To be or not to be? The Role of Private Enquiries in the South African Insolvency Law
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i3a2272Keywords:
Insolvency law, liquidation, section 417 of Companies Act 61 of 1973, private examinations, constitutional, constitutional court cases, balance of rights, abuse of process, concursus creditorum, oral or written interrogatories, Insolvency Act 1986, officAbstract
This article analyses the role of the so-called private examinations in our South African insolvency law and deals with the question of whether or not section 417 of the Insolvency Act (Act 24 of 1936) is adequately and effectively framed in order to fulfil its intended purpose in South African law. The contribution also points out that although the scrutiny of private examinations is not novel; it is argued that further exploration of the subject is justified by virtue of the fact that robust and innovative legislative changes have been experienced in the South African corporate landscape. Although the section has already passed the test of lawfulness and constitutionality, the aim is to ascertain whether the section serves a legitimate purpose and is essential and relevant in a democratic society. This is done by considering the South African law relating to South African private examinations and includes academic texts and judicial interpretation. Both section 417 of the Companies Act (Act 61 of 1973) and the matter of Kebble v Gainsford in particular are discussed. A brief comparative analysis of a similar provision in the Insolvency Act of the United Kingdom (UK), namely section 236 of the Insolvency Act 1986 is also included.
Finally recommendations are made on aspects where the section may be enhanced by reform which in part relies on the premise that South African insolvency law in toto is desperately in need of an overhaul. The article concludes that it is vital that section 417 be retained in a new insolvency regime as there is a greater awareness of the interdependence between companies and the society in which they function, and it is submitted that there should be an increased responsibility in the insolvency process on the reasons why companies have failed. The accessibility of the section to practitioners, the inquisitorial nature of the proceedings, the wide scope of the section and the effective sanctions should examinees not comply together combine to make a formula that has over the years proved impervious to circumvention and it therefore fulfils its function with prudent efficiency.
Downloads
References
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Literature
Bekink 2008 SA Merc LJ
Bekink M "An historical overview of the director's duty of care and skill: from the nineteenth century to the Companies Bill of 2007" 2008 SA Merc LJ 95-116
Bertelsmann Mars: Law of Insolvency
Bertelsmann E et al Mars: The Law of Insolvency in South Africa 9th ed (Juta Cape Town 2008)
Burdette Framework for Corporate Insolvency Law Reform
Burdette D Framework for Corporate Insolvency Law Reform in South Africa (LLD- thesis UP 2002)
Boraine and van der Linde 1998 TSAR
Boraine A and van der Linde K "The Draft Insolvency Bill – an exploration (Part 1)" 1998 TSAR 621-646
Calitz 2006 Obiter
Calitz JC "Section 417 and 418 Of the Companies Act 61 of 73 - relevance prevailing over the right to privacy - Gumede v Subel NO 2006 3 SA 498 SCA" 2006 Obiter 403- 409
Calitz 2011 De Jure
Calitz JC "Some thoughts on state regulation of South African insolvency law" 2011 De Jure 290-318
Calitz 2011 Obiter
Calitz JC "Some administrative law aspects of state regulation of insolvency law revisited- Musenwa v Master of the North Gauteng High Court" 2011 Obiter 747-759
Calitz Reformatory Approach
Calitz JC A Reformatory Approach to State Regulation of Insolvency Law in South Africa (LLD thesis, UP 2009)
Cassim Contemporary Company Law
Cassim F et al Contemporary Company Law 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2012)
Du Plessis 2010 Acta Juridica
Du Plessis JJ "A comparative analysis of directors' duty of care, skill and diligence in South Africa and in Australia" 2010 Acta Juridica 263-289
Evans Critical Analysis of Problem Areas
Evans RG A Critical Analysis of Problem Areas in Respect of Assets of Insolvent Estates of Individuals (LLD-thesis UP 2009)
Feinstein 2010 De Rebus
Feinstein M "A practical guide to the new Companies Act - directors' duties and responsibilities" 2010 De Rebus 43
Finch Corporate Insolvency Law
Finch V Corporate Insolvency Law: Perspectives and Principles 2nd ed (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2009)
Fletcher Law of Insolvency
Fletcher IF The Law of Insolvency 4th ed (Sweet and Maxwell London 2009)
Goode Principles of Corporate Insolvency Law
Goode RM Principles of Corporate Insolvency Law 4th ed (Sweet and Maxwell London 2011)
Havenga 2001 SA Merc LJ
Havenga M "Simplification and unification in corporate and insolvency law - are we making any progress?" 2001 SA Merc LJ 408-420
Keay 2000 NILQ
Keay AR "Insolvency Law: A Matter of Public Interest?" 2000 NILQ 509-534
Keay 2001 Anglo-American LR
Keay AR "Balancing Interests in Bankruptcy Law" 2001 Anglo-American LR 206-236
Loubser 2007 SA Merc LJ
Loubser A "An international perspective on the regulation of insolvency practitioners" 2007 SA Merc LJ 123-139
Luiz and Taljaard 2009 SA Merc LJ
Luiz S and Taljaard Z "Mass resignation of the board and social responsibility of the company: Minister of Water Affairs and Forestry v Stilfontein Gold Mining Co Ltd" 2009 SA Merc LJ 420-425
Mayson et al Company law
French D, Mayson SW and Ryan CL Company Law 26th ed (Oxford University Press Cape Town 2009)
Meskin et al Insolvency Law
Meskin PM et al Insolvency Law (Butterworths Durban 1990)
O'Brien 2002 TSAR
O'Brien P "The application of the statutory mechanisms providing for private enquiries in terms of the insolvency act in the winding up of companies" 2002 TSAR 736-746
Rajak Company Liquidations
Rajak H Company Liquidations 2nd ed (Sweet and Maxwell London 2005)
Sealy and Milman Annotated Guide
Sealy LS and Milman D Annotated Guide to the Insolvency Legislation 13th ed (Sweet and Maxwell London 2010)
Swart Rol van 'n Concursus Creditorum
Swart BH Die Rol van 'n Concursus Creditorum in die Suid-Afrikaanse Insolvensiereg (LLD-thesis UP 1990)
Van der Linde "South Africa"
Van der Linde "South Africa" in Anderson H (ed) Directors' Personal Liability for Corporate Fault (Kluwer Law International Alpen aan den Rijn 2008)
Van der Linde 2008 SA Merc LJ
Van der Linde K "The personal liability of directors for corporate fault - an exploration" 2008 SA Merc LJ 439-461
Van der Linde and Boraine 1999 TSAR
Van der Linde K and Boraine A "The Draft Insolvency Bill - an exploration Part 2" 1999 TSAR 38
Case Law
South Africa
Akoo v Master of the High Court 2012 ZAKZPHC 45 (31 July 2012)
Bernstein v Bester 1996 2 SA 751 (CC)
Botha v Strydom 1992 2 SA 155 (N)
Caroline Trekkers en Implemente (Edms) Bpk v Venter 1982 2 PH E9 (A)
Cassimjee v Minister of Finance 2012 ZASCA 101 (1 June 2012)
Concorde Leasing Corporation (Rhodesia) Ltd v Pringle-Wood 1975 4 SA 231 (R)
Cordiant Trading CC v Daimler Chrysler Financial Services (Pty) Ltd 2005 4 SA 389 (D&CLD)
Ex parte Klopper: In re Sogervim SA (Pty) Ltd (in Liq) (Sogervim SA Intervening) 1971 3 SA 791 (T)
Ferreira v Levin; Vryenhoek v Powell 1996 1 SA 984 (CC)
Fey and Whiteford v Serfontein 1993 2 SA 605 (A)
Gilbert v Bekker 1984 3 SA 774 (W)
Gumede v Subel 2006 3 SA 498 (SCA)
Huang v Bester 2012 5 SA 551 (GSJ)
James v Magistrate Wynberg 1995 1 SA 1 (C)
Jeeva v Receiver of Revenue, Port Elizabeth 1995 2 SA 433 (SE)
Kawie v The Master of the High Court unreported case number 21353/2011 WC of 3 November 2011
Kebble v Gainsford 2010 1 SA 561 (GSJ)
Laskarides v German Tyre Centre (Pty) Ltd 2010 1 SA 390 (W)
Lategan v Lategan 2003 6 SA 611 (D)
Leech v Farber 2000 2 SA 444 (W)
Lynn v Kreuger 1995 2 SA 940 (SE)
Merchant Shippers SA v Millman 1986 1 SA 413 (C)
Mitchell v Hodes 2003 3 SA 176 (CC)
P Nyathi v M P Cloete 2012 6 SA 631 (GSJ)
Parboo v Getz 1997 4 SA 1095 (CC)
Podlas v Bryden 1994 4 SA 662 (T)
Re Corporation, Gooch's Case 1872 7 Ch App 207
Richter v Riverside Estates (Pty) Ltd 1946 OPD 209
Standard Bank of South Africa v The Master of the High Court 2010 4 SA 405 (SCA)
Strauss v The Master 2001 1 SA 649 (T)
Thorn v The Master 1964 3 SA 38 (N)
Western Bank Ltd v Thorne 1973 3 SA 661 (C)
UK
British and Commonwealth Holdings plc v Spicer and Oppenheim 1993 AC 426
Cloverbay Ltd (Joint Administrators) v Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA 1991 1 All ER 900
Cowlishaw v O & D Building Contractors Ltd 2009 EWHC 2445 (Ch)
Green v BDO Stoy Hayward LLP 2005 EWHC 2413 (Ch)
In re Highgrade Trades Ltd1984 BCLC 151
In re John T Rhodes Ltd1986 2 BCC 99
In re North Australian Territory Co 1890 45 ChD 87
Official Receiver v Wadge Rapps & Hunt 2003 UKHL 49
Re Embassy Art Products Ltd 1987 3 BCC 292
Re Pantmaenog Timber Co Ltd 2004 1 AC 158
Re RGB Resources plc 2002 EWHC 1612 (Ch)
Re Rolls Razor Ltd (2) 1970 Ch 576
Sasea Finance Ltd v KPMG 1998 BCC 216
Legislation
South Africa
Ordinance 64 of 1829
Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965
Cape of Good Hope Ordinance 64 of 1829
Citation of Constitutional Laws Act 5 of 2005
Companies Act 61 of 1973
Companies Act 71 of 2008
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Insolvency Act 24 of 1936
National Credit Act 34 of 2005
UK
Company Directors Disqualification Act, 1986
Insolvency Act, 1986
Internet sources
Lawcite Date Unknown http://www.saflii.org/cgi-bin/LawCite?cit=1996+ZACC+2
Lawcite Date Unknown Bernstein v Bester http://www.saflii.org/cgi-bin/LawCite?cit=1996+ZACC+2 accessed 27 July 2013
Merriam Webster Date Unknown Draconian http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/draconian accessed
Merriam Webster Date Unknown Draconian http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/draconian accessed 24 July 2013
Robinson Date Unknown http://www.practicallaw.com/5-521-0528
Robinson T Date Unknown Duty to Co-operate with Office-holder Under s 235 of the Insolvency Act 1986 http://www.practicallaw.com/5-521-0528 accessed 27 July 2013
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Yvette Joubert, Juanitta Calitz
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}