Advancing the Protection of the Right to Freedom of Religion in South Africa
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2024/v27i0a17856Keywords:
Freedom of religion, freedom of belief, diversity, law and religion, church and state, religion and the public sphereAbstract
Since the inception of South Africa's democracy, the Constitutional Court has been confronted with only a few challenges regarding the protection of the right to freedom of religion (and the same applies to the other courts). Although part of the reason for the sparse jurisprudence on the protection of the right to freedom of religion is South Africa's relatively young democracy when compared to many other democracies around the world, an ideal opportunity is presented for contributing towards the laying of a sturdy foundation conducive to the advancement of inclusivity pertaining to religious freedoms. Consequently, this article critically explores aspects related to what is presented as essential underpinnings to the debate, namely the importance of the right to freedom of religion (and implied in this, non-religious belief as well), the presence of subjective moral convictions (or beliefs) in the practising of law and the accompanying risks related to unnecessary dominance in the practising of law, tolerance, the pretext of neutrality and modes of judicial reasoning. Following on this, and as an extension of the aforementioned, the Constitutional Court's approach in Prince v President of the Cape Law Society (hereafter Prince) is investigated. Accompanying all of the above is the countering of the strong pull in many democracies towards the marginalisation of religion regarding inclusion in the public sphere and that which is deemed to be rational; something that South Africa's democracy should not be perceived as being immune to.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Ahdar R "Is Secularism Neutral?" 2013 Ratio Juris 404-429
Ahdar R and Leigh I Religious Freedom in the Liberal State 2nd ed (Oxford Oxford University Press 2013)
Alexander L "Liberalism, Religion, and the Unity of Epistemology" 1993 San Diego L Rev 763-797
Asad T Formations of the Secular: Christianity, Islam, Modernity (Stanford University Press Redwood City 2003)
Benson IT "Notes Towards a Re(Definition) of the 'Secular'" 2000 UBC L Rev 519-549
Benson IT "South African Charter of Religious Rights and Freedoms: Constitutional Framework, Formation and Challenges" 2011 IJRF 125-134
Benson IT "Considering Secularism" in Farrow D (ed) Recognizing Religion in a Secular Society (McGill-Queens Montreal 2004) 83-98
Benson IT "Foreword" in Benson IT and Bussey BW (ed) Religion, Liberty and the Jurisprudential Limits of Law (LexisNexis Canada Toronto 2017) xxi-xlvi
Berman JH "The Interaction of Law and Religion" 1979 Cap U L Rev 345-356
Berman HJ Law and Revolution. The Formation of the Western Legal Tradition (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1983)
Calo ZR "Religion, Human Rights, and Post-Secular Legal Theory" 2011 St John's L Rev 495-520
Carter SL The Culture of Disbelief: How American Law and Politics Trivialize Religious Devotion (Anchor Books New York 1994)
Carter SL The Dissent of the Governed: A Meditation on Law, Religion, and Loyalty (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1998)
Carter SL God's Name in Vain: The Wrongs and Rights of Religion in Politics (New York Basic Books 2000)
Curtis K "The Partiality of Neutrality" 2018 Harv J L & Pub Pol'y 935-971
Deagon A "Secularism as a Religion: Questioning the Future of the 'Secular' State" 2017 Western Australian Jurist 31-94
Deneen PJ Why Liberalism Failed (Yale University Press New Haven 2018)
Du Plessis L "Affirmation and Celebration of the 'Religious Other' in South Africa's Constitutional Jurisprudence on Religious and Related Rights: Memorial Constitutionalism in Action?" 2008 AHRLJ 376-408
Fish S "Stanley Fish Replies to Richard John Neuhaus" Feb 1996 First Things 1-11
Froneman JC "Legal Reasoning and Legal Culture: Our 'Vision' of Law" 2005 Stell LR 3-20
Gedicks M "Public Life and Hostility to Religion" 1992 Va L Rev 671-696
George RP "Religious Liberty and the Human Good" 2012 IJRF 35-44
Hitchcock J The Supreme Court and Religion in American Life. Vol 2, From "Higher Law" to "Sectarian Scruples" (Princeton University Press Princeton 2004)
Horwitz P The Agnostic Age: Law, Religion, and the Constitution (Oxford University Press New York 2011)
Inazu J Confident Pluralism: Surviving and Thriving through Deep Difference (Chicago Chicago University Press 2016)
Kelman MG A Guide to Critical Legal Studies (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1987)
Malherbe R "The Background and Contents of the Proposed South African Charter of Religious Rights and Freedoms" 2011 BYU L Rev 613-636
Moschella M "Beyond Equal Liberty: Religion as a Distinct Moral Good and the Implications for Religious Freedom" 2017 J L & Relig 123-146
Neal P "A Liberal Theory of the Good?" 1978 Can J Philos 567-581
Nussbaum LM "A Garment for the Naked Public Square: Nurturing American Public Theology" 1985 Cumb L Rev 53-83
Peller G "The Metaphysics of American Law" 1985 CLR 1151-1290
Perry MJ "Comment On 'The Limits of Rationality and the Place of Religious Conviction: Protecting Animals and the Environment'" 1986 Wm & Mary L Rev 1067-1073
Sachs AL The Strange Alchemy of Life and Law (Oxford University Press Oxford 2009)
Schoeman WJ "South African Religious Demography: The 2013 General Household Survey" 2017 HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies 1-7
Scruton R "TS Eliot, 'Eliot as Conservative Mentor'" 2008 Intercoll Rev 1-8
Smith SD "The Plight of the Secular Paradigm" 2013 Notre Dame L Rev 1409-1456
Smith SD The Disintegrating Conscience and the Decline of Modernity (University of Notre Dame Press Notre Dame 2023)
Smith SD "Idolatry in Constitutional Interpretation" in Campos PF, Schlag P and Smith SD (eds) Against the Law (Duke University Press Durham 1996) 157-190
Spykman GJ "The Principled Pluralist Position" in Smith GS (ed) God and Politics: Four Views on the Reformation of Civil Government (Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing House Phillipsburg 1989) ch 5
Case law
Antonie v Governing Body, Settlers High School 2002 4 SA 738 (C)
Christian Education South Africa v Minister of Education 2000 4 SA 757 (CC)
Crossley v National Commissioner of South African Police Service 2004 3 All SA 436 (T)
De Lange v Presiding Bishop, Methodist Church of Southern Africa 2015 1 SA 106 (SCA)
De Lange v Presiding Bishop of the Methodist Church of Southern Africa for the Time Being 2016 2 SA 1 (CC)
Department of Correctional Services v POPCRU 2013 4 SA 176 (SCA)
Dlamini v Green Four Security 2006 27 ILJ 2098 (LC)
FAWU v Rainbow Chicken Farms 2000 1 BLLR 70 (LC)
Garden Cities Incorporated Association Not for Gain v Northpine Islamic Society 1999 2 SA 268 (C)
Gaum v Van Rensburg 2019 2 All SA 722 (GP)
Hendricks v The Church of the Province of Southern Africa, Diocese of Free State (108/2021) 2022 ZASCA 95 (20 June 2022)
Kievits Kroon Country Estate (Pty) Ltd v Mmoledi 2014 1 SA 585 (SCA)
Kotze v Kotze 2003 3 SA 628 (T)
Lewis v Media24 Ltd 2010 31 ILJ 2416 (LC)
MEC for Education: KwaZulu-Natal v Pillay 2008 1 SA 474 (CC)
Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie; Lesbian and Gay Equality Project v Minister of Home Affairs 2006 3 BCLR 355 (CC)
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development v Prince (Clarke Intervening); National Director of Public Prosecutions v Rubin; National Director of Public Prosecutions v Acton 2018 6 SA 393 (CC)
Mohamed v Jassiem 1996 1 SA 673 (SCA)
National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v Minister of Justice 1999 1 SA 6 (CC)
Nkosi v Bührmann 2002 1 SA 372 (SCA)
Organisasie vir Godsdienste-Onderrig en Demokrasie v Laerskool Randhart 2017 6 SA 129 (GJ)
Prince v President of the Cape Law Society of the Cape of Good Hope 2002 2 SA 794 (CC)
Radebe v Principal of Leseding Technical School (1821/2013) [2013] ZAFSHC 111 (30 May 2013)
Ryland v Edros 1997 2 SA 690 (C)
S v Lawrence, S v Negal, S v Solberg 1997 4 SA 1176 (CC)
Singh v Ramparsad 2007 3 SA 445 (D)
Strydom v Nederduitse Gereformeerde Gemeente, Moreletta Park 2009 4 SA 510 (EqC)
Taylor v Kurtstag 2005 1 SA 362 (W)
TDF Network Africa (Pty) Ltd v Deidre Beverley Faris 2018 CA 4/17 (LCA)
Wittmann v Deutscher Schulverein, Pretoria 1998 4 SA 423 (T)
Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Drugs and Drug Trafficking Act 140 of 1992
Medicines and Related Substances Control Act 101 of 1965
Government publications
GN 1307 in GG 25459 of 12 September 2003 (National Policy on Religion and Education)
International instruments
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966)
United Nations Convention against Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (1988)
Internet sources
https://classic.iclrs.org/content/blurb/files/South%20African%20Charter.pdf
accessed 23 May 2024
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Shaun de Freitas
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}