The Emerging International Constitutional order: The Implications of Hierarchy in International Law for the Coherence and Legitimacy of International Decision-Making
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2007/v10i2a2806Keywords:
emerging international constitutional order, , fundamental substantive and structural norms, supreme legal frameworkAbstract
The article examines the contours and implications of the emerging international constitutional order. The "constitutional" nature of this order relates to the fact that it contains certain fundamental substantive and structural norms that form a supreme legal framework for the exercise of public power. The substantive elements primarily include the value system of the international legal order, meaning norms of positive law with a strong ethical underpinning (notably human rights norms) that have acquired a special hierarchical standing vis-à-vis other international norms through state practice. The structural elements refer to the subjects of the international legal order that collectively constitute the international community (polity), as well as the mechanisms for enforcement of the international value system.
This vision of an international constitutional model is inspired by the intensification in the shift of public decision-making away from the nation state towards international actors of a regional (for example EU) or functional (for example WTO, UN) nature, and its eroding impact on the notion of a “total” constitutional order, where the fundamental substantive and structural norms that form the supreme legal framework for the exercise of public power are concentrated in the nation state. It is also inspired by the belief that such a supreme legal framework is only possible in a system where different national,
regional and functional legal orders complement each other in order to form an international constitutional order.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Allott Eunomia
Allott P Eunomia: New Order for a New World (Oxford University Press New York 1991)
Annacker 1994 AJPIL 131
Annacker C “The Legal Regime of Erga Omnes Obligations in International
Law” 1994 46 Austrian Journal of Public International Law 131-166
Bassiouni 1996 Law and Contemporary Problems 63
Bassiouni MC “International Crimes: Jus Cogens and Obligations Erga Omnes” 1996 Law and Contemporary Problems 63
Beutler Das Staatsbild
Beutler B Das Staatsbild in den Länderverfassungen nach 1945 (Duncker &
Humblot Berlin 1973)
Byers 1997 Nordic Journal of International Law 112
Byers M “Conceptualizing the Relationship between Jus Cogens and Erga
Omnes Rules” 1997 Nordic Journal of International Law 112
Crawford (ed) Articles on State Responsibility
Crawford J (ed) The International Law Commission’s Articles on State
Responsibility: Introduction Text and Commentaries (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2002)
De Hoogh 1991 Österreichische Zeitschrift für öffentliches und Völkerrecht 183
De Hoogh A “The Relationship between Jus Cogens, Obligations Erga
Omnes and International Crimes: Peremptory Norms in Perspective” 1991
Österreichische Zeitschrift für öffentliches und Völkerrecht 183
De Wet 2006 ICLQ 51
De Wet E “The International Constitutional Order” 2006 55 International &
Comparative Law Quarterly 51-76
De Wet 2007 ZaöRV 1-21
De Wet E "Zur Zukunft der Völkerrechtswissenchaft in Deutschland" 2007
Zeitschrift für Ausländisches Öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 1-21
De Wet and Nollkaemper 2002 German YIL 192
De Wet E and Nollkaemper A “Review of Security Council Decisions by
National Courts” 2002 German Yearbook of International Law 166-202
De Wet E “The Emergence of International and Regional Value Systems as a Manifestation of the International Constitutional Order” 2006 Leiden Journal of International Law 611
Dugard and Van den Wyngaert 1998 AJIL 210
Dugard J and Van den Wyngaert C “Reconciling Extradition with Human
Rights” 1998 92 American Journal of International Law 187-212
Dupuy 2002 RCADI 385
Dupuy PM ‘’L’unité de l’ordre juridique international’’ 2002 297 Recueil des
Cours de l’Académie de Droit International 9-490
Dupuy 2005 EJIL 133
Dupuy PM “Some Reflections on Contemporary International Law and the
Appeal to Universal Values: A Response to Martti Koskenniemi” 2005 16 European Journal of International Law 131-137
Fassbender 1998 CJTL 532
Fassbender B “The United Nations Charter as Constitution of the
International Community” 1998 36 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 529-561
Fischer-Lescano and Teubner 2004 Mich JIL 999
Fischer-Lescano A and Teubner G “Regime-Collission: The Vain Search for Legal Unity in the Fragmentation of Global Law” 2004 25 Michigan Journal of International Law 999-1046
Fischer-Lescano 2003 ZaöRV 734
Fischer-Lescano A ”Die Emergenz der Globalverfassung“ 2003 Zeitschrift für Ausländisches Öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 717-160
Francioni 1999 Italian YIL 22
Francioni F “Customary International Law and the European Convention on
Human Rights?” 1999 Italian Yearbook of International Law 22-39
Frowein 1987 ZaöRV 71
Frowein JA “Collective Enforcement of International Obligations” 1987
Zeitschrift für Ausländisches Öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 67-79
Frowein 1992 Collected Courses of the Academy of European Law 267
Frowein JA “The European Convention on Human Rights as the Public
Order of Europe“ 1992 Collected Courses of the Academy of European Law 267
Frowein Obligations Erga Omnes
Frowein JA “Obligations Erga Omnes” in Bernhardt R (ed) Encyclopedia of Public International Law Vol III (Elsevier Amsterdam 1997)
Hoffmeister 2001 Der Staat 362
Hoffmeister F “Die Europaïsche Menschenrechtskonvention als
Grundrechtsverfassung und ihre Bedeutung in Deutschland“ 2001 40 Der
Staat: Zeitschrift Für Staatslehre, Öffentliches Recht Und
Verfassungsgeschichte 349-382
Kadelbach and Kleinlein 2006 AVR 235
Kadelbach S and Kleinlein T “Überstaatliches Verfassungsrecht: zur
Konstitutionalisierun im Volkerrecht“ 2006 Archiv des Völkerrechts 235-266
Kadelbach Zwingendes Volkerrecht
Kadelbach S Zwingendes Volkerrecht (Duncker & Humblot Berlin 1992)
Maddex State Constitutions
Maddex RL State Constitutions of the United States (Congressional Quarterly Washington 1998)
Maduro Europe and the Constitution
Maduro MP “Europe and the Constitution: What if this is as Good as it Gets?” in Weiler JHH and Wind M (eds) European Constitutionalism beyond the State (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2003)
Orakhelashvili 2004 Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 246
Orakhelashvili A “The European Convention on Human Rights and
International Public Order“ 2004 Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 237-270
Orakhelashvili Peremptory Norms
Orakhelashvili A Peremptory Norms in International Law (Oxford University
Press Oxford 2006)
Peters 2006 LIJL 579
Peters A “Compensatory Constitutionalism: The Function and Potential of Fundamental International Norms and Structures” 2006 19 Leiden Journal of International Law 579-610
Riegler Konflikte zwischen Grundgesetz und Länderverfassungen
Riegler JJ Konflikte zwischen Grundgesetz und Länderverfassungen
(Universitätsverlag Würzburg 1996)
Schermers 163 Internationale Spectator 292
Schermers HG “Internationaal institutioneel recht” 1963 17 Internationale Spectator 292
Seiderman Hierarchy in International Law
Seiderman I Hierarchy in International Law: The Human Rights Dimension
(Intersentia Antwerp 2001)
Slaughter A New World Order
Slaughter AM A New World Order (Princeton University Press Princeton 2004)
Sudre Existe-il un ordre public européen?
Sudre F “Existe-Il un ordre public européen?“ in Tavernier P (eds) Quelle Europe pour les droit de l’homme? (Bruylant Brussels 1996)
Tams Enforcing Obligations Erga Omnes
Tams CJ “Enforcing Obligations Erga Omnes in International Law” in
Series: Cambridge Studies in International and Comparative Law 44
(Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2005)
Von Bogdandy and Bast (eds) Principles of European Constitutional Law
Von Bogdandy A and Bast J (eds) Principles of European Constitutional Law (Rowman & Littlefield Lanham 2006)
Walker Post-national Constitutionalism
Walker N “Post-national Constitutionalism and the Problem of Translation” in Weiler JHH and Wind M (eds) European Constitutionalism beyond the State (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2003)
Walter 1999 ZaöRV 979
Walter C “Die Europäische Menschenrechtskonvention als Konstitutionalizierungsprozess“ 1999 Zeitschrift für Ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 961-983
Walter 2001 German YIL 192
Walter C “Constitutionalising (Inter)national Governance – Possibilities for and Limits to the Development of an International Constitutional Law” 2001
German Yearbook of International Law 170-210
Weiler In Defence of the Status Quo
Weiler JHH “In Defence of the Status Quo: Europe´s Constitutional Sonderweg” in Weiler JHH and Wind M (eds) European Constitutionalism beyond the State (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2003)
Zemanek 2000 Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 6
Zemanek K “New Trends in the Enforcement of erga omnes Obligations”
Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 1-52
Register of legislation
Treaty of 17.06.1951 Trb (1951) 114, Trb (1953)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/955 (8.11.1994)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1244 (10.06.1999)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1267 (15.10.1999)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1333 (19.12.2000)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1390 (16.01.2002)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1452 (20.12.2002)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1455 (17.01.2003)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1456 (20.01.2003)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1526 (30.01.2004)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1617 (29.07.2005)
UN Security Council Resolution S/RES/1699 (8.08.2006)
Register of Institutional Publications
European Constitution 47 OJ 2004 (2004/C 310/01)
HRC Decision 20.12.2003 Judge/ Canada, Communication No 829/1998
HRC Decision 30.07.1993 Kindler v. Canada, Communication No 470/1990 HRC General Comment No 24 CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.6, 4. 11. 2004 HRC General Comment No 31 [80] Nature of the General Legal Obligation Imposed on States Parties to the Covenant CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.13 v.
05.2004
Report of the International Law Commission, A/61/10 (2006) 419
Register of case law
International Court of Justice:
Agim Behrami and Bekir Behrami v. France (Application No 71412/01)
Judgment 31.05.2007
Al Adsani v. United Kingdom (Application No 35763/97) Judgment 21.11.2001
Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Company Ltd Judgment 5.2.1970 (2nd Phase)
Belilos v. Switzerland (Application No 10328/83) Judgment 29.4.1988
Bosphorus Hava Yollari Turizm ve Ticaret Anonim Sirketi v. Ireland (Application
No 45036/98) Judgment 20.06.2005
European Court of Human Rights
Fogarty v. United Kingdom (Application No 37112/97) Judgment 21.11.2001
Iorgov v. Bulgaria (Application No 40653/98) Judgment 7.07.2004 unpublished
Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory Advisory Opinion 9.7.2004
Legality of the Use by a State of Nuclear Weapons in Armed Conflict Advisory Opinion 8.7.1996
Loizidou v. Turkey (Application No 40/1993/435/514) Judgment 25.03.1995
Mamatkulov & Askarov v. Turkey (Application No 46827/99; 46951/99) Judgment 4.02.2005
Matthews v. United Kingdom (Application No 24833/94) Judgment 18.02.1999
McElhinney v. Ireland (Application No 31253/96) Judgment 21.11.2001
Öcalan v. Turkey (Application No 46221/99) Judgment 12.05.2005
Ruzhdi Saramati v. France, Norway and Germany (Application No 78166/01)
Grand Chamber 22.11.2006
Slivenko v. Latvia (Application No 48321/99) Judgment 9.07.2003
Soering v. The United Kingdom (Application No 14038/88) Judgment
07.1989
Waite and Kennedy v. Germany (Application No 26083/94) Judgment
02.1999
European Court of First Instance
Ahmed Ali Yusuf and Al Barakaat International Foundation v Council of the
European Union and Commission of the European Communities, 21
September 2005, case T-306/01
Yassin Abdullah Kadi v Council of the European Union and Commission of the European Communities, 21 September 2005, case T-315/01
National Courts
Belgium
Siedler v Western European Union Brussels Labour Court of Appeal (4th chamber) 17 September 2003 Journal des Tribunaux 2004 617 ILDC 53 (BE 2003)
France
Banque Africaine de Developpement v M.A. Degboe Judgment 25.01.2005 Nr 04-41012 [Found on internet] http://www.courdecassation.fr/ [Date of use 19 November 2007]
United Kingdom
R. (on the application of Al-Jeddah) v Secretary of State for Defence [2005] EWHC 1809 (Admin)
Switzerland
Emmanuel Rukundo v. l'Office fédéral de la justice Judgment 3.9.2001 Nr 1A.129/2001 [Found on internet] http://www.bger.ch/ [Date of use 19 November 2007]
Register of conventions and treaties
European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms 1950
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1966
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 1966
NATO Status of Forces Treaty 1951
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1969
Register of internet sources
EU 2007 Main stages http://europa.eu/ 19 Nov
European Union 2007 The main stages in the institutional reform of the European Union [Found on internet]
http://europa.eu/roadtoconstitution/index_en.htm [Date of use 19 November 2007]
UN 2005 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties http://untreaty.un.org/ 19
Nov
United Nations 2005 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties of 1969
[Found on internet]
http://untreaty.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/conventions/1_1_1969.pdf
[Date of use 19 November 2007]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 E de Wet
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}