A Historical Overview of the Regulation of Market Abuse in South Africa

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i3a2275

Keywords:

insider trading, market abuse, regulation, financial markets, market manipulation

Abstract

In an early attempt to combat market abuse in the South African financial markets, legislation such as the Companies Act, the Financial Markets Control Act and the Stock Exchanges Control Act were enacted. However, these Acts failed to effectively curb market abuse activities that were allegedly rife in the financial markets. Consequently, the Insider Trading Act was enacted and came into effect on 17 January 1999. While the introduction of the Insider Trading Act brought some confidence in the financial markets, market abuse activities were still not extinguished. The provisions of the Insider Trading Act were to some extent inadequate and ineffectively implemented. Eventually, the Securities Services Act was enacted to repeal all the flawed provisions of the Insider Trading Act. Notwithstanding these efforts on the part of the legislature, more may still need to be done to increase the number of convictions and settlements in cases involving market abuse in South Africa. It is against this background that a historical overview analysis of the regulation of market abuse is carried out in this article to expose the flaws that were previously embedded in the South African market abuse laws prior to 2004. This is done to raise awareness of the situation on the part of the relevant stakeholders, as they consider whether such flaws were adequately resolved or subsequently re-introduced under the Securities Services Act and the Financial Markets Act. To this end, the article firstly discusses the historical development and regulation of market manipulation prior to 2004. Secondly, the regulation and enforcement of insider trading legislation prior to 2004 are examined. Moreover, where possible, certain flaws of the previous market abuse laws that were re-incorporated into the current South African market abuse legislation are isolated and recommendations are made in that regard.

    

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Literature

Benade et al Entrepreneurial Law

Benade ML et al Entrepreneurial Law 3rd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2003)

Beuthin and Luiz Basic Company Law

Beuthin RC and Luiz SM Beuthin`s Basic Company Law 3rd ed (Butterworths Durban 2000)

Bhana 1987 SAJBM

Bhana N "Take-Over Announcements and Insider Trading Activity on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange" 1987 SAJBM 198-208

Botha 1990 SALJ

Botha D "Increased Maximum Fine for Insider Trading: A Realistic and Effective Deterrent?" 1990 SALJ 504-508

Botha 1991 SA Merc LJ

Botha D "Control of Insider Trading in South Africa: A Comparative Analysis" 1991 SA Merc LJ 1-18

Chanetsa Business Report

Chanetsa B "Insider Trading is Notoriously Hard to Prosecute" Business Report (26 April 2004) Page number unknown

Chitimira Regulation of Insider Trading

Chitimira H The Regulation of Insider Trading in South Africa: A Roadmap for an Effective, Competitive and Adequate Regulatory Statutory Framework (LLM-dissertation UFH 2008)

Chitimira Comparative Analysis

Chitimira H A Comparative Analysis of the Enforcement of Market Abuse Provisions (LLD-thesis NMMU 2012)

Henning and Du Toit 2000 JJS

Henning JJ and Du Toit S "The Regulation of False Trading, Market Manipulation and Insider Trading" 2000 JJS 155-165

Jooste 1990 De Ratione

Jooste R "Insider Dealing in South Africa - The Criminal Aspects" 1990 De Ratione 21-28

Jooste 1991 BML

Jooste R "Insider Trading: A New Clamp-Down" 1991 BML 248-250

Jooste 2000 SALJ

Jooste R "The Regulation of Insider Trading in South Africa - Another Attempt" 2000 SALJ 284-305

Jooste 2006 SALJ

Jooste R "A critique of the insider trading provisions of the 2004 Securities Services Act" 2006 SALJ 437-460

King Task Group First Report

King Task Group into Insider Trading Legislation First Report (15 May 1997)

King Task Group Final Report

King Task Group into Insider Trading Legislation Final Report (21 October 1997)

King Task Group Minority Report

King Task Group into Insider Trading Legislation Minority Report on Insider Trading (1997)

Luiz 1990 SA Merc LJ

Luiz SM "Prohibition Against Trading on Inside Information - The Saga Continues" 1990 SA Merc LJ 328-332

Luiz 1999 SA Merc LJ

Luiz SM "Insider Trading Regulation - If at First You Don't Succeed…" 1999 SA Merc LJ 136-151

Milne et al Henochsberg

Milne A et al Henochsberg on the Companies Act 3rd ed (Butterworths Durban 1975)

Osode 1999 AJICL

Osode PC "The Regulation of Insider Trading in South Africa: A Public Choice Perspective" 1999 AJICL 688-708

Osode 2000 J Afr L

Osode PC "The new South African Insider Trading Act: Sound law reform or legislative overkill?" 2000 J Afr L 239-263

Van der Lingen 1997 FSB Bulletin

Van der Lingen B "Tougher Legislation to Combat Insider Trading" 1997 FSB Bulletin 10

Van Deventer 1999 FSB Bulletin

Van Deventer G "New watchdog for insider trading" 1999 FSB Bulletin 3

Van Wyk de Vries Commission Report

Van Wyk de Vries Commission of Inquiry into the Companies Act Report (1963)

Van Zyl 1992 Transactions of the Center for Business Law

Van Zyl FH "Aspekte van Beleggersbeskerming in die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg" 1992 Transactions of the Center for Business Law 231-357

Case law

Percival v Wright 1902 2 Ch 421

Pretorius v Natal South Sea Investment Trust 1965 3 SA 410 (W)

Legislation

Companies Act 61 of 1973

Companies Act 71 of 2008

Companies Amendment Act 78 of 1989

Companies Amendment Act 37 of 1999

Financial Markets Act 19 of 2012

Financial Markets Control Act 55 of 1989

Insider Trading Act 135 of 1998

Second Companies Amendment Act 69 of 1990

Securities Services Act 36 of 2004

Stock Exchanges Control Act 1 of 1985

Government publications

Draft Financial Markets Bill, 2011

Financial Markets Bill [B12-2012]

Gen N 724 in GG 18868 of 8 May 1998 (Explanatory Remarks on Disclosure Requirements)

Memorandum on the Objects of the Companies Second Amendment Bill, 1989 [B99-89] (GA)

Memorandum on the Objects of the Companies Second Amendment Bill, 1990 [B119-90] (GA)

Internet sources

Barron 2014 http://www.timeslive.co.za/Feeds/2014/02/02/greg-draws-a-blank-in-belfort-parallel

Barron C 2014 Greg Draws a Blank in Belfort Parallel http://www.timeslive.co.za/Feeds/2014/02/02/greg-draws-a-blank-in-belfort-parallel accessed 3 March 2014

Bhattacharya and Daouk Date Unknown http://www.faculty.

fuqua.duke.edu/~charvey/Teaching/BA453_2004/BD_The world.pdf

Bhattacharya U and Daouk H Date Unknown The World Price of Insider Trading http://www.faculty.fuqua.duke.edu/~charvey/Teaching/BA453_2004/BD_The world.pdf accessed 19 June 2004

Blincoe 2001 http://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/05/23/datatec_directors_pay_up/

Blincoe R 2001 Datatec Directors Pay Up on Insider Trading Charges http://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/05/23/datatec_directors_pay_up/ accessed 3 March 2014

JSE 2013 http://www.jse.co.za/Libraries/JSE_Regulatory_Environment_Insider_Trading/InsiderTrading_Booklet.sflb.ashx

Johannesburg Stock Exchange 2013 Insider Trading and Other Market Abuses (Including the Effective Management of Price–sensitive Information) in the Insider Trading Booklet http://www.jse.co.za/Libraries/JSE_Regulatory_Environment_Insider_Trading/InsiderTrading_Booklet.sflb.ashx accessed 3 March 2014

Loubser 2006 http://www.jse.co.za/public/insider/JSEbooklet.pdf

Loubser R 2006 Insider Trading and other Market Abuses (Including the Effective Management of Price–sensitive Information) in the Insider Trading Booklet final draft http://www.jse.co.za/public/insider/JSEbooklet.pdf accessed 3 March 2014

Myburgh and Davis 2004 http://www.genesis-analytics.com/public/FSBReport.pdf

Myburgh A and Davis B 2004 The Impact of South Africa's Insider Trading Regime: A Report for the Financial Services Board http://www.genesis-analytics.com/public/FSBReport.pdf accessed 9 February 2009

Van Deventer 2008 http://www.fsb.co.za/public/marketabuse/FSBReport.pdf

Van Deventer G 2008 Anti-Market Abuse Legislation in South Africa http://www.fsb.co.za/public/marketabuse/ FSBReport.pdf accessed 5 May 2009

Published

2017-04-24

How to Cite

Chitimira, H. (2017). A Historical Overview of the Regulation of Market Abuse in South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 17(3), 936–971. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i3a2275

Issue

Section

Articles

Most read articles by the same author(s)