Demystifying the Role of Copyright as a Tool for Economic Development in Africa: Tackling the Harsh Effects of the Transferability Principle in Copyright Law


  • J Joel Baloyi University Of South Africa



Entrepreneurship, Barriers to entrepreneurship, Copyright, Authors’ rights, Droit d’auteur, Anglo-American law, Continental system, Monist, Dualist, Transferability, Sub-Saharan Africa


In the English common law tradition copyright is seen as being in the nature of a property right and thus alienable and transmissible from one person to the other. In contrast, the droit d’auteur system of Continental Europe sees copyright as being an author’s right, which attaches to the personality of the author. However, even in this system a distinction can be made between the monist system (as applies in Germany), which treats both moral rights and economic rights as being inseparable and thus equally inalienable, and the dualist system applicable in France, which distinguishes between moral and economic rights, with the former considered inalienable, while the latter is freely alienable. In this way French law embodies the transferability principle in respect of economic rights, in the same way as the Anglo-American system does. Many countries in Sub-Saharan Africa have inherited copyright laws from their erstwhile colonial masters (whether England or France), resulting in the laws of these countries also embodying the transferability principle. It is argued, however, that the transferability principle has had the inadvertent effect of stifling copyright-based entrepreneurship, and thus economic development in these countries. Because of the conditions of impoverishment prevailing in these countries, authors find that they do not have the material resources to economically exploit their copyright works. They thus have no option but to assign their copyrights to others, mainly foreign entities, resulting in an endless cycle where they can never act entrepreneurially in respect of their copyrights. The paper seeks to explore this phenomenon and make proposals of possible solutions. 



Download data is not yet available.


Metrics Loading ...




Acs and Virgill 2009 Jena Economic Research Papers

Acs Z and Virgill N "Entrepreneurship in Developing Countries" 2009 Jena Economic Research Papers 1-80

Alemazung 2010 JPAS

Alemazung JA "Post-colonial Colonialism: An Analysis of International Factors and Actors marring African Socio-Economic and Political Development" 2010 JPAS 62-84

Alesina et al 1996 Journal of Economic Growth

Alesina A et al "Political Instability and Economic Growth" 1996 Journal of Economic Growth 189-211

Ambert Promoting the Culture Sector

Ambert C Promoting the Culture Sector through Job Creation and Small Enterprise Development in SADC Countries: The Music Industry (ILO Geneva 2003)

Balganesh "Alienability and Copyright Law"

Balganesh S "Alienability and Copyright Law" in Howe H and Griffiths (eds) Concepts of Property in Intellectual Property Law (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2013) 161-181

Baloyi Intellectual Property

Baloyi JJ Intellectual Property, Entrepreneurship and the Music Industry: A New Ray of Hope for Enhancing African International Trade Capacity? A South African Case Study (LLM-minithesis University of the Western Cape 2005)

Baloyi 2012 SA Merc LJ

Baloyi JJ "To Publish or not to Publish: A Critical Consideration of the Role of the Music Publisher Today" 2012 SA Merc LJ 218-232

Banerjee and Gokhale 2010 NUJS L Rev

Banerjee D and Gokhale P "The '3 Idiots' Controversy - Focusing on the Contractual Liabilities and Moral Rights of the Author" 2010 NUJS L Rev 53-76

Bitton 2008 BTLJ

Bitton M "Exploring European Union Copyright Policy through the Lens of the Database Directive" 2008 BTLJ 1411-1470

Bizri et al 2012 World Journal of Social Sciences

Bizri et al "Barriers to Entrepreneurial Endeavours in a Developing Economy" 2012 World Journal of Social Sciences 79-100

Brereton 2009 Cardozo Arts & Ent LJ

Brereton I "The Beginning of a New Age? The Unconscionability of the '360 degree' Deal" 2009 Cardozo Arts & Ent LJ 167-197

Child The Guardian

Child B "Slumdog Millionaire Makers Deny Allegations of Child Exploitation" The Guardian (30 January 2009) available online accessed 14 January 2014

Chinni 1992 W New Eng L Rev

Chinni CL "Droit D'Auteur versus the Economics of Copyright: Implications for American Law of Accession to the Berne Convention" 1992 W New Eng L Rev 145-174

Copeling Copyright Law

Copeling AJC Copyright Law in South Africa (Butterworths Durban 1969)

Corbin 2008 VUE Magazine

Corbin RM "A Practical Six-Point Guide to Copyright Valuation" 2008 VUE Magazine Nov 24-27

Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook

Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Claremont 2005)

Dean Copyright Law

Dean OH Handbook of South African Copyright Law (Juta Cape Town 1987)

Dean 1997 THRHR

Dean OH "The case for Recognition of Intellectual Property in the Bill of Rights" 1997 THRHR 105-119

Dean 2005 De Rebus

Dean OH "Trade Mark Dilution Laughed Off" 2005 De Rebus Oct 18-22

Dean 2006 De Rebus

Dean O "Stalking the Sleeping Lion" 2006 De Rebus Jul 16-21

Du Plessis, Brown and Tanziani Practical Guide to Intellectual Property

Du Plessis ED, Brown S and Tanziani DF (eds) Adams & Adams Practical Guide to Intellectual Property in Africa (PULP Pretoria 2012)

Ford and Swedberg 2009 Economic Sociology

Ford L and Swedberg R "Law in Economy and Society: Introductory Remarks" 2009 Economic Sociology: The European Electronic Newsletter 1-44

Garnett, Davies and Harbottle Copyright

Garnett K, Davies G and Harbottle G (eds) Copinger and Skone James on Copyright 16th ed (Sweet & Maxwell London 2011)

Glensy 2011 Colum Hum Rts L Rev

Glensy RD "The right to dignity" 2011 Colum Hum Rts L Rev 65-142

Grzelak 2002 J Marshall Rev Intell Prop L

Grzelak VA "Mickey Mouse and Sonny Bono go to court: The Copyright Term Extension Act and its effect on Current and Future Rights" 2002 J Marshall Rev Intell Prop L 95-115

Hayes 2003 Vand J Transnat'l L

Hayes R "Promoting Intellectual Property for Economic Growth" 2003 Vand J Transnat'l L 793-798

Helfer "Collective Management"

Helfer LR "Collective Management of Copyrights and Human Rights: An Uneasy Alliance Revisited" in Gervais D (ed) Collective Management of Copyright and Related Rights 2nd ed (Kluwer Law International The Netherlands 2010) 75-104

Hindman 2006 Ariz J Int'l & Comp Law

Hindman D "The Effect of Intellectual Property Regimes on Foreign Investment in Developing Countries" 2006 Ariz J Int'l & Comp Law 467-492

Idris Intellectual Property

Idris K Intellectual Property - A Powertool for Economic Growth (WIPO Publications Geneva 2003)

Karubian 2009 S Cal Interdisc LJ

Karubian S "360 Deals: An Industry reaction to the Devaluation of Recorded Music" 2009 S Cal Interdisc LJ 395-462

Kilian 2003 J Marshall Rev Intell Prop L

Kilian M "A hollow victory for the common law? TRIPs and the Moral Rights Exclusion" 2003 J Marshall Rev Intell Prop L 321-336

Kohn and Khon Music Licensing

Kohn A and Khon B Khon on Music Licensing 4th ed (Aspen New York 2010)

Kretschmer 2009 EIPR

Kretcshmer M "The Failure of Property Rules in Collective Administration: Rethinking Copyright Societies as Regulatory Instruments" 2009 EIPR Issue 126-137

Kretschmer 2012 IJMBR

Kretschmer M "Copyright Term Reversion and the 'Use-It-Or-Lose-It' Principle" 2012 IJMBR 44-53

Kretschmer, Klims and Wallis 1999 Prometheus

Kretschmer M, Klims GM and Wallis R "The Changing Location of Intellectual Property Rights in Music: A study of Music Publishers, Collecting Societies and Media Conglomerates" 1999 Prometheus 163-186

Malackowski et al 2007 Licensing Journal

Malackowski JE et al "The Intellectual Property Marketplace: Emerging Transaction and Investment Vehicles" 2007 The Licensing Journal 1-11

Maskus 1998 Duke J Comp & Int'l L

Maskus KE "The Role of Intellectual Property Rights in Encouraging Foreign Direct Investment and Technology Transfer" 1998 Duke J Comp & Int'l L 109-161

Menell and Nimmer 2009-2010 J Copyright Soc'y USA

Menell PS and Nimmer D "Pooh-Poohing Copyright Law's 'Inalienable' Termination Rights" 2009-2010 J Copyright Soc'y USA 799-858

Mengenli 2010 Ankara Bar Review

Mengenli OA "Does it Make a Difference to follow Monism or Dualism?" 2010 Ankara Bar Review 85-96

Monta 1958-1959 S Cal L Rev

Monta R "The Concept of 'Copyright' versus the 'Droit D'Auteur'" 1958-1959 S Cal L Rev 177 177-186

Netanel 1994 Cardozo Arts & Ent LJ

Netanel N "Alienability Restrictions and the Enhancement of Author Autonomy in United States and Continental Copyright Law" 1994 Cardozo Arts & Ent LJ 1-78

Parker Music Business Infrastructure

Parker N Music Business Infrastructure, Practice and Law (Sweet & Maxwell London 2004)

Passman All You Need to Know

Passman DS All You Need to Know About the Music Business 6th ed (Penguin Books London 2008)

Patry Copyright Law

Patry WF Copyright Law and Practice (BNA Books Rockville 1994)

Penna, Thornmann and Finger "Africa Music Project"

Penna FJ, Thornmann M and Finger JM "The Africa Music Project" in Finger JM and Schuler P (eds) Poor People's Knowledge - Promoting Intellectual Property in Developing Countries (Oxford University Press Washington 2004) 95-112

Pierson 2010 Entertainment and Sports Lawyer

Pierson E "Negotiating a 360 Deal - Considerations on the Promises and Perils of a new Music Business Model" 2010 Entertainment and Sports Lawyer 31-35

Rahmatian Copyright and Creativity

Rahmatian A Copyright and Creativity - The Making of Property Rights in Creative Works (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2011)

Reddy 2012 NUJS L Rev

Reddy TP "The Background Score to the Copyright (Amendment) Act 2012)" 2012 NUJS L Rev 469-527

Reece-Davis Unconscionable Contracts

Reece-Davis P Unconscionable Contracts in the Music Industry - The Need for New Legal Relationships (Edwin Mellen Press New York 2005)

Reichman 1995 International Lawyer

Reichman JH "Universal Minimum Standards of Intellectual Property Protection under the TRIPs Component of the WTO Agreement" 1995 International Lawyer 345-388

Rosa, Kodithuwakku and Balunywa 2006 Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research

Rosa P, Kodithuwakku S and Balunywa W "Entrepreneurial Motivation in Developing Countries: What does 'Necessity' and 'Opportunity' Entrepreneurship Really Mean?" Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research 531-544

Sanderson Musicians and the Law

Sanderson P (ed) Musicians and the Law in Canada 3rd ed (Carswell Ontario 2000)

Schultz and Van Gelder 2008-2009 Ky LJ

Schultz M and Van Gelder A "Creative Development: Helping Poor Countries by Building Creative Industries" 2008-2009 Ky LJ 79-148

Singh 2012 THRHR

Singh A "A Re-evaluation of the Common Law Presumptions in the Light of the Constitution" 2012 THRHR 74-95

Sterling World Copyright Law

Sterling JAL World Copyright Law (Sweet & Maxwell London 2008)

Stern 2012 UTLJ

Stern S "From Authors' Rights to Property Right" 2012 UTLJ 29-91

Vaver 2001 EJCL

Vaver D "The Copyright mixture in a mixed legal system: Fit for human consumption?" 2001 EJCL available online accessed 29 October 2012

WIPO Intellectual Property Handbook

World Intellectual Property Organisation WIPO Intellectual Property Handbook: Policy, Law and Use 2nd ed (WIPO Geneva 2004)

Yanover and Kotler 1989 Loy LA Ent L Rev

Yanover MI and Kotler HG "Artist/Management Agreements and the English Music Trilogy: Another British Invasion?" 1989 Loy LA Ent L Rev 211-235

Zucconi 1996 Pace Int'l L Rev

Zucconi K "Freedom: Long-term Recording Agreements and the International Music Industry" 1996 Pace Int'l L Rev 161-197

Case law


Tele-Direct (Publications) Inc v American Business Information, Inc 1998 2 FC 22 (CA)

South Africa

Barkuizen v Napier 2007 5 SA 323 (CC)

Biotech Laboratories (Pty) Ltd v Beecham Group Plc 786 JOC (A)

Disney Enterprises Inc v Griesel 2006 BIP 299 (T)

Ex Parte Chairperson of the Constitutional Assembly: In re Certification of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 1996 4 SA 744 (CC)

First National Bank of SA Ltd t/a Wesbank v Commissioner, South African Revenue Services 2002 4 SA 768 (CC)

Investigating Directorate: Serious Economic Offences v Hyundai Motor Distributors (Pty) Ltd: In re Hyundai Motor Distributors (Pty) Ltd v Smit 2001 1 SA 545 (CC)

Laugh it Off Promotions CC v SAB International (Finance) BV t/a Sabmark International 2005 2 SA 46 (SCA)

Laugh it Off Promotions CC v SAB International (Finance) BV t/a Sabmark International 2006 1 SA 144 (CC)

Mkontwana v Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality 2005 2 BCLR 150 (CC)

Mohlomi v Minister of Defence 1997 1 SA 124 CC

Sunshine Records (Pty) Ltd v Frohling 1990 4 SA 782 (A)

United Kingdom

A Schroeder Music Publishing Co Ltd v Macaulay 1974 3 ALL ER 616 (HL)

Crosstown Music Company 1 LLC v Rive Droite Music Ltd 2010 EWCA Civ 1222

Donaldson v Becket 4 Burr 2408, 98 Eng Re 257 (HL 1774)

Ladbroke (Football) Ltd v William Hill (Football) Ltd 1964 1 ALL ER 465 (HL)

Williams v Roffey Bros & Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd 1989 EWCA Civ 5

United States

Eldred v Ashcroft 537 US 186 (2003)

Scorpio Music SA v Victor Willis (RBB) case number 11cv1557 BTM

Twentieth Century Music Corp v Aiken 422 US (1975)

Warren v Fox Family Worldwide Inc 328 F3 d 1136 (2003)



Copyright Act of Canada of 1921


Copyright Act 14 of 1957


Copyright Act 12 of 2001

South Africa

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008

Copyright Act 98 of 1978

Patents, Trademarks, Designs and Copyright Act 9 of 1916

United Kingdom

Copyright Act of 1956

Copyright, Designs and Patents Act of 1988

Imperial Copyright Act of 1911

Statute of Anne of 1710

United States

Copyright Act USC 17 §§ 101 et seq

Jumpstart Our Business Start-ups Act of 2012

Sonny Bono Act (Copyright Term Extension Act) of 1998

Visual Artists Rights Act of 1990

International instruments

Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (1994) (TRIPS Agreement)

Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works (1886) (Berne Convention)

International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966)

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)

Internet sources

Alter 2008

Alter S 2008 Copyright Reversions - Protecting your Musical Copyrights accessed 30 October 2012

American Federation of Musicians 2012

American Federation of Musicians 2012 Home Page accessed 30 October 2012

Andersen, Kozul-Wright and Kozul-Wright 2002


Andersen B, Kozul-Wright Z and Kozul-Wright R 2000 Copyrights, Competition and Development: The Case of the Music Industry

docs/dp_145.en.pdf accessed 19 October 2012

Autio and Acs 2010

Autio E and Acs ZJ 2010 Intellectual Property Protection and the Formation of Entrepreneurial Growth Aspirations

sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1646954 accessed 20 October 2012

Basofin 2010

Basofin JE 2010 360 Deals and What they Indicate about the Future of the Music Industry Structure

seminar/Basofin-360%20Deals-FINAL.pdf accessed 30 October 2012

Bently and Ginsburg 2010

Bently L and Ginsburg JC 2010 "The Sole Right … Shall return to the Authors": Anglo-American Authors' Reversion Rights from the Statute of Anne to Contemporary U.S. Copyright accessed 25 October 2012

Chace 2011

Chace Z 2011 How Much does it Cost to Make a Hit Song? accessed 22 October 2012

Clifford 2013

Clifford C 2013 U.S. Remains Dominant Force in Global Entrepreneurship... For Now accessed 14 January 2014

Commission on Intellectual Property Rights date unknown

Commission on Intellectual Property Rights date unknown Integrating Intellectual Property Rights and Development Policy accessed 30 October 2012

Copyright Review Commission 2011


Copyright Review Commission 2011 Copyright Review Commission Report accessed 23 October 2012

Daniel 2010

Daniel 2010 Artist or Business Person - Can They be One? accessed 22 October 2012

E-Myth Business Coach 2010


E-Myth Business Coach 2010 Entrepreneurial Artist to Business Owner accessed 22 October 2012

Janjua date unknown


Janjua PZ date unknown Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) and Economic Growth: A Case Study of Middle-Income Developing Countries accessed 20 October2012

Kameri-Mbote 2005

Kameri-Mbote P 2005 Intellectual Property Protection in Africa: An Assessment of the Status of Laws, Research and Policy Analysis on Intellectual Property Rights in Kenya accessed 25 October 2012

Khan 2002


Khan BZ 2002 Intellectual Property and Economic Development: Lessons from American and European History

study_papers/sp1a_khan_study.pdf accessed 21 October 2012

Lingelbach, De la Vina and Asel 2005


Lingelbach D, De la Vina L and Asel P 2005 What's Distinctive about Growth-oriented Entrepreneurship in Developing Countries

sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=742605 accessed 30 October 2012

Nunnenkamp and Spatz 2003


Nunnenkamp P and Spatz J 2003 Intellectual Property Rights and Foreign Direct Investment: The Role of Industry and Host-Country Characteristics accessed 20 October 2012

Okorocha 2011

Okorocha D 2011 A Full 360: How the 360 Deal Challenges the Historical Resistance to Establishing a Fiduciary Duty Between Artist and Label accessed 30 October 2012

Olinto and Uematsu date unknown


Olinto P and Uematsu H date unknown The State of the Poor: Where are the Poor and where are they Poorest?

dam/Worldbank/document/State_of_the_poor_paper_April17.pdf accessed 2 January 2014

Omidyar Network 2013


Omidyar Network 2013 Omidyar Network Releases Report on the Challenges Faced by African Entrepreneurs and Recommendations for Accelerating High-Impact Entrepreneurship Across the Continent

about_us/news/2013/04/25/omidyar-network-report-reveals-challenges-faced-African-entrepreneurs-and-0 accessed 12 January 2014

PriceWaterhouseCoopers 2010


PriceWaterhouseCoopers 2010 Economic Contribution of Indian Film and Television Industry

Contribution.pdf accessed 10 January 2014

Rosso 2012

Rosso W 2012 Whitney to Sony: "I Will Always Owe You" http://www.wayne accessed 14 January 2014

Sahn and Younger 2009


Sahn DE and Younger S 2009 Living Standards in Africa accessed 2 January 2014

SAHO date unknown

South African History Online date unknown Solomon Popoli Linda, Singer and Composer, Dies accessed 22 October 2012

UK Intellectual Property Office 2009

UK Intellectual Property Office 2009 © The Way Ahead: A Copyright Strategy for the Digital Age accessed 30 October 2012


United Nations Conference on Trade and Development 2008 Creative Economy Report accessed 18 October 2012



United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation 2007 Statistics on Cultural Industries - Framework for the Elaboration of National Data Capacity Building Projects

intracenorg/Content/About_ITC/Where_are_we_working/Multi-country_programmes/CARIFORUM/stat_clt_industries.pdf accessed 20 October 2012



United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation 2003 Asia-Pacific Regional Consultation on a New Framework for Culture Statistics (Background Paper) %20workshop%20dox/Background%20paper

_Bangkok%202008.pdf accessed 20 October 2012


United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation 2010 The ABC of Copyright

CLT/diversity/pdf/WAPO/ABC_Copyright_en.pdf accessed 30 October 2012

University of Virginia Darden School 2002



University of Virginia Darden School Foundation 2002 Methods of Intellectual Property Valuation

PEPortal/Documents/IP%20Valuation%20F-1401%20_watermark_.pdf accessed 22 October 2012

Von Lewinski 1998


Von Lewinski S 1998 Intellectual Property, Nationality, and Non-Discrimination accessed 30 October 2012

Von Lewinski 2004


Von Lewinski S 2004 Mandatory Collective Administration of Exclusive Rights - A Case Study on its Compatibility with International and EC Copyright Law accessed 30 October 2012

WIPO 2004

World Intellectual Property Organisation 2004 WIPO Report: The Economic Contribution of Copyright-based Industries in USA accessed 19 October 2012

WIPO 2006


World Intellectual Property Organisation Guide on Surveying the Economic Contribution of the Copyright-based Industries

freepublications/en/copyright/893/wipo_pub_893.pdf accessed 20 October 2012

WIPO 2012


World Intellectual Property Organisation 2012 Studies on the Economic Contribution of the Copyright Industries accessed 18 October 2012

Yeluri 2013

Yeluri M 2013 Coming Soon: Minimum Basic Agreement for Screenwriters in India

-basic-agreement-for-screenwriters-in-india/ accessed 14 January 2014



How to Cite

Baloyi, J. J. (2017). Demystifying the Role of Copyright as a Tool for Economic Development in Africa: Tackling the Harsh Effects of the Transferability Principle in Copyright Law. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 17(1), 086–165.




Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.