The Quest for a Supranational Entity in West Africa: Can the Economic Community of West African States attain the Status?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i3a2367Keywords:
Regional integration, ECOWAS Commission, Supranational entity, Intergovermental organisation, Community Court of JusticeAbstract
To reflect the growing trends in the international scene and in furtherance of the objective of its Revised 1993 Treaty, the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) summit in December 2006 revolutionised the structure of ECOWAS by re-designating the Executive Secretariat into a quasi-independent commission headed by a President with a Vice President and seven commissioners. The rationale behind the revision was to make ECOWAS a supranational entity. This article considers whether or not a supranational system is essential for the attainment of ECOWAS' objectives. It asks if the conditions for an effective supranational system are in place in the West African sub-region which could provide a solid foundation for its success and why the quest for a supranational system has not yielded any fruitful result in West Africa. It argues that a retreat from the quest for supranationalism and a return to an inter-governmental system would be a retreat rather than the way forward, and expresses the need for the course of action to be sustained courageously till the impact of integration begins to emerge, and the disguised, patriotic impulse of states to protect their national sovereignty gives way to the full manifestation of ECOWAS as a supranational entity.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Abubakar "Implementing the Moratorium on Light Weapons"
Abubakar MK "Implementing the Moratorium on Light Weapons" in Anatole A and Ibrahima S (eds) Combating the Proliferation of Small Arms and Light Weapons in West Africa (UNIDIR United Nations 2005) 47-53
Adedeji 1970 Journal of Modern African Studies
Adedeji A "Prospects of Regional Economic Cooperation in West African" 1970 Journal of Modern African Studies 213-231
Aning 2000 Africa Security Review
Aning EK "Towards the New Millennium: ECOWAS's evolving conflict management system" 2000 Africa Security Review 50-63
Burton "Functionalism and the Resolution of Conflict"
Burton JW "Functionalism and the Resolution of Conflict" in Groom AJR and Taylor P (eds) Functionalism Theory and Practice in International Relations (University of London Press London 1975) 238-249
Cheong 2004 East Asian Review
Cheong SC "Establishing Supranational Institutions: European Lessons for a Unified Korea" 2004 East Asian Review 73-96
Dakas "Responsibility for International War Crimes"
Dakas CJ "Responsibility for International War Crimes, Peace and Security in West Africa: Issues, Dilemmas and Challenges" (Unpublished paper delivered at the National Conference of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) Abuja Nigeria August 2004)
Elkanah Daily Trust (Nig)
Elkanah C 'Ministers to hold talks on ECOWAS Commission' Daily Trust (Nig) 25 August 2006 10
Fukuyama State Building
Fukuyama F State Building: Governance and World Order in the 21st Century (Cornell University Press Ithaca 2004)
Hartog 1953 Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv
Hartog F "European Economic Integration: A Realistic Conception" 1953 Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv 165-181
Helman and Ratner 1992-1993 Foreign Policy
Helman Gerald and Ratner S "Saving failed states" 1992-1993 Foreign Policy 3-20
Horacio 1996 Law and Policy in International Business
Horacio G "Sovereignty and Regionalism" 1996 Law and Policy in International Business 1073-1180
Hugo Rights of War and Peace
Hugo G The Rights of War and Peace (Liberty Fund Indianapolis 2005)
Ijalaye "African Economic Community Treaty"
Ijalaye SAN "African Economic Community Treaty: Free Movement of Establishment" (Unpublished paper delivered at the International Conference on the African Economic Community 22-30 January 1992 Abuja Nigeria)
Jide The Guardian (Nig)
Jide O 'ECOWAS summit: Time for radical changes' The Guardian (Nig) 20 December 2001 14
Kufuor Institutional Transformation
Kufuor OK The Institutional Transformation of the Economic Community of West African States (Ashgate Surrey 2006)
Meltzer 2005 U Pa J Int'l Econ L
Meltzer JP "The legitimacy of the WTO" 2005 U Pa J Int'l Econ L 10-15
Michael The Punch (Nig)
Michael F 'ECOWAS: Ministry to enforce Protocol on Free Trade' The Punch (Nig) 23 November 2006 19
Nwakile "Degree of Commitment of Member States"
Nwakile BN "The Degree of Commitment of Member States to the Overall Objectives of ECOWAS" in Owosekun A (ed) Towards an African Economic Community: Lessons of Experience from ECOWAS (Nigeria Institute of Social and Economic Research Ibadan 1986) 135-154
Nwauche 2011 Journal of African Law
Nwauche ES "Enforcing ECOWAS Law in West African National Courts" 2011 Journal of African Law 181-202
Oghogho The Guardian (Nig) 4 April
Oghogbo O 'Dressing ECOWAS in a new garb' The Guardian (Nig) 4 April 2007 16
Oghogho The Guardian (Nig) 31 July
Oghogho O 'ECOWAS commission wills fast-track regional integration' The Guardian (Nig) 31 July 2007 17
Omoniyi "West Africa's Multiple Inter-Governmental Organisations"
Omoniyi A "West Africa's Multiple Inter-Governmental Organisations as Building Blocks for an African Common Market" in Owosekun A (ed) Towards an African Economic Community: Lessons of Experience from ECOWAS (Nigeria Institute of Social and Economic Research Ibadan 1986) 8-37
Onwuka "Role of ECOWAS"
Onwuka R "The Role of ECOWAS in Ensuring a Working Peace System" in Owosekun A (ed) Towards an African Economic Community: Lessons of Experience from ECOWAS (Nigeria Institute of Social and Economic Research Ibadan 1986) 374-392
Pfaff 1995 Foreign Affairs
Pfaff W "A new colonialism: Europe must go into Africa" 1995 Foreign Affairs 2-6
Raustiala 2006 Ga J In't & Comp Law
Raustiala K "Defining the limits of international law" 2006 Ga J In't & Comp Law 423- 444
Robinson 2003 Am U Int'l L Rev
Robinson M "Shaping Globalisation: The Role of Human Rights" 2003 Am U Int'l L Rev 1-26
Rodney How Europe Undeveloped Africa
Rodney W How Europe Underdeveloped Africa (Howard University Press Washington 1972)
Slaughter and Burke-White 2006 Harv Int'l LJ
Slaughter A-M and Burke-White W "The future of international law is domestic or, the European way of law" 2006 Harv Int'l LJ 327-352
Tallberg 2002 West European Politics
Tallberg J "Delegation to supranational institutions: Why, How and with What Consequences" 2002 West European Politics 23-46
Tilman 1995 Law and State
Tilman EK "Supranational statehood the case of the European Union: Civitas civitatum or monstrum" 1995 Law and State 31-48
Umozurike Introduction
Umozurike UO Introduction to International Law (Spectrum Books Limited Nigeria 2006)
West Brook 2008 Tex Int'l LJ
West Brook LJ "Legal Integration of NAFTA through supranational adjudication" 2008 Tex Int'l LJ 349-363
Register of cases
Dame Hadijatou Mani Koraou v Republic of Niger ECW/JUD/06/08
SERAP v The Federal Government of Nigeria ECW/CCJ/JUD/18/12
Register of international and regional instruments
ECOWAS Instruments
Amended Protocol of the Jurisdiction of the Court (2005)
Protocol A/P.1/5/79 Relating to Free Movement of Persons, Residence and Establishment (1979)
Protocol A/P.2/8/94 Relating to the Community Parliament (1994)
Protocol A/P.1/7/91 Establishing the Community Court of Justice (1991)
Protocol on Democracy and Good Governance (2001)
Protocol Relating to the Mechanism for Conflict Resolution, Management Resolution, Peace Keeping and Security (1999)
Revised Treaty of the Economic Community of West African States (1993)
Supplementary Protocol A/P1/7/91 (2005)
Supplementary Protocol A/SP.3/06/06 (Amending Protocol A/P.2/8/94 Relating to the Community Parliament) (2006)
Treaty of the Economic Community of West African States (1975)
Other
Association of Southeast Asian Nations Protocol on Enhanced Dispute Settlements Mechanisms (2009)
Maastricht Treaty of the European Union (1992)
Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (1998)
Treaty of Rome (1957)
United Nations Charter (1945)
Register of internet sources
Abuja 2009 http://www.bit.ly/15JrKu4
Abuja EM 2009 ECOWAS Can Survive Only on Regional Structures http://www.bit.ly/15JrKu4 [date of use 2 Jan 2013]
Adeleye 2007 http://www.bit.ly/172frYN
Adeleye S 2007 Anxiety as Cote D'Ivoire Signs Interim Trade Deal with EU http://www.bit.ly/172frYN [date of use 2 Jan 2013]
African Manager 2013 http://www.bit.ly/1bRm2MS
African Manager 2013 ECOWAS Single Currency for Launch in 2020 http://www.bit.ly/1bRm2MS [date of use 25 Feb 2013]
Bensah 2012 http://www.bitly/IpRzpK
Bensah EK 2012 From the Archives: Thirty Years of ECOWAS: An Appraisal http://www.bitly/IpRzpK [date of use 16 Jan 2013]
Cedeao ECOWAS 2013 http://www.bit.ly/12LPQ5g
Cedeao ECOWAS 2013 ECOWAS President Accredits Eight Envoys http://www.bit.ly/12LPQ5g [date of use 16 Feb 2013]
Comfort 1995 http://www.bit.ly/HdjiZV
Comfort E 1995 ECOWAS and the Sub Regional Peace Keeping in Liberia Journal of Humanitarian Assistance http://www.bit.ly/HdjiZV [date of use 18 Jan 2013]
Cooljoe 2012 http://www.bit.ly/Tl99Qk
Cooljoe 2012 Parliament and its Quest for Legislative powers General Nigeria Best Forum Topics http://www.bit.ly/Tl99Qk [date of use 18 Jan 2013]
ECOWAS 1999 http://www.bit.ly/18ZQVKI
ECOWAS 1999 Achievements and Prospects http://www.bit.ly/18ZQVKI [date of use 27 Aug 2013]
ECOWAS 2013 http://www.bit.ly/3mLrD7
ECOWAS 2013 ECOWAS Member States http://www.bit.ly/3mLrD7 [date of use 24 Jan 2013]
ECOWAS Commission 2007 http://www.bit.ly/1c39tg1
ECOWAS Commission 2007 Un Apercu de la Commission de la Cedeao http://www.bit.ly/1c39tg1 [date of use 20 Feb 2013]
ECOWAS Commission 2013 http://www.bit.ly/13HDChd
ECOWAS Commission 2013 ECOWAS Commission at a Glance http://www.bit.ly/13HDChd [date of use 24 Jan 2013]
Institute for Human Rights and Development in Africa 2013 http://www.bit.ly/145HifV
Institute for Human Rights and Development in Africa 2013 Court of Justice of Community Court of West African States http://www.bit.ly/145HifV [date of use 24 Feb 2013]
News Agency of Nigeria 2012 http://www.bit.ly/183JaSW
News Agency of Nigeria 2012 60% of ECOWAS Court's Judgments not Enforced - Chief Registrar http://www.bit.ly/183JaSW [date of use 27 Aug 2013]
OHADA Legis Date Unknown http://www.bit.ly/17kV2Ak
OHADA Legis Date Unknown Introducing OHADA http://www.bit.ly/17kV2Ak [date of use 26 Feb 2013]
Panapress 2005 http://www.bit.ly/192Q4MG
Panapress 2005 ECOWAS Lifts Sanctions on Togo http://www.bit.ly/192Q4MG [date of use 26 Jan 2013]
Tan and Samtani 2002 http://www.bit.ly/18BMhDh
Tan LH and Samtani A 2002 The Shifting Paradigm in Regional Economic Integration: The ASEAN Perspective http://www.bit.ly/18BMhDh [date of use 18 Feb 2013]
This Day Live 2012 http://www.bit.ly/172qq4z
This Day Live 2012 West African Common Currency: A Worthwhile Venture? http://www.bit.ly/172qq4z [date of use 18 Feb 2013]
Unachukwu 2008 http://www.bit.ly/16eo6br
Unachukwu JA 2008 Agbakoba Calls for Reform in Foreign Policy http://www.bit.ly/16eo6br [date of use 25 Feb 2013]
WAHO 2013 http://www.bit.ly/12LOzuU
WAHO 2013 About WAHO http://www.bit.ly/12LOzuU [date of use 23 Feb 2013]
WTO Date Unknown http://www.bit.ly/11Ws5w8
WTO Date Unknown Overview of Trade Facilitation Work in the WTO http://www.bit.ly/11Ws5w8 [date of use 20 Feb 2012]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Jadesola O Lokulo-Sodipe, Abiodun J Osuntogun
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}