Religious and Cultural Dress at School: A Comparative Perspective
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2011/v14i6a2608Keywords:
Religious dress, cultural dress, school discipline, learners' rights, comparison with the United States of AmericaAbstract
This article investigates and compares the different approaches towards the dress code of learners[1] in South Africa and the United States of America (US), as the US mainly base litigation concerning school dress code on their freedom of speech/expression clause, while similar South African court cases focus more on religious and cultural freedom.
In South Africa, school principals and School Governing Bodies are in dire need of clear guidelines on how to respect and honour the constitutionally entrenched right to all of the different religions and cultures. The crisis of values in education arises from the disparity between the value system espoused by the school and the community, and that expressed in the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, which guarantees learners' fundamental rights, including those of freedom of religion, culture, expression and human dignity. On the one hand, the South African Schools Act requires of School Governing Bodies to develop and implement a Code of Conduct for learners, and on the other, that they strictly adhere to the Constitution of the country when drawing up their dress codes. The right of a religious group to practise its religion or of a cultural group to respect and sustain its culture must be consistent with the provisions of the Bill of Rights (which is entrenched in the Constitution) and this implies that other rights may not infringe on the right to freedom of religion and culture.
In the US, although there is no legislation that protects learners' freedom of religion and culture at schools, their First Amendment guides the way. Their Supreme Court respects the religious values of all citizens provided that they are manifested off public school premises. While we acknowledge the existence of religious and cultural diversity at South African schools, this paper focuses on the tension among and on the existence of different approaches towards the human rights of learners from different religious and cultural backgrounds in respect of dress codes.
The terms learner/s and student/s are used interchangeably in the article, since South Africa uses the one and the US uses the other to indicate school-going persons.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Alston, Van Staden and Pretorius 2003 SAJE
Alston KG, Van Staden JG and Pretorius JL "The Constitutional Right to Freedom of Expression: How Enforceable are School Rules?" 2003 SAJE 23(3) 163-167
Anonymous Star
Anonymous 'Striving for Equality' The Star 28 May 1998 20
Arweck, Nesbitt and Jackson 2005 Scriptura
Arweck E, Nesbitt E and Jackson R "Educating the Next Generation in Universal Values? Hindu-related New Religious Movements and Values Education in the Common School" 2005 Scriptura 328-337
Clayton and Tomlinson Privacy and Freedom of Expression
Clayton R and Tomlinson H Privacy and Freedom of Expression (London Oxford 2001)
Coertzen 2002 Ned Geref Teol T
Coertzen P "Freedom of Religion and Religious Education in a Pluralistic Society" 2002 Ned Geref Teol T 43(1&2) 185-196
Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)
De Groof and Lauwers 2001 Perspectives in Education
De Groof J and Lauwers G "Education Policy and Law: the Politics of Multiculturalism in Education" 2001 Perspectives in Education 19(4) 47-63
Govindjee 2007 Obiter
Govindjee A "Of Nose Studs, Beards and Issues of Discrimination - Pillay v KwaZulu-Natal MEC for Education 2006 10 BCLR 1237 (N), Dlamini v Green Four Security 2006 11 BLLR 1074 (LC)" 2007 Obiter 357-373
Louw 2005 Ned Geref Teol T
Louw LP "Religie-onderwys in die brandpunt: gereedheidsvlak van Suid-Afrikaanse opvoeders vir 'n multireligieuse bedeling" 2005 Ned Geref Teol T 46(1&2) 191-199
Malherbe 2006 TSAR
Malherbe R "Enkele kwelvrae oor die grondwetlike beskerming van die reg op godsdiensvryheid" 2006 TSAR 629-650
Monayi Citizen
Monayi D 'Boy sick without goatskin bracelet' The Citizen 16 March 2007 3
Moran San Diego Union Tribune
Moran G 'High Court Backs School Dress Code in T-shirt Case' The San Diego Union Tribune 6 March 2007 1
Onions Shorter Oxford English Dictionary
Onions CT The Shorter Oxford English Dictionary on Historical Principles 3rd ed (Clarendon Press Oxford 1964)
Pretorius Beeld
Pretorius R ''n Geloofsaak' Beeld 20 January 1998 8
Rautenbach, Jansen van Rensburg and Pienaar 2003 PELJ
Rautenbach C, Jansen van Rensburg F and Pienaar GJ "Culture (and Religion) in Constitutional Adjudication" 2003 PELJ 1(6) 2-20
Rondganger and Govender Star
Rondganger L and Govender P 'Wrangler over headscarf at Johannesburg school' The Star 23 January 2004 3
Roos 2003 Koers
Roos R "Legal Requirements for School Rules and Disciplinary Sanctions" 2003 Koers 481-498
Rossouw 2003 Koers
Rossouw JP "Learner Discipline in South African Schools - a Qualitative Study" 2003 Koers 413-436
Snyman 2003 Ned Geref Teol T
Snyman AH "Godsdiensopvoeding op Skool - Enkele Aannames in die Konsepbeleid" 2003 Ned Geref Teol T 44(1&2) 500-506
Thomas, Cambron-McCabe and McCarthy Public School Law
Thomas SB, Cambron-McCabe NH and McCarthy MM Public School Law 6th ed (Allyn and Bacon Boston 2009)
Tribe American Constitutional Law
Tribe LH American Constitutional Law 2nd ed (Foundation Press Harvard 1988)
Van der Westhuizen "Freedom of Expression"
Van der Westhuizen J "Freedom of Expression" in Van Wyk D et al Rights and Constitutionalism: The New South African Legal Order (Juta Kenwyn 1994) 264-291
Van Rooyen Sunday Times
Van Rooyen K 'Culture shock - Principal turns a beady eye on boy's tradition' Sunday Times 1 February 2009 5
Cases
Abrams v United States 250 US 616 (1919)
Antonie v Governing Body, Settlers High School 2002 4 SA 738 (C)
Canady v Bossier Parish School Board 240 F3d 437 (US Ct App 6th Cir)
Castonia v Madison County School Board 246 F3d 536 (US Ct App 6th Cir)
Chalifoux v New Caney Indep School Dist 976 F Supp 659 (SD Tex 1997)
Cheema v Thompson 67 F3d 883 (9th Cir 1995)
Christian Education SA v Minister of Education 1999 9 BCLR 951 (SE)
Christian Education SA v Minister of Education 2000 4 SA 757 (CC)
De Reuck v Director of Public Prosecutions (Witwatersrand Local Division) 2004 1 SA 406 (CC)
Hazelwood School District v Kuhlmeier 484 US 260 (1998), on remand, 840 F2d 596 (8th Cir 1998)
Hines v Caston Sch Corp 651 NE 2d 330 (Ind Ct App 1995)
Isaacs v Board of Educ of Howard County Md 40 F Supp 2d 335 (DMd 1999)
Jacobs v Clark County Sch Dist 373 F Supp 2d 1162 (D Nev 2005)
Khumalo v Holomisa 2002 5 SA 401 (CC)
Littlefield v Forney 268 F3d 275 (5th Cir 2001)
MEC for Education, KwaZulu-Natal v Pillay 2008 1 SA 474 (CC)
Oleson v Board of Education 676 F Supp 820 (ND III 1987)
Pillay v MEC for Education, Kwa-Zulu Natal AR 791/05 2006 ZAKZHC 8 (5 July 2006)
Pillay v MEC for Education, KwaZulu-Natal 2006 6 SA 363 (N)
Police Department of Chicago v Mosley 408 US 92 (1972)
S v Mamabolo (E TV Intervening) 2001 3 SA 409 (CC)
Senate of California v Mosbacher 968 F2d 974 (9th Cir 1992)
Taylor v Kurtstag 2005 1 SA 362 (W)
Tinker v Des Moines Independent School District 393 US 503 (1969)
Wilkins v Penns Grove-Carneys Point Reg'l Sch Dist 123 Fed Appx 493 (3rd Cir 2005)
Register of legislation
California Education Code 1977
California Penal Code 2009
Children's Act 38 of 2005
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Federal Constitution of the United States of America 1787 (as amended)
Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000
Religious Freedom Restoration Act 42 USC 1993
South African Schools Act 84 of 1996
Register of government publications
Gen N 776 in GG 18900 of 15 May 1998 (Guidelines for the Consideration of Governing Bodies in Adopting a Code of Conduct for Learners)
Gen N 1307 in GG 2549 of 12 September 2003 (National Policy on Religion and Education)
GN 173 in GG 28538 of 23 February 2006 (National Guidelines on School Uniforms)
Register of internet sources
Lumsden and Miller 2002 www.asbj.com
Lumsden l and Miller G 2002 School Dress Codes and Uniforms American School Board Journal www.asbj.com/2002/03/0302schoollaw.html [date of use 11 Mar 2010]
SA Ministry of Education 2001 www.info.gov.za
South African Ministry of Education 2001 Manifesto on Values, Education and Democracy www.info.gov.za/view/DownloadFileAction?id=70295 [date of use 11 Mar 2011]
US Department of Education 1996 www.ed.gov
United States Department of Education 1996 Manual on School Uniforms www.ed.gov/updates/uniforms.html [date of use 11 Mar 2010]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Elda de Waal
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}