Rent Control: A Comparative Analysis




Constitution, landlord-tenant law, rent control, rent regulation, development of the common law, comparative law, housing law, statutory interpretation


Recent case law shows that vulnerable, previously disadvantaged private sector tenants are currently facing eviction orders – and consequential homelessness – on the basis that their leases have expired. In terms of the case law it is evident that once their leases have expired, these households do not have access to alternative accommodation. In terms of the Constitution, this group of marginalised tenants have a constitutional right of access to adequate housing and a right to occupy land with legally secure tenure. The purpose of this article is to critically analyse a number of legislative interventions, and specifically rent control, that were imposed in various jurisdictions in order to provide strengthened tenure protection for tenants. The rationale for this analysis is to determine whether the current South African landlord-tenant regime is able to provide adequate tenure protection for vulnerable tenants and therefore in the process of transforming in line with the Constitution. The legal construction of rent control was adopted in pre-1994 South Africa, England and New York City to provide substantive tenure protection for tenants during housing shortages. These statutory interventions in the different private rental markets were justified on the basis that there was a general need to protect tenants against exploitation by landlords. However, the justification for the persistent imposition of rent control in New York City is different since it protects a minority group of financially weak tenants against homelessness. The English landlord-tenant regime highlights the importance of a well-structured social sector that can provide secure, long-term housing options for low-income households who are struggling to access the private rental sector. Additionally, the English rental housing framework shows that if the social sector is functioning as a "safety net" for low-income households, the private sector would be able to uphold deregulation. In light of these comparisons and the fact that the South African social sector is not functioning optimally yet, the question is whether the South African private sector is able to provide the required level of tenure protection for struggling tenants. Recent case law shows that tenants are at liberty to lodge unfair practice complaints with the Rental Housing Tribunals on the basis that the landlords' ground for termination of the lease constitutes an unfair practice. The Court defined an unfair practice as a practice that unreasonably prejudices the tenants' rights or interests. This judicial development signifies some transformation in the private sector since it allows the Tribunals to scrutinise landlords' reasons for termination of tenancies in light of tenants' personal and socio-economic circumstances. The Tribunals are therefore empowered to weigh the interests of both parties and decide whether to confirm termination of the lease or set aside such termination. In light of this recent development, the Tribunals can provide strengthened tenure protection for destitute tenants on a case by case basis, which incorporates a flexible context-sensitive approach to the provision of secure housing rights in the landlord-tenant framework. This methodology is similar to the German approach. Even though this judicial development is welcomed, it raises some concerns with regard to landlords' property rights and specifically landlords' constitutional property rights since Tribunals are now at liberty to set aside contractually agreed grounds for termination of leases without any statutory guidance. The legislation fails to provide any information regarding legitimate grounds for termination, which might have to be rectified in future. The grounds listed in the rent control legislation should serve as a starting point to determine which grounds for termination of a lease should generally be upheld. However, German landlord-tenant law shows that a statutory ground for termination of a lease should not be imposed in an absolutist fashion but rather place a heavier burden on the tenant to prove why the lease should not come to an end.



Download data is not yet available.


Metrics Loading ...



Alexander and Penalver 2009 Theoretical Inquiries in Law

Alexander GS and Peñalver EM "Properties of Community" 2009 Theoretical Inquiries in Law 127-160

Allen Property

Allen T Property and the Human Rights Act 1998 (Hart Oxford 2005)

Badenhorst, Pienaar and Mostert Law of Property

Badenhorst PJ, Pienaar JM and Mostert H Silberberg & Schoeman's The Law of Property 5th ed (Butterworths Durban 2006)

Balchin and Rhoden Housing Policy

Balchin P and Rhoden M Housing Policy: An Introduction 4th ed (Routledge London 2002)

Blandy "Housing Standards"

Blandy S "Housing Standards in the Private Rented Sector and the Three Rs: Regulation, Responsibility and Rights" in Cowan D and Marsh A (eds) Two Steps Forward: Housing Policy in the New Millennium (Policy Press Bristol 2001) 73-92

Bridge Residential Leases

Bridge SB Residential Leases (Blackstone Press London 1994)

Bright Landlord and Tenant

Bright S Landlord and Tenant Law in Context (Hart Oxford 2007)

Cooper Landlord and Tenant

Cooper WE Landlord and Tenant 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 1994)

Cooper Rent Control Act

Cooper WE The Rent Control Act (A Supplement to the South African Law of Landlord and Tenant) (Juta Cape Town 1977)

Dukeminier et al Property

Dukeminier J et al Property 6th ed (Aspen New York 2006)

Ellickson 1991 Chicago-Kent LR

Ellickson RC "Rent Control: A Comment on Olsen" 1991 Chicago-Kent LR 947-954

Epstein 1988 Brooklyn LR

Epstein RA "Rent Control and the Theory of Efficient Regulation" 1988 Brooklyn LR 741-774

Evans and Smith Landlord and Tenant

Evans DL and Smith PF Evans: The Law of Landlord and Tenant 2nd ed (Butterworths London 1985)

Fox Conceptualising Home

Fox L Conceptualising Home: Theories, Laws and Policies (Hart Oxford 2007)

Friedman Friedman on Leases

Friedman MR Friedman on Leases Volume 2 5th ed (Practising Law Institute New York 2009)

Garner Landlord and Tenant

Garner S A Practical Approach to Landlord and Tenant 2nd ed (Blackstone London 1998)

Hill Landlord and Tenant

Hill DS Landlord and Tenant Law in a Nutshell 4th ed (Thomson/West St Paul, MN 2004)

Hirsch Law and Economics

Hirsch WZ Law and Economics: An Introductory Analysis (Academic Press New York 1979)

Keating "Rent Control"

Keating WD "Rent Control: Its Origins, Histories and Controversies" in Keating WD, Teitz MB and Skaburskis A Rent Control: Regulation and the Rental Housing Market (Center for Urban Policy Research New Brunswick, NJ 1998) 1-15

Kerr Law of Lease

Kerr AJ The Law of Lease 2nd ed (Butterworths Durban 1976)

Kerr Law of Sale and Lease

Kerr AJ The Law of Sale and Lease 2nd ed (Butterworths Durban 1996)

Kleinman Comparative Analysis

Kleinman M Housing, Welfare and the State in Europe: A Comparative Analysis of Britain, France and Germany (Elgar Cheltenham 1996)

Legwaila 2001 Stell LR

Legwaila T "An Introduction to the Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999" 2001 Stell LR 277-282

Maass Tenure Security

Maass S Tenure Security in Urban Rental Housing (LLD-dissertation University of Stellenbosch 2010)

Maass and Van der Walt 2011 SALJ

Maass S and Van der Walt AJ "The Case in Favour of Substantive Tenure Reform in the Landlord-Tenant Framework: the Occupiers, Shulana Court, 11 Hendon Road, Yeoville, Johannesburg v Steele; City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Blue Moonlight" 2011 SALJ 436-451

Michelman 1970 Harvard Civil Rights- Civil Liberties LR

Michelman FI "The Advent of a Right to Housing: A Current Appraisal" 1970 Harvard Civil Rights- Civil Liberties LR 207-226

Miron 1990 Urban Studies

Miron JR "Security of Tenure, Costly Tenants and Rent Regulation" 1990 Urban Studies 167-183

Mohamed Tenant and Landlord

Mohamed SI Tenant and Landlord in South Africa (Organisation of Civic Rights Durban 2003)

Mukheibir 2000 Obiter

Mukheibir A "The Effect of the Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999 on the Common Law of Landlord and Tenant" 2000 Obiter 325-350

Mullins and Murie Housing Policy

Mullins D and Murie A Housing Policy in the UK (Palgrave Macmillan Basingstoke 2006)

Olsen 1991 Chicago-Kent LR

Olsen EO "Is Rent Control Good Social Policy?" 1991 Chicago-Kent LR 931-946

Partington Landlord and Tenant

Partington M Landlord and Tenant: Text and Materials on Housing and Law 2nd ed (Weidenfeld and Nicolson London 1980)

Penny 1966 SALJ

Penny P "Rent Control" 1966 SALJ 493-502

Radin 1981-1982 Stanford LR

Radin MJ "Property and Personhood" 1981-1982 Stanford LR 957-1015

Radin 1986 Philosophy and Public Affairs

Radin MJ "Residential Rent Control" 1986 Philosophy and Public Affairs 350-380

Rosenow and Diemont Rents Act

Rosenow REG and Diemont MA The Rents Act in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 1945)

RSA First Report on Rent Control

Republic of South Africa First Report of the Select Committee on Rent Control (Government Printer Pretoria 1983)

RSA Hansard

Republic of South Africa Debates of Parliament (Hansard) (Government Printer Pretoria 1983)

RSA, Department of Human Settlements National Housing Code

Republic of South Africa, Department of Human Settlements National Housing Code: Community Residential Units Part 3 Vol 6 (Department of Human Settlements Pretoria 2009)

Scherer Landlord-Tenant Law

Scherer A Residential Landlord-Tenant Law in New York (Thomson West Eagen, MN 2008)

Schnably 1993 Stanford LR

Schnably SJ "Property and Pragmatism: A Critique of Radin's Theory of Property and Personhood" 1993 Stanford LR 347-407

Singer Entitlement

Singer JW Entitlement: The Paradoxes of Property (Yale University Press New Haven 2000)

Stassen and Stassen 2000 De Rebus

Stassen K and Stassen P "New Legislation: Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999" 2000 De Rebus 55-59

Stegman "Rent Control in New York City"

Stegman MA "The Model: Rent Control in New York City" in Niebanck PL (ed) The Rent Control Debate (University of North Carolina Press Chapel Hill 1985) 29-56

Tucker Zoning

Tucker W Zoning, Rent Control and Affordable Housing (Cato Institute Washington, DC 1991)

Underkuffler Idea of Property

Underkuffler LS The Idea of Property: Its Meaning and Power (Oxford University Press Oxford 2003)

UK Law Commission Landlord and Tenant

United Kingdom Law Commission Landlord and Tenant: Reform of the Law No 162 (TSO London 1987)

UK Law Commission Termination of Tenancies

United Kingdom Law Commission Termination of Tenancies for Tenant Default No 303, Part 2 (TSO London 2006)

Van der Walt 2002 TSAR

Van der Walt AJ "Exclusivity of Ownership, Security of Tenure, and Eviction Orders: A Model to Evaluate South African Land-Reform Legislation" 2002 TSAR 254-289

Van der Walt Margins

Van der AJ Walt Property in the Margins (Hart Oxford 2009)

Visser 1985 Acta Juridica

Visser C "Rent Control" 1985 Acta Juridica 349-368

Wilkie et al Landlord and Tenant

Wilkie M et al Landlord and Tenant Law 5th ed (Palgrave MacMillan Basingstoke 2006)

Register of legislation and government documents


Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch (BGB)

South Africa

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998

Rent Control Act 80 of 1976

Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999

Rents Act 13 of 1920

Rents Act 43 of 1950

Rents Act Extension Act 29 of 1924

Rents Act Extension and Amendment Act 30 of 1921

Rents Act Extension and Further Amendment Act 10 of 1922

Rents Amendment Act 26 of 1940

Rents Extension Act 20 of 1923

Social Housing Act 16 of 2008

Tenants Protection (Temporary) Act 7 of 1920

War Measure 42 of 1941 (Proc 195 in GG 2952 of 13 October 1941)

United Kingdom

Housing Act 1980

Housing Act 1985

Housing Act 1988

Housing Act 1996

Protection from Eviction Act 1964

Rent Act 1915

Rent Act 1965

Rent Act 1977

United States

New York City Administrative Code 1979

New York City Housing Authority Management Manual

New York City Local Emergency Housing Rent Control Act 1962

New York City Rent and Eviction Regulations

New York City Rent Control Law 1962

New York City Rent Stabilization Code 1987

New York City Rent Stabilization Law 1969

United States Code Annotated

Register of case law

South Africa

Blue Moonlight Properties 39 (Pty) Ltd v Occupiers of Saratoga Avenue 2010 JOL 25031 (GSJ)

City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Blue Moonlight Properties 39 (Pty) Ltd 2011 4 SA 337 (SCA)

City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Blue Moonlight Properties 39 (Pty) Ltd 2012 2 SA 104 (CC)

Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (CC)

Jackpersad v Mitha 2008 4 SA 522 (D)

Maphango v Aengus Lifestyle Properties 2011 5 SA 19 (SCA)

Maphango v Aengus Lifestyle Properties (Pty) Ltd 2012 ZACC 2

Ndlovu v Ngcobo / Bekker v Jika 2003 1 SA 113 (SCA)

Occupiers, Shulana Court, 11 Hendon Road, Yeoville, Johannesburg v Steele 2010 4 All SA 54 (SCA)

Residents of Joe Slovo Community, Western Cape v Thubelisha Homes 2010 3 SA 454 (CC)

Tiopaizi v Bulawayo Municipality 1923 AD 317

United Kingdom

Britannia Building Society v Earl 1990 1 WLR 422 (CA)

Cobstone Investments Ltd v Maxim 1985 QB 140

Cumming v Danson 1942 2 All ER 653

Harrison v Hammersmith and Fulman London Borough Council 1981 1 WLR 650 (CA)

Keeves v Dean 1924 1 KB 685

Schneiders & Sons Ltd v Abrahams 1925 1 KB 301

Shelley v London County Council 1948 1 KB 274 (CA)

Whitbread v Ward 1952 159 EG 494

United States

Block v Hirsh 256 US 135 (1921)

Edgar A Levy Leasing Co v Siegel 258 US 242 (1922)

Register of international documents

International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966)

Register of internet sources

Association of Residential Letting Agents 2011

Association of Residential Letting Agents 2011 The Private Rental Sector is Nearing Capacity [date of use 13 April 2012]

Bundesministerium der Justiz 2012

Bundesministerium der Justiz 2012 German Civil Code [date of use 13 April 2012]

Confessore and Kaplan 2011

Confessore N and Kaplan T 2011 Albany Reaches Deal on Tax Cap and Rent Rules New York Times

res=9F07E2DA1231F931A15755C0A9679D8B63&ref=rentcontrolandstabilization [date of use 13 April 2012]

Development Action Group 2010

Development Action Group 2010 Urban Land Matters: Tenure Options for Low Income Groups

&id=89:resources&catid=9:research-reports&Itemid=8 [date of use 13 April 2012]

Hills 2007

Hills J 2007 Ends and Means: The Future Roles of Social Housing in England Case Report [date of use 13 April 2012]

Joseph Rowntree Foundation 2002

Joseph Rowntree Foundation 2002 Shortage of Homes Over Next 20 Years Threatens Deepening Housing Crisis [date of use 13 April 2012]

SAPA 2012

SAPA 2012 ConCourt dismisses bid to put pressure on city [date of use 13 April 2012]

Tissington 2011

Tissington K 2011 A Resource Guide to Housing in South Africa 1994-2010: Legislation, Policy, Programmes and Practice [date of use 13 April 2012]

Western Cape Rental Housing Tribunal 2003

Western Cape Rental Housing Tribunal 2003 Annual Report, April 2002 to March 2003 [date of use 13 April 2012]

Wiessner 2011

Wiessner D 2011 New York Reaches Pact on Rent Regulations and Property Tax Reuters [date of use 13 April 2012]



How to Cite

Maass, S.-M. (2017). Rent Control: A Comparative Analysis. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 15(4), 40–100.




Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.