Do boards of trustees of South African retirement funds owe fiduciary duties to both the funds and fund members? The debate continues




Retirement Fund, Board of Trustees, Best Interests of Members, Pension Fund Act, Fiduciary Duties, Trusts


Over the years, the South African retirement fund industry has experienced major regulatory changes. These changes were aimed at imposing a higher standard of governance on the boards of trustees governing various pension funds. As such, there has been a debate within the retirement fund industry as to whom the board, as the governing and managing body of the retirement fund, is accountable. South African courts and tribunals adjudicating pension fund related disputes and the retirement industry at large seem to share the view that the board of trustees is accountable to both the fund and its members. In that the board of trustees owes fiduciary duties to both the fund and its members, meaning that the board is required to act in the best interest of the fund and its members. However, in this paper I demonstrate that the boards of trustees of South African Pension Funds are accountable to and owe fiduciary duties only to the fund they serve and not members of those funds. Furthermore, I submit that at the very best the board owes a duty of good faith towards the members of the fund. In order to substantiate my submissions, I distinguish the legal position relating to trust law from the law relating to retirement funds in South Africa.



Download data is not yet available.


Metrics Loading ...



Andrews 2004 SAAJ

Andrews JP "The Conversion of Members' Rights in South African Retirement Funds from Defined Benefits to Defined Contributions and the Statutory Apportionment of the Resulting Actuarial Surplus" 2004 SAAJ 1-52

Asher 2001 SAAJ

Asher A "The Appropriate Disposal of Retirement Fund Surpluses" 2001 SAAJ 1-33

Cameron et al South African Law of Trusts

Cameron E et al The South African Law of Trusts (Juta Cape Town 2002)

Du Toit 2007 Stell LR

Du Toit F "The Fiduciary Office of Trustee and the Protection of Contingent Trust Beneficiaries" 2007 Stell LR 469-482

Geach Trusts

Geach WD Trusts: Law and Practice (Juta Cape Town 2007)

George Analysis of South African Pension Fund Conversions

George DT Analysis of South African Pension Fund Conversions: 1980-2006; Developing a Model for Dealing with Environmental Changes (DBL-thesis UNISA 2006)

Hayton "Pension trustees"

Hayton D "The Extent of Pension Trustees' Obligation in South Africa" in PLA Annual Conference 15-17 February 2004 Cape Town 1-14

Hunter et al Pension Funds Act

Hunter R et al The Pension Funds Act: A Commentary on the Act, Regulations, Selected Notices, Directives and Circulars (Hunter Employee Benefits Law Johannesburg 2010)

Vivian "South African Insurance Markets"

Vivian RW "South African Insurance Markets" in Cummins D and Venard B (eds) Handbook of International Insurance Between Global Dynamics and Local Contingencies (Springer New York 2007)

Register of case law

Bellairs v Hodnett 1978 1 SA 1109 (A)

Boulting v Association of Cinematograph Television & Allied Technicians 1963 2 QB 606

Caffin v African Oxygen Limited Pension Fund Case Nos PFA/WE/14/98 & PFA/WE/26/98

Doyle v Board of Executors 1999 2 SA 805 (C)

Ferguson v Sapref Pension Fund Case No PFA/WE/673/99/SM

Fisheries Development Corporation of SA Ltd v Jorgensen 1980 4 SA 156 (W)

Harris v Rees 2011 2 SA 294 (GSJ)

Hofer v Kevitt 1996 2 SA 402 (C)

Isaacs v SAMA Pension Fund Case No PFA/WE/278/98/NJ

Johannesburg Municipality Pension Fund v NCB Employee Benefits (Pty) Ltd (Unpublished case) Case No 74/01

Jowell v Bramwell-Jones 2000 3 SA 274 (SCA)

Land and Agricultural Bank of South Africa v Parker 2005 2 SA 77 (SCA)

Mahlangu v Soweto City Council Pension Fund Case No PFA/GA/9384/2006/SM

Marais v Momentum Life Pension Fund Case No PFA/GA/1459/01/CN 2002

McDonald v Horn 1995 1 All ER 961 (CA)

Phillips v Fieldstone Africa (Pty) Ltd 2004 1 All SA 150 (SCA)

PPWAWU National Provident Fund v Chemical Energy Paper Printing Wood and Allied Workers Union 2007 ZAGPHC 146

Registrar of Pension Funds v ICS Pension Fund 2010 ZASCA 63

Robinson v Randfontein Estates Gold Mining Co Ltd 2 1921 AD 168

Tex Corporation Provident Fund v Lorentz 1999 4 SA 884 (SCA)

Transvaal Cold Storage Co Ltd v Palmer 1904 TS 4

Volvo (Southern Africa) (Pty) Ltd v Yssel 2009 6 SA 531 (SCA)

Van der Westhuizen v Van Sandwyk 1996 2 SA 490 (W)

Register of legislation

Companies Act 71 of 2008

Financial Institutions (Protection of Funds) Act 28 of 2001

Pensions Fund Act 24 of 1956

Trust Property Control Act 57 of 1988

Register of Internet sources

Cheadle, Thompson and Haysom Attorneys Date Unknown

Cheadle, Thompson and Haysom Attorneys Date Unknown Accountability of Pension Fund Service Providers: The Role of Trustees [date of use 30 May 2012]

Edward Jones Trust Company 2008

Edward Jones Trust Company 2008 Fundamental Duties of a Trustee: A Guide for Trustees in a Post-Uniform Trust Code World [date of use 10 Oct 2011]

Hunter 2000

Hunter R 2000 Retirement Funds: Case Law Update - Workshop 4, Labour Law Conference 19-21 July 2000 Durban[date of use 10 Oct 2011]

Ikard 2006

Ikard FN Jr 2006 Trust Litigation and Defending a Trustee for Breach of Fiduciary Duty [date of use 10 Oct 2011]

Liberty Corporate 2009

Liberty Corporate 2009 The Fiduciary Duties of Retirement Fund Trustees [date of use 2 Oct 2011]

Sanlam 2012

Sanlam 2012 Employee Benefits – Retirement

/sa/en/content/en/5049/Employee-benefits-retirement# [date of use 30 May 2012]



How to Cite

Marumoagae, M. C. (2017). Do boards of trustees of South African retirement funds owe fiduciary duties to both the funds and fund members? The debate continues. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 15(2), 553–569.




Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.