In Defence of Pashukanism
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2011/v14i4a2586Keywords:
Capitalism, Commodity form, Homologue, Legal form, Legal subject, Marxism, Mode of production, Principle of equivalence, Relations of exchange and Relations of productionAbstract
This essay presents an extended defence of the general theory of law formulated by the Bolshevik jurist, Evgeny Pashukanis, and published in his Law and Marxism: A General Theory in 1924. The general theory is a theory of the legal form. Although Pashukanis did not name his theory, it has become known as the commodity form theory of law because of its theorising the legal form as a homologue of the commodity form. However, despite having weighty Marxist and revolutionary Bolshevik credentials, the general theory has been subjected to sustained attack, especially from new left and neo-Marxist circles. This essay identifies and explicates six major objections to Pashukanism from its left critics. These are that the general theory is too abstract to comprehend the reality of legal relations; that it is infused with economic reductionism; that it derives the legal form wrongly from commodity exchange; that it classifies the legal form incorrectly as an attribute of capitalism only; that it lacks the generality required of a general theory of law; and that it is imbricated in the growth of anarchism and Stalinism.
Following a brief exegetical exercise, the bulk of the essay is devoted to demonstrating in detail that each of the six objections to the general theory is without merit, and that none makes any serious incursion into its integrity as a theory of the legal form. The central submission of the essay is that the Pashukanist general theory of law is rooted in the first principles of classical Marxism and hence may lay claim legitimately to being the Marxist theory of law.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Alexander An Ordinary Country
Alexander N An Ordinary Country: Issues in the Transition from Apartheid to Democracy in South Africa (University of Natal Press Pietermaritzburg 2002)
Anderson Passages from Antiquity to Feudalism
Anderson P Passages from Antiquity to Feudalism (Verso London 1981)
Arthur "Editor’s Introduction"
Arthur C "Editor’s Introduction" in Pashukanis E Law and Marxism: A General Theory (Ink Links London 1978) 9-31
Balbus "Commodity Form and Legal Form"
Balbus I "Commodity Form and Legal Form: An Essay on the Relative Autonomy of Law" in Reasons C and Rich R. The Sociology of Law: A Conflict Perspective. (Butterworths Toronto 1978) 73-90
Balibar "The Basic Concepts of Historical Materialism"
Balibar E "The Basic Concepts of Historical Materialism" in Althusser L and Balibar E Reading Capital. (New Left Books London 1970) 199-308
Beirne and Sharlet "Introduction"
Beirne P and Sharlet R (1979) "Introduction" in Evgeny Pashukanis: Selected Writings on Marxism and Law (Academic Press London 1980) 1-36
Binns 1980 Capital and Class
Binns P "Review Article: Law and Marxism" 1980 Capital and Class 100-113
Butler Soviet Law
Butler W Soviet Law (Butterworths London 1988)
Collins Marxism and Law
Collins H Marxism and Law (Oxford University Press Oxford 1984)
Davis "Legality and Struggle"
Davis D "Legality and Struggle: Towards a Non-Instrumentalist View of Law" in Corder H (ed) Essays on Law and Social Practice in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 1988) 65-92
Engels "Speech"
Engels F "Speech at the Graveside of Karl Marx" in Tucker R (ed) The Marx-Engels Reader (WW Norton & Company New York 1978) 681-682
Engels "Lawyers’ Socialism"
Engels F "Lawyers’ Socialism" in Marx K. and Engels F. Collected Works: Volume 26 (Lawrence & Wishart London 1990) 597-616
Fine Democracy and the Rule of Law
Fine B Democracy and the Rule of Law: Liberal Ideals and Marxist Critiques (Pluto Press London 1984)
Fuller 1949 Michigan LR
Fuller L "Pashukanis and Vyshinsky: A Study in the Development of Marxian Legal Theory" 1949 Michigan LR 1157-1166
Gavigan 1981 Canadian Criminology Forum
Gavigan S "Marxist Theories of Law: A Survey, with Some Thoughts on Women and Law" 1981 Canadian Criminology Forum 1-12
Harvey The Limits to Capital
Harvey D The Limits to Capital (Basil Blackwell Oxford 1982)
Hayek Law, Legislation and Liberty
Hayek FA Law, Legislation and Liberty Volume 2: The Mirage of Social Justice (The University of Chicago Press Chicago 1978)
Hazard 1954 American Journal of International Law
Hazard J "Pashukanis is no Traitor" 1954 American Journal of International Law 385-388
Head Evgeny Pashukanis
Head M Evgeny Pashukanis: A Critical Reappraisal (Routledge-Cavendish Oxford 2008)
Hegel The Philosophy of History
Hegel G The Philosophy of History (Dover Publications New York 1956)
Hirst On Law and Ideology
Hirst P On Law and Ideology (Macmillan London 1979)
Hitchens 2009 The Atlantic
Hitchens C "He’s Back: The Current Crisis and the Enduring Relevance of Marx" 2009 The Atlantic 88-95
Hunt Explorations in Law and Society
Hunt A Explorations in Law and Society: Toward a Constitutive Theory of Law (Routledge New York 1993)
Jakubowski Ideology and Superstructure
Jakubowski F Ideology and Superstructure in Historical Materialism (Pluto Press London 1990)
Jessop The Capitalist State
Jessop B The Capitalist State: Marxist Theories and Methods (Martin Robertson Oxford 1982)
Kelsen The Communist Theory of Law
Kelsen H The Communist Theory of Law (Stevens & Sons Limited London 1955)
Korsch "Appendix"
Korsch K "Appendix: An Assessment by Karl Korsch" in Pashukanis E Law and Marxism: A General Theory (Ink Links London 1978) 189-195
Larrain A Reconstruction of Historical Materialism
Larrain J A Reconstruction of Historical Materialism (George Allen & Unwin London 1986)
Lipson "Is there a Marxist Theory of Law?"
Lipson L "Is there a Marxist Theory of Law? Comments on Tushnet" in Pennock J and Chapman J (eds) Marxism: NOMOS XXVI (New York University Press New York 1983) 189-195
Lloyd and Freeman Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence
Lloyd of Hampstead and Freeman M Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence (Stevens & Sons London 1985)
Löwy The Politics of Combined and Uneven Development
Löwy M The Politics of Combined and Uneven Development: The Theory of Permanent Revolution (Verso London 1981)
Makepeace Marxist Ideology and Soviet Criminal Law
Makepeace R Marxist Ideology and Soviet Criminal Law (Croom Helm London 1980)
Mandel Introduction to Marxism
Mandel E Introduction to Marxism (Ink Links London 1979)
Marx Capital
Marx K Capital: Volume 1 (Lawrence & Wishart London 1954)
Marx Grundrisse
Marx K Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy (Penguin Books Middlesex 1973)
Marx A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy
Marx K A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (Progress Publishers Moscow 1977)
Melossi and Pavarini The Prison and the Factory
Melossi D and Pavarini M The Prison and the Factory: Origins of the Penitentiary System (The Macmillan Press London 1981)
Miéville Between Equal Rights
Miéville C Between Equal Rights: A Marxist Theory of International Law (Brill Leiden 2005)
Milovanovic "Introduction"
Milovanovic D "Introduction to the Transaction Edition" in Pashukanis E The General Theory of Law and Marxism (Transaction Publishers New Brunswick 2002) vii-xxvi
Norrie 1982 International Journal of the Sociology of Law
Norrie A "Pashukanis and the Commodity Form Theory: A Reply to Warrington" 1982 International Journal of the Sociology of Law 419-437
Ollman Dialectical Investigations
Ollman B Dialectical Investigations (Routledge London 1993)
Pashukanis Law and Marxism
Pashukanis EB Law and Marxism: A General Theory (Ink Links London 1978)
Plamenatz Man and Society
Plamenatz J Man and Society: Volume 2 (Longmans London 1963)
Plekhanov The Materialist Conception of History
Plekhanov G The Materialist Conception of History (Lawrence & Wishart London 1976)
Reed Woman's Evolution
Reed E Woman's Evolution: From Matriarchal Clan to Patriarchal Family (Pathfinder Press New York 1975)
Sayer The Violence of Abstraction
Sayer D The Violence of Abstraction: The Analytic Foundations of Historical Materialism (Basil Blackwell Oxford 1987)
Schlesinger R Soviet Legal Theory
Schlesinger R Soviet Legal Theory: Its Social Background and Development (Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co London 1946)
Schumpeter Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy
Schumpeter JA Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (Unwin University Books London 1966)
Sparkes Talking Philosophy
Sparkes A Talking Philosophy: A Wordbook (Routledge London 1991)
Stone 1985 Law and Society Review
Stone A "The Place of Law in the Marxian Structure-Superstructure Archetype" 1985 Law and Society Review 39-67
Stuchka "Proletarian Law"
Stuchka P "Proletarian Law" in Rosenberg W (ed) Bolshevik Visions: First Phase of the Cultural Revolution in Soviet Russia Part 1(University of Michigan Press Michigan: 1990)
Stuchka "The Old and New Court"
Stuchka P "The Old and New Court" in Rosenberg W (ed) Bolshevik Visions: First Phase of the Cultural Revolution in Soviet Russia Part 1 (University of Michigan Press Michigan: 1990)
Stuchka "Five Years of Revolution in Law"
Stuchka P "Five Years of Revolution in Law" in Rosenberg W (ed) Bolshevik Visions: First Phase of the Cultural Revolution in Soviet Russia Part 1 (University of Michigan Press Michigan: 1990)
Sumner Reading Ideologies
Sumner C Reading Ideologies (Academic Press London 1979)
Sweezy The Theory of Capitalist Development
Sweezy P The Theory of Capitalist Development (Monthly Review Press New York 1942)
Timpanaro On Materialism
Timpanaro S On Materialism (Verso London 1980)
Trotsky Literature and Revolution
Trotsky L Literature and Revolution (University of Michigan Press Michigan 1975)
Tushnet "Is there a Marxist Theory of Law?"
Tushnet M "Is there a Marxist Theory of Law?" in Pennock J and Chapman J (eds) Marxism: NOMOS XXVI (New York University Press New York 1983) 171-188
Vincent 1993 Journal of Law and Society
Vincent A "Marx and Law" 1993 Journal of Law and Society 371-397
Vyshinsky The Law of the Soviet State
Vyshinsky A The Law of the Soviet State (Macmillan New York 1954)
Warrington "Pashukanis and the Commodity Form Theory"
Warrington R "Pashukanis and the Commodity Form Theory" in Sugarman D (ed) Legality, Ideology and the State (Academic Press London 1983) 43-67
Young "Punishment and Social Organization"
Young P "Punishment and Social Organization" in Bankowski Z and Mungham G (eds) Essays in Law and Society (Routledge Direct Editions London 1980) 113-126
Register of internet sources
Angus Reid Global Monitor 2008 http://www.angus-reid.com
Angus Reid Global Monitor 2008 Europe, US blame capitalism abuses for crisis http://www.angus-reid.com/polls/34157/europe_us_blame_capitalism_abuses_
for_crisis/ [date of use 14 June 2011]
BBC World Service 2009 http://www.worldpublicopinion.org
BBC World Service 2009 Wide dissatisfaction with capitalism – twenty years after the fall of Berlin Wall http://www.worldpublicopinion.org/pipa/articles/
btglobalizationtradera/644.php [date of use 14 June 2011]
Boyes 2008 http://business.timesonline.co.uk
Boyes R 2008 Banking crisis gives added capital to Karl Marx’s writings http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/economics/article4974912.ece [date of use 7 June 2011]
Connolly 2008 http://www.guardian.co.uk
Connolly K 2008 Booklovers turn to Karl Marx as financial crisis bites in Germany http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2008/oct/15/marx-germany-popularity-financial-crisis [date of use 7 June 2011]
De Santis 2009 http://www.humaniteinenglish.com
De Santis G 2009 Round the world, opposition to capitalism continues http://www.humaniteinenglish.com/spip.php?article1381 [Date of use 14 June 2011]
NBC News 2009 http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com
NBC News/Bo Gu 2009 Chinese coming back to Marx amid crisis http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2009/04/08/4376532-chinese-coming-back-to-marx-amid-crisis [date of use 7 June 2011]
The Economist 2011 http://www.economist.com
The Economist 2011 Public opinion on capitalism: Market troubles http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/04/public_opinion_capitalism [date of use 14 June 2011]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 R Koen
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}