The Prosecution of Incitement to Genocide in South Africa

Authors

  • Hermanus J Van der Merwe University of Western Cape

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i5a2436

Keywords:

Incitement, Genocide, South Africa, Genocide Convention, ICTR, Rome Statute, Domestic implementation, Prosecution, Prevention.

Abstract

The inchoate crime of direct and public incitement to commit genocide was first recognised under the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (1948). The creation of the crime was a direct result of the horrific effects of acts of incitement before and during the Second World War. Today the crime is firmly established under international law and is also criminalised in many domestic legal systems.

 

History shows that incitement to crime and violence against a specific group is a precursor to and catalyst for acts of genocide. Consequently, the goal of prevention lies at the core of the prohibition of direct and public incitement to genocide. However, it may be said that this preventative objective has thus far been undermined by a general lack of prosecutions of the crime, especially at the domestic level. This prosecutorial void is rather conspicuous in the light of the new vision of international criminal justice under which domestic legal systems (including that of South Africa) bear the primary responsibility for the enforcement of the law of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (Rome Statute), which in Article 25(3)(e) includes the crime of direct and public incitement to commit genocide.

 

This article provides a brief historical and teleological overview of the crime of direct and public incitement to commit genocide under international law, as well as the definitional elements thereof as interpreted and applied by the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR). Thereafter it examines the criminalisation of incitement to genocide in contemporary South African law in order to assess South Africa’s capacity to prosecute incitement to genocide at the domestic level. In this regard there are, in theory, various 'legal avenues' for the prosecution of incitement to commit genocide in South Africa, namely: as a crime under the Riotous Assemblies Act 17 of 1956; as a crime under the Implementation of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court Act 27 of 2002 (the ICC Act); or as a crime under customary international law pursuant to section 232 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996. The article reflects critically on the viability of prosecuting incitement to genocide in terms of each of these alternatives.

 

The article highlights a number of practical and legal problems as regards the prosecution of incitement to commit genocide under the Riotous Assemblies Act as well as under customary international law. It is argued that the prosecution of incitement to genocide in terms of the ICC Act is preferable, as this would respond directly to an international consensus as regards the unique and egregious nature of genocide by providing for a limited form of extraterritorial criminal jurisdiction. Prosecution under the ICC Act would also reflect the objectives of the Rome Statute pursuant to which South Africa has certain international legal obligations.

 

However, it is submitted that legislative amendment of the ICC Act is needed, since the crime is not explicitly provided for thereby at present. It is submitted that the legislative amendment must provide for the distinct crime of direct and public incitement to genocide in terms of South African criminal law. Such an amendment will remove the existing legal obstacles to the domestic prosecution of incitement to genocide and enable effective prosecution thereof at the domestic level. The proposed amendment will have the effect of strengthening the alignment between South African law and the objectives of the Rome Statute and may have preventative benefits in the long run.

    

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Bibliography

Burchell Principles

Burchell J Principles of Criminal Law 3rd ed (Juta Cape Town 2010)

Cassese International Criminal Law

Cassese A et al International Criminal Law: Cases and Commentary (Oxford University Press Oxford 2011)

Ceretti "Collective Violence"

Ceretti A "Collective Violence and International Crime" in Cassese A (ed) The Oxford Companion to International Criminal Justice (Oxford University Press Oxford 2009)

Davies 2009 Harv Hum Rts J

Davies TE "How the Rome Statute weakens the international prohibition on incitement to genocide" 2009 Harv Hum Rts J 245-270

Du Plessis 2007 JICJ

Du Plessis M "South Africa's implementation of the ICC Statute" 2007 JICJ 460-479

Gordon 2013 Vanderbilt J Transnat'l L

Gordon G "Hate speech and persecution: A contextual approach" 2013 Vanderbilt J Transnat'l L 303-373

Joubert Criminal Procedure

Joubert JJ (ed) Criminal Procedure Handbook 10th ed (Juta Cape Town 2011)

Kemp Criminal Law

Kemp G (ed) et al Criminal Law in South Africa (Oxford University Press Oxford 2012)

Mendel "Study on International Standards"

Mendel T "Study on International Standards Relating to Incitement to Genocide or Racial Hatred" (UN New York 2006)

Orentlicher 2006 Am U Int'l L Rev

Orentlicher D "Criminalizing hate speech in the crucible of trial: Prosecutor v. Nahimana" 2006 Am U Int'l L Rev 557-596

Schabas Genocide

Schabas W Genocide in International Law (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2009)

Schabas 2000 McGill LJ

Schabas W "Hate speech in Rwanda: The road to genocide" 2000 McGill LJ 141-171

Snyman Strafreg

Snyman CR Strafreg 6th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2012)

Timmerman 2006 IRRC

Timmerman WK "Incitement in International Criminal Law" 2006 IRRC 823-852

Werle 2007 JICJ

Werle G "Individual criminal responsibility in article 25 ICC Statute" 2007 JICJ 953-975

Werle International Criminal Law

Werle G Principles of International Criminal Law 2nd ed (TMC Asser Press The Hague 2009)

Zahar 2005 Criminal Law Forum

Zahar A "The ICTR's 'Media' judgment and the reinvention of direct and public incitement to commit genocide" 2005 Criminal Law Forum 33-48

Register of case law

African National Congress v Harmse: In Re Harmse v Vawda (Afriforum Intervening) 2011 5 SA 460 (GSJ)

Basebya District Court of The Hague, Case No. 09/748004-09, 1 March 2013

ICC Prosecutor v Thomas Lubanga Dyilo (Trial Chamber I: Judgment) Case No. ICC-01/04-01/06, 14 March 2012

ICJ Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Bosnia and Herzegovina v Serbia and Montenegro), Judgment, ICJ Reports 2007 43

ICTR Prosecutor v Akayesu (Trial Chamber: Judgment) Case No ICTR-96-4-T, 2 September 1998

ICTR Prosecutor v Karemera, Ngirumpatse, Nzirorera (Decision on prosecutor's interlocutory appeal of decision on judicial notice) Case No ICTR-98-44-AR73(C)

ICTR Prosecutor v Muvunyi (Trial Chamber: Judgment) Case No ICTR-2000-55A-T, 12 September 2006

ICTR Prosecutor v Nahimana et al (Trial Chamber: Judgment and Sentence) Case No ICTR 99-55-T, 3 December 2003

ICTR Prosecutor v Nahimana et al (Appeals Chamber: Judgment) Case No ICTR-99-52-A, 28 November 2007

ICTY Prosecutor v Jelisic (Trial Chamber: Judgment) Case No IT-95-10-T, 14 December 1999

ICTY Prosecutor v Kordić and Čerkez (Trial Chamber: Judgment) Case No IT-95-14/2-T, 26 February 2001

ICTY Prosecutor v Krstić (Trial Chamber: Judgment) Case No IT-98-33, 2 August 2001

ICTY Prosecutor v Krstić (Appeals Chamber: Judgment) Case No IT-98-33-A, 19 April 2004

Mugesera v Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) (2005) 2 SCR 100, 2005 SCC 40

Nazi Conspiracy and Aggression: Opinion and Judgment (United States Government Printing Office Washington 1947)

R v Segale 1960 1 SA 721 (A)

Southern African Litigation Centre v National Director of Public Prosecutions 2012 10 BCLR 1089 (GNP)

S v Basson 2007 1 SACR 566 (CC)

S v Nkosiyana 1966 4 SA 655 (A)

S v Nlhovo 1921 AD 485

Register of legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Implementation of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court Act 27 of 2002

Riotous Assemblies Act 17 of 1956

Register of international instruments

Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (1965)

Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (1948)

Draft Code of Crimes against the Peace and Security of Mankind (1996)

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966)

Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (1998)

Register of miscellaneous sources

UN Doc A/C.6/SR.84 (1948)

UNGAOR, Sixth Committee, 3rd Session, 84th Meeting UN Doc A/C.6/SR.84 (1948)

UN Doc CERD/C/67/Misc.8 (2005)

Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination Decision on Follow Up to the Declaration on Prevention of Genocide: Indicators of Patterns of Systematic and Massive Racial Discrimination UN Doc CERD/C/67/Misc.8 (2005)

UN Doc E/AC.25/12 (1948)

Ad Hoc Committee Draft Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide UN Doc E/AC.25/12 (1948)

UN Doc E/623 (1948)

UNESCOR Prevention and Punishment of Genocide: Comments by Governments on the Draft Convention Prepared by the Secretariat

UN Doc E/447 (1947)

Secretariat Draft Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide UN Doc E/447 (1947)

UNGA Resolution 60(1) (2005)

World Summit Outcome Document of the High-level Plenary Meeting of the General Assembly UNGA Resolution 60(1) (2005)

UNSC Resolution 955 (1994)

Establishment of an International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda and Adoption of the Statute of the Tribunal UNSC Resolution 955 (1994)

Register of internet sources

Benesch 2011 voicesthatpoison.files.wordpress.com

Benesch S 2011 Incitement as International Crime: Contribution to Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights Initiative on Incitement to National, Racial, or Religious Hatred voicesthatpoison.files.wordpress.com/

/01/beneschohchr1.pdf [date of use 21 Aug 2013]

Jonassohn 1998 migs.concordia.ca

Jonassohn K 1998 Precursors of Genocide - A Research Agenda migs.concordia.ca/occpapers/precursors.html [date of use 19 Jun 2013]

Ki-moon 2012 www.un.org

Ki-moon B 2012 UN Secretary-General's remarks to General Assembly Informal Interactive Dialogue on the Responsibility to Protect: Timely and Decisive Response www.un.org/sg/statements/index.asp?nid=6271 [date of use 26 Sep 2013]

Krug 2002 whqlibdoc.who.int

Krug EG et al 2002 World Report on Violence and Health whqlibdoc.who.int/hq/2002/9241545615.pdf [date of use 19 Jun 2013]

Schabas Date Unknown untreaty.un.org

Schabas W Date Unknown Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide untreaty.un.org/cod/avl/ha/cppcg/cppcg.html [date of use 30 Sep 2013]

Stanton Date Unknown www.genocidewatch.org

Stanton G Date Unknown The 8 Stages of Genocide www.genocidewatch.org/aboutgenocide/8stagesofgenocide.html [date of use 14 Jun 2013]

Wouters and Verhoeven 2010 dx.doi.org

Wouters J and Verhoeven S 2010 The Domestic Prosecution of Genocide dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1766554 [date of use 21 Aug 2013]

Published

17-05-2017

How to Cite

Van der Merwe, H. J. (2017). The Prosecution of Incitement to Genocide in South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 16(5), 327–368. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i5a2436

Issue

Section

Articles

Similar Articles

<< < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.