The protection of fundamental rights in the Netherlands and South Africa compared: can the many differences be justified?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2008/v11i2a2759Keywords:
South Africa, The Netherlands, comparative fundamental rights.Abstract
This contribution considers the protection of fundamental rights in the Netherlands and South Africa. Both countries strive to be constitutional democracies that respect basic rights. But both countries go about this aim in very different ways. These different paths to constitutionalism are compared, as well as the reasons for these differences and whether it can be said that these differences are justifiable. This is done by comparing the character of the rights guaranteed in the Dutch and South African legal orders, the sources of these rights and the locus or centre of protection in both systems. The conclusion is reached that no single or perfect route to attaining the desired protection of fundamental rights exists, but that one should always enquire as to the state of individual freedom and the right to make free political choices in measuring the worth of a system's protection of rights.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Adams Recht en Democratie
Adams M Recht en Democratie ter Discussie: Essays over Democratische Rechtsvorming (Universitaire Pers Leuven 2006)
Adams and Van der Schyff 2006 ZaöRV
Adams M and Van der Schyff G “Constitutional review by the judiciary in the Netherlands: A question of politics, democracy or compensating strategy?” 2006 (66) Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 399-413
Akkermans, Bax and Verhey Grondrechten
Akkermans PWC, Bax CJ and Verhey LFM Grondrechten 3rd ed (Tjeenk Willink Deventer 1999)
Austin Province of Jurisprudence
Austin J The Province of Jurisprudence Determined (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1995)
Böckenförde State, Society and Liberty
Böckenförde E-W Society and Liberty (Berg New York 1991)
Bouckaert 1997 Stanford J of Int'l L
Bouckaert PN “The Negotiated Revolution: South Africa’s transition to a Multiracial Democracy”1997 (33) Stanford Journal of International Law 375-411
Brenninkmeijer Judicial Organization
Brenninkmeijer AFM “Judicial Organization” in Chorus JMJ, Gerver PHM, Hondius EH and Koekkoek AK (eds) Introduction to Dutch Law 3rd ed (Kluwer The Hague 1999)
Brewer-Carias Judicial Review
Brewer-Carias AR Judicial Review in Comparative Law (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1989)
Burkens Algemene Leerstukken
Burkens MC Algemene Leerstukken van Grondrechten naar Nederlands Constitutioneel Recht (Tjeenk Willink Zwolle 1989)
Burkens et al Democratische Rechtsstaat
Burkens MC, Kummeling HRBM, Vermeulen BP and Widdershoven RJGM Beginselen van de Democratische Rechtsstaat 6th ed (Kluwer Alphen aan den Rijn 2006)
Cappelletti Judicial Process
Cappelletti M Judicial Process in Comparative Perspective (Clarendon Press Oxford 1989)
Cappelletti 1992 TSAR
Cappelletti M “Judicial review of the constitutionality of state action: Its expansion and legitimacy” 1992 Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 256-266
Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Lansdowne 2005)
De Blois Grondslagen
De Blois M Grondslagen van het Recht (Boom Juridische Uitgevers Den Haag 2005)
De Meij and Van der Vlies Inleiding
De Meij JM and Van der Vlies IC Inleiding tot het Staatsrecht en het Bestuursrecht (Tjeenk Willink Deventer 2000)
Dölle and Engels Constitutionele Rechtspraak
Dölle AHM and Engels JWM Constitutionele Rechtspraak (Wolters-Noordhoff Groningen 1989)
Doyle and Wells Common Law
Doyle J and Wells B “How far can the common law go towards protecting human rights?” in Alston P (ed) Promoting Human Rights Through Bills of Rights: Comparative Perspectives (Oxford University Press Oxford 1999)
Hatchard et al Comparative Constitutionalism
Hatchard J, Muna N and Slinn P Comparative Constitutionalism and Good Governance in the Commonwealth (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2004)
Hirsch Ballin Constitutionele Toetsing
Hirsch Ballin EMH “Constitutionele toetsing van wetten als bijdrage aan de rechtsontwikkeling” in Konijnenbelt W (ed) Rechter en Wetgever (Raad van State Den Haag 2001)
Hovell and Williams 2005 Melbourne University LR
Hovell D and Williams G “A Tale of Two Systems: The use of International Law in Constitutional Interpretation in Australia and South Africa” 2005 Melbourne University Law Review 131-178
Jayawickrama Judicial Application
Jayawickrama N The Judicial Application of Human Rights Law: National, Regional and International Jurisprudence (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2002)
Klaaren Institutional Interpretation
Klaaren J “An Institutional Interpretation of socio-economic rights and judicial remedies after TAC” in Botha H, Van der Walt A and Van der Walt J (eds) Rights and Democracy in a Transformative Constitution (Sun Press Stellenbosch 2003)
Koopmans Courts
Koopmans T Courts and Political Institutions: A Comparative View (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2003)
Kortmann and Bovend’ Eert Constitutioneel Recht
Kortmann CAJM and Bovend’ Eert PPT Inleiding: Constitutioneel Recht 5th ed (Kluwer Deventer 2006)
Kortmann and Bovend’ Eert Kingdom of the Netherlands
Kortmann CAJM and Bovend’ Eert PT The Kingdom of the Netherlands: An Introduction to Dutch Constitutional Law (Kluwer Deventer 1993)
Malherbe 2005 ZöR
Malherbe R “The development of socio-economic rights in South Africa” 2005 (60) Zeitschrift für öffentliches Recht 111-126
Olivier 2003 TSAR
Olivier ME “South Africa and international human rights agreements: procedure, policy and practice” (Part 1) 2003 (2) Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 293-310
Olivier 2003 TSAR
Olivier ME “International human rights agreements in South African law: Procedure, policy and practice” (Part 2) 2003 (3) Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 490-511
Pierson Modern State
Pierson C The Modern State 2nd ed (Routledge London 1996)
Prakke, De Reede and Van Wissen Handboek
Prakke L, De Reede JL and Van Wissen GJM Handboek van het Nederlandse Staatsrecht 14th ed (Tjeenk Willink Deventer 2001)
Rautenbach and Malherbe Constitutional Law
Rautenbach IM and Malherbe EFJ Constitutional Law 4th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2004)
Sadurski 2002 Oxford J of Legal Studies
Sadurski W “Judicial review and the protection of constitutional rights” 2002 (22) Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 275-299
Sap Netherlands Constitution
Sap JW The Netherlands Constitution 1848-1998: Historical Reflections (Lemma Utrecht 2000)
Stern 1981 TSAR
Stern K “A society based on the rule of law and social justice: Constitutional model of the Federal Republic of Germany” 1981 Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 241-250
Taekema Understanding
Taekema S (ed) Understanding Dutch Law (Boom Juridische Uitgevers Den Haag 2004)
Troper 2003 Int'l J of Constitutional Law
Troper M “The Logic of Justification of Judicial Review” 2003 (1) International Journal of Constitutional Law 99-121
Van der Hoeven Plaats van de Grondwet
Van der Hoeven J De Plaats van de Grondwet in het Constitutionele Bestel (Tjeenk Willink Zwolle 1988)
Van der Roest Basisboek Recht
Van der Roest OAP (ed) Basisboek Recht (Wolters-Noordhoff Groningen 2006)
Van der Schyff Concept van Democratie
Van der Schyff G “Het Concept van Democratie in het EVRM” in Adams M and Popelier P (eds) Recht en Democratie (Intersentia Antwerpen 2004)
Van Eikema Hommes 1978 TSAR
Van Eikema Hommes HJ “De materiële rechtsstaatidee” 1978 Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 42-52
Van Houten Zicht op Wetgeving
Van Houten MLP Meer Zicht op Wetgeving: Rechterlijke Toetsing van Wetgeving aan de Grondwet en Fundamentele Rechtsbeginselen (Tjeenk Willink Zwolle 1997)
Venter Constitutional Comparison
Venter F Constitutional Comparison: Japan, Germany, Canada and South Africa as Constitutional States (Juta Cape Town 2000)
Vlemminx Nieuw Profiel
Vlemminx F Een Nieuw Profiel van de Grondrechten: een Analyse van de Prestatieplichten ingevolge Klassieke en Sociale Grondrechten 3rd ed (Boom Juridische Uitgevers Den Haag 2002)
Zoethout Rechtsstaat
Zoethout C “Wat is de Rechtsstaat? Een reflectie op rechtsstatelijke beginselen voor Wetgever, Bestuur en Rechter” in Van Ommeren FJ and Zijlstra SE (eds) De Rechtsstaat als Toetsingskader (Boom Juridische Uitgevers Den Haag 2003)
Register of legislation
The Netherlands
Constitution of the Netherlands 30 March 1814
Charter of the Kingdom of the Netherlands 28 October 1953
Wet van 9 maart 1962 op de Raad van State
Wet van 18 april 1827 op de samenstelling der rechterlijke macht en het beleid der justitie
South Africa
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 200 of 1993
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996
Register of cases
Council of Europe
Chassagnou v France of 29 April 1999 (ECHR)
The Netherlands
Hoge Raad 27 January 1961 NJ 1961, 248 (annotated by DJ Veegens)
Hoge Raad 14 April 1989 NJ 1989, 469 (annotated by M Scheltema)
South Africa
Government of the RSA v Grootboom 2001 (1) SA 46 (CC), 2000 (11) BCLR 1169 (CC)
New National Party of SA v Government of the RSA 1999 5 BCLR 489 (CC), 1999 3 SA 191 (CC)
S v Makwanyane 1995 (6) BCLR (CC), 1995 (3) SA 391 (CC)
Register of treaties, international documents and parliamentary papers
Eerste Kamer vergaderjaar 2004-2005, 28, 331
Tweede Kamer vergaderjaar 2001-2002, 28, 331
Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Gerhard van der Schyff
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}