Vox Populi? Vox Humbug! - Rising Tension between the South African Executive and Judiciary Considered in Historical Context: Part One





constitutional democracy, separation of powers, majoritarian democracy, Golden Metwand, James I, Edward Coke, Jacob Zuma, executive, judiciary, Ronald Dworkin, rule of law


This article takes as its starting point a controversy which has arisen around a proposed assessment by the South African government of the decisions of the Constitutional Court, giving rise to concerns that this will constitute undue interference with the independence of the judiciary. Part One of this article traces and analyses the developing controversy. It then compares the current clash between the South African Executive and Judiciary to a similar clash which took place in seventeenth century England, between King James I and Chief Justice Edward Coke. Such clashes appear to be fairly common, particularly in young democracies in which democratic institutions are yet to be properly consolidated. Although not immediately apparent, the similarities between the situation which existed in seventeenth England at the time of James I and that in present-day South Africa are instructive. In tracing the development of these two clashes between the executive and judiciary, Part One of this article lays the foundation for a more in-depth comparison in Part Two.




Download data is not yet available.


Metrics Loading ...



Bizos "Public Address"

Bizos G "Public Address" (Unpublished address delivered at the University of Pretoria 9 December 2011)

Bragg Book of Books

Bragg M The Book of Books: The Radical Impact of the King James Bible 1611-2011 (Hodder and Stoughton London 2011)

Churchill History of the English-speaking Peoples

Churchill WS A History of the English-speaking Peoples - 5. The Civil War (1603-1649) (Cassel London 1965)

Dugard Human Rights

Dugard J Human Rights and the South African Legal Order (Princeton University Press Princeton NJ 1978)

Gardiner Constitutional Documents

Gardiner SR The Constitutional Documents of the Puritan Revolution 1625-1660 (Clarendon Press Oxford 1906)

Jones Politics and the Bench

Jones WJ Politics and the Bench: The Judges and the Origins of the English Civil War (Allen and Unwin London 1971)

Keir Constitutional History

Keir DL The Constitutional History of Modern Britain 1485-1937 (Adam and Charles Black London 1938)

Prosser and Sharp Short Constitutional History

Prosser CW and Sharp M A Short Constitutional History of England (Longmans London 1941)

Schama History of Britain

Schama S A History of Britain (Hyperion Books New York 2000)

Register of cases

Democratic Alliance v The Acting National Director of Public Prosecutions (288/11) 2012 ZASCA 15 (20 March 2012)

Glenister v President of the Republic of South Africa 2011 3 SA 347 (CC)

National Director of Public Prosecutions v Zuma 2009 2 SA 277 (SCA)

S v Shaik 2007 1 SACR 142 (D)

S v Shaik 2007 1 SA 240 (SCA)

S v Shaik 2008 2 SA 208 (CC)

Zuma v National Director of Public Prosecutions 2009 1 All SA 54 (N)

Register of internet sources

Britannica Date Unknown www.britannica.com

Britannica Online Encyclopaedia Date Unknown Estates General www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/193320/Estates-General [date of use 28 Aug 2012]

Anon 2008a www.bdlive.co.za

Anon 'Editorial: A disgrace' Business Day 14 February 2008 www.bdlive.co.za/articles/2008/02/14/editorial-a-disgrace [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Anon 2008b www.bdlive.co.za

Anon 'Editorial: ANC bulldozer' Business Day 7 May 2008 www.bdlive.co.za/articles/2008/05/07/editorial-anc-bulldozer [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Anon 2011 www.bdlive.co.za

Anon 'Editorial: Zuma's fortress is almost complete' Business Day 1 December 2011 www.bdlive.co.za/articles/2011/12/01/editorial-zuma-s-fortress-is-almost-complete [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

CASAC 2011 www.casac.org.za

CASAC 2011 Press Release of 27 November 2011 www.casac.org.za/?news=media-statement-on-cabinet%E2%80%99s-announcement-on-an-%E2%80%98assessment%E2%80%99-of-performance-of-constitutional-court [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Chaskalson 2012 www.timeslive.co.za

Chaskalson A 'When Law Irks Power' Sunday Times 29 January 2012 www.timeslive.co.za/sundaytimes/2012/01/29/when-law-irks-power [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

De Vos 2011 constitutionallyspeaking.co.za

De Vos P 2011 Why Ramatlhodi Promotes an Autokratic Kleptocracy constitutionallyspeaking.co.za/why-ramatlhodi-promotes-an-autokratic-kleptocracy/ [date of use 9 Dec 2012]

Ensor 2009 www.armsdeal-vpo.co.za

Ensor L 'Demise of Scorpions "hits arms inquiry"' Business Day 18 February 2009 www.armsdeal-vpo.co.za/articles14/demise.html [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Ferreira 2012 mg.co.za

Ferreira E 'Radebe announces study of ConCourt rulings' Mail & Guardian 28 February 2012 mg.co.za/article/2012-02-28-radebe-announces-study-of-concourt-rulings [date of use 30 May 2012]

GCIS 2011 www.info.gov.za

GCIS 2011 Statement on the Cabinet Meeting of 23 November 2011 www.info.gov.za/speech/DynamicAction?pageid=461&sid=23498&tid=50012 [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Hoffman 2009 www.bdlive.co.za

Hoffman P 'Case for last link in Zuma's judicial safety chain is weak' Business Day 3 December 2009 www.bdlive.co.za/articles/2009/12/03/case-for-last-link-in-zuma-s-judicial-safety-chain-is-weak [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Maluleke 2009 www.unisa.ac.za

Maluleke TS 'Was Mpshe reading the last rites of SA's democracy?' Business Day 17 April 2009 www.unisa.ac.za/contents/research/docs

/Burial_RitesDemocracy.pdf [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Mokone 2012 m.thetimes.co.za

Mokone T 'Ramatlhodi flays judiciary' Times Live 7 June 2012 m.thetimes.co.za/?name=timeslive&i=11263/1/0&artId=28383 [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Monare 2012 www.iol.co.za

Monare M 'Concourt's powers need reviewing, says Zuma' The Star 13 February 2012 www.iol.co.za/the-star/concourt-s-powers-need-reviewing-says-zuma-1.1232428 [date of use 30 May 2012]

Mthembu 2012 www.politicsweb.co.za

Mthembu J 2012 Statement of 20 March 2012 www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71656?oid=287557&sn=Detail&pid=71656 [date of use 26 Aug 2012]

Norton Topics Online Date Unknown www.wwnorton.com

Norton Topics Online Date Unknown Norton Anthology of English Literature www.wwnorton.com/college/english/nael//17century/topic_3/truelaw.htm [date of use 10 Dec 2012]

Perseus Digital Library Date Unknown www.perseus.tufts.edu

Perseus Digital Library Date Unknown The Political Works of James I www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.03.0071%3Asection%3D4%3Asubsection%3D2 [date of use 10 Dec 2012'

Rabkin 2012 www.businessday.co.za

Rabkin F 'Black Lawyers take Zuma to task over court review' Business Day 17 February 2912 www.businessday.co.za/articles/Content.aspx?id=165172 [date of use 30 May 2012]

Radebe 2012 www.justice.gov.za

Radebe J 2012 Media statement of 28 February 2012 www.justice.gov.za/m_statements/2012/20120228_m_transformation.html [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Ramatlhodi 2011 www.timeslive.co.za

Ramatlhodi N 'The Big Read: ANC's fatal concessions' Times Live 1 September 2011 www.timeslive.co.za/opinion/commentary/2011/09/01/the-big-read-anc-s-fatal-concessions [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Sapa 2005 www.iol.co.za

Sapa 'Zuma feels the sting of the Scorpions' IOL News 18 August 2005 www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/zuma-feels-the-sting-of-the-scorpions-1.251171 [date of use 27 Aug 2012]

Smuts 2012 www.politicsweb.co.za

Smuts D 2012 Ramatlhodi's tactics dirty www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb

/view/politicsweb/en/page71654?oid=304334&sn=Detail&pid=71654 [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Staff Reporter 2010 www.mg.co.za

Staff Reporter 'Arms deal probe (2000-2010)' Mail & Guardian 15 October 2010 www.mg.co.za/article/2010-10-15-arms-deal-probe-20002010 [date of use 9 Dec 2012]

The Presidency 2012 www.info.gov.za

The Presidency 2012 President Zuma's comments on judicial review www.info.gov.za/speech/DynamicAction?pageid=461&sid=25037&tid=56231 [date of use 30 May 2012]

Wikiquotes Date Unknown en.wikipedia.org

Wikiquotes Date Unknown Vox Populi en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vox_populi [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

Zille 2008 www.da.org.za

Zille H 'ANC confirms that it wants Scorpions disbanded for political reasons' SA Today 15 April 2008 www.da.org.za/newsroom.htm?action=view-news-item&id=6041 [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Zille 2010 www.da.org.za

Zille H 'Will Zuma side with Malema or the Constitution?' SA Today 12 March 2010 www.da.org.za/newsroom.htm?action=view-news-item&id=8038 [date of use 11 Jun 2012]

Zuma 2011 www.info.gov.za

Zuma J 2011 Address in bidding farewell to Former Chief Justice Sandile Ngcobo and welcoming Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng, National Assembly, Cape Town, 1 November 2011 www.info.gov.za/speech/Dynamic

Action?pageid=461&sid=22876&tid=47864 [date of use 11 Jun 2012]



How to Cite

Hulme, D., & Peté, S. (2017). Vox Populi? Vox Humbug! - Rising Tension between the South African Executive and Judiciary Considered in Historical Context: Part One. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 15(5), 15–43. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i5a2517




Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.