The South African Defence Review (2012) and Private Military / Security Companies (PMSCs): Heralding a Shift from Prohibition to Regulation?

  • Laurence Juma Rhodes University
  • James Tsabora Rodes University
Keywords: Defence policy (South Africa), Regulation of Private Military/Security Companies (PMSCs), South African Defence Review (2012), UN Working Group on Mercenaries, AU Mercenary Convention, UN Mercenary Convention, Montreux Document, Prohibition of Mercenary

Abstract

This article discusses the possibility of South Africa enacting a new law regulating private military/security companies (PMSCs) beyond the Prohibition of Mercenary Activities and Regulation of Certain Activities in Country of Armed Conflict Act of 2006. It argues that such a possibility arises from the policy direction expressed in the Defence Review of 2012, and the recent developments at the international level, which indicate a shift towards accommodation of PMSCs as legitimate players in the security sector. The article surveys the current state of national and international law relating to PMSCs and illustrates how the emerging shift from prohibition to regulation has affirmed the need for legislative intervention in this field. It concludes that since the future is on the side of regulation and not prohibition, legislation that furthers the policy agenda envisioned by the Defence Review 2012 may be the best tool to unlock the inhibitions of the past and create a viable climate for reframing the debate on domestic law governing private militarism in South Africa.

   ScienceOpen_Log0343290.png

References

Bibliography

Abrahams "Contemporary Legal Environment"

Abrahams G "The Contemporary Legal Environment" in Mills G and Stremlau J (eds) The Privatisation of Security in Africa (SAIIA Johannesburg 1999) 81-106

Abrahamsen and William 2007 Int'l Relations

Abrahamsen A and William M "Securing the city: Private security companies and none-state authority in global governance" 2007 Int'l Relations 237-253

Amann 2005 U Pa L Rev

Amann D "Abu Ghraib" 2005 U Pa L Rev 2085-2141

Barker 2005 Int'l Affairs

Barker J "The new South African foreign policy: Principle and practice" 2005 Int'l Affairs 1079-1096

Barlow Executive Outcomes

Barlow E Executive Outcomes: Against All Odds (Galago Alberton 2008)

Bosch and Maritz 2011 PELJ

Bosch S and Maritz M "South African private security contractors active in armed conflict: Citizenship, prosecution and the right to work" 2011 14(7) PELJ 71-125

Brooks 2007 JIPO

Brooks D "In Search of Adequate Legal and Regulatory Frameworks" 2007 2(5) JIPO 4-14

Bryton 2002 J Int Aff

Bryton S "Outsourcing war: mercenaries and the privatization of peacekeeping" 2002 J Int Aff 303-329

Cashore, Auld and Newsom Governing Through Markets

Cashore BW, Auld G and Newsom D Governing Through Markets: Forest Certification and the Emergence of Non-state Authority (Yale University Press New Haven 2004)

Cilliers and Cornwell 1999 ASR

Cilliers J and Cornwell R "Mercenaries and the Privatisation of Security in Africa" 1999 8(2) ASR 31-42

Cockayne 2009 JCSL

Cockayne J "Regulating private military and security companies: The content, negotiation, weakness and promise of the Montreux Document" 2009 JCSL 401-428

Cockayne et al Beyond Market Forces

Cockynae J et al Beyond Market Force: Regulating the Global Security Industry (Lynne Rienner Boulder, Col. 2010)

Conteh "Security Sector Reform in Sierra Leone"

Conteh K "Security Sector Reform in Sierra Leone and the Role of the Office of the National Security" in Jackson P and Albrecht P (eds) Security Sector Reform in Sierra Leone 1997-2007: Views From the Frontline (DCAF Geneva 2008) 177-189

Davidson 2000 Pub Cont LJ

Davidson M "Ruck up: An introduction to the legal issues associated with civilian contractors on the battlefield" 2000 Pub Cont LJ 233-261

Desai 2005 USFL Rev

Desai D "Have your Cake and Eat it Too: A Proposal for Layered Approach to Regulating Private Military Companies" 2005 USFL Rev 825-871

Ebrahim 2010 BU Int'l LJ

Ebrahim A "Going to war with an army you can afford: The United States, international law and private military industry" 2010 BU Int'l LJ 181-218

Fallah 2006 IRRC

Fallah K "Corporate Actors: The Legal Status of mercenaries in Armed Conflict" 2006 IRRC 599-611

Franklin 2008 Transnat'l L & Contemp Probs

Franklin S "South African and international attempts to regulate mercenaries and private military companies" 2008 Transnat'l L & Contemp Probs 239-264

Geldenhuys 1982 Politikon

Geldenhuys D "The destabilisation controversy: an analysis of a high-risk foreign policy option for South Africa" 1982 9(2) Politikon 16-31

Gichanga Fusing Privatisation

Gichanga M Fusing Privatisation of Security with Peace and Security Initiatives (Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 2010)

Gillard 2006 IRRC

Gillard E "Business Goes to War: Private Military/Security Companies and International Humanitarian Law" 2006 IRRC 525-572

Gumedze 2007 ASR

Gumedze S "Towards the review of the OAU/African Union Convention on the Elimination of Mercenarism" 2007 16(4) ASR 22-33

Gumedze Addressing the Use of Private Security

Gumedze S Addressing the Use of Private Security and Military Companies at the International Level (Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 2009)

Gruenbaum 2010 Round Table

Gruenbaum O "Commonwealth News Update" 2010 Round Table 585-600

Hanlon 1987 Third World Quarterly

Hanlon J "Post-apartheid South Africa and its neighbours" 1987 Third World Quarterly 437-450

Holmqvist Private Security Companies

Holmqvist C Private Security Companies: The Case for Regulation (SIPRI Stockholm 2005)

Hoppe 2008 EJIL

Hoppe C "Passing the buck: State responsibility for private military companies" 2008 EJIL 989-1014

Howe 1998 J Mod Afr Stud

Howe H "Private security forces and African stability: The case of Executive Outcomes” 1998 J Mod Afr Stud 307-331

Hurst 2010 S Cal L Rev

Hurst S "Trade in force: The need for effective regulation of private military and security companies" 2010-2011 S Cal L Rev 447-487

Jackson 2007 J Nat'l Ass'n Admin L Judiciary

Jackson K "Not quite a contractor, not quite a soldier: How five words could subject civilian contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan to military jurisdiction" 2007 J Nat'l Ass'n Admin L Judiciary 255-290

Juma "Mercenarism"

Juma L "Mercenarism: Looking beyond the Current International and Regional Normative Regimes" in Gumedze S (ed) Elimination of Mercenarism in Africa: A Need for a New Continental Approach (Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 2008) 197-227

Juma 2011 Law Democracy & Development

Juma L "Privatisation, Human Rights and Security: Reflections on the Draft International Convention on Regulation, Oversight and Monitoring of Private Military and Security Companies" 2011 Law Democracy & Development 182-214

Juma 2011 Obiter

Juma L "Going against the tide: Seeking regulation for private military/security companies in a globalized world" 2011 Obiter 63-82

Kagwanja 2006 JCAS

Kagwanja P "Power and peace: South Africa and the refurbishing of Africa’s multilateral capacity for peace making" 2006 JCAS 159-184

Kinsey Corporate Soldiers

Kinsey C Corporate Soldiers and International Society: The Rise of Private Military Companies (Routledge Oxford 2006)

Krahmann 2011 Millenn J Int Stud

Krahmann E "From 'mercenaries' to private security contractors': The (re)construction of armed security providers in international legal discourse" 2011 Millenn J Int Stud 343-363

Lock "Africa, Military Downsizing"

Lock P "Africa, Military Downsizing and the Growth in the Private Security Industry" in Cilliers J and Mason P (eds) Peace Profit or Plunder? The Privatization of Security in War-torn African Societies (Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 1999) 11-36

McIntyre 2004 ASR

McIntyre A "Private military firms in Africa: Rogue or regulated" 2004 ASR 101-103

Mehra 2009-2010 Pac McGeorge Global Bus & Dev LJ

Mehra A "Bridging accountability gaps: The proliferation of private military and security companies and ensuring accountability for human rights violations" 2009-2010 22 Pac McGeorge Global Bus & Dev LJ 323-332

Mesner "Working Towards Effective Legislation"

Mesner J "Working Towards Effective Legislation and Regulatory Solutions for Private Security Industry in Africa" in Gumedze S (ed) Elimination of Mercenarism in Africa: A Need for Continental Approach (Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 2008) 145-178

Nevers 2010 J Pub Pol'y

Nevers R "The effectiveness of self-regulation by private military and security industry" 2010 J Pub Pol'y 219-240

Pattinson 2010 Int'l Theory

Pattinson J "Outsourcing responsibility to protect: humanitarian intervention and private military and security companies" 2010 Int'l Theory 1-31

Percy Regulating the Private Security Industry

Percy S Regulating the Private Security Industry (Routledge Oxford 2006)

Percy Mercenaries

Percy S Mercenaries: The History of a Norm in International Relations (Oxford University Press New York 2007)

Prado 2008 JC & SL

Prado J "Private military and security companies and the UN Working Group on the Use of Mercenaries" 2008 JC & SL 429-450

Prado 2011 BJWA

Prado J "Impact on human rights of a new non-state actor: Private military and security companies" 2011 BJWA 151-170

Prado 2012 Criminal Justice Ethics

Prado J "A UN Convention to regulate PMSCs?" 2012 Criminal Justice Ethics 262-286

Prakash 1999 Business Strategy and the Environment

Prakash A "A new institutional perspective on ISO 14000 and responsible care" 1999 Business Strategy and the Environment 322-335

Roux "Revision of the South African Defence Review"

Roux L "The Revision of the South African Defence Review and International Trends in Force Design: Implications for the South African Army" in Le Roux L (ed) South African Army Vision 2020: Security Challenges Shaping the Future South African Army (Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 2007) 269-286

Salzman 2008 NYUJ Int'l L & Pol

Salzman Z "Private military contractors and the taint of mercenary reputation" 2008 NYUJ Int’l L & Pol 853-892

Schmitt 2005 Chi J Int'l L

Schmitt M "Humanitarin law and direct participation in hostilities by private contractors or civilian employees" 2005 Chi J Int'l L 511-546

Shearer Private Armies

Shearer D Private Armies and Military Intervention (Oxford University Press New York 1998)

Singer Corporate Warrior

Singer P Corporate Warrior: The Rise of Private Military Industry and Its Ramifications for International Security (Cornel University Press New York 2003)

Spearin 2011 Int'l Peacekeeping

Spearin C "UN Peacekeeping and the international private military and security industry" 2011 Int'l Peacekeeping 196-209

Spearin 2012 JICJ

Spearin C "Private military and security companies v. international naval endeavours v. Somali pirates: A security studies perspective" 2012 JICJ 823-837

Steinhoff "What are Mercenaries? "

Steinhoff U "What are Mercenaries?" in Alexandria A et al (eds) Private Military and Security Companies: Ethics Policies and Civil Military Relations (Routledge New York 2008) 19-29

Stürchler 2008 JIPO

Stürchler N "The Swiss Initiative Comes Alive" 2008 4(3) JIPO 9-12

Taljaard "Private and Public Security"

Taljaard R "Private and Public Security in South Africa" in Gumedze S (ed) Private Security Sector in Africa (Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 2008) 69-98

White 2011 Hum Rts Rev

White N "The privatisation of military and security functions and human rights: Comments on the UN Working Group's Draft Convention" 2011 Hum Rts Rev 133-151

Zarate 1998 Stan J Int'l L

Zarate J "The Emergence of the New Dog of War: Private International Security Companies, International Law and the New World Order" 1998 Stan J Int'l L 75-162

Register of legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Regulation of Foreign Military Assistance Act 15 of 1998

National Conventional Arms Control Act 41 of 2002

Prohibition of Mercenary Activities and Prohibition and Regulation of Certain Activities in Areas of Armed Conflict Act 27 of 2006

Rome Statute of International Criminal Court Act 27 of 2002

Register of policy documents

White Paper on National Defence for the Republic of South Africa (1996)

White Paper on South Africa Defence Related Industries (1999)

Register of treaties

OAU Convention for the Elimination of Mercenaries in Africa (1972)

International Convention Against the Recruitment, Use, Financing and Training of Mercenaries (1989) (UN Mercenary Convention)

Montreux Document on Pertinent International Legal Obligations and Good Practices for States Related to Operations of Private Military and Security Companies During Armed Conflict, Annex, addressed to the Secretary General (2008) (Montreux Document)

Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 Aug 1949 and Relating to the Protection of the Victims of International Armed Conflicts (1979) (Additional Protocol I)

Register of UN reports

ECOSOC 2003

UN Economic and Social Council Norms and Responsibilities of Transnational Corporations and the Business Enterprise with Regards to Human Rights UN Doc E/CN.4/Sub.2/2003/12/Rev.2 (2003)

HRC 2007

Report of the Working Group on the Use of Mercenaries as a Means of Violating Human Rights and Impeding the Exercise of the Right of Peoples to Self-Determination to the 4th Session of Human Rights Council A/HRC/4/42 (2007)

HRC 2008

Protect, Respect and Remedy: A Framework for Business and Human Rights UN Doc A/HRC/8/5 (2008)

HRC Res 2005/2

The Use of Mercenaries as a Means of Violating Human Rights and Impeding the Exercise of Rights of Peoples to Self-determination E/CN.4/2005/RES/

/2 (2005)

UNDP 1999

United Nations Development Programme Human Development Report (1999)

UN GA Res 2625

Implementation of the Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples UNGA Res 2465, 23UN GAOR Supp (No 18) at 4 UN Doc A/1218 (1968)

Register of internet sources

Ahmadou and Gumedze 2008 www.iss.co.za

Ahmadou N and Gumedze S 2008 Seminar Report on Prohibition of Mercenary Activities and Prohibition and Regulation of Certain Activities in Areas of Armed Conflict Act 2006 www.iss.co.za/uploads/RPSSREPFIN.PDF [date of use 10 Mar 2013]

BAPSC 2008 www.org.uk

BAPSC 2008 Charter www.org.uk/key_documents-charter.asp [date of use 24 Sep 2008]

BBC 2004 news.bbc.co.uk

BBC News 2004 Mercenaries Face Zimbabwe Court news.bbc.co.uk/

/hi/africa/3500132.stm [date of use 7 Feb 2013]

BBC 2010 news.bbc.co.uk

BBC News 2010 Henry Okah Charged in South Africa over Nigeria Bombs news.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-11466445 [date of use 10 Feb 2013]

BBC 2013 news.bbc.co.uk

BBC News 2013 Henry Okah: South African Court Convicts Nigeria Rebel news.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-21119470 [date of use 7 Feb 2013]

Clarno and Vally 2005 www.corpwatch.org

Clarno A and S Vally 'Iraq: The South African connection' Corp Watch 6 March 2005 www.corpwatch.org/article.php?id=12061 [date of use 15 Mar 2013]

CNN 2013 edition.cnn.com

CNN 2013 South African Police Seize Alleged Coup Plotters edition.cnn.com/2013/02/06/world/africa/south-africa-congo-arrests/

index.html accessed on 07/02/2013 [date of use 6 Feb 2013]

Department of Defence 2012 www.info.gov.za

Department of Defence 2012 South African Defence Review (Draft Document for Public Engagement) www.info.gov.za/view/DownloadFileAction?id=

[date of use 15 Mar 2013]

Du Plessis 2008 www.iss.co.za

Du Plessis M 2008 South Africa's International Criminal Court Act: Countering Genocide, War Crimes and Crimes against Humanity, Institute of Security Studies, Paper No. 172 www.iss.co.za/uploads/PAPER172.PDF [date of use 2 Feb 2013]

ICRC 2009 www.icrc.org

ICRC 2009 ICRC's Interpretive Guidance on the Notion of Direct Participation in Hostilities under International Humanitarian Law www.icrc.org/eng/

resources/documents/article/review/review-872-p991.htm [date of use 20 Nov 2012]

Jobson 2012 www.guardian.co.uk

Jobson A 'African Union chooses first female leader' The Guardian 16 July 2012 www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/jul/16/african-union-first-female-leader [date of use 20 Nov 2012]

Raghavan and White 2007 www.washingtonpost.com

Raghavan S and White J 'Blackwater Guards Fired at Fleeing Cars, Soldiers Say' Washington Post 12 October 2007 www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/10/11/AR2007101101030.html [date of use 20 Nov 2012]

SABC 2013 www.sabc.co.za

SABC 2013 DRC Awaits SA Brief on Alleged Coup www.sabc.co.za/news/a/

a91f2d004e74f94c9908fb7da4cd6ad7/DRC-awaits-SA-brief-on-alleged-coup-20130602 [date of use 7 Feb 2013]

Staff Reporter 2013 mg.co.za

Staff Reporter 'Seven arrested for Mangaung bomb plot' Mail & Guardian 17 December 2012 hmg.co.za/article/2012-12-17-seven-arrested-for-right-wing-bomb-plot accessed on 07/02/2013 [date of use 7 Feb 2013]

Tempest and Jeffrey 2004 www.guardian.co.uk

Tempest and S Jeffrey 'Mark Thatcher denies coup charges' The Guardian 25 August 2004 www.guardian.co.uk/world/2004/aug/25/southafrica.politics [date of use 10 Mar 2013]

UN 2009 mgimo.ru

United Nations 2009 Draft Convention on the Regulation, Oversight and Monitoring of Military and Security Companies mgimo.ru/files/121626/

draft.pdf [date of use 7 Feb 2013]

UN OHCHR Date Unknown www.ohchr.or

United Nations Office of the High Commission for Human Rights Date Unknown Working Group on the Use of Mercenaries as a Means of Violating Human Rights and Impeding the Exercise of the Right of Peoples to Self-determination www.ohchr.org/EN/Issues/Mercenaries/WGMercenaries/Pages/

WGMercenariesIndex.aspx [date of use 2 Mar 2013]

Published
2017-05-17
How to Cite
JumaL., & TsaboraJ. (2017). The South African Defence Review (2012) and Private Military / Security Companies (PMSCs): Heralding a Shift from Prohibition to Regulation?. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 16(4), 231-283. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i4a2415
Section
Articles