesand
communities.org/article.php?a=14501 accessed 26 January 2024
Chamber of Mines of Zimbabwe 2022 Annual Report 2022 https://chamines.co.zw/assets/uploads/2023/application/3bb36313-f1fc-470d-81fe-dd628d9a2694.pdf accessed 26 January 2024
Chimonyo GR, Mangure S and Scott PD 2012 The Social, Economic and Environmental Implications of Diamond Mining in Chiadzwa https://www.readkong.com/page/the-social-economic-and-environmental-implications-of-1059367 accessed 26 January 2024
Chipkin I and Meny-Gibert S 2013 Understanding the Social Justice Sector in South Africa https://kipdf.com/queue/understanding-the-social-justice-sector-in-south-africa accessed 26 January 2024Department of Mineral Resources 2009 https://www.gov.za/sites/default/
files/gcis_document/201409/miningcharterimpact.pdf
Department of Mineral Resources 2009 Mining Charter Impact Assessment Report https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201409/miningcharterimpact.pdf accessed 26 January 2024
Human Rights Watch 2016 "They Destroyed Everything": Mining and Human Rights in Malawi https://www.hrw.org/report/2016/09/27/they-destroyed-everything/mining-and-human-rights-malawi accessed 26 January 2024
Minister of Finance and Economic Development 2016 The 2016 National Budget Statement https://www.veritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/2016%20%20Budget%20Statement.pdf accessed 26 January 2024
Ministry of Finance, Economic Development and Investment Promotion 2023 2024 Budget Statement https://parlzim.gov.zw/download/2024-budget-statement/ accessed 26 January 2024
Portfolio Committee on Mines and Energy 2013 First Report of the Portfolio Committee on Mines and Energy on Diamond Mining (with Special Reference to Marange Diamond Fields 2009-2013) https://veritaszim.net/node/1633 accessed 26 January 2024
Portfolio Committee on Mines and Energy 2018 Second Report of the Portfolio Committee on Mines and Energy on the Diamond Sector in Zimbabwe for the Period 2009-2016 https://parlzim.gov.zw/download/
second-report-on-mines-energy-on-the-diamond-sector-in-zimbabwe-2009-2016/ accessed 26 January 2024
Portfolio Committee on Mines and Mining Development 2022 Report of the Portfolio Committee on Mines and Mining Development on a Self-Assessment of the Diamond Sector in Zimbabwe Fourth Session, Ninth Parliament April 2022 https://www.veritaszim.net/node/5665 accessed 26 January 2024
Republic of Zimbabwe 2020 National Development Strategy 1 (2021-2025) https://www.veritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/NDS.pdf accessed 26 January 2024
Shookner M 2002 An Inclusion Lens: Workbook for Looking at Social and Economic Exclusion and Inclusion https://www.allianceon.org/sites/default/
files/documents/Workbook%20for%20looking%20at%20Social_and_Economic_Inclusion_Lens%202002.pdf accessed 26 January 2024
United States Geological Survey 2022 Mineral Commodity Summaries https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2022/mcs2022.pdf accessed 26 January 2024
World Platinum Investment Council 2023 Platinum Supply http://www.platinuminvestment.com/investment-research/articles accessed 26 January 2024
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Stanford Chagadama, Prof Germarie Viljoen
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}