"Just say sorry?" Ubuntu, Africanisation and the Child Justice System in the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2011/v14i4a2584Keywords:
Restorative justice, Ubuntu, Child Justice Act 75 of 2008, Child offenders, Criminal justice system and Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996Abstract
In the midst of concerns about serious offences committed by young people, the Child Justice Act is the first formal legislative step to introduce restorative justice in South Africa, and promotes reconciliation and problem solving as an approach to the criminal behaviour of youth.
This article analyses the new place of restorative justice and ubuntu in the Act through an analysis of the Preamble, Objects and General Principles sections of the Act as well as the chapters on diversion and sentencing. It notes that there is a clear and consistent framework for restorative justice and ubuntu in the Act that accords with the Constitutional Court’s understanding of both concepts.
In addition, the article also enquires if the inclusion of these concepts has created a criminal justice system for children that does not hold them properly accountable for their actions. The question as to whether or not the Act has created a "just say sorry" regime is answered in the negative by way of reference to the numerous checks and balances included in the Act by the legislature.
In this context it is contended that the inclusion of ubuntu-related ideologies remains relevant to the development of indigenous and locally constructed images of Africanised forms of justice, but that the true test of how it is integrated into the criminal justice system lies in the manner in which criminal justice role-players engage with ubuntu and how its implementation is effected.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Books
Bronfenbrenner U The Ecology of Human Development
Bronfenbrenner U The Ecology of Human Development: experiments by nature and design (Harvard University Press USA 1979)
De Ville JR Constitutional and statutory interpretation
De Ville JR Constitutional and statutory interpretation (Interdoc Consultants (Pty) Ltd Cape Town 2000)
Chapters in Books
Maxwell G and Morris A "What is the place of Shame in Restorative Justice",
Maxwell G and Morris A "What is the place of Shame in Restorative Justice", in Zehr H and Toews B (eds) Critical Issues in Restorative Justice (Criminal Justice Press and Willan Publishing Monsey 2004
Pete S "A brief history of human rights in the prisons of Africa"
Pete S "A brief history of human rights in the prisons of Africa" in Sarkin J (ed) Human Rights in African Prisons (HSRC Press Cape Town, 2008)
Sloth–Nielsen J "The Business of Child Justice"
Sloth–Nielsen J "The Business of Child Justice" in Burchell J and Erasmus A (eds) Criminal Justice in a New Society (Juta Lansdowne 2003)
Contribution at conferences
Wakefield L "South Africa’s compliance
Wakefield L "South Africa’s compliance with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and other international instruments: Does the new Child Justice Act 75 of 2008 truly comply?" in The Children's Convention at 21: The Rights of the Child come of Age? 18 – 20 June 2010 University of Ulster (Magee Campus) Northern Ireland
Theses and dissertations
Gallinetti J An Assessment of the Significance
Gallinetti J An Assessment of the Significance of the International Labour Organisation’s Convention 182 in South Africa with specific reference to the instrumental use of Children in the Commission of Offences as a Worst form of Child Labour (PhD thesis UWC 2008)
Skelton A The Influence of the Theory and Practice
Skelton A The Influence of the Theory and Practice of Restorative Justice in South Africa with Special Reference to Child Justice (LLD thesis UP 2006)
Sloth-Nielsen J The Role of International law
Sloth-Nielsen J The Role of International law in Juvenile Justice Reform in South Africa (LLD thesis UWC 2001)
Journal articles
Keevy I "Ubuntu versus the core values
Keevy I "Ubuntu versus the core values of the South African constitution" 2009 Journal for Juridical Science
Skelton A "The South African Child Justice Bill"
Skelton A "The South African Child Justice Bill: Transition as Opportunity" in Jensen E and Jepson J (eds) Juvenile Law Violators, Human Rights and the Development of New Juvenile Justice Systems (Hart Publishing: Oxford 2006).
Skelton A "Severing the Umbilical Cord"
Skelton A "Severing the Umbilical Cord: A subtle jurisprudential shift regarding children and their primary caregivers" 2008 Constitutional Court Review
Skelton A "Face to face: Sachs on restorative justice"
Skelton A "Face to face: Sachs on restorative justice" (forth coming 2010) SA Public Law.
Skelton A and Gallinetti J "A long and winding road"
Skelton A and Gallinetti J "A long and winding road: The Child Justice Bill, civil society and advocacy 2008 SA Crime Quarterly
Other writings
Gallinetti J Getting to know the Child Justice Act
Gallinetti J Getting to know the Child Justice Act (Child Justice Alliance Cape Town 2009)
Muntingh L A Societal Responsibility
Muntingh L A Societal Responsibility: The role of civil society organisations in prisoner support, rehabilitation and reintegration (Civil Society Prison Reform Initiative and Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 2009)
Muntingh L "Ex-prisoners'"
Muntingh L Ex-prisoners’ Views in Imprisonment and Re-Entry (Civil Society Prison Reform Initiative and Community Law Centre Cape Town 2010)
Skelton A and Bately M 'Charting progress"
Skelton A and Bately M Charting progress, mapping the future: restorative justice in South Africa (Restorative Justice Centre and Institute for Security Studies 2006).
Sloth-Nielsen J "A short history of time"
Sloth-Nielsen J "A short history of time" in Gallinetti J et al Child Justice: Children’s Rights under Construction (The Child Justice Alliance and the Open Society Foundation for South Africa Cape Town 2006)
Legisation
Child Justice Bill 49 of 2002
Child Justice Act 75 of 2008
Children’s Act 38 of 2005
Criminal Law (Sentencing) Amendment Act 2007
List of Cases
Centre for Child Law v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and Others 2009 ZACC 18
Dikoko v Mokhatla 2006 6 SA 235 (CC)
DPP Kwa-Zulu Natal v P 2006(1) SACR 243 (SCA)
Le Roux and others v Dey and others CCT 45/2010
M v S (Centre for Child Law Amicus Curiae) 2007 (12) BCLR 1312 (CC)
MV Golden North Governor and Bank of Scotland v Fund Constituting the Proceeds of the Judicial Sale of the MV Golden North (Maritime Technical Co Ltd Intervening) 1999 (1) SA 144 (D) 152
National Association of Welfare Organisations and Non-Governmental Organisations and Others v Member of the Executive Council for Social Development, Free State, unreported, case no. 1719/2010
Port Elizabeth Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 (1) SA 217 (CC)
S v Makwanyane and Another 1995 (6) BCLR 665 (CC)
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 J Sloth-Nielsen, J Gallinetti
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}