Ecosystem Services and International Water Law: towards a more effective determination and implementation of Equity?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i2a2343Keywords:
Ecosystem services, International water law, Trans-boundary watercourses, Reasonable and equitable use of water, Natural resource managementAbstract
Interest in an ecological- or an ecosystem-centred approach to natural resource management is not new, and in the case of water management has been very well emphasised for many decades. Recently however, a new focus has emerged around the identification and assessment of ecosystem services, and the potential to somehow use valuation of these services as a basis for more effective management of natural and human-linked systems. Despite this growing recognition, attempts to apply such an approach to transboundary watercourses are few and far between. While key principles of international water law, for example, equitable and reasonable utilisation, are not in conflict with an ecosystem services approach; significant challenges remain in its implementation. However, as the methods and tools used to identify ecosystem services improve, it is likely that such an approach will offer an important means by which to reconcile competing interests over shared watercourses in the future.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Allan and Rieu-Clarke 2010 Irrigation and Drainage Systems
Allan A and Rieu-Clarke A "Good Governance and IWRM – A Legal Perspective" 2010 Irrigation and Drainage Systems 239-248
Aylward et al "Freshwater Ecosystem Services"
Aylward B et al "Freshwater Ecosystem Services" in Hassan R, Scholes R and Ash N Ecosystem and Human Well-being: Current State and Trends (Island Press Washington DC 2005) 213-255
Bateman et al 2011 Environmental and Resource Economics
Bateman IJ et al “Economic Analysis for Ecosystem Service Assessments” 2011 Environmental and Resource Economics 177-218
Bateman et al "Economic Values from Ecosystems"
Bateman IJ et al “Economic Values from Ecosystems” in The UK National Ecosystem Assessment Technical Report (UNEP-WCMC Cambridge 2011) 1067-1151
Bateman et al "Valuing Changes in Ecosystem Services"
Bateman IJ et al "Valuing Changes in Ecosystem Services: Scenario Analyses" in The UK National Ecosystem Assessment Technical Report (UNEP-WCMC Cambridge 2011) 1265-1307
Benvenisti 1996 AJIL
Benvenisti E "Collection Action in the Utilization of Shared Freshwater: The Challenges of International Water Resources Law" 1996 AJIL 384-415
Benvenisti Sharing Transboundary Resources
Benvenisti E Sharing Transboundary Resources – International Law and optimal Resource Use (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2002)
Berber Rivers in International Law
Berber FJ Rivers in International Law (Stevens London 1959)
Biswas 2004 Water International
Biswas AK "Integrated Water Resources Management: A Reassessment – A Water Forum Contribution" 2004 Water International 248-256
Biswas 2008 Journal of Water Resources Development
Biswas AK "Integrated Water Resources Management: Is it Working?" 2008 International Journal of Water Resources Development 5-22
Blanco and Razzaque 2009 Hum Rts Q
Blanco E and Razzaque J "Ecosystem Services and Human Well-Being in a Globalised World: Assessing the Role of Law" 2009 Hum Rts Q 692-720
Bogdanović (ed) International Law of Water Resources
Bogdanović S (ed) International Law of Water Resources – Contribution of the International Law Association (1954-2000) (Kluwer Law International The Hague 2004)
Bond and Mayers Fair Deals for Watershed Services
Bond I and Mayers J Fair Deals for Watershed Services: Lessons from a Multi-country Action-learning Project (IEED London 2010)
Bourne 1972 UTLJ
Bourne CB "Procedure in the Development of International Drainage Basins" 1971 UTLJ 172-206
Brown Weiss Evolution of International Water Law
Brown Weiss E The Evolution of International Water Law (Martinus Nijhoff The Hague 2009)
Brunée and Toope 1994 Yearbook of International Environmental Law
Brunée J and Toope S "Environmental Security and Freshwater Resources: A Case for International Ecosystem Law" 1994 Yearbook of International Environmental Law 41-76
Bruch et al "From Theory to Practice"
Bruch C et al "From Theory to Practice: An Overview of Approaches to Involving the Public in International Watershed Management" in Bruch C et al (eds) Public Participation in the Governance of International Freshwater Resources (United Nations University Tokyo 2005) 3-18
Burchi and Mechlem Groundwater in International Water Law
Burchi S and Mechlem K Groundwater in International Water Law (FAO Rome 2005)
Cook and Spray 2012 Journal of Environmental Management
Cook BR and Spray CJ "Ecosystem Services and Integrated Water Resource Management: Different Paths to the Same End?" 2012 109 Journal of Environmental Management 93-100
Costanza et al 1997 Nature
Costanza R et al "The Value of the World’s Ecosystem Services and Natural Capital" 1997 Nature 253-260
Dellapenna and Gupta Evolution of the Law and Politics of Water
Dellapenna JW and Gupta JW The Evolution of the Law and Politics of Water (Springer Berlin 2009)
Dombrovsky Conflict, Cooperation and Institutions
Dombrovsky I Conflict, Cooperation and Institutions in International Water Management – An Economic Analysis (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2007)
Duraiappah Markets for Ecosystem Services
Duraiappah AK Markets for Ecosystem Services – A Potential Tool for Multilateral Environmental Agreements (IISD Winnipeg 2007)
Duit et al 2010 Global Environmental Change
Duit A et al "Governance, Complexity and Resilience" 2010 Global Environmental Change 363-368
FAO and UNEP Atlas of International Freshwater Agreements
FAO and UNEP Atlas of International Freshwater Agreements (UNEP Nairobi 2002)
Feldman and Blaustein 2007 Env’t L Rep
Feldman IR and Blaustein RJ "Ecosystem Services as a Framework for Law and Policy" 2007 Env’t L Rep 1-34
Fisher and Turner 2008 Biological Conservation
Fisher B and Turner RK "Ecosystem Services: Classification for Valuation" 2008 Biological Conservation 1167-1169
Global Water Partnership Technical Advisory Committee Integrated Water Resources Management
Global Water Partnership Technical Advisory Committee Integrated Water Resources Management (GWP Stockholm 2000)
Ganoulis & Skoulikaris A Conceptual Model
Ganoulis J & Skoulikaris Ch (2011) A Conceptual Model for Implementing Integrated Transboundary Water Resources Management (ITWRM) Proc 2nd International Symposium on Building Knowledge Bridges for a Sustainable Water Future, Panama, 21-24 November, 2011 (Panama Canal Authority (ACP) and UNESCO 2011) 99-103
Graham "Mythology of Environmental Markets"
Graham N "The Mythology of Environmental Markets" in Grinlinton DP and Taylor P (eds) Property Rights and Sustainability (Martinus Nijhoff Leiden 2011) 149-166
Greiber et al Conservation with Justice
Greiber T et al Conservation with Justice – A Rights-based Approach (IUCN Gland 2009)
Haines-Young and Potschin "Links Between Biodiversity"
Haines-Young R and Potschin M "The Links Between Biodiversity, Ecosystem Services and Human Well-being" in Rafaelli DG and Frid CJ (eds) Ecosystem Ecology: A New Synthesis (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2010) 110-139
Hamerlynck et al 2011 Hydrological Sciences Journal
Hamerlynck O et al "To Connect or Not to Connect? Floods, Fisheries and Livelihoods in the Lower Rufiji Floodplain Lakes, Tanzania" 2011 Hydrological Sciences Journal 1436-1451
Hardin 1968 Science
Hardin G "The Tragedy of the Commons" 1968 Science 1243-1248
Hassan, Scholes and Ash Ecosystem and Human Well-being
Hassan R, Scholes R and Ash N Ecosystem and Human Well-being: Current State and Trends (Island Press Washington DC 2005)
Irwin and Ranganathan Restoring Nature’s Capital
Irwin F and Ranganathan J Restoring Nature’s Capital – An Action Agenda to Sustain Ecosystem Services (WRI Washington DC 2007)
ISARM Atlas of Transboundary Aquifers
ISARM Atlas of Transboundary Aquifers (UNESCO Paris 2009)
Jax 2007 Acta Biotheoretica
Jax K "Can we Define Ecosystems? On the Confusion Between Definition and Description of Ecological Concepts" 2008 Acta Biotheoretica 341-355
Kumar Economics of Ecosystems
Kumar P The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity: Ecological and Economic Foundations (London Earthscan 2010)
Landell-Mills and Porras Silver Bullet or Fool’s Gold?
Landell-Mills N and Porras I Silver Bullet or Fool’s Gold? A Global Review of Markets for Forest Environmental Services and their Impacts on the Poor (IIED London 2002)
Maltby and Acreman 2011 Hydrological Sciences Journal
Maltby E and Acreman MC "Ecosystem Services of Wetlands: Pathfinder for a New Paradigm" 2011 Hydrological Sciences Journal 1341-1359
Maltby et al "Freshwaters"
Maltby, Ormerod, Acreman, Blackwell, Durance, Everard, Morris & Spray "Freshwaters – Openwaters, Wetlands and Floodplains" in The UK National Ecosystem Assessment Technical Report (UNEP-WCMC Cambridge 2011) 295-365
McCaffrey 1992 AJPIL
McCaffrey SC "The Evolution of the Law of International Watercourses" 1992 AJPIL 87-111
McCaffrey 1996 Natural Resources Journal
McCaffrey SC "The Harmon Doctrine One Hundred Years Later: Buried, not Praised" 1996 Natural Resources Journal 549-590
McCaffrey 2000 JLREL
McCaffrey SC "An Overview of the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Non-navigational Uses of International Watercourses" 2000 JLREL 55-75
McCaffrey Law of International Watercourses
McCaffrey SC The Law of International Watercourses 2nd ed (Oxford University Press London 2007)
McCaffrey and Neville "Politics of Sharing Water"
McCaffrey SC and Neville K "The Politics of Sharing Water: International Law, Sovereignty, and Transboundary Rivers and Aquifers" in Wegerich K and Warner J The Politics of Water – A Survey (Routledge London 2010) 18-44
McIntyre 2004 RECIEL
McIntyre O "The Emergence of an 'Ecosystem Approach' to the Protection of International Watercourses under International Law" 2004 RECIEL 1-14
McIntyre Environmental Protection of International Watercourses
McIntyre O Environmental Protection of International Watercourses (Ashgate London 2007)
Mitchell 2005 Environment and Planning
Mitchell B "Integrated Water Resources Management: Institutional Arrangements and Land-use Planning" 2005 Environment and Planning 1335-1352
Norgaard 2010 Ecological Economics
Norgaard RB "Ecosystem Services: From Eye-opening Metaphor to Complexity Blinder" 2010 Ecological Economics 1219-1227
Ostrom Governing the Commons
Ostrom E Governing the Commons – The Evolution of Institutions and Collective Action (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1990)
Porras, Grieg-Gran and Neves All that Glitters
Porras I, Grieg-Gran M and Neves N All that Glitters – A Review of Payments for Watershed Services in Developing Countries (IIED London 2008)
Revenga et al Watersheds of the World
Revenga C et al Watersheds of the World: Ecological Value and Vulnerability (Worldwatch Institute Washington DC 1988)
Rieu-Clarke "International Freshwater Law"
Rieu-Clarke A "International Freshwater Law" in Shawkat A and Techera E Handbook of International Environmental Law (Routledge London 2012) 243-257
Rieu-Clarke International Law and Sustainable Development
Rieu-Clarke A International Law and Sustainable Development (IWA London 2005)
Rieu-Clarke et al "Science-Policy-Stakeholder Interface"
Rieu-Clarke A et al "The Science-Policy-Stakeholder Interface and Participation" in Gooch GD and Stalnacke P (eds) Science, Policy and Stakeholders in Water Management (Earthscan London 2010) 29-50
Roy, Barr and Venema Ecosystem Approaches
Roy D, Barr J and Venema H Ecosystem Approaches in Integrated Water Resources Management (UNEP and IISD Nairobi 2011)
Ruhl, Kraft and Lant Law and Policy of Ecosystem Services
Ruhl JB, Kraft SE and Lant CL The Law and Policy of Ecosystem Services (Island Press Washington DC 2007)
Sabatier et al (eds) Swimming Upstream
Sabatier PA et al (eds) Swimming Upstream. Collaborative Approaches to Watershed Management (MIT Press Cambridge MA 2005)
Sadoff et al Share
Sadoff C et al Share – Managing Water Across Boundaries (IUCN Gland 2008)
Sadoff and Grey 2002 Water Policy
Sadoff CW and Grey D "Beyond the River: The Benefits of Cooperation on International Rivers" 2002 Water Policy 389-403
Sands Principles of International Environmental Law
Sands P Principles of International Environmental Law 2nd ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 2003)
Scanlon and Iza 2003 Yb Int’l Env L
Scanlon J and Iza A "International Legal Foundations for Environmental Flows" 2003 Yb Int’l Env L 81-100
Smith et al Pay
Smith M et al Pay – Establishing Payments for Watershed Services (IUCN Gland 2006)
Tanzi and Arcari United Nations Convention
Tanzi A and Arcari M The United Nations Convention on the Law of International Watercourses (Kluwer The Hague 2001)
Tarlock "Ecosystems"
Tarlock D "Ecosystems" in Bodansky D, Bruneé J and Hey E The Oxford Handbook of International Environmental Law (Oxford University Press Oxford 2007) 574-598
Turner, Georgiou and Fisher Valuation of Ecosystem Services
Turner RK, Georgiou S and Fisher B Valuation of Ecosystem Services: The Case of Multi-functional Wetland (Earthscan London 2008)
UK National Ecosystem Assessment Technical Report
UK National Ecosystem Assessment Technical Report (UNEP-WCMC Cambridge 2011)
UNECE Recommendations on Payments
UNECE Recommendations on Payments for Ecosystems Services in Integrated Water Resources Management (UN New York 2007)
Utton and Utton "Adequate Stream Flows"
Utton AE and Utton J "Adequate Stream Flows" in Bogdanović S (ed) International Law of Water Resources – Contribution of the International Law Association (1954-2000) (Kluwer Law International The Hague 2004) 387-413
Vilardy et al 2011 Hydrological Sciences Journal
Vilardy S et al "Relationships Between Hydrological Regimes and Ecosystem Services Supply in a Caribbean Coastal Wetland: A Social-ecological Approach" 2011 Hydrological Sciences Journal 1423-1435
Vörösmarty et al "Freshwater"
Vörösmarty CJ et al "Freshwater" in Hassan R, Scholes R and Ash N Ecosystem and Human Well-being: Current State and Trends (Island Press Washington DC 2005)
Wallace 2008 Biological Conservation
Wallace K "Ecosystem Services: Multiple Classifications or Confusion?" 2008 141 Biological Conservation 353-354
Wouters, Vinogradov and Magsig 2009 Yb Int’l Env L
Wouters PK, Vinogradov S and Magsig BO "Water Security, Hydrosolidarity and International Law: A River Runs Through It…" 2009 Yb Int’l Env L97-134
Zawahri and McLaughlin 2011 International Studies Quarterly
Zawahri NA and McLaughlin S "Fragmented Governance in International Rivers: Negotiating Bilateral Versus Multilateral Treaties" 2011 International Studies Quarterly 835-858
Register of legislation
National Water Act 36 of 1998
Register of international documents
Agreement on the Cooperation for the Sustainable Development of the Mekong River Basin (1995)
Convention on the Protection and Use of Transboundary Watercourses and International Lakes (1992) (Helsinki Convention)
Declaration of the UN Conference on Environment and Development (1992) (Rio Declaration)
Draft Articles on the Law of the Non-navigational Uses of International Watercourses (1994)
Draft International Covenant on Environment and Development (2004)
Dublin Statement on Water and Sustainable Development (1992)
EU Water Framework Directive (2000)
Tripartite Interim Agreement for Co-operation on the Protection and Sustainable Utilisation of the Water Resources of the Incomati and Maputo Watercourse (2002)
UN Convention on Biological Diversity (1992)
UN Convention on the Law of the Non-navigational Uses of International Watercourses (1997)
Register of cases
Case Concerning the Gabčíkovo-Nagymaros Project (Hung v Slovak) Sep 25 1997, 37 ILM 162 (1998)
Territorial Jurisdiction of the International Commission of the River Oder (UK, Czech, Den, Fr, Ger, Swed v Pol) (Judgement) [1929] PCIJ (Ser A) No 23
Würtemberg and Prussia v Baden Ann Dig 128 (1927-28)
Register of Internet sources
Ban Ki-Moon 2008 www.un.org
Ban Ki Moon 2008 Address as Prepared for Delivery to the Davos Work Economic Forum
www.un.org/apps/news/infocus/sgspeeches/search_full.asp?statID=177 [date of use 19 Feb 2012]
CBD 2010 www.cbd.int
Convention on Biological Diversity 2010 COP 5 Decision V/5 www.cbd.int/decision/cop/?id=7148 [date of use 19 Feb 2012]
ICWE 1992 www.wmo.int
International Conference on Water and the Environment 1992 Dublin Statement on Water and Sustainable Development www.wmo.int/pages/prog/hwrp/documents/english/icwedece.html [date of use 19 Feb 2012]
IUCN 2004 www.i-c-e-l.org
International Union for Conservation of Nature 2004 Draft International Covenant on Environment and Development www.i-c-e-l.org/indexen.html [date of use 18 Feb 2012]
IUCN and WWF 1998 www.uicmed.org
International Union for Conservation of Nature and World Wide Fund for Nature 1998 Strategic Approaches to Freshwater Management: Background Paper – The Ecosystem Approach
www.uicnmed.org/web2007/cdflow/conten/5/pdf/5-2-RAMSAR-Guidelines/Strategic-Freshwater-Manag/Strategic-Approach.htm [date of use 18 Feb 2012]
Schwebel 1980 untreaty.un.org
Schwebel S 1980 Second Report on the law of the non-navigational uses of international watercourses
untreaty.un.org/ilc/documentation/english/a_cn4_332.pdf [date of use 19 Feb 2012]
Schwebel 1982 untreaty.un.org
Schwebel S 1982 Third Report on the Law of the Non-navigational Uses of International Watercourses untreaty.un.org/ilc/documentation/english/
a_cn4_348.pdf [date of use 19 Feb 2012]
UN 1994 untreaty.un.org
United Nations 1994 Draft Articles on the Law of the Non-navigational Uses of International Watercourses
untreaty.un.org/ilc/documentation/english/a_cn4_l493.pdf [date of use 19 Feb 2012]
UN 1992 www.un.org
UN 1992 UNCED Agenda 21 www.un.org/esa/dsd/agenda21 [date of use 18 Feb 2012]
UN 2005 www.un.org
UN 2005 Johannesburg Plan of Action www.un.org/esa
/sustdev/documents/WSSD_POI_PD/English/POIToc.htm [date of use 18 Feb 2011]
UN-Water 2011 www.unwater.org
UN-Water 2011 Transboundary Waters: Sharing Benefits, Sharing Responsibilities www.unwater.org/downloads/UNW_TRANSBOUNDARY.pdf [date of use 21 Sep 2011]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Alistair Rieu-Clarke
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}