"Originality" and "Reproduction" in Copyright Law with Special Reference to Photographs
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i5a2446Keywords:
Originality, Reproduction, Copyright Law, Photographs, Artistic Work, Temple Island Collections Ltd v New English Teas Ltd, Sweat- of- the- brow testAbstract
Turning to lessons from foreign jurisdictions, this note explores from a copyright perspective the fact that photographs are produced mechanically and more often than not without any effort or mental input. A minute number are taken for anything but personal use and in the digital age photographs tend to have a high degree of mobility and are also ephemeral and without any commercial value. It is accordingly difficult to justify in general terms copyright protection for photographs. Two of the main legal issues in this context are the criteria for originality and the meaning of the reproduction of a photograph. These two issues form the central point of discussion in this contribution.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Arnold 2005 EIPR
Arnold R "Copyright in photographs: a case for reform" 2005 EIPR 303-305
Barnes Levels of Life
Barnes J Levels of Life (Alfred A Knopf New York 2013)
Garnett Copinger and Skone James on Copyright
Garnett K et al Copinger and Skone James on Copyright 14th ed (Sweet & Maxwell London 1999)
Ginsberg 2003 DePaul L Rev
Ginsberg JC "The concept of authorship in comparative copyright law" 2003 DePaul L Rev 1063-1092
Jones 1990 Pace L Rev
Jones RH "The Myth of the Idea/Expression Dichotomy in Copyright Law" 1990 Pace L Rev 551-607
Laddie, Prescott and Vitoria Modern Law of Copyright
Laddie H, Prescott P and Vitoria M The Modern Law of Copyright and Designs 2nd ed (Butterworths London 1995)
Lee 2012 EIPR
Lee YH "Photographs and the standard of originality in Europe" 2012 EIPR 290-293
Michalos Law of Photography
Michalos C The Law of Photography and Digital Images (Sweet & Maxwell Londong 2004)
Moran 2011 Wash J L Tech & Arts
Moran C "How much is too much?" 2011 Wash J L Tech & Arts 247-258
Rahmatian 2012 EIPR
Rahmatian A "Temple Island Collections v New English Teas: an incorrect decision based on the right law?" 2012 EIPR 796-799
Ricketson and Ginsburg International Copyright
Ricketson S and Ginsburg JC International Copyright and Neighbouring Rights: The Berne Convention and Beyond 2nd ed (Butterworths London 2006)
Rosati 2013 JIPLP
Rosati E "Case Comment: Harney v Sony Pictures Television" 2013 JIPLP 356
Vaver Intellectual Property Law
Vaver D Intellectual Property Law 2nd ed (Irwin Law Toronto 2011)
Vaver 2012 IPJ
Vaver D "Harmless Copying" 2012 IPJ 19-28
Register of cases
Annie Leibovitz v Paramount Pictures Corp 137 F 3d 109
Antiquesportfolio Com Plc v Rodney Fitch & Company Ltd 2001 ECDR 5
Appleton v Harnischfeger Corporation 1995]2 All SA 693 (A)
Argus Printing and Publishing Co Ltd v Perskorporasie van Suid-Afrika Bpk 1975 4 SA 668 (A)
Bauman v Fussel 1978 RPC 485
Bridgeman Art Library Ltd v Corel Corp 36 F Supp 2d 191 (SDNY 1999)
CCH Canadian Ltd. v Law Society of Upper Canada 2004 SCC 13
Creation Records Ltd v News Group Newspapers Ltd 1997 EWHC Ch 370
Designer Guild Limited v Russell Williams (Textiles) Limited 2001 1 All ER 700
Eldred v Ashcroft 537 US 186
Eva-Maria Painer v Standard Verlags GmbH C-145/10, 1 December 2011 (CJEU)
Exxon Corp v Exxon Insurance Consultants Ltd 1982 Ch 119
Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Reed International Books Australia Pty Ltd 2010 FCA 984
Feist Publications Inc v Rural Telephone Service Co 499 US 340 (1991)
Francis Day and Hunter Ltd v Twentieth Century Fox Corporation Ltd 1940 AC 112 (PC)
Galago Publishers (Pty) Ltd v Erasmus 1989 1 SA 276 (A)
Graves' Case 1869 LR 4 QB 715
Harney v Sony Pictures Television Inc LLC US Court of Appeal First Circuit No. 11-1760, 7 January 2013
Haupt t/a Softcopy v Brewers Marketing Intelligence (Pty) Ltd 2006 4 SA 458 (SCA)
Hyperion Records Ltd v Sawkins 2005 EWCA Civ 565
Infopaq International A/S v Danske Dagblades Forening 2009 EUECJ C-5/08
Klep Valves (Pty) Ltd v Saunders Valve Co Ltd 1987 2 SA 1 (A)
Krisarts SA v Briarfine Limited 1977 FSR 557
Ladbroke Football Ltd v William Hill Football Ltd 1964 1 WLR 273
Laubscher v Vos 3 JOC (W)
Lucasfilm Ltd v Ainsworth 2009 EWCA Civ 1328
Newspaper Licensing Agency Ltd & Ors v Meltwater Holding BV & Ors 2011 EWCA Civ 890
Patrick Cariou v Richard Prince US Court of Appeal (2d Circ) 25 April 2013, Doc 11-1197cv
Prinsloo v RPC Media Ltd t/a Rapport 2003 4 SA 456 (T)
Progress Office Machines v SARS 2007 SCA 118
Public Relations Consultants Association Limited v The Newspaper Licensing Agency Limited 2013 UKSC 18
Rapid Phase Entertainment CC v SABC 1997 JOL 393 (W)
Rogers v Koons 960 F 2d 301 (2d Cir 1992)
Rudolph Jan Romme v Van Dale Lexicografie BV Hoge Raad, 4 January 1991, Nr. 14 449
Sahuc v Tucker 300 F Supp 2d 461 (EDLA 2004)
SAS Institute Inc v World Programming Ltd 2013 EWHC 69 (Ch)
Stranex Judgments on Copyright 597 1997 JOL 393 (W)
Temple Island Collections Ltd v New English Teas Ltd 2012 EWPCC 1
Waylite Diary CC v First National Bank Ltd 1995 1 SA 645 (A)
Register of legislation
Copyright Act 63 of 1965
Copyright Act 98 of 1978
Copyright, Designs and Patents Act of 1988 (UK)
Fine Arts Copyright Act of 1862 (UK)
Patents, Designs, Trade Marks and Copyright Act 9 of 1916
Register of international instruments
Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (1994) (TRIPS Agreement)
Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (2011) (ACTA)
Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works (1886)
Berne Convention – Brussels revision (1948)
Berne Convention – Paris version (1971)
Directive 2001/29/EC on the harmonisation of certain aspects of copyright and related rights in the information society
Directive 2006/116/EC on the term of protection of copyright and certain related rights OJ L372/12, modi-ied by Directive 2011/77/EU, OJ L265/1
Register of internet sources
Concorde Photographs Case 2012 www.legalis.net
Concorde Photographs Case 2012 Tribunal de grande instance de Paris 3ème chambre, 4ème section Jugement du 20 décembre 2012 www.legalis.net/spip.php?page=jurisprudence-decision&id_article=3578 [date of use 11 Apr 2013]
Greenspun 1999 photo.net
Greenspun P 1999 History of Photography Timeline photo.net/
learn/history/timeline [date of use 11 Apr 2013]
Nadar Date Unknown www.photoquotes.com
Nadar Date Unknown Quotes www.photoquotes.com/showquotes.
aspx?id=281&name=Nadar [date of use 1 May 2013]
Picture Archive Academy of America Date Unknown www.pacaoffice.org
Picture Archive Academy of America Date Unknown Presentation: Copyright and Copywrong www.pacaoffice.org/copyrightInfo/PACAcopEd.ppt [date of use 1 May 2013]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Louis Harms
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}