Deference and Diffèrance: Judicial Review and the Perfect Gift


  • J de Ville University of the Western Cape



administrative law, deconstruction, deference, democracy, Derrida, différance, Dyzenhaus, gift, justice, liberalism, positivism, responsibility, review


The highest courts in both Canada and South Africa have expressed themselves in favour of an approach of deference as respect in the review of administrative action. The notion of deference as respect derives from the thinking of David Dyzenhaus, who has developed a theory of democracy in support of this approach to judicial review. Dyzenhaus’ model of review attempts to steer clear from the problems he associates particularly with positivism and liberalism. Dyzenhaus’ model of review furthermore attempts to allow space for the administration to play a significant role in giving effect to democratic values, on the understanding that all such decisions need to be reasonably justifiable. In this article the views of Dyzenhaus are contrasted with those of Jacques Derrida, especially insofar as the latter has reflected on the relation between law and justice, as well as concepts such as the gift and democracy. The argument developed in this article is that Dyzenhaus’ model of review, despite its many positive features, needs to be rethought with reference to the perfect gift, unconditional justice and democracy to come. Such a rethinking is required because of the limited conception of justice – as simply ‘our’ justice – in Dyzenhaus’ model. 



Download data is not yet available.


Metrics Loading ...



Bauman Postmodern Ethics

Bauman Z Postmodern Ethics (Blackwell Oxford 1993)

Borradori Philosophy in a Time of Terror

Borradori G Philosophy in a Time of Terror: Dialogues with Jürgen

Habermas and Jacques Derrida (University of Chicago Press Chicago 2003)

Botha 2004 SAJHR

Botha H "Freedom and Constraint in Constitutional Adjudication" 2004 (20) SAJHR 249

Caputo Against Ethics

Caputo JD Against Ethics: Contributions to a Poetics of Obligation with

Constant Reference to Deconstruction (Indiana University Press Bloomington 1993)

Caputo Deconstruction

Caputo JD Deconstruction in a Nutshell (Fordham University Press New York 1997)

Caputo More Radical Hermeneutics

Caputo JD More Radical Hermeneutics (Indiana University Press Bloomington 2000)

Caputo Prayers and Tears

Caputo JD The Prayers and Tears of Jacques Derrida Religion without

Religion (Indiana University Press Bloomington 1997)

Caputo Radical Hermeneutics

Caputo JD Radical Hermeneutics: Repetition, Deconstruction, and the

Hermeneutic Project (Indiana University Press Bloomington 1987)

Caputo What do I Love?

Caputo JD "What do I Love when I Love my God? Deconstruction and

Radical Orthodoxy" in Caputo JD et al. (eds) Questioning God (Indiana

University Press Bloomington 2001) 291

Caputo, Dooley and Scanlon Introduction

Caputo JD, Dooley M and Scanlon MJ "Introduction: God Forgive" in

Caputo JD et al. (eds) Questioning God (Indiana University Press Bloomington 2001)

Cornell Philosophy of the Limit

Cornell D The Philosophy of the Limit (Routledge New York 1992)

Critchley and Kearney Preface

Critchley S and Kearney R "Preface" in Derrida J On Cosmopolitanism and Forgiveness (Routledge London 2001)

Derrida 1999 Fragmente

Derrida J "Die Tragiese, die Onmoontlike en die Demokrasie: 'n Onderhoud met Jacques Derrida" 1999 Fragmente 35

Derrida 1999 South African Journal of Philosophy

Derrida J "Justice, Law and Philosophy – an interview with Jacques

Derrida" 1999 (18) South African Journal of Philosophy 279

Derrida 2000 Constellations

Derrida J "Performative Powerlessness: A Response to Simon Critchley" 2000 (7) Constellations 466

Derrida Adieu

Derrida J Adieu: To Emmanuel Levinas (Stanford University Press Stanford 1999)

Derrida Aporias

Derrida J Aporias (Stanford University Press Stanford 1993)

Derrida At this very Moment

Derrida J "At this very Moment in this Work here I am" in Kamuf P (ed)

Between the Blinds (Columbia University Press New York 1991) 403

Derrida Eyes of the University

Derrida J Eyes of the University: Right to Philosophy 2 (Stanford University Press Stanford 2004)

Derrida Force of Law

Derrida J "Force of Law: The 'Mystical Foundation of Authority'" in Cornell

D et al. (eds) Deconstruction and the Possibility of Justice (Routledge New York 1992) 3

Derrida Gift of Death

Derrida J The Gift of Death (University of Chicago Press Chicago 1995)

Derrida Given Time

Derrida J Given Time: I. Counterfeit Money (University of Chicago Press Chicago 1992)

Derrida Hospitality

Derrida J "Hospitality, Justice and Responsibility: A Dialogue with Jacques Derrida" in Kearney R and Dooley M (eds) Questioning Ethics:

Contemporary Debates in Philosophy (Routledge London 1999) 65

Derrida Negotiations

Derrida J Negotiations: Interventions and Interviews 1971-2001 (Stanford University Press Stanford 2002)

Derrida On Forgiveness

Derrida J "On Forgiveness: A Roundtable Discussion with Jacques Derrida"

in Caputo JD et al. (eds) Questioning God (Indiana University Press Bloomington 2001) 52

Derrida Passions

Derrida J "Passions: 'An Oblique Offering'" in Wood D (ed) Derrida: A Critical Reader (Blackwell Oxford 1992) 5

Derrida Points

Derrida J Points…Interviews 1974-1994 (Stanford University Press Stanford 1995)

Derrida Politics of Friendship

Derrida Politics of Friendship (Verso London 1997)

Derrida Positions

Derrida J Positions (Continuum London 2004)

Derrida Remarks on Deconstruction

Derrida J "Remarks on Deconstruction and Pragmatism" in Mouffe C (ed)

Deconstruction and Pragmatism (Routledge London 1996) 77

Derrida Rogues

Derrida J Rogues: Two Essays on Reason (Stanford University Press Stanford 2005)

Derrida Roundtable

Derrida J "The Villanova Roundtable: A Conversation with Jacques

Derrida" in Caputo JD (ed) Deconstruction in a Nutshell (Fordham

University Press New York 1997) 3

Derrida Specters of Marx

Derrida J Specters of Marx: The State of Debt, the Work of Mourning, & the New International (Routledge New York 1994)

Derrida Speech and Phenomena

Derrida J Speech and Phenomena and Other Essays on Husserl's Theory of Signs (Northwestern University Press Evanston 1973)

Derrida To Forgive

Derrida J "To Forgive: The Unforgivable and the Imprescriptible" in Caputo

JD et al. (eds) Questioning God (Indiana University Press Bloomington 2001) 21

Derrida Violence and Metaphysics

Derrida J "Violence and Metaphysics: An Essay on the Thought of

Emmanuel Levinas" in Writing and Difference (Routledge London 2001) 97

Derrida and Roudinesco For What Tomorrow

Derrida J and Roudinesco E For What Tomorrow… (Stanford University Press Stanford 2004)

Douzinas The End of Human Rights

Douzinas C The End of Human Rights (Hart Publishing Oxford 2000)

Dyzenhaus 1994 Ratio Juris

Dyzenhaus D "The Legitimacy of Law: A Response to Critics" 1994 (7) Ratio Juris 80

Dyzenhaus 1996 ARSP

Dyzenhaus D "The Legitimacy of Legality" 1996 (82) ARSP 324

Dyzenhaus 1996 OJLS

Dyzenhaus D "Hermann Heller and the Legitimacy of Legality" 1996 (16) OJLS 641

Dyzenhaus 1998 SAJHR

Dyzenhaus D "Law as justification: Etienne Mureinik's conception of legal culture" 1998 (14) SAJHR 11

Dyzenhaus 2000 OJLS

Dyzenhaus D "Positivism's Stagnant Research Programme" 2000 (20) OJLS 703

Dyzenhaus 2002 NZLR

Dyzenhaus D "Formalism's Hollow Victory" 2002 NZLR 525

Dyzenhaus 2002 Queen's LJ

Dyzenhaus D "Constituting the Rule of Law: Fundamental Values in

Administrative Law" 2002 (27) Queen's LJ 445

Dyzenhaus 2005 Law & Contemporary Problems

Dyzenhaus D "The Rule of (Administrative) Law in International Law" 2005

(68) Law & Contemporary Problems 127

Dyzenhaus 2005 UTLJ

Dyzenhaus D "The Logic of the Rule of Law" 2005 (55) UTLJ 691

Dyzenhaus (ed) Baker

Dyzenhaus D "Baker: The Unity of Public Law?" in The Unity of Public Law (Hart Publishing Oxford 2004) 1

Dyzenhaus Mullan's Theory

Dyzenhaus D "David Mullan's Theory of the Rule of Law" in Huscroft G and Taggart M (eds) Festschrift for Mullan (forthcoming)

Dyzenhaus Form and Substance

Dyzenhaus D "Form and Substance in the Rule of Law: A Democratic

Justification for Judicial Review?" in Forsyth C (ed) Judicial Review and the Constitution (Hart Publishing Oxford 2000) 141

Dyzenhaus Hard Cases

Dyzenhaus D Hard Cases in Wicked Legal Systems: South African Law in the Perspective of Legal Philosophy (1991)

Dyzenhaus Juristic Force of Injustice

Dyzenhaus D "The Juristic Force of Injustice" in Dyzenhaus D and Moran

M (eds) Calling Power to Account: Law, Reparations and the Chinese

Canadian Head Tax (University of Toronto Press Toronto 2005)

Dyzenhaus Justice of the Common Law

Dyzenhaus D "The Justice of the Common Law: Judges, Democracy and the Limits of the Rule of Law" in Saunders C and Le Roy K (eds) The Rule of Law (Federation Press Sydney 2003) 33

Dyzenhaus Legality and Legitimacy

Dyzenhaus D Legality and Legitimacy: Carl Schmitt, Hans Kelsen and

Hermann Heller in Weimar (Oxford University Press Oxford 1997)

Dyzenhaus Politics of Deference

Dyzenhaus D "The Politics of Deference: Judicial Review and Democracy" in Taggart M (ed) The Province of Administrative Law (Hart Publishing Oxford 1997) 279

Dyzenhaus Recrafting the Rule of Law

Dyzenhaus D "Recrafting the Rule of Law" in Dyzenhaus D (ed) Recrafting the Rule of Law: The Limits of Legal Order (Hart Publishing Oxford 1999) 1

Dyzenhaus Rule of Law

Dyzenhaus D "The Rule of Law as the Rule of Liberal Principle" in Ripstein

(ed) Cambridge Companion to Dworkin (forthcoming)

Dyzenhaus State of Emergency

Dyzenhaus D "The State of Emergency in Legal Theory" in Ramraj V et al

(eds) Global Anti-Terrorism Law and Policy (forthcoming)

Dyzenhaus Truth, Reconciliation

Dyzenhaus D Truth, Reconciliation and the Apartheid Legal Order (Juta Cape Town 1998)

Dyzenhaus With the Benefit of Hindsight

Dyzenhaus D "'With the Benefit of Hindsight': Dilemmas of Legality in the Face of Injustice" in Christodoulidis E and Veitch S (eds) Lethe's Law:

Justice, Law and Ethics in Reconciliation (Hart Publishing Oxford 2001) 65

Dyzenhaus and Fox-Decent 2001 UTLJ

Dyzenhaus D and Fox-Decent E "Rethinking the Process/Substance

Distinction: Baker v Canada" 2001 (51) UTLJ 193

Dyzenhaus, Hunt and Taggart 2001 OUCLJ

Dyzenhaus D, Hunt M and Taggart M "The Principle of Legality in

Administrative Law: Internationalisation as Constitutionalisation" 2001 (1) OUCLJ 5

Genesis 22:1-19

The Holy Bible containing the Old and New Testaments (Nelson New York 1952)

Gutting French Philosophy

Gutting G French Philosophy in the Twentieth Century (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2001)

Holtmaat 2005 Filosofie Magazine

Holtmaat R "Een Studie in Ironie" 2005 (14) Filosofie Magazine 14

Hutchinson 1985 MLR

Hutchinson AC "The rise and ruse of administrative law and scholarship" 1985 (48) MLR 293

McCormick 1999 New York University Review of Law and Social Change

McCormick JP "Book review: Judging the judges, judging ourselves" 1999

(25) New York University Review of Law and Social Change 109

Mortley French Philosophers

Mortley R French Philosophers in Conversation (Routledge London 1991)

Moyaert Ethiek en het Verlangen

Moyaert P "Ethiek en het Verlangen naar het absolute Goed" in Van Haute

P and Ijsseling S (eds) Deconstructie en Ethiek (Universitaire Press Leuven Van Gorcum Assen 1992)

Mullan and Ceddia 2003 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies

Mullan D and Ceddia A "The Impact on Public Law of Privatization,

Deregulation, Outsourcing, and Downsizing: A Canadian Perspective" 2003 (10) Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 199

Offe Modernity and the State

Offe C Modernity and the State: East, West (Polity Press Cambridge 1996)

Slangen 2005 Filosofie Magazine

Slangen I "Ook wij zijn bezeten: De existentiële horror van Kierkegaard" 2005 (9) Filosofie Magazine 38

Stern 2003 Philosophy Today

Stern DS "The Bind of Responsibility: Kierkegaard, Derrida, and the

Akedah of Isaac" 2003 Philosophy Today 34

Van der Walt and Botha 2000 Constellations

Van der Walt J and Botha H "Democracy and Rights in South Africa:

Beyond a Constitutional Culture of Justification" 2000 (7) Constellations 341

Van der Walt Future and Futurity

Van der Walt J Tangible mais Intouchable, la Loi du Tact, la Loi de la Loi:

The Future and Futurity of the Public-Private Distinction in the View of the

Horizontal Application of Fundamental Rights (Wolf Legal Productions Nijmegen 2002)

Register of court cases

Baker v Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) (1999) DLR (4th) 193 (SCC)

Bato Star Fishing (Pty) Ltd v Minister of Environmental Affairs and Others 2004 4 SA 490 (CC)

Canadian Union of Public Employees Local 963 v New Brunswick Liquor

Corporation [1979] 2 SCR 227

International Woodworkers of America Local 2-69 v Consolidated Bathurst

Packaging Ltd [1990] 1 SCR 282

Nicholson v Haldimand-Norfolk Regional Board of Commissioners of Police

1 SCR 311



How to Cite

de Ville, J. (2017). Deference and Diffèrance: Judicial Review and the Perfect Gift. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 9(2), 40–89.




Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.