African-Style Mediation and Western-Style Divorce and Family Mediation: Reflections for the South African Context

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i5a2529

Keywords:

, Dispute resolution, family mediation, divorce mediation, African-styled mediation, Western-styled mediation law

Abstract

Both Western-styled mediation and African-styled mediation are practised in South Africa. Each of these models is applied in specific social contexts. In this article a brief explanation of what is meant by the term divorce and family mediation is provided.  Thereafter the principles and processes of both Western-styled divorce and family mediation and African-styled group mediation are explored. Attention is given to the roles of mediators in both of these models as well as the ubuntu-styled values found in African group mediation. In Africa, there is a tradition of family neighbourhood negotiation facilitated by elders and an attitude of togetherness in the spirit of humanhood. Both of these show a commitment to the community concerned and a comprehensive view of life. In Africa conflicts are viewed as non-isolated events and are viewed in their social contexts. Not only are consequences for the disputing parties taken into account but also consequences for others in their families. These methods can be found in present-day methods, which are either used independently of imported Western structures or used alternatively to such structures.

 In this article the concept of mediation circles, as currently found in Western-styled mediation are also covered. Additionally, the provisions of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005 referring to mediation as well as the provisions of the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008 and family group conferencing in the realm of restorative justice in South Africa are  critiqued. It is suggested that divorce and family mediation can learn from the principles of restorative justice applied during family group conferencing as well as from African-styled group mediation.

    

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bibliography

Anderson 2007 JEP

Anderson S "The Economics of Dowry and Brideprice" 2007 JEP 151-174

Bennett TW "Ubuntu: An African Equity" 2011 PELJ 14(4) 30-61

Boniface "Revolutionary Changes"

Boniface AE "Revolutionary Changes to the Parent-Child Relationship in South Africa" in Sloth-Nielsen J and Du Toit Z (eds) Trials and Tribulations, Trends and Triumphs: Developments in International, African and South African Child and Family Law (Juta Cape Town 2008) 151-163

Brigg 2003 CRQ

Brigg M "Mediation, Power and Cultural Difference" 2003 CRQ 287-306

Charlton and Dewdney Mediator's Handbook

Charlton R and Dewdney M The Mediator's Handbook: Skills and Strategies for Practitioners (LBC Information Service Sydney 1995)

Choudree 1999 AJCR

Choudree RBG "Traditions of Conflict Resolution in Africa" 1999 AJCR 9-27

Clark 1993 THRHR

Clark B "No Holy Cow – Some Caveats on Family Mediation" 1993 THRHR 454-462

Cooper and Brandon 2007 Aust J Fam L

Cooper D and Brandon M "How can Family Lawyers Effectively Represent Their Clients in Mediation and Conciliation Processes?" 2007 Aust J Fam Law 288-308

De Jong 2008 THRHR

De Jong M "Opportunities for Mediation in the Children's Act 38 of 2005" 2008 THRHR 630-641

De Jong "Child-focused Mediation"

De Jong M "Child-focused Mediation" in Boezaart T (ed) Child Law in South Africa (Juta Claremont 2009) 112-132

Dlamini 1991 Acta Juridica

Dlamini CRM "The Role of Customary Law in Meeting Social Needs" 1991 Acta Juridica 71-85

Faris 2006 CILSA

Faris J "Deciphering the Language of Mediatory Intervention in South Africa" 2006 CILSA 427-449

Faris "From Alternative Dispute Resolution"

Faris J "From Alternative Dispute Resolution to African Dispute Resolution: Towards a New Vision" (Unpublished paper delivered at the 5th Caribbean Conference on Dispute Resolution 28-30 April 2011 Jamaica)

Gaynier 2005 CRQ

Gaynier LP "Transformative Mediation: In Search of a Theory of Practice" 2005 CRQ 397-408

Hargovan 2009 Acta Criminologica

Hargovan H "Doing Justice Differently: A Community-based Restorative Justice Initiative in Kwazulu-Natal" 2009 Acta Criminologica 63-87

Heaton 2005 SAJHR

Heaton J "Striving for Substantive Gender Equality in Family Law: Selected Issues" 2005 SAJHR 547-574

Levy and Mowatt 1991 De Jure

Levy MH and Mowatt JG "Mediation in the Legal Environment" 1991 De Jure 63-76

Malan Conflict Resolution

Malan J Conflict Resolution: Wisdom from Africa (Accord Durban 1997)

Masango 2006 VeE

Masango MJS "African Spirituality that Shapes the Concept of Ubuntu" 2006 VeE 930-943

Masenya 1997 OTE

Masenya M "Redefining Ourselves: A Bosadi (Womanhood) Approach" 1997 OTE 439-448

Mayer 1987 CRQ

Mayer B "The Dynamics of Power in Mediation and Negotiation" 1987 CRQ 75-86

Mnookin and Kornhauser 1979 Yale L J

Mnookin RH and Kornhauser L "Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law: the Case of Divorce" 1979 Yale L J 950-997

Moore Mediation Process

Moore C The Mediation Process: Practical Strategies for Resolving Conflict (Jossey-Bass San Francisco 1996)

Murithi 2006 JPAS

Murithi T "Practical Peacemaking Wisdom from Africa: Reflections on Ubuntu" 2006 JPAS 25-52

Murove Theory of Self-interest

Murove MF The Theory of Self-interest in Modern Economic Discourse: A Critical Study in Light of African Humanism and Process Philosophical Anthropology (Doctor of Theology-thesis UNISA 2005)

Nabudere Afrikology, Philosophy and Wholeness

Nabudere DW Afrikology, Philosophy and Wholeness: an Epistemology (African Institute of South Africa Pretoria 2011)

Naude, Prinsloo and Ladikos 2003 Acta Criminologica

Naude B, Prinsloo J and Ladikos A "Restorative Mediation Practices" 2003 Acta Criminologica 10-22

Nyaumwe and Mkabela 2007 IAJIKS

Nyaumwe LJ and Mkabela Q "Revisiting the Traditional African Cultural Framework of Ubuntuism: a Theoretical Perspective" 2007 IAJIKS 152-163

Obarrio "Traditional Justice"

Obarrio J "Traditional Justice as the Rule of Law in Africa: An Anthropological Perspective" in Sriram C , Martin-Ortega O and Herman J (eds) Peace Building and the Rule of Law in Africa: Just Peace? (Routledge London 2011) 23-43

Ozoemena African Customary Law

Ozoemena RN African Customary Law and Gender Justice in a Progressive Democracy (LLM-thesis Rhodes University 2006)

Ozoemena and Hasungule Re-envisioning Gender Justice

Ozoemena RN and Hansungule M Re-envisioning Gender Justice in African Customary Law through Traditional Institutions: Policy Brief 63 (Centre for Policy Studies Johannesburg 2009)

Palmary Traditional Leaders

Palmary I Traditional Leaders in the eThekwini Metropolitan Region: Their Role in Crime Prevention and Safety Promotion (Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation Johannesburg 2004)

Paquin and Harvey 2001-2002 Fla Coastal L J

Paquin G and Harvey L "Therapeutic Jurisprudence, Transformative Mediation and Narrative Mediation: A Natural Connection" 2001-2002 Fla Coastal L J 167-188

Parkinson Family Mediation

Parkinson L Family Mediation (Sweet & Maxwell London 1997)

Roberts Mediation in Family Disputes

Roberts M Mediation in Family Disputes (Wildwood House Aldershot 1998)

Scott-Macnab and Mowatt 1987 De Jure

Scott-MacNab D and Mowatt JG "Family Mediation South Africa's Awakening Interest" 1987 De Jure 41-52

Singer Settling Disputes

Singer LR Settling Disputes (Westview Press Boulder 1990)

Skelton "Family Group Conferencing"

Skelton A "Family Group Conferencing in the Proposed Child Justice Bill: Implications for the Child Care System" in Sloth-Nielsen J and Du Toit Z (eds) Trials and Tribulations, Trends and Triumphs: Developments in International, African and South African Child and Family Law (Juta Cape Town 2008) 175-187

Skelton and Frank "Conferencing in South Africa"

Skelton A and Frank C "Conferencing in South Africa: Returning to Our Future" in Morris A and Maxwell G (eds) Restorative Justice for Juveniles: Conferencing, Mediation and Circles (Hart Portland 2003) 103-119

Sloth-Nielsen and Gallinetti 2011 PELJ

Sloth-Nielsen J and Gallinetti J "'Just Say Sorry?' Ubuntu, Africanisation and the Child Justice System in the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008" 2011 PELJ 14(4) 62-90

Stintzing Mediation

Stintzing H Mediation – A Necessary Element in Family Dispute Resolution? (Peter Lang Frankfurt 1994)

Umbreit 1997 MQ

Umbreit MS "Humanistic Mediation: a Transformative Journey of Peacemaking" 1997 MQ 201-213

Umbreit et al 2007 CJCR

Umbreit MS et al "Restorative Justice: An Empirically Grounded Movement Facing Many Opportunities and Pitfalls" 2007 CJCR 511-564

Van Zyl Divorce Mediation

Van Zyl L Divorce Mediation and the Best Interests of the Child (HSRC Pretoria1997)

Zulu 1998 OTE

Zulu E "Reconciliation from an African Perspective: an Alternative View" 1998 OTE 182-194

Register of cases

Mabuza v Mbatha 2003 4 SA 218 (C)

S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)

Register of legislation

Child Justice Act 75 of 2008

Children's Act 38 of 2005

Traditional Courts Bill B15-2008

Register of internet sources

Curan and Bonthuys 2004 www.csvr.org.za

Curan E and Bonthuys E 2004 Customary Law and Domestic Violence in Rural South African Communities www.csvr.org.za/wits/papers/papclaw.htm [date of use 27 Feb 2012]

Onazi 2009 www.gowarwick.ac.uk

Onazi O 2009 "Good Governance and the Marketization of Human Rights: A Critique of the Neoliberal Normative Approach" Law, Social Justice and Global Development Journal www.go.warwick.ac.uk/elj/lgd/2009_2/onazi [date of use 12 Feb 2012]

Zumeta 2000 www.mediate.com

Zumeta Z 2000 Styleds of Mediation: Facilitative, Evaluative, and Transformative Mediation www.mediate.com/articles/zumeta.cfm [date of use 29 Feb 2012]

Published

01-06-2017

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Boniface, A. (2017). African-Style Mediation and Western-Style Divorce and Family Mediation: Reflections for the South African Context. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 15(5), 377-401. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i5a2529

Similar Articles

1-10 of 1188

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.