Constitutional Analysis of Intellectual Property

Authors

  • Andre J Van der Walt Stellenbosch University
  • Ray M Shay Stellenbosch University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i1a2194

Keywords:

Intellectual property law, constitutional property law, constitutional property clause, trademarks, copyright, parody, plain packaging, subsidiarity, deprivation, regulation, substantive arbitrariness

Abstract

This article analyses the Constitutional Court’s treatment of property interests in the face of state regulation to gain an understanding of the type of state interference that is justifiable in terms of section 25(1) of the Bill of Rights. This is done by examining the Constitutional Court’s dicta relating to the meaning of deprivation and how these inform the meaning of property in the constitutional context. The methodology that the Constitutional Court has formulated to assess if state interference complies with the provisions of section 25 is explained to show the type of state regulation that has been found legitimate. We then consider how this understanding of constitutional property and the state’s legitimate exercise of its inherent police power interact in the setting of intellectual property by contrasting the various policy objectives underlying the different statutory regimes governing intellectual property. This theoretical analysis is then applied to two contemporary examples of feasible state interference with existing intellectual property interests, namely the proposed plain packaging measures which severely restrict the use of tobacco trade marks, and a fair dealing exception allowing the use of copyright works for the purpose of parody. These examples serve to illustrate the context and manner in which intellectual property interests may come before the Court and the necessary differentiation with which these interests should be treated. The appropriate judicial assessment of the true impact that state action could have on vested property interests is explained and contrasted with the balancing exercise that is employed at the earlier stage of policy making. This discussion is concluded by highlighting some of the interpretational issues that will arise and how some constitutional values could be curtailed in the absence of legislative intervention.

    ScienceOpen_Log0343212.png

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Literature

Boyle Public Domain

Boyle J The Public Domain: Enclosing the Commons of the Mind (Yale University Press Yale 2008)

Castleman 2013 Without Prejudice

Castleman A "Plain packaging" 2013 Without Prejudice (Jun) 60-61

Child The Times

Child K "Joy Greets Aussie Smoking Ruling" The Times (16 August 2012) available online http://www.timeslive.co.za/thetimes/2012/08/16/joy-greets-aussie-smoking-ruling accessed 12 November 2013

Craig Copyright, Communication and Culture

Craig CJ Copyright, Communication and Culture: Towards a Relational Theory of Copyright Law (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2011)

Davies Copyright and the Public Interest

Davies G Copyright and the Public Interest 2nd ed (Sweet & Maxwell London 2002)

Dean 1997 THRHR

Dean OH "The case for the recognition of intellectual property in the Bill of Rights" 1997 THRHR 105-119

Dean 2005 De Rebus

Dean OH "Trade mark dilution laughed off" 2005 De Rebus (Oct) 18-22

Dean Handbook of South African Copyright Law

Dean OH Handbook of South African Copyright Law (Juta Cape Town 2012)

Deazley 2010 MLR

Deazley R "Copyright and parody: Taking back the Gowers Review?" 2010 MLR 785-823

Du Bois 2012 SAMLJ

Du Bois M "Intellectual property as a constitutional property right: The South African approach" 2012 SAMLJ 177-193

Kellerman Constitutional Property Clause

Kellerman M The Constitutional Property Clause and Immaterial Property Interests (LLD-thesis Stellenbosch University 2010)

Louw Ambush Marketing

Louw AM Ambush Marketing and the Mega-Event Monopoly: How Laws are Abused to Protect Commercial Rights to Major Sporting Events (TMC Asser Press The Hague 2012)

Merges 1993 AIPLA QJ

Merges RP "Are you making fun of me? Notes on market failure and the parody defense in copyright" 1993 AIPLA QJ 305-312

Moodie et al 2011 Tobacco Control

Moodie C et al "Young adult smokers' perceptions of plain packaging: A pilot naturalistic study" 2011 Tobacco Control 367-373

Mossoff "Introduction"

Mossoff A "Introduction" in Mossoff A (ed) Intellectual Property and Property Rights (Edward Elgar Publishing 2013) ix-xxii

Patry and Perlmutter 1992 CAELJ

Patry WF and Perlmutter S "Fair use misconstrued: Profit, presumptions, and parody" 1992 CAELJ 667-719

Posner Economic Analysis of Law

Posner RA Economic Analysis of Law 3rd ed (Aspen New York 1986)

Rahmatian Copyright and Creativity

Rahmatian A Copyright and Creativity: The Making of Property Rights in Creative Works (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2011)

Roux "Property"

Roux T "Property" in Woolman S, Roux T and Bishop M (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa III 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2003) ch 46

Slade 2013 TSAR

Slade BV "The less invasive means argument in expropriation law" 2013 Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 199-216

Stilwell 2012 Without Prejudice

Stilwell V "Unbranded cigarettes" 2012 Without Prejudice (Oct) 60-61

Van der Walt 2005 SALJ

Van der Walt AJ "Retreating from the FNB arbitrariness test already? Mkontwana v Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality; Bissett v Buffalo City Municipality; Transfer Rights Action Campaign v MEC for Local Government and Housing, Gauteng" 2005 SALJ 75-89

Van der Walt 2008 CCR

Van der Walt AJ "Normative pluralism and anarchy: Reflections of the 2007 term" 2008 CCR 77-128

Van der Walt "Constitutional Property Law"

Van der Walt AJ "Constitutional Property Law" in Visser C (ed) Annual Survey of South African Law (Juta Cape Town 2010) ix-xxii

Van der Walt Constitutional Property Law

Van der Walt AJ Constitutional Property Law 3rd ed (Juta Cape Town 2011)

Van der Walt Property and Constitution

Van der Walt AJ Property and Constitution (PULP Pretoria 2012)

Van der Walt 2012 Stell LR

Van der Walt AJ "Procedurally arbitrary deprivation of property" 2012 Stell LR 88-94

Van der Walt and Shay 2013 SAMLJ

Van der Walt AJ and Shay RM "Parody as a means to advance the objectives of copyright law" 2013 SAMLJ 1-12

Case law

Canada

Compagnie Générale des Établissements Michelin-Michelin & Cie v National Automobile, Aerospace, Transportation and General Workers Union of Canada (CAW-Canada) 1997 2 FC 306

South Africa

African Banking Corporation of Botswana Ltd v Kariba Furniture Manufacturers (Pty) Ltd (in Business Rescue) 2013 ZAGPPHC 259

Agri South Africa v Minister for Minerals and Energy 2013 4 SA 1 (CC)

First National Bank of SA Ltd t/a Wesbank v Commissioner, South African Revenue Service; First National Bank of SA Ltd t/a Wesbank v Minister of Finance 2002 4 SA 768 (CC)

Laugh It Off Promotions CC v SAB International (Finance) BV t/a SABMARK International 2006 1 SA 144 (CC)

Law Society of South Africa v Minister for Transport 2011 1 SA 400 (CC)

Mkontwana v Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality; Bissett v Buffalo City Municipality; Transfer Rights Action Campaign v MEC, Local Government and Housing, Gauteng 2005 1 SA 530 (CC)

National Credit Regulator v Opperman 2013 2 SA 1 (CC)

Offit Enterprises (Pty) Ltd v Coega Development Corporation (Pty) Ltd 2011 1 SA 293 (CC)

Reflect-All 1025 CC v MEC for Public Transport, Roads and Works, Gauteng Provincial Government 2009 6 SA 391 (CC)

Thebus v S 2003 6 SA 505 (CC)

United States of America

Fisher v Dees 794 F 2d 432 (9th Cir 1986)

Pro Arts Inc v Hustler Magazine Inc 787 F 2d 592 (6th Cir 1986)

Wright v Warner Bros Inc 953 F 2d 731 (2nd Cir 1991)

Legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Copyright Act 98 of 1978

Counterfeit Goods Act 37 of 1997

Minerals and Petroleum Resources Act 28 of 2002

Trade Marks Act 194 of 1993

International instruments

Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (1994)

Internet sources

Dean 2013 http://blogs.sun.ac.za/iplaw/files/2013/05/Prof-Owen-H-Dean_Inaugural-lecture_15-May_final-version.pdf

Dean OH 2013 Deprivation of Trade Marks Through State Interference in their Usage - Inaugural Lecture Delivered at Stellenbosch University on 21 May 2013 http://blogs.sun.ac.za/iplaw/files/2013/05/Prof-Owen-H-Dean_Inaugu-

ral-lecture_15-May_final-version.pdf accessed 12 November 2013

Deloitte 2011 http://www.bata.com.au/group/sites/bat_7wykg8.nsf/vwPages

WebLive/DO7WZEX6/$FILE/medMD8EHAM5.pdf

Deloitte 2011 Illicit Trade of Tobacco in Australia: A Report Prepared for British American Tobacco Australia Limited, Philip Morris Limited and Imperial Tobacco Australia Limited http://www.bata.com.au/group/sites/

bat_7wykg8.nsf/vwPagesWebLive/DO7WZEX6/$FILE/medMD8EHAM5.pdf accessed 12 November 2013

Harms 2013 http://web.up.ac.za/sitefiles/file/47/10568/PLAIN%20PACKAGING%20

AND%20THE%20FUTURE%20OF%20TRADEMARK%20LAW.pdf

Harms LTC 2013 Plain Packaging and its Impact on Trade-Mark Law - Lecture Delivered at the University of Pretoria on 13 March 2013 http://web.up.ac.za/sitefiles/file/47/10568/PLAIN%20PACKAGING%20AND%20THE%20FUTURE%20OF%20TRADEMARK%20LAW.pdf accessed 12 November 2013

Philip Morris Limited 2012 http://www.pmi.com/eng/tobacco_regulation/

submissions/documents/submission%20and%20all%20annexes%20(combined).pdf

Philip Morris Limited Standardised Tobacco Packaging will Harm Public Health and Cost UK Taxpayers Billions: A Response to the Department of Health Consultation on Standardised Packaging of Tobacco Products http://www.pmi.com/eng/tobacco_regulation/submissions/documents/submission %20and%20all%20annexes%20(combined).pdf accessed 12 November 2013

WTO 2013 http://www.wto.org/english/news_e/news13_e/ds458rfc_03may

_e.htm

World Trade Organisation 2013 News Report http://www.wto.org/english/news_e/news13_e/ds458rfc_03may13_e.htm accessed 12 November 2013

Published

2017-04-21

How to Cite

Van der Walt, A. J., & Shay, R. M. (2017). Constitutional Analysis of Intellectual Property. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 17(1), 051–085. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i1a2194

Issue

Section

Articles