DNA Profiling and the Law in South Africa
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2011/v14i4a2587Keywords:
DNA, Profiling, Evidence, DNA Analysis, Forensic, Scientific evidence, Criminal, Trial, Law of Evidence, Crime SceneAbstract
DNA evidence is currently at the forefront of the arsenal of evidence employed in criminal trials. To ensure its optimum use in criminal proceedings, it is imperative that the legal fraternity is properly conversant with the scientific basis and presentation of such evidence, as well as with its potential pitfalls. In an effort to provide the legal profession with a background to this complex and useful type of evidence, this article looks at the biochemical nature of DNA, at DNA profiling and its use in criminal trials, and at the processes of DNA collection and analysis in the Biology Unit of the Forensic Science Laboratory of the South African Police Service. The presentation of DNA evidence in court is then evaluated and the future of DNA evidence, including legislative reform, and the creation of a DNA database are discussed.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
B
Bronstein Law for the Expert Witness
Bronstein DA Law for the Expert Witness 2nd ed (CRC Press Boca Raton 1999)
Buckleton et al Forensic DNA Evidence Interpretation
Buckleton J; Triggs CM and Walsh SJ Forensic DNA evidence interpretation (CRC Press Boca Raton 2005)
Butler Fundamentals of Forensic DNA Typing
Butler JM Fundamentals of Forensic DNA Typing (Academic Press Publications USA 2010)
C
Cassim 1997 Acta Criminol
Cassim Y "DNA profiling: What can South Africa gain from the British experience?" 1997 Acta Criminologica 10(1):11-16
Clare 2002 The Journal of Criminal Law
Clare A "Retention of DNA samples" 2002 The Journal of Criminal Law 66(4):296-297
Clare 2003 The Journal of Criminal Law
Clare A "Retention of fingerprints and DNA samples: Compatibility with the European Convention on Human Rights" 2003 The Journal of Criminal Law 67(1):23-24
D
DefenceWeb 2009 DNA database delayed?
DefenceWeb 2009 DNA database delayed?
http://www.defenceweb.co.za/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=5112&Itemid=426. Accessed 03/06/2011.
De Gama 2002 De Jure
De Gama J "Forensic and scientific developments in genomics and the impact on criminal and legal investigations: DNA testing" 2002 De Jure 35(2):297-305
DNA Project 2010 DNA Laws are passed everywhere but here!
DNA Project 2010 DNA Laws are passed everywhere but here!
E
Ellis 2003 TRW
Ellis A "Baby rape: Why does the law not protect them?" 2003 Tydskrif vir Regswetenskap 28(1):59-75
G
Ginsbourg 1998 Law Institute Journal
Ginsbourg S "Forensic samples under s 464ZF of the Crimes Act" 1998 Law Institute Journal 12(72):50-52
GN 33607 in GG 31759 of 29 December 2008
Goodwin and Meintjes-Van der Walt 1997 SALJ
Goodwin JA and Meintjes-Van der Walt L "The use of DNA evidence in South Africa: Powerful tool or prone to pitfalls?" 1997 The South African Law Journal 114(1):151-173
J
Joh 2011 Boston Univ L Rev
Joh EE "DNA Theft: Recognizing the crime of non-consensual genetic collection and testing" 2011 Boston University Law Review 91:665-700.
K
Kiely Forensic Evidence
Kiely TF Forensic Evidence: Science and the Criminal Law 2nd ed (CRC Press Boca Raton 2006)
Kirby and Downing 1999 Obiter
Kirby R and Downing TG "The principles and problems of DNA – profiling for legal purposes in South Africa" 1999 Obiter 2(20):307-326
Koehler 1997 Journal of Legal Education
Koehler JJ "One in millions, billions and trillions: Lessons from People v Collins (1968) for People v Simpson (1995) 1997 Journal of Legal Education 47:214-223
L
Ligertwood 2003 Australian Law Journal
Ligertwood A "Avoiding Bayes in DNA cases" 2003 Australian Law Journal 77(5):317-326
Lucassen "Structured qualitative interview"
Lucassen A (Chief Forensic Analyst and Population Database Custodian: DNA Unit of the Forensic Science Laboratory of the South African Police Service) "Structured qualitative interview" (Bloemfontein Magistrate's Office 10 November 2004)
Lupton 1996 Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg
Lupton ML "Genetic engineering – the legal implications" 1996 Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 1:56-67
M
Martin 1998 De Rebus
Martin C "DNA profiling" 1998 De Rebus August 66-68
Mathews and Van Holde Biochemistry
Mathews CK and Van Holde KE Biochemistry 2nd ed (The Benjamin/Cummings Publishing Company Menlo Park 1996)
Meintjes-Van der Walt 2000 Tydskrif vir Regsvergelyking en Internasionale Reg van Suidelike Afrika
Meintjes-Van der Walt L "Many a slip… The need for strengthening the chain of expert evidence" 2000 Tydskrif vir Regsvergelyking en Internasionale Reg van Suidelike Afrika 3(33):348-365
Meintjes-Van der Walt 2000a SACJ
Meintjes-Van der Walt L "Pre-trial disclosure of expert evidence: Lessons from abroad" 2000a South African Journal of Criminal Justice (13):145-159
Meintjes-Van der Walt 2001 SACJ
Meintjes-Van der Walt L "Dealing with DNA-evidence: S v Maqhina 2001(1) SACR 241(T)" 2001 South African Journal of Criminal Justice (14):378-383
Meintjes-Van der Walt 2008 SACJ
Meintjes-Van der Walt L "An overview of the use of DNA evidence in South African criminal courts" 2008 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 21(1):22-62
Meintjes-Van der Walt DNA in the Courtroom:Principles and Practice
Meintjes-Van der Walt DNA in the Courtroom: Principles and Practice (Juta & Co. Ltd Cape Town 2010)
Mooki 1997 The South African Journal on Human Rights
Mooki O "DNA typing as a forensic tool: Applications and implications for civil liberties" 1997 The South African Journal on Human Rights 13(4):565-580
Muller and Saayman 2003 SA Huisartspraktyk
Muller K and Saayman G "Forensic science in medicine: What every doctor in SA should know" 2003 SA Huisartspraktyk 45(6):41-45
Murphy 2008 Emory Law Journal
Murphy E "The art in the science of DNA: A layperson's guide to the subjectivity inherent in forensic DNA typing" 2008 Emory Law Journal 58:489-512
O
Olivier 2002 Acta Criminol
Olivier N "The role of DNA in the investigation of crime: A case for its use by South African investigators" 2002 Acta Criminologica 15(2):83-92
P
PMG 2010 Criminal Law (Forensic Procedures) Amendment Bill: Secretariat of Police presentation.
Parliamentary Monitoring Group (PMG) 2010 Criminal Law (Forensic Procedures) Amendment Bill: Secretariat of Police presentation.
http://www.pmg.org.za/report/20100728-secretariat-police-presentation-criminal-law-forensic-procedures-amen. Accessed on 03/06/2011.
R
Redmayne 2002 MLR
Redmayne M "Appeals to reason" 2002 The Modern Law Review 65(1):19-35
S
SANAS "Technical guidelines for forensic DNA testing laboratories"
SANAS (South African National Accreditation System) "Technical guidelines for forensic DNA testing laboratories" Version 4 (October 2002)
Swergold BC Int’l & Comp L Rev
Swergold JM "To have and to hold: The future of DNA retention in the United Kingdom" 2010 Boston College International and Comparative Law Review 33(1):179-200.
V
Van Niekerk 2001 Prosecutor's Manual
Van Niekerk J "Human identification through forensic genetic typing (DNA)" 2001 Prosecutor's Manual 1:C10 1-14
W
Watson, Gilman, Witkowski and Zoller 1992 Recombinant DNA
Watson JD, Gilman M, Witkowski, J and Zoller M Recombinant DNA 2nd ed (WH Freeman and Company New York 1992)
Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996
Crimes Act of 1958 (Victoria, Australia)
Criminal Law (Forensic Procedures) Amendment Bill (South Africa)
Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 (South Africa)
DNA Identification Act of 1998 (Manitoba, Canada)
Police and Criminal Evidence Act of 1984 (England)
Register of cases
Frye 293 F.1013 DC Cir 1923
Klink v Regional Magistrate NO 1996 3 BCLR 402 (SE)
People v Simpson 1995 (case reference not available)
R v Chamberlain (2) 1984 153 CLR 521
R v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire [2002] EWCA Civ 1275
R v Clark CA 07495Y3 (2 Oct 2000)
S v Maqhina 2001 1 SACR 241 (T)
S v Van der Sandt 1997 2 SACR 116 (W)
S v Van Tonder 1976 3 SA 391 (T)
S and Marper v United Kingdom 30562/04 [2008] ECHR 1581 (4 December 2008)
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 S de Wet, J Visser
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}