Restorative Justice as an Alternative Response to Student Academic Dishonesty in South African Higher Education Institutions
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2024/v27i0a16784Keywords:
Academic dishonesty, punitive approach, punitive measures, expulsion, suspension, restorative justice, institution, community, apologyAbstract
Academic dishonesty among students is a persistent problem in higher education institutions throughout the world, including in South Africa. The traditional methods of dealing with academic dishonesty have not succeeded in curtailing the rise of this phenomenon. Dissatisfied with the methods, some countries have started searching for other ways of responding to academic dishonesty. One such way is restorative justice, which is not a new phenomenon in the history of dealing with disciplinary problems in the education environment. International research shows its potential to enhance academic honesty among students. This article examines restorative justice as an alternative method of dealing with student academic dishonesty in South African higher education institutions. After reviewing the literature the article concludes firstly that restorative justice can reduce academic dishonesty, and secondly, that restorative justice can inculcate a good behaviour among students. The article recommends that restorative justice be adopted as one of measures to deal with academic dishonesty in South African higher education institutions.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Allan A et al "Apology in Restorative and Juvenile Justice" 2014 Psychiatry, Psychology and Law 176-190
Anderman EM and Koenka AC "The Relation between Academic Motivation and Cheating" 2017 Theory into Practice 95-102
Ballantine JA, McCourt Larres P and Mulgrew M "Determinants of Academic Cheating Behavior: The Future for Accountancy in Ireland" 2014 Accounting Forum 55-66
Barnett RE "Restitution: A New Paradigm of Criminal Justice" in Johnstone G (ed) A Restorative Justice Reader 2nd ed (Routledge New York 2013) 47-56
Batley M "Restorative Justice in South Africa" in Peacock R (ed) Victimology in South Africa 2nd ed (Van Schaik Pretoria 2013) 115-128
Bekker JC and Van der Merwe A "Indigenous Legal Systems and Sentencing: S v Maluleke 2008 1 SACR 49 (T)" 2009 De Jure 239-250
Bidois LM "The Value of Restorative Justice" 2016 CLB 596-613
Booth T, Stuhmcke A and Wangmann J "There is Plagiarism … and then there is Plagiarism: Academic Misconduct and Admission to Legal Practice" 2020 IJLP 291-316
Bosch T et al "South African University Students' Use of AI-Powered Tools for Engaged Learning" 2023 SSRN Electronic Journal 1-16
Braithwaite J "Shame and Criminal Justice" 2000 Can J Crim 281-298
Clark KL "A Call for Restorative Justice in Higher Education Judicial Affairs" 2014 Student College Journal 707-715
Darling-Hammond S et al "Effectiveness of Restorative Justice in US K-12 Schools: A Review of Quantitative Research" 2020 Contemporary School Psychology 295-308
De Bruin GP and Rudnick H "Examining the Cheats: The Role of Conscientiousness and Excitement Seeking in Academic Dishonesty" 2007 South African Journal of Psychology 153-164
Department of Justice and Constitutional Development Restorative Justice: The Road to Healing (The Department Pretoria 2011)
Diego LAB "Friends with Benefits: Causes and Effects of Learners' Cheating Practices during Examination" 2017 IAFOR Journal of Education 121-138
Dzur AW and Olson SM "The Value of Community Participation in Restorative Justice" 2004 Journal of Social Philosophy 91-107
Erguvan ID "University Students' Understanding of Contract Cheating: A Qualitative Case Study in Kuwait" 2022 Language Testing in Asia 1-19
Fronius T et al Restorative Justice in US Schools: An Updated Research Review (The WestEd Justice and Prevention Research Center San Francisco 2019)
Gade CBN "Is Restorative Justice Punishment?" 2021 Conflict Resolution Quarterly 127-155
Harris N and Maruna S "Shame, Shaming and Restorative Justice: A Critical Appraisal" in Sullivan D and Tifft L (eds) Handbook of Restorative Justice: A Global Perspective (Routledge London 2006) 452-462
Hayes H "Apologies and Accounts in Youth Justice Conferencing: Reinterpreting Research Outcomes" 2006 Contemporary Justice Review 369-385
Ikpa TS "Balancing Restorative Justice Principles and Due Process Rights in Order to Reform the Criminal Justice System" 2007 Wash U J L & Pol'y 301-326
Janosik SM and Stimpson MT "The Influence of the Conduct System and Campus Environments on Student Learning" 2017 Journal of Student Affairs Research and Practice 28-41
Johnstone G Restorative Justice: Ideas, Values, Debates (Willan Publishing Devon 2002)
Kara F and MacAlister D "Responding to Academic Dishonesty in Universities: A Restorative Justice Approach" 2010 Contemporary Justice Review 443-453
Karp DR and Breslin B "Restorative Justice in School Communities" 2001 Youth and Society 249-272
Karp D and Conrad S "Restorative Justice and College Student Misconduct" 2005 Public Organization Review 315-333
Kgosimore DL "Restorative Justice as an Alternative Way of Dealing with Crime" 2002 Acta Criminologica 69-76
Kwong T et al "Students' and Faculty's Perception of Academic Integrity in Hong Kong" 2010 Campus-Wide Information Systems 341-355
Levrant S et al "Reconsidering Restorative Justice: The Corruption of Benevolence Revisited?" 1999 Crime and Delinquency 3-27
Louw D and Van Wyk L "The Perspectives of South African Legal Professionals on Restorative Justice: An Explorative Qualitative Study" 2016 Social Work 489-510
Makiwane PN "Restorative Justice: Bringing Justice for Crime Victims?" 2015 Obiter 79-94
Malik MA "Studying the Effect of Cognitive Difficulty of Students on their Academic Achievement" 2019 IAHRW International Journal of Social Sciences 1896-1899
Marais IE "Institutionalisation of Academic Integrity: Experiences at a Distance Education University in South Africa During COVID-19" 2022 Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning 57-79
Matsebatlela E and Kuhudzai AG "Attitudes toward Plagiarism: The Case of Undergraduate Health Sciences Students at the University of Pretoria" 2018 Alternation 181-209
McCold P "What is the Role of Community in Restorative Justice Theory and Practice?" in Zehr H and Toews B (eds) Critical Issues in Restorative Justice (Willan Publishing Devon 2004) 155-171
Metz T "Ubuntu as a Moral Theory and Human Rights in South Africa" 2011 AHRLJ 532-559
Meyer LH and Evans IM The School Leader's Guide to Restorative School Discipline (Corwin Thousand Oaks 2012)
Ministry of Justice Restorative Justice: Best Practice Framework (Ministry of Justice Wellington 2017)
Miron J et al "Academic Integrity Policy Analysis of Publicly-Funded Universities in Ontario, Canada: A Focus on Contract Cheating" 2021 CJEAP 62-75
Morrison B "Bullying and Victimisation in Schools: A Restorative Justice Approach" 2002 Trends and Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice 1-6
Morrison B "School Bullying and Restorative Justice: Toward a Theoretical Understanding of the Role of Respect, Pride, and Shame" 2006 Journal of Social Issues 371-392
Mousourakis G "Understanding and Implementing Restorative Justice" 2003 Tilburg Foreign L Rev 626-652
Mulisa F and Ebessa SD "The Carryover Effects of College Dishonesty on the Professional Workplace Dishonest Behaviors: A Systematic Review" 2021 Cogent Education 1-28
Mwamwenda TS "Academic Integrity: South African and American University Students" 2006 Journal of Independent Teaching and Learning 34-44
Nonis S and Swift CO "An Examination of the Relationship between Academic Dishonesty and Workplace Multicampus Investigation" 2001 Journal of Education for Business 69-77
Orr JE and Orr K "Restoring Honor and Integrity through Integrating Restorative Practices in Academic Integrity with Student Leaders" 2021 Journal of Academic Ethics 1-17
Peled Y, Barczyk CC and Sarid M "Institutional Policies and Faculty Perceptions of Student Academic Dishonesty" 2012 Educational Practice and Theory 61-79
Pointer L "Building a Restorative University" 2017 JANZSSA 63-70
Radulovic U and Uys T "Academic Dishonesty and Whistle‑Blowing in a Higher Education Institution: A Sociological Analysis" 2019 African Journal of Business Ethics 16-41
Reyneke RP "A Restorative Justice Approach to Address Cyber Bullying" in Kowalczuk-Walêdziak M et al (eds) Rethinking Teacher Education for the 21st Century: Trends, Challenges and New Directions (Verlag Barbara Budrich Berlin 2019) 340-354
Reyneke M "The Right to Dignity and Restorative Justice in Schools" 2011 PELJ 129-171
Riad J "Academic Dishonesty in Higher Education: What We Know and What We Can Do" 2023 Journal of Research Initiatives 1-11
Roe J "Reconceptualizing Academic Dishonesty as a Struggle for Intersubjective Recognition: A New Theoretical Model" 2022 Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 1-7
Schmid DJ "Restorative Justice: A New Paradigm for Criminal Justice Policy" 2002 VUWLR 91-134a
Shapoval RV et al "Academic Honesty: Current Status and Forms of Improvement" 2021 Justicia 37-46
Shi Y and Qu S "The Effect of Cognitive Ability on Academic Achievement: The Mediating Role of Self-Discipline and the Moderating Role of Planning" 2022 Frontiers in Psychology 1-18
Sibomana E, Ndayambaje I and Uwambayinema E "Plagiarism in Higher Education Environment: Causes and Solutions" 2018 Rwandan Journal of Education 15-23
Sliva SM and Lambert CG "Restorative Justice Legislation in the American States: A Statutory Analysis of Emerging Legal Doctrine" 2015 Journal of Policy Practice 77-95
Skelton A "Tapping Indigenous Knowledge: Traditional Conflict Resolution, Restorative Justice and the Denunciation of Crime in South Africa" 2007 Acta Juridica 228-246
Skelton A "The South African Constitutional Court's Restorative Justice Jurisprudence" 2013 Restorative Justice: An International Journal 122-145
Sopcak P and Hood K "Building a Culture of Restorative Practice and Restorative Responses to Academic Misconduct'' in Eaton SE and Hughes JC (eds) Academic Integrity in Canada: An Enduring and Essential Challenge (Springer Cham 2022) 553-571
Söylemez NH "A Problem in Higher Education: Academic Dishonesty Tendency" 2023 Bulletin of Education and Research 23-46
Starovoytova D and Namango S "Factors Affecting Cheating-Behavior at Undergraduate-Engineering" 2016 Journal of Education and Practice 66-82
Strang H "Justice for Victims of Young Offenders: The Centrality of Emotional Harm and Restoration" in Morris A and Maxwell G (eds) Restorative Justice for Juveniles: Conferencing, Mediation and Circles (Hart Oxford 2001) 183-193
Strang H Repair or Revenge: Victims and Restorative Justice (Oxford University Press New York 2002)
Strang H and Sherman LW "Repairing the Harm: Victims and Restorative Justice" 2003 Utah L Rev 15-42
Stellenbosch University Policy on Academic Integrity: The Prevention and Handling of Plagiarism (SU Stellenbosch 2010)
Suvall C "Restorative Justice in Schools: Learning from Jena High School" 2009 Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review 547-569
Tarisayi KS "Lustre and Shadows: Unveiling the Gaps in South African University Plagiarism Policies Amidst the Emergence of AI‑Generated Content" 2023 AI and Ethics 1-7
Tarisayi KS "ChatGPT Use in Universities in South Africa through a Socio-Technical Lens" 2024 Cogent Education 1-10
Thornock SB "Proactive Solutions to Academic Dishonesty" 2013 Open Journal of Nursing 552-556
Tshehla B "The Restorative Justice Bug Bites the South African Criminal Justice System" 2004 SACJ 1-16
Umbreit Ms and Armour MP Restorative Justice Dialogue: An Essential Guide for Research and Practice (Springer New York 2011)
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime Handbook on Restorative Justice Programmes 2nd ed (UN Vienna 2020)
University of South Africa Policy on Academic Integrity (UNISA Pretoria 2017)
University of KwaZulu-Natal Plagiarism Policy and Procedures (UKZN Durban 2014)
Vaandering D "Implementing Restorative Justice Practice in Schools: What Pedagogy Reveals" 2014 Journal of Peace Education 60-84
Van Ness DW and Strong KH Restoring Justice: An Introduction to Restorative Justice 3rd ed (Anderson Publishing Cincinnati 2006)
Varfi T, Parmentier S and Aertsen I (eds) Developing Judicial Training for Restorative Justice: Towards A European Approach (European Forum for Restorative Justice Leuven 2014)
Varnham S "Seeing Things Differently: Restorative Justice and School Discipline" 2005 Education and Law 87-104
University of the Witwatersrand Annual Report (WITS Johannesburg 2022)
Zehr H The Little Book of Restorative Justice (Good Books Intercourse PA 2002)
Zivcakova L et al "Investigating Perceptions of Students to a Peer-Based Academic Integrity Presentation Provided by Residence Dons" 2014 Journal of Academic Ethics 89-99
Case law
Centre for Child Law and v Media 24 Limited 2020 1 SACR 469 (CC)
Dikoko v Mokhatla 2007 1 BCLR 1 (CC)
Freedom of Religion South Africa v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development 2020 1 SACR 113 (CC)
Port Elizabeth Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)
S v Makwanyane 1995 2 SACR 1 (CC)
S v M 2007 2 SACR 539 (CC)
S v Maluleke 2008 1 SACR 49 (T)
S v Saayman 2008 1 SACR 393 (E)
S v Seedat 2015 2 SACR 612 (GP)
S v Shilubane 2008 1 SACR 295 (T)
S v Tabethe 2009 2 SACR 62 (T)
The Citizen 1978 (Pty) Ltd v McBride 2011 4 SA 191 (CC)
Van der Ross v University of Cape Town (8473/2018) [2018] ZAWCHC 152 (15 November 2018)
Legislation
Child Justice Act 75 of 2008
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998
Probation Services Amendment Act 35 of 2002
Government publications
GN 3461 in GG 48660 of 26 May 2023 (Mosia NT Report of the Independent Assessor into the Affairs of the University of South Africa (UNISA))
Internet sources
Anonymous 2002 Serious Consequences for Exam Cheaters https://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/serious-consequences-for-exam-cheaters 95927 accessed 12 January 2023
Briscoe K 2019 Integrity in Business - A Priceless Essential for Success https://www.cfoselections.com/perspective/integrity-in-business-a-priceless-essential-for-success accessed 14 January 2023
De Castro C 2020 Wits Institutes Security Measures to Curb Cheating in Online Assessments https://witsvuvuzela.com/2020/05/19/wits-institutes-security-measures-to-curb-cheating-in-onlineassessments/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CSome%20of%20these%20include%20randomising,%2C%E2%80%9D%20she%20told%20Wits%20Vuvuzela accessed 2 September 2023
Fengu M 2021 With Online Exams, Unisa Sees an Increase in Cheating and Plagiarism https://www.news24.com/citypress/news/with-online-exams-unisa-sees-an-increase-in-cheating-and-plagiarism-20210210 accessed 12 January 2023
Ferlazzo L 2020 Ways to Implement Restorative Practices in the Classroom https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/opinion-ways-to-implement-restorative-practices-in-the-classroom/2020/01 accessed 16 May 2024
Govender P 2014 Universities Battle a Rising Tide of Cheating https://www.timeslive.co.za/sunday-times/lifestyle/2014-08-17-universities-battle-a-rising-tide-of-cheating/ accessed 12 January 2023
Govender P 2015 Stiff Penalties Don't Deter University Cheaters https://www.timeslive.co.za/sunday-times/news/2015-03-15-stiff-penalties-dont-deter-university cheaters/#:~:text=The%20threat%20of%20lengthy%20bans,years%20because%20of%20academic%20dishonesty accessed 13 January 2023
Heath-Thornton D 2018 Restorative Justice https://www.britannica.com/
topic/restorative-justice accessed 14 January 2023
Lotter C 2018 Why a Resettlement Grant for Ex-Offenders in SA is a Really Good Idea https://www.iol.co.za/news/opinion/why-a-resettlement-grant-for-ex-offenders-in-sa-is-a-really-good-idea-17128366 accessed 14 January 2023
Macupe B 2020 There is no Honour in Leaking a Matric Exam Paper https://mg.co.za/education/2020-11-21-there-is-no-honour-in-leaking-a-matric-exam-paper/ accessed 12 January 2023
Mlamla 2021 Universities See Steep Rise in Cheating, Misconduct with Move to Online Assessments https://www.iol.co.za/capeargus/news/
universities-see-steep-rise-in-cheating-misconduct-with-move-to-online-assessments-1ad26d3d-ce66-4d4f-87c3-2d38a6443452 accessed 12 January 2023
Nkosi B 2021 Learning to Cheat (Remotely) on a Massive Scale https://www.iol.co.za/capetimes/news/learning-to-cheat-remotely-on-a-massive-scale-9da3968f-eab7-41c3-b3d3-f166cf348e60 accessed 12 January 2023
Peachessay 2021 What is Academic Dishonesty – Useful Guide https://peachyessay.com/blogs/academic-dishonesty/ accessed 12 January 2023
Reimer K date unknown How to Use Restorative Justice in your Classroom and School https://www.monash.edu/education/teachspace/articles/how-to-use-restorative-justice-in-your-classroom-and school#:~:text=Listen%20for%20understanding.,does%2C%20you%20will%20support%20them accessed 14 January 2023
Sopcak P 2020 Restorative Practices for Academic Integrity https://academicintegrity.org/resources/blog/149-restorative-practices-for-academic-integrity accessed 13 January 2023
StudyCorgi 2022 Academic Dishonesty and Its Detrimental Effects https://studycorgi.com/academic-dishonesty-and-its-detrimental-effects/ accessed 12 January 2023
Stellenbosch University date unknown Disciplinary Committee Notice https://www.sun.ac.za/english/Lists/notices/DispForm.aspx?ID=1829 accessed 6 April 2024
University of South Africa 2022 Student Values and Plagiarism https://www.unisa.ac.za/sites/myunisa/default/Study-@-Unisa/Student-values-and-rules accessed 14 January 2023
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Reliance Bongani Mokomane
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.