Misplacing Nema A Consideration of Some Problematic Aspects of South Africa's New EIA Regulations

Authors

  • Jeremy Ridl Faculty of Law, University of KwaZulu-Natal
  • Ed Couzens University of KwaZulu-Natal

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2010/v13i5a2711

Keywords:

Assessment, authorisation, environment, Environmental Impact Assessment, Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism, Minister of Water and Environmental Affairs, National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998, Environment Conservation Act 73

Abstract

In mid-2006, new Regulations governing environmental impact assessment were published in terms of the National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998.  It is argued in this article that the old Regulations under the Environment Conservation Act 73 of 1989, which were replaced, had proved inadequate not because of any inherent deficiency, but because they were never properly implemented and because they were instead subjected to much inaccurate criticism.  The article then canvasses the old Regulations and considers criticisms thereof, before canvassing the new Regulations and assessing differences between the old and the new.  Various specific concerns and potential shortcomings are raised and considered; and various interpretations are offered of problematic provisions.  A prognosis for the success and/or failure of the new Regulations is then put forward in the context of the South African government's present approach to economic growth, environmental protection and the enforcement of environmental legislation.  Finally, it is argued that there are danger signs that the new Regulations will be as misunderstood and misapplied as were the old Regulations and that the fundamental principles of the National Environmental Management Act are likely not to be adhered to in the implementation of the new Regulations.

   ScienceOpen_Log049.png

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bibliography

Aucamp 2009 Environmental Impact Assessment

Aucamp PJ Environmental Impact Assessment: A Practical Guide for the Discerning Practitioner (Pretoria Van Schaik 2009)

Bray 1999 SAJELP

Bray E "Focus on the National Environmental Management Act: Co-operative governance in the context of the National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998" 1999 SAJELP 1–12

Couzens 2008 SAJELP

Couzens E "Filling Station Jurisprudence: Environmental Law in South African Courts and the Judgment in Fuel Retailers Association of Southern Africa v Director-General: Environmental Management, Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Environment, Mpumalanga Province, and Others 2007 (6) SA 4 (CC)" 2008 SAJELP 23–56

Couzens and Dent 2006 PER

Couzens E and Dent M "Finding NEMA: The National Environmental Management Act, the De Hoop Dam, conflict resolution and Alternative Dispute Resolution in environmental disputes" 2006 PER 9(3) 2–51

Couzens and Gumede 2007 SAJELP

Couzens E and Gumede K "Losing NEMA: Wildlife and Environmental Society of South Africa v MEC for Economic Affairs, Environment and Tourism, Eastern Cape, and Others 2005 6 SA 123 (E) Case no. 28761/05, TPD, decided on 23 June 2006" 2007 SAJELP 125–134

Field 2005 SALJ

Field T "Public participation in environmental decision-making: Earthlife Africa (Cape Town) v Director General: Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism" 2005 SALJ 748–765

Glazewski Environmental Law

Glazewski J Environmental Law in South Africa (Durban LexisNexis 2005)

IUCN et al Caring for the Earth

IUCN et al Caring for the Earth: A Strategy for Sustainable Living (IUCN, United Nations Environment Program and World Wide Fund for Nature Gland 1991)

Jain et al Environmental Impact Analysis

Jain RK et al Environmental Impact Analysis: A New Dimension in Decision-Making (Van Nostrand Reinhold New York 1977)

Kidd Environmental Law

Kidd M Environmental Law (Cape Town Juta 2008)

Kidd and Retief "Environmental assessment"

Kidd M and Retief F "Environmental assessment" in Strydom HA and King ND (eds) Fuggle and Rabie's Environmental Management in South Africa 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2009) 971–1047

Peckham 1997 SAJELP

Peckham B "Environmental impact assessments in South African law" 1997 SAJELP 113–133

Rabie 1986 SA Public Law

Rabie A "Strategies for the implementation of environmental impact assessment in South Africa" 1986 SA Public Law 18–33

Ridl 1994 SAJELP

Ridl J "IEM: Lip-service and licence?" 1994 SAJELP 61–83

Ridl, Carnelley & Couzens 2005 SAJELP

Ridl J, Carnelley M & Couzens E “(Bio)Tracing Poor Exemptions: South Durban Community Environmental Alliance (SDCEA) v Head of Department: Department of Agriculture and Environmental Affairs and Others 2003 (6) SA 631 (D)” 2005 SAJELP 151-171

Robinson 2006 SAJELP

Robinson NA "Environmental impact assessments: Essential methodology or paper tiger?" 2006 SAJELP 97–104

Van Schalkwyk Mail & Guardian 21

Van Schalkwyk M "Simpler. Better. Greener?" Mail & Guardian 21 Apr 2006 21

Ward Biological Environmental Impact Studies

Ward DV Biological Environmental Impact Studies: Theory and Methods (Academic Press New York 1978)

Weaver et al "Strengthening the effectiveness of EIA"

Weaver A et al "Strengthening the effectiveness of EIA in South Africa" (Paper presented at the International Association for Impact Assessment – South Africa Conference Cathedral Peak 1998) 300–310

Register of legislation

Environment Conservation Act 73 of 1989

National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998

National Environmental Management Amendment Act 62 of 2008

Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act 28 of 2002

Register of government publications

GN R1182 in GG 18261 of 5 September 1997

GN R1183 in GG 18261 of 5 September 1997

GN R1184 in GG 18261 of 5 September 1997

GN R385 in GG 28753 of 21 April 2006

GN R386 in GG 28753 of 21 April 2006

GN R387 in GG 28753 of 21 April 2006

GN 657 in GG 28854 of 19 May 2006

GN 22 in GG 31789 of 9 January 2009

Council for the Environment Integrated Environmental Management

Council for the Environment Integrated Environmental Management in South Africa (Joan Lotter Publications Pretoria 1989)

DEA Guidelines

DEA Integrated Environmental Management Guideline Series (DEA Pretoria 1992)

DEAT Environmental Impact Reporting

DEAT Environmental Impact Reporting: Integrated Environmental Management Information Series 0–16 (DEAT Pretoria 2004)

Register of cases

Director: Mineral Development, Gauteng Region v Save the Vaal Environment 1999 2 SA 709 (SCA)

Fuel Retailers Association of Southern Africa v Director-General: Environmental Management, Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Environment, Mpumalanga Province 2007 6 SA 4 (CC)

Register of Internet sources

DEAT 2004 http://bit.ly/fbYE0P

DEAT 2004 Final N2 Wild Coast decision http://bit.ly/fbYE0P [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

DEAT 2006 http://bit.ly/gzGOJ4

DEAT 2006 New regulations to speed up EIA processes http://bit.ly/gzGOJ4 [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

DEAT 2006 http://bit.ly/hbqAP8

DEAT 2006 Presentation on Revised National Environmental Management Act: Environmental Impact Assessment Regulations http://bit.ly/hbqAP8 [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

DEAT and ICBEAPSA 2007 http://bit.ly/hFn6PI

DEAT and ICBEAPSA 2007 Towards the establishment of a registration authority for environmental assessment practitioners in South Africa consultative process with key stakeholders: Process update and invitation to comment on: Draft proposal for the establishment of a Registration Board for Environmental Assessment Practitioners of South Africa http://bit.ly/hFn6PI [date of use 22 Feb 2011]

DEAT 2008 http://bit.ly/g5YXCz

DEAT 2008 Draft environmental impact assessment report for a 400 MW(t) Pebble Bed Modular Reactor demonstration power plant http://bit.ly/g5YXCz [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

Ensor 2008 http://bit.ly/gLjIKO

Ensor L "Environmental assessments 'easily bought'" Business Day 26 Nov 2008 http://bit.ly/gLjIKO [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

LED SALGA 2010 http://bit.ly/hBg7HU

LED SALGA 2010 Document: Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Regulations 2010 http://bit.ly/hBg7HU [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

MacLeod 2006 http://bit.ly/if07ZJ

MacLeod F "Mbeki joins assault on green laws" Mail & Guardian Online 7 Aug 2006 http://bit.ly/if07ZJ [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

Sonjica 2009 http://bit.ly/14PlVU

Sonjica BP Speech on the environment budget vote 18 Jun 2009 http://bit.ly/14PlVU [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

Tempelhoff 2009 http://bit.ly/aDP6B0

Tempelhoff E "Sonjica trek skouers op oor onwettige mynbou" Volksblad 23 Sept 2009 http://bit.ly/aDP6B0 [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

Van der Merwe 2008 http://bit.ly/fXM6BN

Van der Merwe C "MRC granted right to mine along SA's Wild Coast" Creamer Media's Mining Weekly 4 Aug 2008 http://bit.ly/fXM6BN [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

Van Schalkwyk 2006 http://bit.ly/fsdco5

Van Schalkwyk M 2006 Environmental protection: Quicker, simpler, better new EIA regulations for South Africa http://bit.ly/fsdco5 [date of use 23 Feb 2011]

Published

19-06-2017

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Ridl, J., & Couzens, E. (2017). Misplacing Nema A Consideration of Some Problematic Aspects of South Africa’s New EIA Regulations. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 13(5), 79-120. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2010/v13i5a2711

Similar Articles

1-10 of 1165

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.