Gesondheidsorg vir Kinders: Voldoen Suid-Afrikaanse Wetgewing Aan die Land se Verpligtinge Ingevolge die Konvensie Oor die Regte van die Kind en die Grondwet?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i1a2459Keywords:
Children, basic healthcare, UN Children's Convention, Convention on the Rights of the Child, South African legislation, responsibilities, socio-economic rights, section 28 of the ConstitutionAbstract
Included in the Convention on the Rights of the Child, 1989 (UN Children's Convention) is the right of children to the highest attainable standard of health. In terms of article 4 of the UN Children's Convention, in implementing the UN Children's Convention state parties must "undertake all appropriate legislative, administrative, and other measures for the implementation of the rights recognised in the present Convention".
South Africa showed its commitment to protecting and promoting children's health when it ratified the UN Children's Convention and subsequently adopted the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996, which includes provisions guaranteeing the health rights of children. South Africa also showed commitment to giving legislative effect to the protection and promotion of children's health by promulgating the National Health Act 61 of 2003, the Children's Act 38 of 2005 and the Mental Health Care Act 17 of 2002.
The article evaluates existing policy and legislation affecting child health in order to assess how well South African legislation addresses the issue of children's healthcare rights and whether or not it complies with its international law and constitutional obligations in this regard. The article concludes that although much legislation exists, none provides comprehensively for children's healthcare rights, and there are many gaps in existing legislation. Most importantly, there is no reference to the core minimum requirements for the state in providing for the health of children, particularly in the way of healthcare services and nutrition. Further, there is a complete lack of legislation which protects the health needs of children with disabilities. In order to ensure that the health rights of children are protected and promoted, we propose more comprehensive legislative protection.
Downloads
References
Bibliografie
Bekink en Brand "Constitutional Protection of Children"
Bekink B en Brand D "Constitutional Protection of Children" in Davel CJ et al (red) Introduction to Child Law in South Africa (Juta Kaapstad 2000)
Berger "Constitution and Public Health Policy"
Berger J "The Constitution and Public Health Policy" in Hassim A, Heywood M & Berger J (reds) Health and Democracy (Siber Ink Kaapstad 2007)
Bilchitz 2010 SALJ
Bilchitz D "Is the Constitutional Court wasting away the rights of the poor? Nokotyana v Ekurhuleni Municipality" 2010 SALJ 591-604
Botha 1997 SAYIL
Botha N "Treaties after the 1996 Constitution: More questions than answers" 1997 SAYIL 95-103
Brand 2003 Law, Democracy & Development
Brand D "Between availability and entitlement: The Constitution, Grootboom and the right to food" 2003 Law, Democracy & Development 1-28
Bryan Review of Legislation
Bryan K A Review of Legislation Affecting Child Health in South Africa (Community Law Centre, Universiteit van Wes-Kaap en Child Health Policy Institute, Universiteit van Kaapstad Kaapstad 1998)
Dugard International Law
Dugard J International Law: A South African Perspective 2nd ed (Juta Kenwyn 2001)
Dugard "Public International Law"
Dugard J "Public International Law" in Chaskalson M et al (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa (Juta Kenwyn 1996)
Dugard 1994 SAJHR
Dugard J "The role of international law in interpreting the Bill of Rights" 1994 SAJHR 208-215
Government of National Unity Initial Country Report
Government of National Unity Initial Country Report South Africa: Convention on the Rights of the Child (GNU Cape Town 1997)
Heywood "Background to Health Law and Human Rights"
Heywood M "A Background to Health Law and Human Rights in South Africa" in Hassim A, Heywood M en Berger J (reds) Health and Democracy: A Guide to Human Rights, Health Law and Policy in Post-apartheid South Africa (Siber Ink Kaapstad 2007)
Jansen van Rensburg 2008 Stell LR
Jansen van Rensburg L "The right of access to adequate water [Discussion of Mazibuko v The City of Johannesburg case no 13865/06]" 2008 Stell LR 415-435
Landman and Henley 2000 SA J of Philosophy
Landman WA and Henley LD "Rationing and children's constitutional healthcare rights" 2000 SA J of Philosophy 41-50
Mbazira Litigating Socio-economic Rights
Mbazira C Litigating Socio-economic Rights in South Africa (PULP Pretoria 2009)
Meerkotter, Gernholtz en Govender "Rights of Vulnerable Groups to Health Care"
Meerkotter A, Gernholtz L en Govender M "The Rights of Vulnerable Groups to Health Care" in Hassim A, Heywood M en Berger J (reds) Health and Democracy (Siber Ink Kaapstad 2007)
Memzur 2008 SAPR/PL
Memzur B D "The African Children's Charter Versus the UN Convention on the Rights and Welfare of the Child: A zero-sum game" 2008 SAPL/R 1-29
Nicholson 2002 CILSA
Nicholson MA "The right to health care, the best interests of the child, and AIDS in South Africa and Malawi" 2002 CILSA 351-376
Nienaber 2008 THRHR
Nienaber A "The statutory regulation of children's participation in HIV-related clinical research: More questions than answers" 2008 THRHR 671-677
Nowak Introducing the International Human Rights Regime
Nowak M Introducing the International Human Rights Regime (Martinus Nijhoff Leiden 2003)
Office on the Rights of the Child Children in 2001
Office on the Rights of the Child, The Presidency Children in 2001: A Report on the State of the Nation's Children (Office on the Rights of the Child Pretoria 2001)
Olivier 1997 SAYIL
Olivier M "Informal international agreements under the 1996 Constitution" 1997 SAYIL 63-75
Olivier 2002 SAYIL
Olivier M "Exploring the doctrine of self-execution as enforcement mechanism of international obligations" 2002 SAYIL 99-119
Pieterse 2003 TSAR
Pieterse M "Reconstructing the private/public dichotomy? The enforcement of children's constitutional social rights and care entitlements" 2003 TSAR 1-12
Pieterse 2010 Law, Democracy & Development
Pieterse M "Legislative and executive translation of the right to have access to health care services" 2010 Law, Democracy & Development 1-25
Pillay 2003 Law, Democracy & Development
Pillay K "Tracking South Africa's progress on health care rights: Are we any closer to achieving the goal?" 2003 Law, Democracy & Development 55-81
Pillay "Rights Concerning Health"
Pillay K "Rights Concerning Health" in Centre for Human Rights Centre for Human Rights Report on the Realisation of Socio-economic Rights (Centre for Human Rights Pretoria 2000)
Pillay 2002 ESR Rev
Pillay K "The National Health Bill: A step in the right direction?" 2002 3(2) ESR Rev 11-13
Proudlock 2002 ESR Rev
Proudlock P "Children's socio-economic rights: Do they have a right to special protection?" 2002 3(2) ESR Rev 6-8
Rosa and Dutschke 2006 SAJHR
Rosa S and Dutschke M "Child rights at the core: The use of international law in South African cases on children's socio-economic rights" 2006 SAJHR 224-260
Skelton 2010 SAJHR
Skelton A "Girls' socio-economic rights in South Africa" 2010 SAJHR 141-163
Skelton en Proudlock "Interpretation, Objects, Application and Implementation"
Skelton AM en Proudlock P "Interpretation, Objects, Application and Implementation of the Children's Act" in Davel CJ en Skelton AM (reds) Commentary on the Children's Act (Juta Kaapstad 2007)
Sloth-Nielsen 2003 ESR Rev
Sloth-Nielsen J "Promoting children's socio-economic rights through law reform – the proposed Children's Bill" 2003 4(2) ESR Rev 2-4
Stewart 2010 Penn State International Law Review
Stewart L "Adjudicating Socio-Economic Rights Under a Transformative Constitution" 2010 Penn State International Law Review 487-512
Suid-Afrikaanse Regshervormingskommissie Review of the Child Care Act
Suid-Afrikaanse Regshervormingskommissie The Review of the Child Care Act 74 of 1983: Besprekingsdokument 103, Projek 110 (Die Kommissie Pretoria 2002)
Viljoen 1998 CILSA
Viljoen F "Supra-national human rights instruments for the protection of children in Africa: the Convention on the Rights of the Child and the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child" 1998 CILSA 199-212
Viljoen "Children's Rights"
Viljoen F "Children's Rights: A Response from a South African Perspective" in Brand D en Russel S (reds) Exploring the Core Content of Socio-economic Rights: South African and International Perspectives (Protea Boekhuis Pretoria 2002)
Wesson 2011 Human Rights Law Review
Wesson M "Reasonableness in Retreat? The Judgment of the South African Constitutional Court in Mazibuko v City of Johannesburg" 2011 Human Rights Law Review 390-405
Register van internasionale instrumente
Afrika Handves oor die Regte en Welvaart van die Kind (1990)
Deklarasie van Alma Ata (1978)
VN Konvensie oor die Regte van die Kind (1989)
Register van wetgewing en sekondêre wetgewing
Kinderwet 38 van 2005
Grondwet van die Republiek van Suid-Afrika, 1996
Interpretasiewet 33 van 1957
Mine Health and Safety Act 29 van 1996
Nasionale Gesondheidswet 61 van 2003
Suid-Afrikaanse Skolewet 84 van 1996
Wet op Basiese Diensvoorwaardes 75 van 1997
Wet op Beheer van Tabakprodukte 83 van 1993
Wet op Geestesgesondheidsorg 17 van 2002
Wet op Gesondheid 63 van 1977
Wet op Gevaarhoudende Stowwe 15 van 1973
Wet op Keuse oor die Beëindiging van Swangerskap 92 van 1996
Wet op Kindersorg 74 van 1983
Wet op Seksuele Misdrywe 23 van 1957
Wet op Sterilisasie 44 van 1998
Wet op Voedingsmiddels, Skoonheidsmiddels en Ontsmettingsmiddels 54 van 1972
Wet op Voorkoming van Lugbesoedeling 45 van 1965
Wet op Waterdienste 108 van 1997
Wysigingswet op Beheer van Tabakprodukte 23 van 2007
Wysigingswet op Beheer van Tabakprodukte 63 van 2008
Norms and Standards in Respect of Tariffs for Water Services in terms of Section 10(1) of the Water Services Act 108 van 1997 (GK R652 in SK 22472 van 20 Julie 2001)
Regulations Relating to Compulsory National Standards and Measures to Conserve Water (GK R509 in SK 22355 van 8 June 2001)
Register van hofbeslissings
Dawood v Minister of Home Affairs; Shalabi v Minister of Home Affairs; Thomas v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 1 SA 997 (K)
Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (KH)
Mazibuko v The City of Johannesburg 2010 4 SA 1 (KH)
Minister of Health v Treatment Action Campaign 2002 5 SA 721 (KH)
Nokotyana v Ekurhuleni Municipality 2010 4 BCLR 312 (KH)
S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (KH)
Register van Internet bronne
Komitee oor die Regte van die Kind 2003 daccess-dds-ny.un.org
Komitee oor die Regte van die Kind, 34ste sessie, CRC/2003/5 27 November 2003 "General measures of implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child" (arts 4, 42 and 44, para 6)" (General Comment 5) http://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G03/455/14/PDF/G0345514.pdf?OpenElement [datum van gebruik 7 Maart 2012]
De Vos 2009 constitutionallyspeaking.co.za
De Vos P 2009 Water is life (but life is cheap) constitutionally-speaking.co.za/water-is-life-but-life-is-cheap [datum van gebruik 7 Maart 2012]
Departement van Waterwese en Bosbou 1994 www.gov.za
Departement van Waterwese en Bosbou 1994 Water Supply and Sanitation Policy White Paper www.gov.za/whitepaper/index.html [datum van gebruik 7 Maart 2012]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Mariana Büchner-Eveleigh, Annelize Nienaber
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}