An Embarrassment of Riches or a Profusion of Confusion An Evaluation of the Continued Existence of the Civil Union Act of 2006 in the Light of Prospective Domestic Partnerships Legislation in South Africa
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2010/v13i2a2640Keywords:
Domestic partnership, Life partnership, Domestic Partnerships Bill, 2008, Civil Union Act 17 of 2006, Civil union, Civil partnership, Marriage Act 25 of 1961, Marriage, Civil marriageAbstract
As it stands, South African family law currently holds that the Marriage Act 25 of 1961 applies exclusively to the solemnisation of heterosexual civil marriages while same-sex couples have no choice but to formalise their relationships in terms of the Civil Union Act 17 of 2006. In addition, the legal position is complicated by the fact that the latter Act not only allows both heterosexual and homosexual couples to conclude a civil union, but also provides that a civil union may take the form of either a marriage or a civil partnership, both of which enjoy the same legal recognition as, and give rise to the same legal consequences, as a civil marriage under the Marriage Act.
In January 2008, a draft Domestic Partnerships Bill saw the light of day, the potential enactment of which casts significant doubt as to whether the prevailing framework should be retained. With this potential development in mind, this paper considers the desirability of maintaining the "separate but equal" status quo by: (a) comparing the South African Law Reform Commission's pre-Civil Union Act proposals with the approach eventually adopted by the legislature; (b) comparing and contrasting the post-Civil Union Act position in South Africa with that of an established and well-ordered jurisdiction such as the Netherlands and, in the light hereof, considering the cases for and against repealing the Civil Union Act; and (c) by considering the desirability and practicality of the civil partnership's potential co-existence with the Domestic Partnerships Bill (as modified in accordance with a recent study). A proposal is made that could provide a less complex and better streamlined family law dispensation in South Africa.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Bakker JJS
Bakker P "Die Civil Union Act, Draft Domestic Partnership Bill en moontlike deregulering van die huwelik" 2009 JJS 34(1) 1–20
Bilchitz and Judge SAJHR
Bilchitz D and Judge M "For whom does the bell toll? The challenges and possibilities of the Civil Union Act for family law in South Africa" 2007 SAJHR 466–499
Bonthuys SAJHR
Bonthuys E "Race and gender in the Civil Union Act" 2007 SAJHR 526–542
Bonthuys SALJ
Bonthuys E "Irrational accommodation: Conscience, religion and same-sex marriage in South Africa" 2008 SALJ 473–483
Cronjé and Heaton Family Law
Cronjé DSP and Heaton J South African Family Law 2nd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2004)
Curry-Sumner "The Netherlands"
Curry-Sumner I "The Netherlands: Party Autonomy and Responsibility" in Atkin B and Banda F (eds) International Survey of Family Law 2008 ed (Jordan Publishing Bristol 2008) 255–274
Curry-Sumner and Vonk "It All Depends on Who You Ask"
Curry-Sumner I and Vonk MJ "It All Depends on Who You Ask: Dutch Parentage Law in Four Acts" in Atkin B and Banda F (eds) International Survey of Family Law (Jordan Publishing Bristol 2009) 329–352
De Vos SAJHR
De Vos P "The 'Inevitability' of same-sex marriage in South Africa's post-Apartheid state" 2007 SAJHR 432–465
De Vos and Barnard SALJ
De Vos P and Barnard J "Same-sex marriage, civil unions and domestic partnerships in South Africa: Critical reflections on an ongoing saga" 2007 SALJ 795–826
Goldblatt SALJ
Goldblatt B "Regulating domestic partnerships: A necessary step in the development of South African family law" 2003 SALJ 120 610–629
Hahlo SALJ
Hahlo HR "The law of concubinage" 1972 SALJ 321–332
Heaton THRHR
Heaton J "An overview of the current legal position regarding heterosexual life partnerships" 2005 THRHR 662–670
Merin Equality for Same-Sex Couples
Merin Y Equality for Same-Sex Couples. The Legal Recognition of Gay Partnerships in Europe and the United States (University of Chicago Press Chicago 2000)
Robinson et al South African Family Law
Robinson JA et al Introduction to South African Family Law 4th ed (Printing Things Potchefstroom 2009)
Robson SAJHR
Robson R "Sexual democracy" 2007 SAJHR 409–431
Schrama IJLPF
Schrama WM "The Dutch approach to informal lifestyles: Family function over family form?" 2008 IJLPF 311–332
Sinclair "South Africa"
Sinclair JD " A New Definition of Marriage: Gay and Lesbian Couples May Marry" in Atkin B and Banda F (eds) International Survey of Family Law 2008 ed (Jordan Publishing Bristol 2008) 397–409
Smith Domestic Partnership Rubric
Smith BS The Development of South African Matrimonial Law with Specific Reference to the Need for and Application of a Domestic Partnership Rubric (LLD thesis UFS 2009)
Smith and Robinson BYUJPL
Smith BS and Robinson JA "The South African Civil Union Act 17 of 2006: A good example of the dangers of rushing the legislative process" 2008 BYUJPL 419–439
Smith and Robinson IJLPF
Smith BS and Robinson JA "The South African Civil Union Act 2006: Progressive legislation with regressive implications?" 2008 IJLPF 356–392
Sonnekus THRHR
Sonnekus JC "Huweliksluiting, die ouderdom en ander beperkings" 2009 THRHR 136–148
Van der Burght De Jure
Van der Burght G "Registered partnership in the Netherlands" 2000 De Jure 76–94
Van der Vyver and Joubert Persone- en Familiereg
Van der Vyver JD and Joubert DJ Persone- en Familiereg 3rd ed (Juta Cape Town 1991)
Van Schalkwyk De Jure
Van Schalkwyk LN "Kommentaar op die Civil Union Act 17 van 2006 2007 De Jure 166–173
Vonk ULR
Vonk M "The role of formalised and non-formalised intentions in legal parent-child relationships in Dutch law" 2008 ULR 4(2) 117–134
Waaldijk NELR
Waaldijk K "Others may follow: The introduction of marriage, quasi-marriage, and semi-marriage for same-sex couples in European countries" 2004 NELR 569–589
Register of court cases
Amod v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accidents Fund (Commission for Gender Equality Intervening) 1999 4 SA 1319 (SCA)
Bezuidenhout NO v ABSA Versekeringsmaatskappy Bpk 40688/2008 (unreported)
Daniels v Campbell NO and Others 2004 5 SA 331 (CC)
Du Plessis v Road Accident Fund 2004 1 SA 359 (SCA)
Du Toit and Another v Minister of Welfare and Population Development and Others (Lesbian and Gay Equality Project as Amicus Curiae) 2003 2 SA 198 (CC)
Eskom Holdings Ltd v Hendricks 2005 5 SA 503 (SCA)
Fourie and Another v Minister of Home Affairs and Others 2005 3 SA 429 (SCA)
Gory v Kolver NO and Others 2007 4 SA 97 (CC)
Govender v Ragavayah NO and Others 2009 3 SA 178 (D)
Hassam v Jacobs NO and Others 2009 5 SA 572 (CC)
Investigating Directorate: Serious Economic Offences and Others v Hyundai Motor Distributors (Pty) Ltd and Others: In re Hyundai Motor Distributors (Pty) Ltd and Others v Smit NO and Others 2001 1 SA 545 (CC)
Ismail v Ismail and Others 2007 4 SA 557 (E)
J and Another v Director-General: Department of Home Affairs and Others 2003 5 SA 621 (CC)
Khan v Khan 2005 2 SA 272 (T)
Langemaat v Minister of Safety and Security and Others 1998 3 SA 312 (T)
Minister of Home Affairs and Another v Fourie and Another (Doctors for Life International and Others as Amici Curiae); Lesbian and Gay Equality Project and Others v Minister of Home Affairs and Others 2006 1 SA 524 (CC)
National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality and Others v Minister of Home Affairs and Others 2000 2 SA 1 (CC)
President of the Republic of South Africa and Another v Hugo 1997 4 SA 1 (CC)
Ryland v Edros 1997 2 SA 690 (C)
Satchwell v President of the Republic of South Africa and Another 2002 6 SA 1 (CC)
Satchwell v President of the Republic of South Africa and Another 2003 4 SA 266 (CC)
Singh v Ramparsad and Others 2007 3 SA 445 (D)
Turffontein Estates Ltd v Mining Commissioner, Johannesburg 1917 AD 419
Volks NO v Robinson and Others 2005 5 BCLR 446 (CC)
Register of legislation
South Africa
Children's Act 38 of 2005
Children's Status Act 82 of 1987
Civil Union Act 17 of 2006
Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act 130 of 1993
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977
Divorce Act 70 of 1979
Domestic Violence Act 116 of 1998
Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987
Maintenance of Surviving Spouses Act 27 of 1990
Marriage Act 25 of 1961
Medical Schemes Act 131 of 1998
Pension Funds Act 25 of 1956
Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998
The Netherlands
Burgerlijk Wetboek, 1992
Wet Opneming Buitenlandse Kinderen ter Adoptie Act of 24 October 2008
Register of government publications
GN 35 in GG 30663 of 14 January 2008
GN 36 in GG 30663 of 14 January 2008
GN 149 in GG 31864 of 13 February 2009
Register of internet sources
Mapisa-Nqakula http://home-affairs.pwv.gov.za/
Mapisa-Nqakula (2006) NN http://home-affairs.pwv.gov.za/speeches.asp?id=181 [date of use 18 Oct 2007]
Maxwell EJCL
Maxwell NG “Opening civil marriage to same-gender couples: A Netherlands-United States comparison 2000” EJCL http://www.ejcl.org/43/abs43-1.html [date of use 11 Aug 2010]
Netherlands Ministry of Justice http://english.justitie.nl/
Netherlands Ministry of Justice 2006 Same-Sex Marriages http://english.justitie.nl/currenttopics/factsheets/ [date of use 12 Sept 2007]
South African Broadcasting Corporation http://www.sabcnews.com/
South African Broadcasting Corporation 2006 Mapisa-Nqakula Vouches for Same-Sex Marriages http://196.35.74.234/south_africa/social/0,2172,139205,00.html [date of use 12 Aug 2010]
South African Law Reform Commission http://www.justice.gov.za/
South African Law Reform Commission 2006 Project 118: Report on Domestic Partnerships http://www.justice.gov.za/salrc/reports/r_prj118_2006march.pdf [date of use 11 Aug 2010]
South African Law Reform Commission http://www.justice.gov.za/
South African Law Reform Commission 2001 Report on the Review of the Marriage Act 25 of 1961 (Project 109) http://www.justice.gov.za/salrc/reports/r_prj109_marr_2001may.pdf [date of use 11 Aug 2010]
Waaldijk https://same-sex.web.ined.fr/
Waaldijk K 2005 Major legal consequences of marriage, cohabitation and registered partnership for different-sex and same-sex partners in the Netherlands http://www-same-sex.ined.fr/pdf/DocTrav125/05Doc125TheNetherlands.pdf [date of use 11 Aug 2010]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Bradley Shaun Smith, JA Robbie Robinson
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}