Pre- and Post-Trial Equality in Criminal Justice in the Context of the Separation of Powers
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2011/v14i5a2600Keywords:
prosecutors, nolle prosequi, pre-trial equality, post-trial equality, pardon, parole, administrative act, administration of justice, criminal justice, judicial power, prerogative powerAbstract
The previous Westminster criminal justice system entailed a different kind of separation of powers insofar as it concerns the role of state prosecutors. In the Westminster system prosecutors are part of the executive branch, whereas they were a split-off from the judiciary in constitutional states and function like a de facto second organ of the third branch of state power. Currently executive interference in state prosecutions often leads to pre-trial inequality. A further difficulty arises from the unconsidered manner in which the former royal prerogative of pardoning was retained in the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996. It used to be a royal veto of judicial sentences in the constitutional monarchy of the former Westminster model. Although the corresponding veto of parliamentary legislation by the head of state did not survive into modern times, the pardoning power has not been discontinued. Section 84(2)(j) thus causes an irreconcilable conflict with section 165(5) of the Constitution which guarantees the legally binding force of judicial decisions. It undermines the rule of law and leads to post-trial inequality in the execution of sentences. The parole system, which dates back to 1959, likewise allows the executive to overrule judicial sentences and is in conflict with section 165(5). The perpetuation of the status quo in criminal justice is in effect leading to a re-Westminstering of the constitutional state.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Ambos 2003 Jura
Ambos K "Staatsanwaltliche Kontrolle der Polizei, Verpolizeilichung des Ermittlungsverfahrens und organisierte Kriminalität" 2003 Jura 647-682
Aragão Strategien
Aragão EJG Strategien zur Durchsetzung der völkerrechtliche Verpflichtung zur Strafverfolgung der Folter am Beispiel Brasiliens: Eine Untersuchung zum Verhältnis zwischen Völkerstrafrecht und Staatenverantwortung (Berliner Wissenschafts-Verlag Berlin 2007)
Bachof 1983 Juristenzeitung
Bachof O "Über Fragwürdigkeiten der Gnadenpraxis und der Gnadenkompetenz" 1983 Juristenzeitung 469-475
Bailey Policing and Punishment
Bailey V Policing and Punishment in Nineteenth Century Britain (Taylor and Francis London 1981)
Barcroft 1993 HRLJ
Barcroft AA "The Presidential Pardon: A Flawed Solution" 1993 HRLJ 381-394
Basson and Viljoen Constitutional Law
Basson D and Viljoen H South African Constitutional Law (Juta Cape Town 1988)
Baxter Administrative Law
Baxter L Administrative Law (Juta Cape Town 1984)
Bekink 2003 SAPL
Bekink B "Presidential pardons: Constitutional necessity or political nuisance? Some points of critique" 2003 SAPL 371-392
Beukes 1993 SAPL
Beukes M "A study in severe legal positivism, or: Is expediency synonymous with arbitrariness?" 1993 SAPL 166-170
Birch British System
Birch AH The British System of Government 9th ed (Routledge London 1993)
Blaau 1990 SALJ
Blaau [sic] LC "The Rechtsstaat idea compared to Rule of Law as a paradigm for protecting rights" 1990 SALJ 76-96
Blaauw-Wolf 1999 SAPL
Blaauw-Wolf L "The 'balancing of interests' with reference to the principle of proportionality and the doctrine of Güterabwägung – a comparative analysis" 1999 SAPL 178-214
Blackstone et al Laws of England
Blackstone W et al Commentaries on the Laws of England Vol 2 (Lippencott and Co Philadelphia 1867)
Booysen and van Wyk '83 Grondwet
Booysen H and van Wyk D Die '83 Grondwet (Juta Cape Town 1984)
Bradley and Ewing Constitutional and Administrative Law
Bradley AW and Ewing KD Constitutional and Administrative Law 14th ed (Pearson Education Essex 2007)
Brazier Constitutional Practice
Brazier R Constitutional Practice 3rd ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 1999)
Burchell 2002 SALJ
Burchell J "Criminal law at the crossroads" 2002 SALJ 579-602
Burchell and Milton Principles of Criminal Law
Burchell JM and Milton J Principles of Criminal Law 3rd ed (Juta Lansdowne 2005)
Burns and Beukes Administrative Law
Burns Y and Beukes M Administrative Law under the 1996 Constitution (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2006)
Butler Art of the Possible
Butler, Lord RA The Art of the Possible (Gambit Pubications Boston 1971)
Carpenter Constitutional Law
Carpenter G South African Constitutional Law (Butterworths Durban 1987)
Carpenter 1989 CILSA
Carpenter G "Prerogative powers – an anachronism?" 1989 CILSA 190-205
Casella Asset Forfeiture Law
Casella SD Asset Forfeiture Law in the United States (JurisNet Huntington 2007)
Casella 2007 US Attorneys' Bulletin
Casella SD "Overview of assets forfeiture law in the United States" 2007 US Attorneys' Bulletin 55(6) 8-20
Collin Wächter der Gesetze
Collin P "Wächter der Gesetze" oder "Organ der Staatsregierung"? (Klostermann Frankfurt 2000)
Crouch 2008 Presidential Studies Quarterly
Crouch J "The law: Presidential misuse of the pardon power" 2008 Presidential Studies Quarterly 722-734
Currie and De Waal Constitutional Law
Currie I and De Waal J Constitutional Law (Juta Cape Town 2001)
Dicey Law of the Constitution
Dicey I Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution 5th ed (Macmillan London 1897)
Dimoulis Begnadigung
Dimoulis D Die Begnadigung in vergleichender Perspektive: Rechtsphilosophische, verfassungsrechtliche und strafrechtliche Probleme (Duncker und Humblot Berlin 1996)
Dissel New Release Policy
Dissel A The New Release Policy: Problems Concerning its Structure and Implementation (Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation Braamfontein 1994)
Dölemeyer "Ministère public und Staatsanwaltschaft"
Dölemeyer B "Ministère public und Staatsanwaltschaft – Der Einfluß des 'modèle judiciaire français' im Rheinland" in Durand B et al Staatsanwaltschaft – Europäische und Amerikanische Geschichten (Kostermann Frankfurt 2005) 85-103
Du Plessis 1991 SALJ
Du Plessis JR "Accusatory system – too much a game?" 1991 SALJ 577-582
Ehmke "Verfassungsinterpretation"
Ehmke H "Prinzipien der Verfassungsinterpretation" in Veröffentlichungen der Vereinigung der Deutschen Staatsrechtslehrer (De Gruyter Berlin 1963) 53-98
Fagan 2004 SA Crime Quarterly
Fagan H "Curb the vengeance: Laws on minimum sentencing and parole spell worsening prison conditions" 2004 SA Crime Quarterly (10) 1-5
Feinstein After the Party
Feinstein A After the Party: A Personal and Political Journey Inside the ANC (Jonathan Ball Johannesburg 2007)
Fernandez "Post-TRC Prosecutions"
Fernandez L "Post-TRC Prosecutions in South Africa" in Werle G (ed) Justice in Transition – Prosecution and Amnesty in Germany and South Africa (Berliner Wissenschafts-Verlag Berlin 2006) 65-82
Fionda Public Prosecutors
Fionda J Public Prosecutors and Discretion: A Comparative Study (Oxford University Press Oxford 1995)
Fornauf Dritten Staatsgewalt
Fornauf M Die Marginalisierung der Unabhängigkeit der Dritten Staatsgewalt im System des Strafrechts (Peter Lang Frankfurt 2010)
Fowler, Thompson and Fowler Concise Oxford Dictionary
Fowler HW, Thompson D and Fowler FG The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Current English 9th ed (Clarendon Press Gloucestershire 1995)
Frank and Harms 2008 Deutschen Richterzeitung
Frank H and Harms M "Paradigmenwechsel im Strafprozess – Interview" 2008 Deutschen Richterzeitung 86(5) 126-131
Gaumer 2007 US Attorneys' Bulletin
Gaumer C "A prosecutor's secret weapon: Federal civil forfeiture law" 2007 US Attorneys' Bulletin 55(6) 59-75
Gelber 2003 MLR
Gelber C "Reckley (No 2) and the prerogative of mercy: Act of grace or constitutional safeguard?" 2003 MLR 572-582
Geerds "Weisungsrecht gegenüber Staatsanwälte"
Geerds F "Zum Weisungsrecht gegenüber Staatsanwälte" in Ostendorf H Strafverfolgung und Strafverzicht (Carl Heymans Cologne1992) 297-316
Giffard and Muntingh Effect of Sentencing
Giffard C and Muntingh L The Effect of Sentencing on the Size of the South African Prison Population (CSPRI Publications Belville 2006)
Götz "Bundesverfassungsgericht"
Götz V "Bundesverfassungsgericht und Vertrauensschutz" in Starck C (ed) Bundesverfassungsgericht und Grundgesetz. Festgabe aus Anlaß des 25jährigen Bestehens des BVerfG Vol 2 (Mohr Tübingen 1976) 421-452
Götz Polizei- und Ordnungsrecht
Götz V Allgemeines Polizei- und Ordnungsrecht 14th ed (CH Beck Munich 2008)
Greek "History of Forfeiture"
Greek C "Drug Control and Asset Seizures: A Review of the History of Forfeiture in England and Colonial America" in Mieczkowski T (ed) Drugs, Crime and Social Policy (Allyn and Bacon Boston 1992)
Haas Strafbegriff
Haas V Strafbegriff, Staatsverständnis und Prozeßstruktur (Mohr Siebeck Tübingen 2008)
Hassemer "Legalität and Opportunität"
Hassemer W "Legalität and Opportunität im Strafverfahren – eine Skizze" in Ostendorf H Strafverfolgung und Strafverzicht (Carl Heymans Cologne 1992) 529-540
Hassemer Strafrecht
Hassemer W Strafrecht. Sein Selbstverständnis, seine Welt (Berliner Wissenschafts-Verlag Berlin 2006)
Harris 2003 CLJ
Harris BV "Judicial Review, Justiciability and the Prerogative of Mercy" 2003 CLJ 631-660
Henke Das subjective öffentliche Recht
Henke W Das subjective öffentliche Recht (Mohr Tübingen 1968)
Hesse Grundzüge
Hesse K Grundzüge des Verfassungsrechts 20th ed (CF Müller Heidelberg 1999)
Hirschel, Wakefield and Sasse Criminal Justice
Hirschel J, Wakefield W and Sasse S Criminal Justice in England and the United States (Jones and Bartlett London 2008)
Hoexter Administrative Law
Hoexter C Administrative Law (Juta Cape Town 2002)
Jackson and Leopold Constitutional and Administrative Law
Jackson P and Leopold P O Hood Phillips and Jackson: Constitutional and Administrative Law 8th ed (Sweet and Maxwell London 2001)
Jesch Gesetz und Verwaltung
Jesch D Gesetz und Verwaltung (Mohr Tübingen 1961)
Joliffe Constitutional History
Joliffe JEA The Constitutional History of Medieval England 4th ed (WW Norton London 1961)
Joubert Strafprosesreg
Joubert JJ (ed) Strafprosesreg Handboek 8th ed (Juta Cape Town 2007)
Kalloch 2009 Harvard Law Record
Kalloch A "Presidential pardons undermine the rule of law" 2009 Harvard Law Record (22 Jan)
Keir Constitutional History
Keir DL The Constitutional History of Modern Britain 1485-1937 3rd ed (A & C Black London 1947)
Kelker 2006 ZGS
Kelker B "Die Rolle der Staatsanwaltschaft im Strafverfahren" 2006 ZGS 389-426
King 2000 U Western Aust L Rev
King LJ "The Attorney-General, Politics and the Judiciary" 2000 U Western Aust L Rev 155-179
Köhler Strafrecht
Köhler M Strafrecht: Allgemeiner Teil (Springer Heidelberg 1997)
Koller Staatsanwaltschaft
Koller C Die Staatsanwaltschaft – Organ der Judikative oder Exekutivbehörde? Die Stellung der Anklagebehörde und die Gewaltenteilung des Grundgesetzes (Peter Lang Frankfurt 1997)
Lorenzen "Legalitäts- and Opportunitätsprinzip"
Lorenzen H "Legalitäts- and Opportunitätsprinzip – Kritische Betrachtungen aus der und für die Strafverfolgungspraxis" in Ostendorf H Strafverfolgung und Strafverzicht (Carl Heymans Cologne 1992) 541-548
Love 2007 Federal Sentencing Reporter
Love MC "Reinventing the President's pardon power" 2007 Federal Sentencing Reporter 5-15
Löwe, Böttcher and Riess Strafprozeßordnung und GVG
Löwe E, Böttcher R and Riess P Die Strafprozeßordnung und das Gerichtsverfassungsgesetz Vol 7 (Walter de Gruyter Berlin 2003)
Maitland Constitutional History
Maitland FW The Constitutional History of England (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1968)
Mansfield and Peay Director of Public Prosecutions
Mansfield G and Peay J The Director of Public Prosecutions: Principles and Practices for the Crown Prosecutor (Tavistock London 1987)
Maurer Staatsrecht
Maurer H Staatsrecht – Grundlagen, Verfassungsorgane, Staatsfunktionen 5th ed (CH Beck Munich 2007)
Maurer Allgemeines Verwaltungsrecht
Maurer H Allgemeines Verwaltungsrecht 16th ed (CH Beck Munich 2006)
Merten Rechtsstaatlichkeit und Gnade
Merten D Rechtsstaatlichkeit und Gnade (Duncker und Humblot Berlin 1978)
Mickisch Gnade im Rechtsstaat
Mickisch C Die Gnade im Rechtsstaat – Grundlinien einer rechtsdogmatischen, staatsrechtlichen und Verfahrensrechtlichen Neukonzeption (Peter Lang Frankfurt 1994)
Ministry of Justice Governance of Britain
Ministry of Justice The Governance of Britain - Constitutional Renewal Cm 7342 (The Stationary Office London 2008)
Montesquieu Spirit of the Laws
Montesquieu, Baron Charles de Secondat The Spirit of the Laws (translated from the original French by Nugent T) (Bell and Sons London 1914)
Moore Pardons
Moore D Pardons: Justice, Mercy, and the Public Interest (Oxford University Press New York 1989)
Müller Einheit der Verfassung
Müller F Einheit der Verfassung (Duncker und Humblot Berlin 1979)
Müller Juristische Metodik
Müller F Juristische Metodik 7th ed (Duncker und Humblot Berlin 1997)
Müller Positivität der Grundrechte
Müller F Positivität der Grundrechte 2nd ed (Duncker und Humblot Berlin 1990)
Nerlich "Lessons for the ICC"
Nerlich V "Lessons for the International Criminal Court: The Impact of Criminal Prosecutions on the South African Amnesty Process" in Werle G (ed) Justice in Transition – Prosecution and Amnesty in Germany and South Africa (Berliner Wissenschafts-Verlag Berlin 2006) 55-64
O'Donovan and Redpath Impact of Minimum Sentence
O'Donovan M and Redpath J The Impact of Minimum Sentence in South Africa (Open Society Foundation for South Africa Cape Town 2006)
Ossenbühl 1965 DöV
Ossenbühl F "Probleme und Wege der Verfassungsauslegung" 1965 DöV 649-661
Pieroth, Schlinck and Kniesel Polizei- und Ordnungsrecht
Pieroth B, Schlinck B and Kniesel M Polizei- und Ordnungsrecht 6th ed (CH Beck Munich 2010)
Public Administration Select Committee Taming the Prerogative
Public Administration Select Committee, House of Commons Taming the Prerogative: Strengthening Ministerial Accountability to Parliament HC 422 2003-04 (The Stationary Office London 2004)
Radbruch Rechtsphilosophie
Radbruch G Rechtsphilosophie 5th ed (Köhler Stuttgart 1956)
Raithby Statutes of the Realm
Raithby J (ed) Statutes of the Realm: Volume 7: 1695-1701 (History of Parliament Trust London 1820)
Rautenbach 1971 THRHR
Rautenbach IM "Subjektiewe regte en menseregte" 1971 THRHR 399-403
Rautenbach 1976 TSAR
Rautenbach IM "Die begrip menseregte as sistematiserende faktor in die Suid-Afrikaanse publiekreg" 1976 TSAR 168-189
Rautenbach and Malherbe Constitutional Law
Rautenbach IM and Malherbe EFJ Constitutional Law 5th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2009)
Redpath Scorpions
Redpath J The Scorpions: Analysing the Directorate of Special Operations (ISS Monograph No 96) (Institute for Security Studies Cape Town 2004)
Rüping 1992 Goltdammer's Archiv für Strafrecht
Rüping H "Die Geburt der Staatsanwaltschaft in Deutschland" 1992 Goltdammer's Archiv für Strafrecht 147-158
Sachs Grundgesetz Kommentar
Sachs M Grundgesetz Kommentar (CH Beck Munich 2003)
Schätzler Gnadenrecht
Schätzler J-G Handbuch des Gnadenrechts 2nd ed (CH Beck Munich 1992)
Schenke Polizei- und Ordniungsrecht
Schencke W-R Polizei- und Ordniungsrecht 2nd ed (CF Müller Heidelberg 2003)
Schmitt Glaeser Verwaltungsprozeßrecht
Schmitt Glaeser W Verwaltungsprozeßrecht 13th ed (Boorberg Stuttgart 1994)
Schneider "Verfassungsinterpretation"
Schneider P "Prinzipien der Verfassungsinterpretation" in Veröffentlichungen der Vereinigung der Deutschen Staatsrechtslehrer (De Gruyter Berlin 1963) 1-44
Schulz "Teilung der erkennende Gewalt"
Schulz L "Die Teilung der erkennende Gewalt. Zur Einführung der Staatsanwaltschaft in Deutschland" in Durand B (ed) Staatsanwaltschaft – Europäische und Amerikanische Geschichten (Vittorio Klostermann Frankfurt 2005) 311-338
Sennekamp 2010 Neue Zeitschrift für Verwaltungsrecht
Sennekamp VG "Alle Staatsgewalt geht vom Volke aus! Demokratieprinzip und Selbstverwaltung der Justiz" 2010 Neue Zeitschrift für Verwaltungsrecht (4) 214-217
Sloth-Nielsen 2005 Civil Society Prison Reform Initiative Newsletter
Sloth-Nielsen J "Parole Pandemonium" 2005 Civil Society Prison Reform Initiative Newsletter (Nov) 1-6
Smedovska and Falletti "Prosecuting Service in France"
Smedovska R and Falletti F "Report on the Prosecuting Service in France" in Grozev Y and Schönteich M (eds) Promoting Prosecutorial Accountability, Independence and Effectiveness – Comparative Research (Open Society Institute Sofia 2008) 175-210
Smend Staatsrechtliche Abhandlungen (1)
Smend R Staatsrechtliche Abhandlungen (Ducker und Humblot Berlin 1955)
Smend Staatsrechtliche Abhandlungen (2)
Smend R Staatsrechtliche Abhandlungen 2nd ed (Ducker und Humblot Berlin 1968)
Smend Verfassung und Verfassungsrecht
Smend R Verfassung und Verfassungsrecht 2nd ed (Ducker und Humblot Berlin 1968)
Smith 1983 Public Law
Smith ATH "The prerogative of mercy, the power of pardon and criminal justice" 1983 Public Law 398-439
Stern "Zur Problematik rückwirkende Gesetze"
Stern K "Zur Problematik rückwirkende Gesetze" in Lerche P, Zacher H and Badura P (eds) Festschrift für Theodor Maunz zum 80. Geburtstag am 1. September (CH Beck Munich 1981) 381-393
Stolleis History of Public Law
Stolleis M A History of Public Law in Germany 1914-1945 (Oxford University Press Oxford 2008)
Sullivan Liberalism and Crime
Sullivan RR Liberalism and Crime: The British Experience (Lexington Books Lanham 2000)
Terblanche 2003 Acta Juridica
Terblanche S "Mandatory and minimum sentences: Considering s 51 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 1997" 2003 Acta Juridica 194-219
Terblanche Sentencing Framework Bill
Terblanche S Research on the Sentencing Framework Bill (Open Society Foundation Cape Town 2008)
Terblance "Sentencing in South Africa"
Terblance S "Sentencing in South Africa" in Tonry M and Hatlestad K (eds) Sentencing in Overcrowded Times: A Comparative Perspective (Oxford University Press Oxford 1997) 172-176
Terblanche and Roberts 2005 SAJCJ
Terblanche S and Roberts JV "Sentencing in South Africa: Lacking in principle but delivering on justice?" 2005 SAJCJ 187-202
Thomas Judicial Process
Thomas EW The Judicial Process: Realism, Pragmatism, Practical Reasoning and Principles (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2005)
Tupman and Tupman Policing in Europe
Tupman B and Tupman A Policing in Europe: Uniform in Diversity (Intellect Books Exeter 1999)
Van der Vyver Grondwet
Van der Vyver JD Die Grondwet van die Republiek van Suid-Afrika (Lex Patria Johannesburg 1984)
Van Rensburg 2000 PELJ
Van Rensburg LJ "Die aard van wetgewende diskresies by die Suid-Afrikaanse uitvoerende gesag" 2000 PELJ 26-83
Venter Publiekregtelike Verhouding
Venter F Die Publiekregtelike Verhouding (Butterworths Durban 1985)
Warchol, Payne and Johnson 1996 Police Studies
Warchol D, Payne D and Johnson B "Criminal Forfeiture: An Effective Alternative to Civil and Administrative Proceedings" 1996 Police Studies 19(3) 51-66
Whitman 2009 Journal of Legal Analysis
Whitman JQ "Equality in criminal law: Two divergent Western roads" 2009 Journal of Legal Analysis 119-165
Whitman Harsh Justice
Whitman JQ Harsh Justice: Criminal Punishment and the Widening Divide between America and Europe (Oxford University Press Oxford 2003)
Wiechers Administratiefreg
Wiechers M Administratiefreg (Butterworths Durban 1973)
Wiechers "Publieke Subjektiewe Reg
Wiechers M "Die Publieke Subjektiewe Reg" in Strauss SA (ed) Huldigingsbundel vir WA Joubert (Butterworths Durban 1988) 270-291
Wille "Das externe Weisungsrecht"
Wille H "Das externe Weisungsrecht" in Ostendorf H Strafverfolgung und Strafverzicht (Carl Heymans Cologne 1992) 317-327
Wohlers Entstehung und Funktion der Staatsantwaltschaft
Wohlers W Entstehung und Funktion der Staatsantwaltschaft (Duncker und Humblot Berlin 1994)
Zeffert, Paizes and Skeen Law of Evidence
Zeffert DT, Paizes AP and Skeen A The South African Law of Evidence (Butterworths Durban 2003)
Register of case law
Administrator, Transvaal v Traub 1989 4 SA 731 (A)
Azapo v President 1996 4 SA 672 (CC)
BGH 2 StR 499/2006 (Case No 140/2006), 18 October 2006
Biddle v Perovich 274 US 480 (1927)
Burt v Governor-General 1992 3 NZLR 672 (CA)
BVerfGE 1, 14 (decision of 12.10.1951)
BVerfGE 4, 7 (decision of 20.7.1954)
BVerfGE 12, 45 (decision of 20.12.1960)
BVerfGE 14, 56 (decision of 9.5.1962)
BVerfGE 25, 352 (decision of 23.4.1969)
BVerfGE 26, 79 (decision of 4.6.1969)
BVerfGE 26, 186 (decision of 11.6.1969)
BVerfGE 27, 312 (decision of 17.12.1969)
BVerfGE 31, 137 (decision of 8.6.1971)
BVerfGE 34, 9 (decision of 26.7.1972)
BVerfGE 36, 174 (decision of 27.11.1973)
BVerfGE 45, 187 (decision of 21.6.1977)
BVerfGE 49, 24 (decision of 1.8.1978)
BVerfGE 50, 290 (decision of 1.3.1979)
BVerfGE 55, 372 (decision of 7.1.1981)
BVerfGE 60, 175 (decision of 24.3.1982)
BVerfGE 66, 337 (decision of 4.4.1984)
BVerfGE 87, 48 (decision of 7.7.1992)
BVerwGE 1971 Neue Juristische Woche 795
Carmichele v Minister of Safety and Security 2001 4 SA 938 (CC)
Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation v President of the RSA 2009 ZAGPPHC 35
Certification of the Amended Text of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 1997 2 SA 97 (CC)
Chonco v President of the RSA 2010 ZACC 7 (cited as "Chonco II (CC)")
Council of Civil Unions v Minister for the Civil Service 1985 AC 374 (HL)
De Freitas v Benny 1976 AC 239 (PC)
Democratic Alliance v Acting National Director of the Prosecuting Authority 2011 ZAGPPHC 57 (cited as "DA v Acting NDPP")
Democratic Alliance v President of the Republic of South Africa 2010 ZAGPPHC 194
Derby-Lewis v Minister of Correctional Services 2009 6 SA 205 (GNP)
Du Plessis v De Klerk 1996 3 SA 850 (CC)
Ex Parte Minister of Safety and Security: In re: S v Walters 2002 4 SA 613 (CC)
Ex Parte Attorney-General, Namibia: In re: The Constitutional Relationship between the Attorney-General and the Prosecutor-General 1995 8 BCLR 1070 (NmS)
Glenister v President 2008 ZAGPHC 143
Glenister v President 2009 1 SA 287 (CC) (cited as "Glenister I (CC)").
Glenister v Speaker of the National Assembly 2009 ZAWCHC 1
Glenister v President of the Republic of South Africa 2011 ZACC 6 (cited as "Glenister II (CC)")
Harris v Minister of the Interior 1952 2 SA 428 (AD)
Henry v Minister of Correctional Services, unreported, Case No 04/2569, Johannesburg High Court, 14 October 2005
Herrera v Collins 506 US 390 (1993)
In re Certification of the Constitution of the RSA 1996 1996 4 SA 744 (CC) (cited as "In re Certification of the Constitution")
Landgericht Wiesbaden 6 Js 320.4/00 16 KLS
Lewis v Attorney General of Jamaica 2000 3 WLR 1785
Marcus v President 2009 1 SA 417 (CC)
Masetlha v President 2008 1 SA 566 (CC)
Masiya v Director of Public Prosecutions 2007 5 SA 30 (CC) (cited as "Masiya v NDPP")
Minister of Correctional Services v Van Vuren 2011 ZACC 9
Minister of the Interior v Harris 1952 4 SA 769 (AD)
Minister of Justice v Chonco 2009 6 SA 1 (SCA) (cited as "Chonco (SCA")
Minister of Justice v Chonco 2010 1 SACR 325 (CC) (cited as "Chonco I (CC)")
Moulin v France ECHR Case No. 881, 23 November 2010
National Director of Public Prosecutions v Zuma 2009 2 SA 277 (SCA) (cited as "NDPP v Zuma (SCA)")
OLG Saarbrücken NJW 1973, 2037
OLG Hamburg MDR 1977, 771
President v Hugo 1997 4 SA 1 (CC) (cited as "President v Hugo")
President v SARFU 2000 1 SA 1 (CC)
Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of SA: In re Ex Parte President of the Republic of South Africa 2000 2 SA 674 (CC)
Price v Minister of Correctional Services 2008 2 SACR 64 (SCA) (cited as "Price v Minister of Correctional Services")
R v Foster 1985 QB 115
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, Ex Parte Bentley 1993 4 All ER 442
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department Ex Parte Stafford (AP), unreported judgment of the Law Lords, 23 July 1998 (cited as "Ex Parte Stafford")
Reckley v Minister of Public Safety and Immigration 1996 AC 527
S v Boesak 2000 1 SACR 633 (SCA)
S v Coetzee 1997 3 SA 527 (CC)
S v Ferreira 2004 ZASCA 29
S v Hlongwane 2000 2 SACR 681 (W)
S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)
S v Rabie 1975 4 SA 855 (A)
S v Shaik, unreported, Case No. CC27/04, High Court of SA (DLD), 2 June 2005
S v Shaik 2007 1 SA 240 (SCA)
S v Shaik 2008 2 SA 208 (CC)
S v The State 2011 ZACC 7
S v Wallus 1994 ZASCA 189
S v Willemse 1999 1 SACR 450 (C)
S v Willemse 2008 ZAWCHC 77
S v Yengeni 2006 1 SACR 405 (T) (cited as "S v Yengeni")
S v Zinn 1969 2 SA 537 (A)
Sachs v Dönges 1950 2 SA 265 (A)
Scagell v Attorney-General, Western Cape 1997 2 SA 368 (CC)
Schlick v Reed 419 US 256 (1974)
Shaik v S (2) [2006] SCA 134
Shaik v S 2007 ZACC 19
Shaik v S 2008 2 SA 208 (CC)
Shaik v S 2008 5 SA 354 (CC)
South African Association of Personal Injury Lawyers v Heath 2001 1 SA 883 (CC)
Sudhakar v Government of Andhra Pradesh WP (Crl) Case No 284-285/2006
The Queen on the Application of Corner House Research and Campaign against Arms Trade v The Director of the Serious Fraud Office and BAE Systems plc, unreported, Case No CO/1567/2007, High Court of Justice, Queen's Bench Division (Administrative Court), 14-15 February 2008
Thebus v S 2003 ZACC 12
Thynne, Wilson and Gunnell v United Kingdom 1990 13 EHRR 666
Travers v National Director of Public Prosecutions 2007 3 SA 242 (T)
Zuma v National Director of Public Prosecution 2008 ZAKZHC 71 (cited as "Zuma v NDPP (KZHC)")
Register of legislation
Act of Settlement 1701 (UK)
Attorney-General Act 92 of 1992
Colonial Laws Validity Act 1865
Companies Act 61 of 1973
Companies Act 71 of 2008
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 200 of 1993 (Interim Constitution)
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (Constitution)
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Amendment Act 2 of 1994
Constitution of the Republic of South African Second Amendment Act 3 of 1994
Constitutional Reform Act 2005 (UK)
Correctional Services Act 8 of 1959
Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998
Correctional Services Amendment Act 25 of 2008
Corruption Act 94 of 1992
Criminal Justice Act 1948 (UK)
Criminal Justice Act 1967 (UK)
Criminal Justice Act 1991 (UK)
Criminal Law Amendment Act 105 of 1997
Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977
Gerichtsverfassungsgesetz (Courts Constitution Act) 1877 (GVG)
Grundgesetz für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland (Constitution) 1949 (BGBI 1)
High Court of Parliament Act 35 of 1952
Human Rights Act 1998 (UK)
Implementation of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court Act 27 of 2002
National Prosecuting Authority Act 32 of 1998 (NPA Act)
National Prosecuting Authority Amendment Act 61 of 2000
National Prosecuting Authority Amendment Act 56 of 2008
Prevention and Combating of Corrupt Activities Act 12 of 2004
Prevention of Organised Crime Act 121 of 1998 (POCA)
Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000
Promotion of Administrative Justice Amendment Act 53 of 2002
Promotion of Access to Information Act 2 of 2000
Racketeer Influenced Corrupt Organizations Act (USA) (RICO)
Republic of South Africa Constitution Act 32 of 1961 (1961 Constitution)
Republic of South Africa Constitution Act 110 of 1983 (1983 Constitution)
Separate Representation of Voters Act 46 of 1951
South African Police Service Amendment Act 57 of 2008
Strafgesetzbuch (German Criminal Code) (StGB)
Strafprozeßordnung (German Criminal Procedure Act) (StPO)
Verordnung über das Verfahren in Gnadensachen (Procedural Regulations for Granting Clemency) 1935
Register of government publications
N 1659 in GG 18519 of 19 December 1997
Proc R 43 in GG 18879 of 1 May 1998
N 1543 in GG 19522 of 27 November 1998
Gen 2067 in GG 25282 of 30 July 2003
N 376 in GG 30885 of 18 March 2008
GG 31023 of 9 May 2008
N 1221 in GG 31593 of 11 November 2008
N 68 in GG 32608 of 1 October 2009
N 197 in GG 32999 of 5 March 2010
GG 33216 of 21 May 2010
Register of international instruments
Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (1984)
Protocol No 13 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, concerning the abolition of the death penalty in all circumstances (2002)
Register of official documents and reports
Council of Europe Report (2009)
Council of Europe 2009 Allegations of politically motivated abuses of the criminal justice system in Council of Europe member states Doc 11993 assembly.coe.int/Documents/WorkingDocs/doc09/edoc1193.pdf [date of use 25 Jul 2011]
Draft Constitutional Renewal Bill (2008)
Select Committee of Justice 2008 Provisions in the Draft Constitutional Renewal Bill www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200708/cmselect/cmjust
/698/69806.htm [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Ginwala Report (2008)
Ginwala F 2008 Report of the Enquiry into the Fitness of Advocate VP Pikoli to hold the Office of National Director of Public Prosecutions www.info.gov.za/view/DownloadFileAction?id=93423 [date of use 25 Jul 2011]
Hefer Commision of Inquiry Report (2004)
Hefer J 2004 The Hefer Commission of Inquiry Report www.info.gov.za/otherdocs/2004/hefer/program.pdf [date of use 25 Jul 2011]
Khampepe Inquiry Final Report (2006)
Khampepe S 2006 Inquiry into the Mandate and Location of the Directorate of Special Operations ('the DSO') Final Report www.thepresidency.gov.za
/docs/reports/khampepe/part1.pdf [date of use ?]
Report of the Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation (2009)
Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation 2009 Why does SA have such high rates of violent crime? www.csvr.org.za/docs/study/
unique_about_SA.pdf [date of use ?]
Sentencing: A New Sentencing Framework (2000)
South African Law Reform Commission 2000 Sentencing: A New Sentencing Framework www.justice.gov.za/salrc/dpapers/dp91.pdf [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Register of newspaper reports
"20 cops guard Shaik in hospital" News24 (2006-11-27)
"A final journey" Mail & Guardian (2010-3-5)
"Agliotti ruling: 'Dining with the devil'" Mail & Guardian (2010-11-25)
"Alle Menschen sind gleich, Kohl ist gleicher" Süddeutsche Zeitung (2001-29)
"Andhra Pradesh move to free 1,500 prisoners halted" Legal News India (2006-8-16)
"Armed policemen arrest Scorpions boss" Mail & Guardian (2008-1-9)
"Arms deal probe (2000-2010)" Mail & Guardian (2010-10-15)
"Appeals for Shaik pardon" Sunday Tribune (2008-9-14)
"Balfour: Shaik's condition terminal" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-3)
"Balfour 'vindicated' by Shaik reports" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-10)
"Balfour welcomes clearing of Shaik's doctors" Mail & Guardian (2009-4-20)
"Besser unabhängig" Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (2006-10-6)
"Boesak's parole in national hands – directive" IOL (2001-5-16)
"Boesak to walk free tomorrow" The Star (2001-5-21)
"Bomb scare after Shaik ruling" News24 (2006-11-6)
"Bush aides pushed to get attorneys replaced" International Herald Tribune (2009-8-13)
"Cele's brutal force" Sunday Independent (2011-3-22)
"Charges against Gerrie Nel withdrawn" Mail & Guardian (2008-1-14)
"Court: Remission not an act of grace" The Hindu (2006-10-12)
"Crooked patient, crooked docs" News24 (2007-1-20)
"DA man seeks answers on Shaik" Sunday Independent (2009-8-10)
"DA versoek Motlanthe dat na Shaik se parool gekyk word" Beeld (2009-3-11)
"De Kock deal speculation mounts despite government denials" Legalbrief (2010-1-11)
"Derby-Lewis' cancer 'worse than expected'" Mail & Guardian (2010-11-04)
"Desai admits Shaik parole damaged credibility of system" Mail & Guardian (2009-11-04)
"Diarrhoea hits Shaik jail" News24 (2006-11-16)
"Did the NIA spy on judges?" DA@Work (2008-6-23)
"Discovery investigates Shaik" News24 (2007-1-10)
"Doctors 'unanimous' on Shaik" Sunday Independent (2009-3-4)
"Experts slam medical evidence in Shaik's release" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-10)
"Family shocked by death of 'demoted' law guru" IOL (2010-3-31)
"Full NPA Statement" News24 (2009-4-6)
"Ginwala absolves Mbeki" Mail & Guardian (2008-12-5)
"Glenn Agliotti cleared of Kebble murder" Mail & Guardian (2010-11-25)
"Government is NPA's boss – Zuma" News24 (2009-12-14)
"Govt mum on Schabir Shaik" Mail & Guardian (2011-3-16)
"Hawks boss questions viability of arms-deal probe" Mail & Guardian (2010-9-8)
"How arms-deal 'bribes' were paid" Mail & Guardian (2008-12-5)
"How civil servants fleeced us of R600m" The Times (2009-6-14)
"How Ginwala blew it" Mail & Guardian (2008-12-12)
"How Menzi stymied arms probe" Mail & Guardian (2010-12-3)
"I discharged Shaik months ago from hospital" IOL (2009-3-8)
"I want my f*%#@!! pardon" City Press (2009-12-20)
"I was suspended over Selebi, says Pikoli" Mail &Guardian (2008-5-7)
"I'm the victim – broken Shaik" News24 (2006-1-31)
"Improper not to prosecute JZ" Mail & Guardian (2010-10-1)
"Inside Operation destroy Lucifer" Mail & Guardian (2009-6-19)
"Is Shaik dying?" Sunday Independent (2009-3-4)
"Italian court rules Berlusconi's immunity law unconstitutional" The Guardian (2009-10-7)
"It's hard to visit Shaik, family complains" Mail & Guardian (2007-11-16)
"Jacob Zuma's replying affidavit to the DA" Politicsweb (2009-9-17)
"Journalist's harrowing account" Times Live (2010-8-8)
"JSC should vet NDPP candidates – DA" Politicsweb (2009-2-19)
"Khampepe report: presidency defends delay" The Mercury (2008-5-5)
"Law Lords: Fraud office right to end bribery investigation in BAE Case" The Guardian (2008-8-31)
"Lawyers, NGOs, media urged to oppose judicial bills" Legalbrief Today (2006-2-22)
"Maduna comments lead to SIU brain drain: Heath" ANC Dialy News Briefing (2001-10-18)
"Maduna dashes Boesak's pardon hopes" IOL (2003-8-22)
"Man behind the Zuma deal" Cape Argus (2009-3-20)
"Mbeki, Manuel 'doctored arms deal report'" News24 (2009-10-22)
"Mbeki 'paid R30m arms-deal bribe'" Mail & Guardian (2008-8-3)
"Meddlesome Menzi" Mail & Guardian (2008-8-15)
"Minister fumes after oversight judge releases details of prisons report to press" Sunday Independent (2010-11-21)
"Miscarriage of justice marked by lack of will" Mail & Guardian (2010-11-6)
"Moontlike kwytskelding vir Eugene dalk sluier vir Shaik, IVP's se vryheid" Rapport (2010-1-9)
"Motlanthe asked to act on Shaik" The Times (2009-3-12)
"National Prosecuting Authority vows to clear the air on Shaik deal" Sunday Independent (2009-1-22)
"Nel taken off Agliotti case" Mail & Guardian (2010-5-7)
"New-look judiciary mooted" Mail & Guardian (2009-11-27)
"No basis for review of Shaik parole, says department" Mail & Guardian (2009-8-11)
"No deadline on Shaik" The Times (2009-10-20)
"'No truth' in rumours of Shaik release" Mail & Guardian (2008-10-2)
"On Mpshe's legally flawed decision" Legal Brief (2009-4-17)
"Parliament committee questions Shaik's hospital time" Mail & Guardian (2008-8-4)
"Parole only for terminally ill, says judge" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-3)
"Permanente Erregung. Eine Bilanz des Untersuchungsausschusses zur Parteispendenaffäre" Die Zeit (24/2002)
"Pflicht zum gehorsam" Der Spiegel 13/1991
"Pikoli's replying affidavit in interdict application" Politicsweb (2009-8-12)
"Politics can't be the factor in pardon: SC" Indian Express (2006-10-12)
"Power of pardon subject to review" The Hindu (2006-10-12)
"Prison staff biggest killers" Sunday Independent (2010-11-22)
"Proposed bill threatens constitutional supremacy – Dene Smuts" Politicsweb (2009-2-22)
"Prosecutors look into assault complaint against Shaik" Mail & Guardian (2011-3-22)
"Replying affidavit of Zuma to the DA" Politicsweb (2009-9-17)
"Schabir seen teeing off "The Citizen (2009-8-11)
"Schabir Shaik accused of assaulting journalist" Mail & Guardian (2011-2-27)
"Schabir Shaik and the R10-million house" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-13)
"Schabir Shaik arrested" Mail & Guardian (2011-3-14)
"Schabir Shaik could be a free man soon" The Times (2009-1-10)
"Schabir Shaik denies he was driving in Durban" Mail & Guardian (2009-8-13)
"Schabir Shaik nears 100 days of freedom" Sunday Tribune (2009-6-7)
"Schabir Shaik's bid for freedom" The Sowetan (2008-9-17)
"Schabir Shaik's last bid for freedom" Mail & Guardian (2007-5-22)
"Schabir Shaik's parole paradise" Mail & Guardian (2010-1-8)
"Schabir Shaik still in hospital" Mail & Guardian (2008-4-23)
"Schabir's gambit" Mail & Guardian (2009-12-23)
"Scramble to secure a Zuma presidency" Mail & Guardian (2008-8-9)
"Seeking the Shaik option" The Citizen (2009-3-11)
"Sergeant at the Bar 'One law for the poor, another for the politically connected?'" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-10)
"Shady shrink saved Shaik" Mail & Guardian (2010-3-5)
"Shaik 'could be a prison asset'" News24 (2006-11-9)
"Shaik: DA demands records" Cape Argus (2009-3-6)
"Shaik depressed – in hospital" News24 (2007-4-16)
"Shaik doctor expects fallout" Daily News (2009-3-9)
"Shaik doctors acted professionally – HPCSA" Daily News (2009-4-20)
"Shaik family 'the most optimistic'" The Star (2009-9-15)
"Shaik family 'wants to negotiate'" News24 (2007-3-5)
"Shaik got parole just in time" The Star (2009-3-6)
"Shaik in last bid for freedom" News24 (2007-5-22)
"Shaik is gravely ill – family" Sunday Independent (2009-3-3)
"Shaik is not dying" The Times (2009-3-11)
"Shaik is not under house arrest, says official" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-4)
"Shaik medical parole 'absurd'" News24 (2007-1-8)
"Shaik moved to critical-care unit of Durban hospital" Mail & Guardian (2008-4-27)
"Shaik not eligible for parole" The Citizen (2008-9-16)
"Shaik parole not unprecedented: Surty" The Times (2009-3-5)
"Shaik parole should be reviewed – Kollapen" Sunday Independent (2009-3-4)
"Shaik parole was legally correct – Wolela" IOL (2009-3-4)
"Shaik released on Wednesday afternoon" Mail & Guardian (2011-3-16)
"Shaik 'remained in hospital' until release" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-8)
"Shaik pardon would be 'unfortunate': Devenish" The Times (2009-10-20)
"Shaik sent back to prison" News24 (2007-2-15)
"Shaik settlement 'normal' – National Prosecuting Authority" IOL (2009-1-22)
"Shaik smuggled into cushy ward" News24 (2007-1-12)
"Shaik spits fire" City Press (2009-12-20)
"Shaik spotted driving around Durban" The Times (2009-8-10)
"Shaik spotted playing golf: report" The Times (2009-8-12)
"Shaik, state 'in R5-million deal'" Mail and Guardian (2009-1-22)
"Shaik suffered stroke" News24 (2006-12-3)
"Shaik suffers stroke" News24 (2007-11-15)
"Shaik to meet parole board over golf course report" Mail & Guardian (2011-3-7)
"Shaik to undergo medical test" News24 (2007-2-12)
"Shaik 'too ill' to leave clinic" News24 (2007-2-8)
"Shaik undergoes facial surgery" Sunday Tribune (2007-1-7)
"Shaik walks free" The Star (2009-3-3)
"Shaik was 'strictly confined' – report" Cape Argus (2007-5-23)
"Shaik well enough to dine out?" Sunday Tribune (2009-6-28)
"Shaik windfall normal, says National Prosecuting Authority" The Mercury (2009-1-22)
"Shaik 'won't try medical pardon'" News24 (2007-1-9)
"Shaiking up a storm" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-8)
"Shaik's condition 'terminal' – Balfour" Polity.org.za (2009-3-4)
"Shaik's desperate move to clear his name" IOL (2006-11-18)
"Shaik's hospital costs could be R3m" The Mercury (2008-9-17)
"Shaik's medical miracle" Mail & Guardian (2010-6-15)
"Shaik's mental health 'a worry'" News24 (2007-2-17)
"Shaik's parole 'a strange thing'" The Star (2009-3-7)
"Should the ConCourt be our apex court?" Politicsweb (2011-4-13)
"Silks split over NPA reforms" Mail & Guardian (2010-6-13)
"Simelane backs down on demotions" City Press (2010-4-4)
"Simelane gags NPA staff" Politicsweb (2010-1-21)
"Simelane must explain disbanding of SCCU – DA" Politicsweb (2010-5-11)
"Sources: SIU deputy head facing the axe" News24 (2010-11-28)
"State: Prima facie case against Agliotti exists" Mail & Guardian (2010-11-18)
"Terminal Schabir's midnight ride" Mail & Guardian (2009-8-15)
"The 'Berlusconi principle'" The Times (2008-7-29)
"The big Shaik sham!" The Times (2009-3-8)
"The case against Jacob G Zuma" Mail & Guardian (2009-4-3)
"The high price of political solutions" Mail & Guardian (2009-4-27)
"The incredible Mr Simelane" Mail & Guardian (2008-8-15)
"The man behind the Zuma deal" Cape Argus (2009-3-20)
"The spy who saved Zuma" Mail & Guardian (2009-4-9)
"The Untouchables - the ANC remake" The Daily Maverick (2010-3-19)
"Top cop scuttled Zuma case" Mail & Guardian (2010-5-21)
"Transcript of Kgalema Motlanthe's media briefing" Politicsweb (10-2-2009)
"Trapido: 'Balfour must fall on his sword over Shaik'" Thought Leader Mail & Guardian (2009-3-25);
"Triple play to save Zuma" Mail & Guardian (2008-7-11)
"Unconstitutional to prosecute Zuma – Kemp" Politicsweb (2010-6-10)
"Was Ngcuka an Apartheid Spy" City Press (2003-9-7)
"We had a good case against Jacob Zuma, says prosecutor" Sunday World (2009-04-11)
"What Dramat and Simelane said about the arms deal" Politicsweb (2010-9-10)
"Why did Simelane protect Mphego?" Politicsweb (2010-5-24)
"Why I let Fana Hlongwane off the hook – Menzi Simelane" Politicsweb (2010-3-21)
"Yengeni resigns directorships" IOL (2010-11-4)
"Yengeni's illegal directorships: DA lays criminal charges" Politicsweb (2010-11-1)
"Zille, Kasrils meet over spying" News24 (2008-2-14)
"Zuma has considered IFP pardons – Presidency" Politicsweb (2010-2-4)
"Zuma lashes out at those wanting Shaik dead" Mail & Guardian (2009-3-14)
"Zuma unlikely to be charged again, says judge" The Daily News (2009-4-7).
"Zuma's five minutes to freedom" The Daily News (7 April 2009)
Register of internet sources
Anonymous 2002 www2.stroebele-online.de
Anonymous 2002 Beurteilung der Ergebnisse des Bundestagsunter-suchungsausschusses 'Parteispenden' durch die zuständigen Berichterstatter von SPD und Bündnis 90/Die Grünen (11 June 2002) www2.stroebele-online.de/upload/parteispenden_bericht.pdf [date of use 25 Jul 2011]
Anonymous 2009 www.dcs.gov.za
Anonymous 2009 "Parole: A tough balancing act" Corrections Review (March 2009) www.dcs.gov.za/Publications/Other%20Publications/Corrections%20Review%202009.pdf [date of use unknown]
ANC [no date] www.anc.org.za
ANC [no date] Second Submission to the TRC – Part 2 Appendix One www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=2654 [date of use unknown]
Balfour 2009 www.info.gov.za
Balfour N 2009 Department of Correctional Services press release on the event of the release of Mr Schabir Shaik on medical parole by the Durban Westville Management, 4 March 2009 www.info.gov.za/speeches/2009/
htm [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Collin 2001 fhi.rg.mpg.de
Collin P 2001 Die Geburt der Staatsanwaltschaft in Preußen fhi.rg.mpg.de/articles/0103collin.htm [date of use 25 Jul 2011]
Dept of Correctional Services 2007 www.info.gov.za
Department of Correctional Service 2007 Statement: Mr Yengeni's placement under correctional supervision and parole, 14 January 2007. www.info.gov.za/speeches/2007/07011509151001.htm [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Dept of Justice and Constitutional Development 2008 www.info.gov.za
Dept of Justice and Constitutional Development 2008 Terms of Reference for a Special Dispensation on Presidential Pardoning Process Relating to Certain Offenders www.info.gov.za/events/2008/tor_pres_pardon.pdf [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Deutscher Bundestag 2002 dip.bundestag.de
Deutscher Bundestag 2002 Beschlußempfehlung und Bericht, Bundestag doc. 14/9300 (13 June 2002) dip.bundestag.de/btd/14/093/1409300.pdf [date of use 25 Jul 2011]
Ellis 2009 mg.co.za
Ellis P 2009 Complaint against Adv Menzi Simelane mg.co.za/uploads/2009/12/03/simelanedoc.pdf [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Federal Ministry of Justice [no date] www.bmj.bund.de
Federal Ministry of Justice [no date] Information Brochure www.bmj.bund.de/files/-/1335/Infobroschüre_englisch.pdf [date of use unknown]
Justice, Crime Prevention and Security Cluster 2006 www.info.gov.za
Justice, Crime Prevention and Security Cluster 2006 Government's Programme of Action – Report www.info.gov.za/aboutgovt/poa/report2006
/apr2006/jcps.htm [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Kirby 1999 www.hcourt.gov.au
Kirby J 1999 Legal Institutions in Transition: Modes of Appointment and Training of Judges – A Common Law Perspective: lecture held at a seminar in Belfast on 8 June 1999 www.hcourt.gov.au/speeches/kirbyj
/kirbyj_judicial2.htm [date of ue unknown]
Maduna 2001 www.info.gov.za
Maduna P 2001 Request for a Proclamation under the Special Investigating Units and the Special Tribunals Act, 1996 (Act 74 of 1996) www.info.gov.za/speeches/2001/0101161145a1003.htm [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Maer and Gay 2008 www.parliament.uk
Maer L and Gay O 2008 The Royal Prerogative, Parliament and Constitution Centre UK Parliament Standard Note SN/PC/03861 (updated 3 November 2008) www.parliament.uk/documents/commons/lib/research/briefings/snpc-03861.pdf [date of use?]
Mbeki 2007 www.info.gov.za
Mbeki T 2007 Address by President of South Africa to the Joint Sitting of Parliament to Report on the Processing of some Presidential Pardons, 21 November 2007 www.info.gov.za/speeches/2007/07112115451002.htm [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Development 2005 www.info.gov.za
Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Development 2005 Media statement for presidential pardon in terms of section 84(2)(j) of the Constitution of the RSA, 1996 to expunge criminal records. A special reference to dr Allan Aubrey Boesak's case, 18 January 2005 www.info.gov.za/speeches/2005
/05011815151001.htm [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Naidoo and Khan 2009 www.mg.co.za
Naidoo DP and Khan S 2009 Letter to Mr Marais, Re: Schabir Shaik Patient Number KZ00132232 www.mg.co.za/uploads/2009/03/10/medical-report-dr-naidoo-2.pdf [date of use 26 Jul 2011]
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Loammi Wolf
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}