Rethinking Volks V Robinson: The Implications of Applying a "Contextaulised Choice Model" to Prospective South African Domestic Partnerships Legislation
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2010/v13i3a2691Keywords:
Life partnership, domestic partnership, Domestic Partnerships Bill, choice argument, contextualised choice model, reciprocal duty of support.Abstract
The article considers certain critical failings of the so-called "choice argument" (that is the view that, by opting to cohabit in a life partnership rather than marry or enter into a civil partnership, a life partner is not entitled to the legal benefits provided by matrimonial [property] law) as it was applied to opposite-sex life partnerships by the majority of the Constitutional Court in Volks v Robinson.[1] On the basis of Canadian jurisprudence, a "contextualised choice model" is developed that distinguishes between need-based claims and those involving property disputes, and holds that the "choice argument" could at best be relevant regarding the latter category of claims, while the existence of a reciprocal duty of support is sine qua non for any need-based claim to succeed. These findings are applied to registered and unregistered domestic partnerships under the draft Domestic Partnerships Bill, 2008, with the aim of suggesting certain amendments to the Bill in the hope of ensuring a more consistent and principled legal position once the Bill is enacted.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Bonthuys 2007 JAJHR
Bonthuys E "Race and gender in the Civil Union Act" 2007 SAJHR 526–542
Cronjé and Heaton Family Law
Cronjé DSP and Heaton J South African Family Law 2nd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2004)
Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Lansdowne 2005)
De Vos 2004 SAJHR
De Vos P "Same-sex sexual desire and the re-imagining of the South African family" 2004 SAJHR 179–206
De Vos 2007 SAJHR
De Vos P "The 'Inevitability' of same-sex marriage in South Africa's post-Apartheid state" 2007 SAJHR 432–465
De Vos and Barnard 2007 SALJ
De Vos P and Barnard J "Same-sex marriage, civil unions and domestic partnerships in South Africa: Critical reflections on an ongoing saga" 2007 SALJ 795–826
De Waal 1997 Stell LR
De Waal MJ "The social and economic foundations of the law of succession" 1997 Stell LR 162–175
De Waal "The law of succession and the Bill of Rights"
De Waal MJ "The law of succession and the Bill of Rights: Private succession and freedom of testation in the light of the Constitution" in Bill of Rights Compendium (My LexisNexis Last updated 2006)
Du Toit 2001 JJS
Du Toit F "'n Verdere perspektief op die sosiale en ekonomiese grondslae van die erfreg" 2001 JJS 1–18
Goldblatt 2003 SALJ
Goldblatt B "Regulating domestic partnerships: A necessary step in the development of South African family law" 2003 SALJ 610–629
Lind 2005 AJ
Lind C Domestic partnerships and marital status discrimination 2005 AJ 108–130
Neethling et al Law of delict
Neethling J et al Law of delict 5th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2006)
Schäfer 2006 SALJ
Schäfer L "Marriage and marriage-like relationships: Constructing a new hierarchy of life partnerships" 2006 SALJ 626–647
Sinclair and Heaton Law of Marriage
Sinclair JD and Heaton J The Law of marriage Volume 1 2nd ed (Juta and Co Ltd Kenwyn 1996)
Smith Domestic Partnership Rubric
Smith BS The Development of South African Matrimonial Law with Specific Reference to the Need for and Application of a Domestic Partnership Rubric (LLD thesis UFS 2009)
Smith and Robinson 2008 BYUJPL
Smith BS and Robinson JA "The South African Civil Union Act 17 of 2006: A good example of the dangers of rushing the legislative process" 2008 BYUJPL 419–439
Smith and Robinson 2008 IJLPF
Smith BS and Robinson JA "The South African Civil Union Act 2006: Progressive legislation with regressive implications?" 2008 IJLPF 356–392
Sonnekus "Matrimonial property"
Sonnekus JC "Matrimonial property" in Clark B (ed) Family law service: Division B (My LexisNexis Last updated 2010)
Van Zyl Handbook
Van Zyl L Handbook of the South African Law of Maintenance 2nd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2005)
Visser and Potgieter Introduction
Visser PJ and Potgieter JM Introduction to Family Law 2nd ed (Juta Kenwyn 1998)
Wood-Bodley 2008a SALJ
Wood-Bodley MC "Intestate succession and gay and lesbian couples" 2008 SALJ 46–62
Wood-Bodley 2008b SALJ
Wood-Bodley MC "Establishing the existence of a same-sex life partnership for the purposes of the Intestate Succession Act" 2008 SALJ 259–273
Wood-Bodley 2008c SALJ
Wood-Bodley MC "Same-sex couple discrimination in employment benefits: Where to now?" 2008 SALJ 483–488
Register of legislation
South African legislation
Aliens Control Act 96 of 1991
Alteration of Sex Description and Sex Status Act 49 of 2003
Civil Union Act 17 of 2006
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Draft Domestic Partnerships Bill, 2008
Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987
Maintenance Act 23 of 1963
Maintenance Act 99 of 1998
Maintenance of Surviving Spouses Act 27 of 1990
Marriage Act 25 of 1961
Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984
Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000
Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998
Australian legislation
Property (Relationships) Act 1984
Canada legislation
Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
Family Law Act RSO 1990, c F3
Register of cases
South African case law
Barkhuizen v Napier 2007 5 SA 323 (CC)
Bezuidenhout v ABSA Versekeringsmaatskappy Bpk Case 40688/2008 26 February 2008 (unreported)
Daniels v Campbell 2004 5 SA 331 (CC)
Du Plessis v Road Accident Fund 2004 1 SA 359 (SCA)
Du Toit v Minister of Welfare and Population Development (Lesbian and Gay Equality Project as Amicus Curiae) 2003 2 SA 198 (CC)
Farr v Mutual & Federal Insurance Co Ltd 2000 3 SA 684 (C)
Gory v Kolver 2006 5 SA 145 (T)
Gory v Kolver 2007 4 SA 97 (CC); 2007 3 BCLR 294 (CC)
Harksen v Lane 1998 1 SA 300 (CC)
Investigating Directorate: Serious Economic Offences v Hyundai Motor Distributors (Pty) Ltd: In re: Hyundai Motor Distributors (Pty) Ltd v Smit 2001 1 SA 545 (CC)
J v Director General, Department of Home Affairs 2003 5 SA 621 (CC)
Langemaat v Minister of Safety and Security 1998 3 SA 312 (T)
Laws v Rutherford 1924 AD 261
Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie (Doctors for Life International as Amici Curiae); Lesbian and Gay Equality Project v Minister of Home Affairs 2006 1 SA 524 (CC)
National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 2 SA 1 (CC)
Prinsloo v Van der Linde 1997 3 SA 1012 (CC)
Robinson v Volks 2004 6 SA 288 (C)
Satchwell v President of the Republic of South Africa 2002 6 SA 1 (CC)
Satchwell v President of the Republic of South Africa 2003 4 SA 266 (CC)
Van der Merwe v Road Accident Fund (Women's Legal Centre Trust as Amicus Curiae) 2006 4 SA 230 (CC)
Volks v Robinson 2005 5 BCLR 446 (CC)
Canadian case law
Nova Scotia (Attorney General) v Walsh 2002 SCC 83 (CanLII)
MAS v FKM 2003 BCSC 849 (CanLII)
Register of Internet sources
SALRC 2003 http://bit.ly/hnporV
SALRC Discussion paper 104 (Project 118): Domestic partnerships http://www.justice.gov.za/salrc/dpapers/dp104.pdf [date of use 27 Nov 2010]
SALRC 2006 http://bit.ly/gp7ni6
SALRC Project 118: Report on domestic partnerships http://www.justice.gov.za/salrc/reports/r_prj118_2006march.pdf [date of use 27 Nov 2010]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Bradley Smith
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}