Common Problems Affecting Supranational Attempts in Africa: An Analytical Overview

  • Babatunde Fagbayibo University of South africa
Keywords: Supranationalism, African integration, East African Community, Southern Africa Customs Union, Economic Community of West African States, OHADA, West African Economic and Monetary Union, Central African Economic and Monetary Community

Abstract

Ever since the colonial era, attempts have been made throughout the various regions of Africa at building supranational units chiefly for administrative and legal convenience. Examples of such attempts include the Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasaland, the East African High Commission and the federations in former French West and Equatorial Africa, all of which were attempts at forging a supranational nation state. These experiments laid the foundation for further supranational initiatives in post-colonial Africa. In this respect, every region in Africa has either experimented with or is currently experimenting with the idea of supranational regional organisations. This article aims at investigating selected attempts at supranationalism on the continent, the successes and failures of such experiments, and the lessons to be learnt from them. As Africa embarks on the journey of solidifying its unity through the establishment of leviathan continental institutions, efforts should be geared towards building on the experiences of past and present experiments at the sub-regional level. Such experiments offer instructive lessons as they are rooted in similar historical and social contexts.

    

References

Bibliography

Adebajo 2005 Internationale Politik und Geselleschaft

Adebajo A "The Curse of Berlin: Africa’s Security Dilemmas" 2005 Internationale Politik und Geselleschaft 83-98

Alden and Soko 2005 JMAS

Alden C and Soko M "South Africa’s Economic Relations with Africa: Hegemony and its Discontents" 2005 JMAS 367-392

Alexander, Oleynik and Oliynik WAEMU Business Law Handbook

Alexander N, Oleynik G and Oliynik S (eds) West African Economic and Monetary Union (WAEMU) Business Law Handbook (International Business Publications Washington, DC 2003)

Asante Political Economy of Regionalism

Asante SKB The Political Economy of Regionalism in Africa: A Decade of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) (Praeger New York 1986)

AU and ECA Assessing Regional Integration

African Union and Economic Commission for Africa Assessing Regional Integration in Africa (ECA Addis Ababa 2004)

Bakare The Punch

Bakare W 'ECOWAS, Media and Challenges of Integration' The Punch 2 January 2009 67

Banfield "Structure and Administration"

Banfield J "The Structure and Administration of the East African Common Services Organisation" in Leys C and Robson P (eds) Federation in East Africa: Opportunities and Problems (Oxford University Press Oxford 1965) 30-40

Cilliers 2008 Institute of Security Studies Papers

Cilliers J "The African Standby Force: An Update on Progress" 2008 Institute of Security Studies Paper 160 1-24

Dashwood 1998 E L Rev

Dashwood A "States in the European Union" 1998 E L Rev 201-216

Delupis East African Community

Delupis I The East African Community and Common Market (Longman London 1970)

Dickerson 2005 Colum J Transnat'l L

Dickerson C "Harmonising Business Law in Africa: OHADA Calls the Tune" 2005 Colum J Transnat'l L 17-73

Dowden Africa

Dowden R Africa: Altered States, Ordinary Miracles (Portobello Books London 2008)

Dugard International Law

Dugard J International Law: A South African Perspective (Juta Cape Town 2005)

Fagbayibo 2009 CILSA

Fagbayibo B "Towards the Harmonistion of Laws in Africa: Is OHADA the Way to Go?" 2009 CILSA 309-322

Fredland "Who Killed the East African Community"

Fredland R "Who Killed the East African Community?" in Potholm C and Fredland R (eds) Integration and Disintegration in East Africa (University Press of America Lanham 1980) 63-80

Garba Diplomatic Soldering

Garba J Diplomatic Soldering: The Conduct of Nigerian Foreign Policy, 1975-1979 (Spectrum Books Ibadan1987)

Gibb 1997 JSAS

Gibb R "Regional Integration in Post-Apartheid Southern Africa: The Case of Renegotiating the Southern African Customs Union" 1997 JSAS 67-86

Gregorian "Plowshares into Swords"

Gregorian H "Plowshares into Swords: The Former Member States and the 1978-1979 War" in Fredland R and Potholm C (eds) Integration and Disintegration in East Africa (University Press of America Lanham, MD 1980) 167-191

Hay Federalism and Supranational Organisation

Hay P Federalism and Supranational Organisation: Patterns of New Legal Structure (University of Illinois Press Urbana 1966)

Kufuor 1996 Afr J Int’l Comp L

Kufuor K "Securing Compliance with the Judgments of the ECOWAS Court of Justice" 1996 Afr J Int’l Comp L 1-11

Kufuor Institutional Transformation

Kufuor K The Institutional Transformation of the Economic Community of West African States (Ashgate London 2006)

La Porta et al 1998 Journal of Political Economy

La Porta R et al "Law and Finance" 1998 Journal of Political Economy 1113-1155

Lavergne Regional Integration and Cooperation in West Africa

Regional Integration and Cooperation in West Africa: A Multidimensional Perspective (African World Press Trenton, NJ 1997)

Masson and Pattillo Monetary Union in West Africa

Masson P and Pattillo C Monetary Union in West Africa (ECOWAS): Is it Desirable and How Could it be Achieved? (IMF Washington, DC 2001)

Mazzeo "Experience of the East African Community"

Mazzeo D "The Experience of the East African Community: Implications for the Theory and Practice of Regional Cooperation in Africa" in Mazzeo D (ed) African Regional Organisations (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1984) 150-170

Molle 1997 Inter-American Development Bank Working Paper Series

Molle W "Economic integration and equal distribution" 1997 Inter-American Development Bank Working Paper Series 216 1-41

Mugomba 1978 JMAS

Mugomba A "Regional Organisations and African Underdevelopment: The Collapse of the East African Community" 1978 JMAS 261-272

Ngwenya 2002 Sisebenze Sonke

Ngwenya S "Fair Deal: The New SACU Draft Agreement" 2002 Sisebenze Sonke 24-32

Odhiambo "East African Customs Union"

Odhiambo W "The East African Customs Union and its Implications" in Ajulu R (ed) The Making of a Region: The Revival of the East African Community (Institute for Global Dialogue Midrand 2005) 214-242

Ojeinda 2005 E Afr J Peace & Hum Rts

Ojeinda T "The East African Court of Justice in the Reestablished East African Community: Institutional Structure and Function in the Integration Process" 2005 E Afr J Peace & Hum Rts 220-240

Pescatore Law of Integration

Pescatore P The Law of Integration (Sijthoff Leiden 1974)

Shaw International Law

Shaw M International Law (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1997)

Springer "Community Chronology"

Springer A "Community Chronology" in Fredland R and Potholm C (eds) Integration and Disintegration in East Africa (University Press of America Lanham 1980) 3-36

Thompson Africa and Unity

Thompson V Africa and Unity: The Evolution of Pan-Africanism (Longman London 1969)

Thompson 1990 Afr J Int’l Comp L

Thompson B "Legal Problems of Economic Integration in West African Sub-region" 1990 Afr J Int’l Comp L 85-101

Umozurike Introduction to International Law

Umozurike U Introduction to International Law (Spectrum Ibadan 2005)

Weiler 1981 YEL

Weiler J "The Community System: the Dual Character of Supranationalism” 1981 YEL 267-306

Register of treaties and other international instruments

African Union (AU) Constitutive Act (2001)

Central African Economic and Monetary Community (CEMAC) Treaty (1994)

East African Community (EAC) Treaty (1999)

Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) Treaty (1975) and the Revised ECOWAS Treaty (1993)

Organisation for the Harmonization of Business Law in Africa (OHADA) Treaty (1993)

Protocol on the Establishment of the East African Customs Union (2009)

Southern African Customs Union (SACU) Agreement (2002)

Treaty for East African Cooperation (1967)

West African Economic and Monetary Union (UEMOA) Treaty (1994)

Register of internet sources

Alves, Draper and Halleson 2007 http://bit.ly/YB4KZQ

Alves P, Draper P and Halleson D 2007 SACU, Regional Integration and the Overlap Issue in Southern Africa: From Spaghetti to Cannelloni http://bit.ly/YB4KZQ [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

Busch 2009 http://bit.ly/WPcxpp

Busch G 2009 The CFA, ECOWAS and Monetary Union http://bit.ly/WPcxpp [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

Carton and Cousin 2007 http://bit.ly/16dnpA9

Carton A and Cousin B 2007 OHADA: A Common Legal System Providing a Reliable Legal and Judicial Environment in Africa for Foreign Investors http://bit.ly/16dnpA9 [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

CEMAC Date unknown http://bit.ly/ZMMIpU

Central African Economic and Monetary Community Date unknown Home Page http://bit.ly/ZMMIpU [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

Cilliers 2005 http://bit.ly/14nsKqk

Cilliers J 2005 Towards a Continental Early Warning System for Africa http://bit.ly/14nsKqk [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

EAC Date unknown http://bit.ly/X13X8f

East African Community Date unknown Home Page http://bit.ly/X13X8f [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

ECOWAS Date unknown http://bit.ly/YtEMgE

Economic Community of West African States Date unknown Home Page http://bit.ly/YtEMgE [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

EC Date unknown http://bit.ly/YPSEv1

European Commission Date unknown Home Page http://bit.ly/YPSEv1 [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

Habib, Muchie and Padayachee 2006 http://bit.ly/ZQestQ

Habib A, Muchie M and Padayachee P 2006 African Integration and Civil Society: The Case of the African Union http://bit.ly/ZQestQ [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

IMF 2001 http://bit.ly/WRp0J0

International Monetary Fund 2001 West African Economic and Monetary Union: Recent Economic Developments and Regional Policy Issues in 2000 http://bit.ly/WRp0J0 [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

IMF 2005 http://bit.ly/YDkvPV

International Monetary Fund 2005 Central African Economic and Monetary Community: Recent Developments and Regional Policy Issues http://bit.ly/YDkvPV [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

MacClanahan 2004 http://bit.ly/10daoCG

MacClanahan Y 2004 Supranational Integration: Explaining the Distinctive Levels of Sovereignty Transferral between the Different Integrated Areas http://bit.ly/10daoCG [date of use 20 Jun 2012]

Ncube and Akena 2012 http://bit.ly/14juxwz

Ncube J and Akena A 2012 A Stream Cannot Rise Above its Source: Financing of Africa’s Regional Integration http://bit.ly/14juxwz [date of use 16 Nov 2012]

Obayuwana and Okwe 2009 http://bit.ly/108o2FO

Obayuwana O and Okwe M 2009 Nigeria, Ghana, Others Yet to Meet Conditions for Eco Currency http://bit.ly/108o2FO [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

OHADA Date unknown http://bit.ly/108BPfz

OHADA Date unknown Home Page http://bit.ly/108BPfz [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

Oxfam, IANSA and Saferworld 2007 http://bit.ly/ZlTq6j

Oxfam, IANSA and Saferworld 2007 Africa’s Missing Billions http://bit.ly/ZlTq6j [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

SACU Date unknown http://bit.ly/102Dxkm

Southern African Customs Union Date unknown Home Page http://bit.ly/102Dxkm [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

WAEMU Date unknown http://bit.ly/X50p55

West African Economic and Monetary Union Date unknown Home Page http://bit.ly/X50p55 [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

World Bank Date unknown http://bit.ly/ZQjAy5

World Bank Date unknown Central Africa: CEMAC - Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa http://bit.ly/ZQjAy5 [date of use 27 Sep 2012]

Published
2017-04-26
How to Cite
FagbayiboB. (2017). Common Problems Affecting Supranational Attempts in Africa: An Analytical Overview. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 16(1), 31-69. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i1a2303
Section
Articles