Unpacking the Public Trust Doctrine: A Journey into Foreign Territory
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2010/v13i5a2712Keywords:
Environment, environmental protection, natural resources, ownership, American public trust doctrine, private property, public rights, takings, South African public trusteeship, fiduciary trust, stewardship ethic, res omnium communesAbstract
The past decade has borne witness to the transformation of South Africa's natural resources law with the introduction of a new legal concept, that of "public trusteeship", to South African jurisprudence. The concept of "public trusteeship" as it is embodied in South African legislation encapsulates the sovereign's duty to act as guardian of certain interests to the benefit of the nation as a whole. In the quest to demystify the incorporation of the concept of "public trusteeship" in South Africa, this article, as a first tentative step, focuses solely on the public trust doctrine as it functions in American jurisprudence. It is the aim of this article to give a thorough theoretical exposition of the development and application of the public trust doctrine in American jurisprudence in order to provide the South African scholar with a perspective on a legal construct founded on the philosophical notion that governments exercise a "fiduciary trust" on behalf of their people.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Araiza 1997 UCLA LR
Araiza WD "Democracy, distrust and the public trust: Process-based constitutional theory, the public trust doctrine and the search for a substantive environmental value"1997 UCLA LR 45 385–452
Arnold and Jewel 2008 Hastings W-Nw J Envt'l L & Pol'y
Arnold CA and Jewel LA "Litigation's bounded effectiveness and the real public trust doctrine: The aftermath of the Mono Lake case" 2008 Hastings W-Nw J Envt'l L & Pol'y 14 1177–1210
Bader 1992 BC Envtl Aff L Rev
Bader HR "Antaeus and the public trust doctrine: A new approach to substantive environmental protection in the Common Law" 1992 BC Envtl Aff L Rev 19 749–763
Bader 1994 Hamline LR
Bader HR "An analysis of the potential impact of the public trust doctrine on the Sovereign's use of its eminent domain" 1994 Hamline LR 50–63
Blumm 1989 Envtl L
Blumm M "Public property and the democratization of western water law: A modern view of the public trust doctrine" 1989 Envtl L 573–604
Brady 1990 BC Envtl Aff L Rev
Brady TP "'But most of it belongs to those yet to be born': The public trust doctrine, NEPA and the Stewardship Ethic" 1990 BC Envtl Aff L Rev 17 621–646
Brooks et al Law and Ecology
Brooks RO et al Law and Ecology: The Rise of the Ecosystemic Legal Regime (Ashgate Burlington 2002)
Callies and Breemer 2002 Val U LR
Callies DL and Breemer D "Selected legal and policy trends in takings law: Background principles, custom and public trust 'exceptions' and the (mis)use of investment-backed expectations" 2002 Val U LR 36 339–379
Casey 1984 Nat Resources J
Casey ES "Water law: Public trust doctrine" 1984 Nat Resources J 809–825
Cohen 1970 ULR
Cohen BS "The Constitution, the public trust doctrine and the environment" 1970 ULR 388–394
Connolly 2009 BC Envtl Aff L Rev
Connolly PJ "Saving fish to save the Bay: Public trust doctrine protection for Menhaden's Foundational Ecosystem Services in the Chesapeake Bay" 2009 BC Envtl Aff L Rev 135–169
Coquillette 1979 Cornell L Rev
Coquillette DR "Mosses from an Old Manse: Another look at some historic property cases about the environment" 1979 Cornell L Rev 64 761–821
Dunn "The concept of trust in the politics of John Locke"
Dunn J "The concept of trust in the politics of John Locke" in Rorty R et al (ed) Philosophy in History: Essays on the Historiography of Philosophy (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1984) 279–301
Dunning 1989 Envtl L
Dunning HC "The Public Trust: A fundamental doctrine of American property law" 1989 Envtl L 515–526
Dunphy 1976 Marq L Rev
Dunphy PO "Comments: The public trust doctrine" 1976 Marq L Rev 59(4) 787–808
Fernandez 1998 Alb L Rev
Fernandez JL "Untwisting the Common Law: Public Trust and the Massachusetts Colonial Ordinance" 1998 Alb L Rev 623–665
Foster 2006 AJS
Foster JB "Marx's 'Theory of Metabolic Rift': Classical Foundations for Environmental Sociology'" 2006 AJS 366–405
Grant 1995 Ariz St LJ
Grant DL "Western water rights and the public trust doctrine: Some realism about the takings issue" 1995 Ariz St LJ 423–468
Hannig 1983 Santa Clara L Rev
Hannig TJ "The public trust doctrine expansion and integration: A proposed balancing test" 1983 Santa Clara L Rev 211–236
Huffman 1986 Denv U L Rev
Huffman JL "Trusting the public interest to judges: A comment on the public trust writings of Professors Sax, Wilkinson, Dunning and Johnson" 1986 Denv U L Rev 63(3) 565–584
Huffman 1989 Envtl L
Huffman JL "A fish out of water: The public trust doctrine in a constitutional democracy" 1989 Envtl L 527–572
Kearney and Merrill 2004 U Chi L Rev
Kearney JD and Merrill TW "The origins of the American public trust doctrine: What really happened in Illinois Central" 2004 U Chi L Rev 71 799–931
Lazarus 1986 Iowa L Rev
Lazarus RJ "Changing conceptions of property and sovereignty in natural resources: Questioning the public trust doctrine" 1986 Iowa L Rev 71 631–716
Maguire 1997 J Env L & P
Maguire JC "Fashioning an equitable vision for public resource protection and development in Canada: The public trust doctrine revisited and reconceptualized" 1997 J Env L & P 7 1–42
Manzanetti 1984 Pac LJ
Manzanetti AB "The Fifth Amendment as a limitation on the public trust doctrine in water law" 1984 Pac LJ 15 1291–1319
Marx Capital
Marx K Capital Volume 3 (Vintage Publishers New York 1981)
Olson 1975 Det CLR
Olson J "The public trust doctrine: Procedural and substantive limitations on the governmental reallocation of natural resources in Michigan" 1975 Det CLR 2 161–209
Pearson 2004 J Land Resources & Envtl L
Pearson E "The public trust doctrine in federal law" 2004 J Land Resources & Envtl L 24 173–178
Pound Introduction
Pound R 1954 An Introduction to the Philosophy of Law Revised ed (Yale University Press New Haven 1992)
Rasband 1998 U Colo L Rev
Rasband JR "Equitable compensation for public trust takings" 1998 U Colo L Rev 69 331–405
Reed 1986 J Env L & P
Reed SW "The public trust doctrine: Is it amphibious?" 1986 J Env L & P 1 107–122
Ryan 2001 Envtl L
Ryan E "Public trust and distrust: The theoretical implications of the public trust doctrine for natural resources management" 2001 Envtl L 477–496
Sax 1970 Mich L Rev
Sax JL "The public trust doctrine in natural resource law: Effective in judicial intervention" 1970 Mich L Rev 68(3) 471–566
Sax 1980 UC Davis LR
Sax JL "Liberating the public trust doctrine from its historical shackles" 1980 UC Davis LR 14(2) 185–232
Scott 1998 Fordham Envtl LJ
Scott GR "The expanding of the public trust doctrine: A warning to environmentalists and policy makers" 1998 Fordham Envtl LJ 10 1–70
Searle 1990 SC L Rev
Searle J "Private property rights yield to the environmental crisis: Perspectives on the public trust doctrine" 1990 SC L Rev 41(4) 897–918
Smith and Sweeney 2006 BC Envtl Aff L Rev
Smith II GP and Sweeney MW "The public trust doctrine and natural law: Emanations within a penumbra" 2006 BC Envtl Aff L Rev 307–343
Stevens 1980 UC Davis LR
Stevens JS "The Public Trust: A sovereign's ancient prerogative becomes the people's environmental right" 1980 UC Davis LR 14(2) 195–232
Takacs 2008 NYU Envtl LJ
Takacs D "The public trust doctrine, environmental human rights and the Future of private property" 2008 NYU Envtl LJ 16(3) 711–765
Turnipseed et al 2009 ELQ
Turnipseed et al "The silver anniversary of the United States' Exclusive Economic Zone: Twenty-five years of ocean use and abuse and the possibility of a Blue Water public trust doctrine" 2009 ELQ 36(1) 1–70
Van der Walt Constitutional Property Clause
Van der Walt AJ The Constitutional Property Clause: Comparative analysis of Section 25 of the South African Constitution of 1996 (Juta Kenwyn 1997)
Von Tigerstrom 1998 J Env L & P
Von Tigerstrom B "The public trust doctrine in Canada" 1998 J Env L & P 7 379–401
Walston 1982 Santa Clara L Rev
Walston RE "The public trust doctrine in the water rights context: The wrong environmental remedy" 1982 Santa Clara L Rev 22 63–93
Wilkinson 1989 Envtl L
Wilkinson CF "The headwaters of the Public Trust: Some thoughts on the source and scope of the traditional doctrine" 1989 Envtl L 425–472
Williams 2002 SC Envtl LJ
Williams SM "Sustaining urban green spaces: Can public parks be protected under the public trust doctrine?" 2002 SC Envtl LJ 10 23–52
Register of legislation
American legislation
Constitution of the United States of America, 1787
Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, 1874
Constitution of the State of Florida, 1968
Constitution of the State of Hawai’i, 1995
South African legislation
National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998
National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act 10 of 2004
National Water Act 36 of 1998
Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act 28 of 2002
Register of cases
Register of American cases
Arnold v Mundy 6 NJL 1 (1821)
Barney v City of Keokuk 94 US 324 (1877)
Borough of Neptune City v Borough of Avon-by-the-Sea 61 NJ 296 A 2d 47 (1972)
California Earth Corps v California State Lands Commission 27 Cal Rptr 3d 476 (2005); 2005 Cal LEXIS 625
Caminiti v Boyle 107 Wn 2d 662; 732 P 2d 989 (1987)
City of Milwaukee v State 193 Wis 423; 214 NW 820 (1927)
Glass v Goeckel 473 Mich 667 (2005); 2005 Mich LEXIS 1314
Illinois Central Railroad Company v Illinois 146 US 387 (1892)
In re Water Use Permit Applications 9 P 3d 409 (Hawa 2000)
Kansas ex rel Meek v Hays 785 P 2d 1356 (Kan 1990)
Knight v United States Land Association 142 US 161 (1891)
Landmark West!, Board of Managers of the Parc Vendome Condominium v City of New York and New York City Economic Development Corporation 2005 NY Slip Op 25362; 2005 NY Misc. LEXIS 1853
Lucas v South Carolina 505 US 1003, 112 S Ct 2886 (1992)
Martin v Waddell's Lessee 41 US 367 (Pet) (1842)
Montana Coalition for Stream Access Inc v Curran 682 P 2d 163 (Mont 1984)
Morimoto and Yamada v Board of Land and Natural Resources State of Hawaii 107 Haw 296 (2005)
National Audubon Society v Superior Court of Alpine County 33 Cal 3d 419, 658 P 2d 709, 189 Cal Rptr 346, modified, 33 Cal 3d 726a, cert denied, 104 S Ct 413 (1983)
Orion Corporation v State of Washington 747 P 2d 1062 (Wash 1987)
Parks v Cooper 676 NW 2d 823 (SD 2004)
Penn Central Transportation Company v New York City 438 US 104; 57 L Ed 2d 631 (1978)
Phillips Petroleum Company v Mississippi 484 US 469 (1988); 1988 US LEXIS 939
Raleigh Avenue Beach Association v Atlantis Beach Club, Inc 185 NJ 40 (2005); 2005 NJ LEXIS 932
Shively v Bowlby 152 US 1 (1894)
The Propeller Genesee Chief v Fitzhugh 12 How 443 (1852)
The Times of Trenton Publishing Corporation v Lafayette Yard Community Development Corporation 183 NJ 519 (2005)
Washington State Geoduck Harvest Association v Washington State Department of Natural Resources 124 Wn App 441 (2004); 2004 Wah App LEXIS 2919
Register of German cases
BVerfGE 58, 300 15 July 1981 1 BvL 77/78 (Naßauskiesung case)
Register of South African cases
De Beers Consolidated Mines Ltd v Ataqua Mining (Pty) Ltd High Court of South Africa Orange Free State Provincial Division Case 3215/06 13 December 2007 (unreported)
Hichange Investments (Pty) Ltd v Cape Produce Company (Pty) Ltd t/a Pelts Products 2004 1 All SA 636 (E)
Register of Internet sources
Foster 2002 http://bit.ly/huO54l
Foster JB 2002 Marx’s ecology in historical perspective ISM http://bit.ly/huO54l [date of use 24 Jan 2011]
Government of Florida 1968 http://bit.ly/gzVerk
Government of Florida 1968 The Constitution of the State of Florida http://bit.ly/gzVerk [date of use 24 Jan 2011]
Government of Pennsylvania 1874 http://bit.ly/ig90Pd
Government of Pennsylvania 1874 Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
http://bit.ly/ig90Pd [date of use 24 Jan 2011]
Locke 1690 http://bit.ly/D1Fvi
Locke J 1690 The second treatise of civil government http://bit.ly/D1Fvi [date of use 24 Jan 2011]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Elmarie van der Schyff
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}